The #1 Thing Impacting Your Sleep More Than You Know & How To Overcome It
In this episode of The School of Greatness, Baland Jalal examines the science behind sleep paralysis and lucid dreaming. He explains how the brain's mechanisms during REM sleep can sometimes lead to sleep paralysis—where people experience a collision between wakefulness and dreaming—and describes how lucid dreaming occurs when specific parts of the brain become active during sleep, enabling dreamers to recognize and sometimes control their dreams.
The discussion explores how cultural beliefs and environmental factors influence dream experiences, with examples of how different societies interpret sleep phenomena. Jalal also addresses the topic of premonitory dreams, discussing the current scientific understanding while acknowledging the limitations of research in explaining all aspects of dream experiences. The episode provides insights into the complex relationship between the brain, consciousness, and various sleep states.
This is a preview of the Shortform summary of the Aug 25, 2025 episode of the The School of Greatness
Sign up for Shortform to access the whole episode summary along with additional materials like counterarguments and context.
1-Page Summary
The Neuroscience of Sleep Paralysis and Lucid Dreaming
Sleep Paralysis: When Dreams Meet Wakefulness
During REM sleep, the brain stem typically paralyzes the body to prevent people from acting out their dreams. However, as Baland Jalal explains, this mechanism can sometimes activate while a person is partially awake, resulting in sleep paralysis. During these episodes, the prefrontal cortex is partially active, creating a unique state where wakefulness collides with dreaming. This leads to vivid hallucinations and often terrifying sensations, intensified by hyperactive emotional centers in the brain.
Lucid Dreaming: Controlling the Dream World
Jalal describes lucid dreaming as a state where the pre-dorsolateral prefrontal cortex becomes prematurely activated during REM sleep, enabling enhanced self-awareness and logic within dreams. This activation allows dreamers to recognize they're dreaming and, in some cases, control their dream experiences. These experiences can range from flying to meeting historical figures, with the dreams typically being more vivid than usual.
Cultural Influences on Dream Experiences
Cultural beliefs significantly shape how people experience sleep phenomena. Jalal points out that in Egypt, sleep paralysis is often attributed to evil genies, making episodes more intense and traumatic. In contrast, Danish culture views sleep paralysis as a natural physiological response, resulting in less fearful experiences. Additionally, the physical environment plays a role in dream content, with external factors like temperature, sounds, and smells potentially influencing dream scenarios.
Dreams and Premonitory Phenomena
While discussing premonitory dreams, Jalal acknowledges that while science cannot currently prove psychic abilities or future predictions in dreams, these experiences remain significant in human consciousness. He maintains an open-minded approach, suggesting that while there are baseline brain states influencing dreams, the possibility of spiritual or supernatural influences cannot be entirely dismissed by current scientific understanding.
1-Page Summary
Additional Materials
Clarifications
- The pre-dorsolateral prefrontal cortex plays a crucial role in lucid dreaming by enabling enhanced self-awareness and logic within dreams. Its premature activation during REM sleep allows individuals to recognize they are dreaming and sometimes control their dream experiences. This brain region helps differentiate between the dream world and reality, leading to more conscious dream states. Lucid dreaming experiences are often associated with increased activity in the pre-dorsolateral prefrontal cortex.
- Cultural beliefs can significantly impact how individuals perceive and interpret sleep phenomena like sleep paralysis. For example, in some cultures, sleep paralysis may be attributed to supernatural entities, leading to more intense and frightening experiences. Conversely, cultures that view sleep paralysis as a natural bodily response may experience less fear during episodes. These cultural interpretations can shape the emotional and psychological impact of sleep phenomena on individuals.
- Premonitory dreams are experiences where individuals believe they have dreamt about future events. Some people attribute these dreams to psychic abilities or supernatural influences, although current scientific understanding does not support these claims. While the brain's baseline states influence dreams, the debate continues on whether dreams can predict the future or if there are spiritual elements at play.
- Baseline brain states influencing dreams suggest that the normal functioning of the brain during sleep impacts the content and nature of dreams. This means that the brain's typical activity patterns play a role in shaping dream experiences. The idea of spiritual or supernatural influences in dreams implies the consideration of factors beyond current scientific understanding, such as beliefs in psychic abilities or connections to the supernatural realm. These concepts suggest that while science provides explanations based on known brain functions, there may be aspects of dreams that go beyond conventional scientific explanations.
Counterarguments
- The paralysis mechanism during REM sleep is not always foolproof, and some individuals may experience REM sleep behavior disorder (RBD), where they act out their dreams.
- The experience of sleep paralysis can vary greatly between individuals, and not all episodes are characterized by vivid hallucinations or terrifying sensations.
- The role of the pre-dorsolateral prefrontal cortex in lucid dreaming is still under investigation, and there may be other brain regions or mechanisms involved in the initiation and maintenance of lucid dreams.
- While cultural beliefs may influence the interpretation of sleep paralysis, the physiological basis of the experience is consistent across cultures, suggesting that cultural factors may not alter the fundamental nature of the phenomenon.
- The assertion that external factors like temperature, sounds, and smells can influence dream scenarios is supported by anecdotal evidence, but controlled scientific studies on these influences are limited.
- The significance of premonitory dreams in human consciousness does not necessarily imply that these experiences have a supernatural or predictive quality; they may be better explained by cognitive biases such as the tendency to remember coincidences.
- The open-minded approach to spiritual or supernatural influences on dreams, while respectful of diverse beliefs, may not align with the scientific method, which relies on empirical evidence and falsifiability.
Related Shortform Content
Get access to the context and additional materials
The Neuroscience of Sleep Paralysis and Lucid Dreaming
Understanding the brain's behavior during sleep paralysis and lucid dreaming provides insight into the complex interplay of neural mechanisms that give rise to these peculiar states.
Sleep Paralysis: Partially Awake Brain Paralyzes Body in Rem Sleep, Causing Terrifying Sensations and Hallucinations
Sleep paralysis occurs when the brain stem, specifically the pons and medulla, sends signals to paralyze the body during REM sleep, preventing the physical acting out of dreams—a protective feature. Yet, this mechanism can activate early, during wakefulness, causing the individual to become partially awake with a partially active prefrontal cortex. This collision of wakefulness and dreaming leads to vivid and terrifying sensations and hallucinations.
Brain Stem Induces Sleep Paralysis to Prevent Acting Out Dreams, Occasionally Triggering Early During Wakefulness
Baland Jalal, as described by Howes, mentions that during sleep paralysis, although the eyes are open and the individual feels awake, there's a sense that the brain is only "partially awake." Emotional centers in the brain, particularly those associated with fear, are hyperactive, leading to terrifying sensations. The brain paralyzes the body in REM sleep to prevent the acting out of dreams, ensuring the individual does not harm themselves or a sleeping partner.
Prefrontal Cortex Activity During Sleep Paralysis Causes a Dreamlike State
Jalal further explains that during sleep paralysis, the prefrontal cortex of the brain, usually active when awake, partially turns on while the individual is in REM sleep, which leads to the dreamlike state that characterizes sleep paralysis. The blend of wakefulness with the dream world is due to this prefrontal cortex activity. Additionally, parts of the brain related to body image become dysfunctional, which can lead to altered perceptions of body image or out-of-body experiences.
Lucid Dreaming Happens When the Prefrontal Cortex Activates, Enabling Dream Awareness and Control
Lucid dreaming is characterized by a boost in self-awareness and logic in the dream state, courtesy of the prefrontal cortex's activation.
Prefrontal Cortex Boosts Self-Awaren ...
Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary
The Neuroscience of Sleep Paralysis and Lucid Dreaming
Additional Materials
Clarifications
- The pons and medulla are regions in the brain stem responsible for regulating various essential functions, including sleep and muscle control. During sleep paralysis, these brain regions send signals to temporarily paralyze the body during REM sleep, preventing physical movements that could occur during dreaming. This paralysis is a protective mechanism to ensure safety during sleep by inhibiting the acting out of dreams. Dysfunction in this process can lead to the experience of being awake but unable to move, often accompanied by vivid hallucinations.
- During sleep paralysis, the prefrontal cortex, responsible for decision-making and self-awareness, can become partially active while the body is still in a state of REM sleep. This partial activation of the prefrontal cortex contributes to the unique experience of feeling awake but also dreaming during sleep paralysis. The interplay between wakefulness and dreaming is influenced by this partial activity in the prefrontal cortex, leading to a blend of conscious awareness and dream-like sensations. This phenomenon can result in vivid and sometimes unsettling experiences during sleep paralysis.
- The pre-dorsolateral prefrontal cortex plays a crucial ...
Counterarguments
- The assertion that the brain stem induces sleep paralysis to prevent acting out dreams, while widely accepted, might not fully explain the phenomenon. Other factors such as stress, sleep deprivation, and genetics may also play significant roles.
- While emotional centers are often hyperactive during sleep paralysis, it's not universally the case for all individuals. Some may experience sleep paralysis without intense fear or hallucinations.
- The role of the prefrontal cortex in sleep paralysis is still under investigation. Some studies suggest that other brain regions could also contribute to the dreamlike state experienced during sleep paralysis.
- The dysfunction of brain parts related to body image during sleep paralysis is a hypothesis that may not account for all experiences, as some individuals report no such altered perceptions.
- The exact mechanism of how lucid dreaming occurs is still debated. The activation of the prefrontal cortex is one theory, but it may not be the sole factor enabling dream awareness and control.
- The claim that lucid dreaming boosts self-awareness and logic could be challenged by the fact that even in lucid dreams, logical reasoning can be flawed or different from waking logic.
- The corr ...
Related Shortform Content
Get access to the context and additional materials
Culture and Beliefs' Role In Shaping Unusual Dream Experiences
Dream experiences, such as sleep paralysis, can significantly differ across cultures, influenced by local beliefs, and external sensory input can influence dreams based on the physical environment.
Cultural Beliefs About Supernatural Entities Affect Sleep Paralysis Experiences
Cultural interpretations and beliefs about supernatural entities can greatly affect sleep paralysis experiences.
Sleep Paralysis Seen As Encounter With Evil Spirits
In Egypt, Baland Jalal points out, sleep paralysis is frequently attributed to "the evil genies," akin to those from Aladdin, but not of the benevolent type; rather, these genies are perceived as malevolent spirits that may cause harm or even lead to death. Such cultural beliefs can amplify the severity and duration of the episodes, making them feel more intense and longer-lasting compared to places like Denmark, where sleep paralysis is seen as a benign physiological response to stress, free of any spiritual connotation.
Neutral Views of Sleep Paralysis Reduce Fear and Trauma
In Denmark, because the cultural beliefs concerning sleep paralysis are devoid of sinister connotations, the episodes tend to be seen more neutrally as a brain defect, leading to less fear and trauma. Jalal mentions a therapy he developed for treating sleep paralysis that involves cognitive reappraisal and emotional and psychological distancing. This approach encourages those experiencing sleep paralysis to recognize it as a natural occurrence and to view it as a distant, non-threatening event, thereby reducing fear and distress.
Brain's Integration of External Sensory Input Can Influence Dreams Through the Physical Environment
Drea ...
Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary
Culture and Beliefs' Role In Shaping Unusual Dream Experiences
Additional Materials
Clarifications
- Sleep paralysis is a phenomenon where a person is temporarily unable to move or speak while falling asleep or waking up. Cultural beliefs can influence how people interpret and experience sleep paralysis, with some cultures attributing it to supernatural entities like evil spirits, while others view it more neutrally as a physiological response. These cultural interpretations can impact the intensity and emotional experience of sleep paralysis episodes.
- Cultural beliefs can shape how people interpret and experience phenomena like sleep paralysis in their dreams. For example, in Egypt, sleep paralysis is often linked to evil spirits, leading to more intense and frightening experiences, while in Denmark, it's viewed more neutrally, reducing fear and trauma. These cultural interpretations influence the emotional and psychological responses individuals have during sleep paralysis episodes.
- Cognitive reappraisal and emotional distancing in treating sleep paralysis involve techniques that help individuals change how they perceive and respond to their experiences during sleep paralysis. By reframing the situation and creating psychological distance, individuals can reduce fear and distress associated with sleep paralysis episodes. This approach aims to shift the interpretation of sleep paralysis from a terrifying encounter to a more neutral and manageable event, promoting a sense of control and reducing negative emotional impact.
- Dream incubation is a practice where focusing on a specific thought or idea during waking hours can influence the content of dreams during sleep. For example, if someone spends the day contemplating flying, they may dream about flying at night. This phenomenon sugges ...
Counterarguments
- Cultural interpretations of sleep paralysis, while influential, may not be the sole factor in determining the intensity and duration of episodes; individual psychological differences and personal experiences could also play a significant role.
- The view of sleep paralysis as a benign physiological response in Denmark may not account for all individual experiences within the culture, as personal beliefs and the influence of global media could lead to a variety of interpretations.
- Cognitive reappraisal and emotional distancing techniques may not be universally effective, as some individuals may find it difficult to intellectually detach from intense emotional experiences during sleep paralysis.
- The impact of external sensory input on dreams might be overstated, as not all individuals report such direct correlations between their environment and their dream content.
- Dream incubation, while a recognized phenomenon, may ...
Related Shortform Content
Get access to the context and additional materials
Potential Links Between Dreams and Premonitory Phenomena
Researchers like Baland Jalal and Howes explore the mysterious connections between dreams and phenomena such as premonitions, acknowledging that while science cannot currently prove such links, they remain a significant aspect of human experience.
Premonitory Dreams:
Science Can't Prove Psychic Abilities or Future Predictions In Dreams, but Many Report Such Experiences
Jalal acknowledges the prevalence of people reporting premonitory dreams. He notes that throughout history, cultures have reported prophecies and prophetic dreams. While he personally has experienced dreams that seemed to predict future events, he recognizes that science offers explanations such as a bias in remembering dreams that correlate to future occurrences. However, he believes that subjective experiences cannot be denied by science, even if they go beyond its current capabilities to prove or disprove.
Reduced Prefrontal Cortex Activity in Dreams Linked To Intuitive or Precognitive Feelings
Howes remarks on his experiences with sleep paralysis, suggesting that he could "train his prefrontal cortex captain to say, let things come back on slowly," indicating a certain level of awareness and potential control that could be related to intuitive or precognitive feelings during dreams.
Dream, Consciousness, and Reality: Unresolved Mysteries
Neuroscientists Agree That Dreamers' Subjective Experiences, Like Premonitory Dreams, Can't Be Disproven by Current Science
Neuroscientists, including Jalal, placidly accept that subjective experiences, like premonitory dreams, cannot be invalidated using current scientific methods, which leaves the phenomenon as an unresolved mystery within our ...
Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary
Potential Links Between Dreams and Premonitory Phenomena
Additional Materials
Counterarguments
- The prevalence of reports on premonitory dreams could be influenced by confirmation bias, where individuals remember and report dreams that seem to match future events while forgetting those that do not.
- The human tendency to find patterns and meaning in random data could explain why some dreams are perceived as premonitory.
- Correlation does not imply causation; just because a dream precedes an event does not mean the dream predicted the event.
- The scientific method relies on reproducibility and falsifiability; subjective experiences like premonitory dreams are inherently difficult to study in this framework, which may not necessarily indicate a mysterious connection but rather a limitation of the method.
- Neurological research has not found any mechanism by which the brain could access information about the future, suggesting that what are perceived as premonitory dreams may have more mundane explanations.
- The idea of a connection between dreams and spiritual realms is speculative ...
Actionables
- Start a dream journal to track potential premonitory dreams and their real-life outcomes. By recording your dreams immediately after waking, you create a personal database that can be reviewed for any correlations between dream content and future events. For example, if you dream about an unexpected encounter with a friend and it happens, you can note the coincidence and look for patterns over time.
- Engage in mindfulness meditation before bed to potentially enhance dream recall and intuitive thinking. Mindfulness can increase self-awareness and may lead to a heightened ability to remember dreams, which could be useful for identifying any premonitory elements. As you meditate, focus on the intention to remember your dreams and observe any intuitive feelings that arise.
- Experiment with 'dream incubation' techniqu ...
Related Shortform Content
Get access to the context and additional materials
Create Summaries for anything on the web
Download the Shortform Chrome extension for your browser
