Podcasts > The Mel Robbins Podcast > 4 Signs of Emotionally Immature Parents & How to Heal

4 Signs of Emotionally Immature Parents & How to Heal

By Stitcher

In this episode of The Mel Robbins Podcast, Dr. Lindsay Gibson discusses the four types of emotionally immature parents: emotional, driven, passive, and rejecting. She examines how each type affects child development and explains how children of these parents often develop hypervigilance, struggle with boundaries, and face challenges in adult relationships.

The discussion covers practical strategies for dealing with emotionally immature parents, including setting boundaries and developing emotional detachment when needed. Dr. Gibson addresses the concept of "healing fantasies"—the belief that parents will eventually change—and explores how individuals can process and heal from an emotionally deprived childhood through self-compassion rather than waiting for parental change.

Listen to the original

4 Signs of Emotionally Immature Parents & How to Heal

This is a preview of the Shortform summary of the May 15, 2025 episode of the The Mel Robbins Podcast

Sign up for Shortform to access the whole episode summary along with additional materials like counterarguments and context.

4 Signs of Emotionally Immature Parents & How to Heal

1-Page Summary

Emotionally Immature Parents Characteristics and Types

The podcast explores four distinct types of emotionally immature parents. According to Dr. Lindsay Gibson, emotional parents create volatile environments with unpredictable moods, while driven parents view their children as extensions of themselves, pushing them toward predetermined markers of success. Passive parents, though often favored by children for their playfulness, fail to provide protection from other abusive parents. Rejecting parents treat their children as nuisances, leading children to feel unwanted and unworthy.

Impact on Child Development and Adult Relationships

Children of emotionally immature parents often develop hypervigilance to their parents' moods, as Mel Robbins acknowledges from her own experience as a parent. Dr. Gibson explains that these children frequently struggle with boundary issues and intimacy in their adult relationships, either becoming people-pleasers or avoiding emotional engagement altogether. The impact of childhood emotional deprivation can manifest in perfectionism, procrastination, and persistent feelings of inadequacy.

Facing Childhood Reality Over "Healing Fantasies"

Dr. Gibson emphasizes that understanding a parent's emotional limitations shouldn't be taken personally, as it often stems from their inability to handle discomfort rather than malice. She warns against clinging to "healing fantasies" - the belief that parents will eventually change and provide the emotional support they never could. While parents may occasionally show positive behavior, Gibson explains that these moments shouldn't fuel unrealistic expectations for fundamental change.

Strategies For Setting Boundaries

Gibson recommends developing an "anthropological" detachment when dealing with emotionally immature parents, suggesting techniques like using mantras and maintaining self-connection through physical touch. She advises treating oneself and parents as equally important adults, setting clear boundaries about visit duration and location, and recognizing that while emotional reactions are involuntary, responses can be controlled.

Grieving Process of an Emotionally Deprived Childhood

Gibson describes the journey of processing an emotionally deprived childhood as one requiring deep self-compassion. She notes that many individuals struggle with self-empathy due to conditioning that dismissed their feelings. Rather than seeking to fix the past or waiting for parents to change, Gibson encourages focusing on personal healing and authentic self-development.

1-Page Summary

Additional Materials

Counterarguments

  • While emotionally immature parents may create volatile environments, it's also possible that some children may develop resilience and coping strategies in response to such environments.
  • The idea that driven parents push their children toward success might be seen as a form of encouragement and high expectations, which can sometimes lead to positive outcomes if balanced with emotional support.
  • Passive parents might not always fail to protect their children; in some cases, their laid-back approach could foster independence and problem-solving skills in their children.
  • Rejecting parents' behavior is harmful, but it's important to consider that they might also be struggling with their own unresolved emotional issues or mental health challenges.
  • Hypervigilance to parents' moods could also lead some children to develop keen observational and empathetic skills, although this is not an ideal way to develop such traits.
  • Struggles with boundary issues and intimacy might not solely be attributed to parental emotional immaturity; other factors such as individual temperament, peer relationships, and societal influences can also play a significant role.
  • Perfectionism and procrastination can be multifaceted issues with various contributing factors beyond childhood emotional deprivation.
  • The concept of "healing fantasies" could be reframed as a natural desire for familial connection and reconciliation, which might not always be detrimental if managed with realistic expectations.
  • The recommendation for an "anthropological" detachment might not resonate with everyone, as some individuals may find that a different approach to emotional engagement with their parents is more healing.
  • Mantras and physical touch might not be effective for everyone; individuals may benefit from a wide range of coping strategies and should be encouraged to find what works best for them.
  • The advice to treat oneself and parents as equally important adults may not be applicable in all cultural contexts where familial hierarchies are deeply ingrained and respected.
  • The assertion that emotional reactions are involuntary but responses can be controlled may oversimplify the complexity of emotional regulation for some individuals, especially those with certain neurological or psychological conditions.
  • The grieving process for an emotionally deprived childhood can vary greatly among individuals, and some may find that alternative approaches to healing, such as creative expression or community support, are more effective for them.
  • The struggle with self-empathy might not always be due to conditioning that dismissed their feelings; other factors like personality traits or external influences could also contribute to this challenge.
  • Personal healing and authentic self-development are important, but the role of supportive relationships and community should not be underestimated in the healing process.

Actionables

  • Create a personal mood chart to track emotional patterns and triggers, helping you understand your reactions and plan for steadier emotional responses. Start by noting down your mood at different times of the day, along with what was happening at that time, to identify patterns. For example, you might find that you feel anxious after speaking to certain family members, which could indicate a need to set boundaries in those relationships.
  • Develop a "relationship resume" for yourself, outlining what you bring to and need from relationships, to improve intimacy and boundary issues. This could include qualities like your communication style, your need for personal space, and how you show affection. Sharing this with close friends or partners can open up discussions about mutual needs and expectations.
  • Engage in "role-reversal" journaling where you write from the perspective of a compassionate observer about your own experiences, to foster self-empathy and self-compassion. Imagine you are a friend giving advice to yourself and write down what you would say. This can help you to be kinder to yourself and recognize your worth, especially if you tend to be hard on yourself due to past emotional deprivation.

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
4 Signs of Emotionally Immature Parents & How to Heal

Emotionally Immature Parents Characteristics and Types

The concept of emotionally immature parents is dissected in the podcast, indicating various ways they may negatively impact their children's emotional development and well-being.

Types of Emotionally Immature Parents: Emotional, Driven, Passive, Rejecting

Emotional Parents Have Intense, Unpredictable Moods, Making the Household Volatile and Requiring the Child’s Vigilance

The podcast discusses the various types of emotionally immature parents and their impact on children. Emotional parents can emotionally dominate a household with their moods and reactions, leading everyone to behave differently depending on their state. This can create a volatile environment, as described by Mel Robbins, who admits to her own emotional outbursts and mood swings that affected her children. These parents make the child or other family members feel obligated to help regulate the emotional parent's state, often at the expense of their own emotions.

Driven Parents See Children As Extensions of Themselves

Dr. Lindsey Gibson discusses the driven type of emotionally immature parents, who are highly focused on the materialistic and success-oriented aspects of culture. These parents micromanage their children's activities, seeing their achievements as a reflection of their own success. Driven parents push their child toward what they consider markers of success, such as scoring goals or achieving certain social statuses, often at the cost of their children's individual interests and happiness.

Passive Parents Favored by Children but Lack Protection and Support

Passive parents, as described by Gibson, tend to be favored by children because they can be playful and are often attuned to them. However, they do not protect their children from the other, potentially more emotionally volatile or abusive parent. They lack emotional depth, often providing consolation after an outburst but not intervening during the abuse. Such parents benefit from their lack of intervention while the child’s needs for protection and support remain unmet.

Rejecting Parents Distance Themselves, Leaving Children Feeling Unwanted

The rejecting parents are characterized by Gibson as those who see their children as nuisances. These parents act as if they never wanted children, with the best relationship achieved when the child tries not to bother them. Children of rejecting parents often learn that serving or not distressing the parent is the way to have a relationship with them, thus feeling unwanted and unworthy.

The podcast highlights how emotionally immature parents may make themselves the center of attention, neglecti ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Emotionally Immature Parents Characteristics and Types

Additional Materials

Clarifications

  • Emotionally immature parents are adults who struggle to regulate their emotions and prioritize their children's needs. They may exhibit behaviors like unpredictability, self-centeredness, and a lack of empathy, impacting their children's emotional well-being. These parents often fail to provide a stable and nurturing environment, leading to challenges in the child's development of boundaries, self-esteem, and emotional regulation. Understanding this concept helps recognize how parental behavior can influence a child's upbringing and mental health.
  • Emotionally immature parents can be categorized into four main types: Emotional, Driven, Passive, and Rejecting. Each type exhibits distinct behaviors and characteristics that can impact their children's emotional well-being in different ways. Understanding these types can help identify and address specific challenges that may arise from having emotionally immature parents. These categories provide a framework for recognizing and navigating the complexities of parental behavior and its effects on children.
  • Dr. Lindsey Gibson is a psychologist and author known for her work on emotionally immature parents. She categorizes emotionally immature parents into different types based on their behaviors and interactions with their children. Gibson's descriptions help identify the characteristics and impacts of emotional immaturity within parenting dynamics. Her insights provide a framework for understanding how different types of emotionally immature parents may influence their children's emotional well-being.
  • Emotionally immature parents who make themselves the center of attention often prioritize their own needs, emotions, and desires over those of their children. They may seek validation, admiration, or control from their children, leading to a dynamic where the parent's feelings and actions dominate the family environment. This behavior can result in children feeling neglected, unseen, or ...

Counterarguments

  • While the types of emotionally immature parents are categorized, it's important to recognize that human behavior is complex and not everyone fits neatly into these categories.
  • Some parents may exhibit traits from multiple categories or may change over time, suggesting that these characteristics are not fixed.
  • The concept of emotional immaturity can be subjective and culturally influenced; what is considered immature in one culture may be seen differently in another.
  • It's possible for parents to be emotionally immature in some aspects of parenting but emotionally mature in others, indicating a spectrum rather than distinct types.
  • The impact of emotionally immature parents on children can vary greatly, with some children developing resilience and strong coping mechanisms.
  • The text may not fully acknowledge the systemic and external factors that contribute to a parent's emotional immaturity, such as socioeconomic pressures or mental health issues.
  • The description of passive parents as favored by children might not account for the diverse experiences of children who may not favor passivity in parenting.
  • The notion that driven parents see children as extensions of themselves could be re-evaluated in the context of parents who are genuinely trying to guide their children towards a secure future, albeit in a misguided way.
  • The characterization of rejecting parents might not consider the possibility that some parents may struggle with their own emotional issues or past traumas that affect their ability to connect with their children.
  • The idea that children of emotionally immature parents will struggle with boundaries and approval-seeking ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
4 Signs of Emotionally Immature Parents & How to Heal

Impact of Emotionally Immature Parents on Child Development and Adult Relationships

The impacts of having emotionally immature parents can deeply affect child development and carry into adult relationships.

Children With Emotionally Immature Parents Often Face Insecurity, Self-Doubt, and Difficulty Communicating

Hypervigilance to Parents' Moods

Children of emotionally immature parents often become hypervigilant to their parents' moods. Such children learn that they must constantly monitor their environment to preemptively manage any potential emotional outbursts or instability. Lindsay C. Gibson describes a dynamic where the child feels responsible for the parent's emotions, leading them to constantly stay on alert. This vigilance can result in exhaustion and an exaggerated sense of guilt about self-expression, as they navigate their parent's sensitivities, often feeling responsible for keeping the parent calm, resulting in the child constantly wondering if they've done something wrong.

Boundary and Intimacy Issues in Relationships, Leading To People-Pleasing or Avoidance

Robbins acknowledges her emotional immaturity as a young parent and how it likely led her children to not know what mood to expect from her, making them develop sensitivities and self-doubts. Because they've been frequently blamed or told their feelings were wrong or bad, these children may develop boundary issues in their relationships, leading them to either become people-pleasers or to avoid addressing emotional behaviors altogether. Adults who experienced this dynamic as children might constantly read into every mood and action of their partner, looking for cues as to whether they have done something wrong, which affects how they manage boundaries and intimacy.

Impact of Childhood Emotional Deprivation: Perfectionism, Procrastination, and Inadequacy

The treatment by an emotionally immature parent can give children the sense that they are insignificant or not real, which can be likened to the physical pain of being stepped on. This can lead to adult behaviors such as perfectionism, procrastination, and feelings of inadequacy. As adults, people raised by driven parents might see self-care ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Impact of Emotionally Immature Parents on Child Development and Adult Relationships

Additional Materials

Clarifications

  • Hypervigilance to parents' moods is when a child is constantly alert and sensitive to their parents' emotional states. This behavior stems from a need to anticipate and manage any potential outbursts or instability from the parents. Children may feel responsible for their parents' emotions, leading to a heightened sense of vigilance and self-blame. This can result in the child feeling the need to constantly monitor and adjust their behavior to maintain a sense of emotional stability within the family dynamic.
  • Boundary and intimacy issues in relationships can stem from childhood experiences with emotionally immature parents. Children who grow up with parents who struggle with emotional maturity may have difficulty establishing healthy boundaries and intimacy in their adult relationships. This can manifest as either becoming overly accommodating (people-pleasing) or avoiding emotional discussions altogether. These issues can impact how individuals navigate closeness and emotional vulnerability with their partners.
  • Childhood emotional deprivation can lead to feelings of insignificance or being unseen, akin to the pain of being ignored or overlooked. This experience can result in behaviors like perfectionism, procrastination, and a sense of inadequacy in adulthood. Children who feel emotionally deprived may struggle with settin ...

Actionables

  • Create a mood journal to track your emotional responses to situations, noting when you feel hypervigilant or responsible for others' emotions. By documenting your feelings and the triggers, you can identify patterns and work on strategies to manage your reactions, such as setting aside time for self-reflection or practicing mindfulness when you notice hypervigilance setting in.
  • Establish a "needs and boundaries" diary where you write down one need you have and one boundary you want to set each day. This practice encourages you to recognize and validate your needs and learn to communicate them effectively. For example, if you find yourself people-pleasing, you might write down a need for personal time and set a boundary by saying no to an additional commitment.
  • Engage in role-play exer ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
4 Signs of Emotionally Immature Parents & How to Heal

Facing Childhood Reality Over "Healing Fantasies"

The podcast sheds light on the complex emotional terrain navigated when acknowledging and moving beyond the upbringing by emotionally immature parents.

Acknowledging Emotional Immaturity in Parents and Its Impact

Dr. Gibson advises that a parent's lack of emotional depth should not be taken as a personal affront by the child. The parent's incapacity often stems from an inability to handle their own discomfort, not from malice. Acknowledging the reality of emotionally immature parents is crucial for children to move past experiences of guilt, confusion, or impossible expectations.

Grieving the Gap Between Needs and Parental Reality Is Essential for Healing and Empowerment

By seeing the parents objectively, individuals can increase their self-awareness and find emotional freedom. This process should involve understanding the reasons behind a parent's emotional limitations without resorting to blame.

"Holding Fantasies About a Parent's Potential to Change Can Hinder Acceptance and Progress"

Dr. Gibson explains that children often cling to the hope that their parents' emotional immaturity is temporary and that if something changed, they would get what they need. However, this “healing fantasy” can impede an individual's acceptance and personal progress. The fantasy may be reinforced by the intermittent positive behavior of the parent, especially in response to material or ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Facing Childhood Reality Over "Healing Fantasies"

Additional Materials

Counterarguments

  • While acknowledging a parent's emotional immaturity is important, it's also possible that some parents may indeed have the capacity for change and growth, and it might not always be a fantasy to hope for improvement in the relationship.
  • The concept of not taking a parent's emotional immaturity as a personal affront might overlook the very real and personal impact that a parent's behavior can have on a child's emotional development.
  • Grieving the gap between needs and parental reality is essential, but it's also important to recognize that healing is not a one-size-fits-all process and some individuals may find empowerment through different means.
  • Understanding a parent's emotional limitations without blame is beneficial, but it's also necessary to acknowledge that holding someone accountable for their actions is not inherently the same as blaming them.
  • While holding onto fantasies about a parent's potential to change can be hindering, it's also true that maintaining hope can be a coping mechanism that provides comfort and sho ...

Actionables

  • Create a personal "emotional history map" to visualize your family dynamics and personal development. Start by drawing a timeline of your life, marking significant emotional events and interactions with your parents. Use colors or symbols to represent different emotions and patterns. This visual aid can help you see the long-term patterns of emotional immaturity in your parents and how it has affected you, fostering acceptance and self-awareness.
  • Develop a "reality acceptance" journaling routine to help you come to terms with your parents' limitations. Each day, write down one aspect of your parents' behavior that you wish could change but recognize as part of their emotional immaturity. Next to it, write an affirmation of acceptance, such as "I accept that my parent may never be empathetic, but I can find empathy within myself and others." This practice encourages facing the truth and can aid in letting go of healing fantasies.
  • Engage in "role-reversal" ex ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
4 Signs of Emotionally Immature Parents & How to Heal

Strategies For Setting Boundaries With Emotionally Immature Parents

Expert Lindsay C. Gibson shares insights on the podcast for listeners struggling with emotionally immature parents, highlighting the importance of establishing personal boundaries while maintaining one’s sense of self.

Develop "Anthropological" Detachment to Avoid Dynamics With Emotionally Immature Parents

Lindsay C. Gibson advocates for developing a sense of "anthropological" detachment when interacting with emotionally immature individuals. She suggests maintaining awareness and objectivity, as if studying a new tribe, in order to not get sucked into the "emotionally immature relationship system."

Mantras and Self-Connection Aid In Staying Centered

Gibson recommends the use of mantras, such as "detach, detach, detach," to help remind oneself to stay emotionally distant and avoid fruitless attempts to change an emotionally immature person’s nature. It is crucial to stay connected to oneself to prevent dissociation in the presence of difficult people. She advises maintaining an active inner dialogue or using physical touch, like rubbing one’s arm, to remain grounded and present during interactions.

Setting Boundaries With Emotionally Immature Parents Mitigates Draining Effects

Mel Robbins and Lindsay C. Gibson explore how recognizing the dynamic with emotionally immature parents can change one's approach within that relationship. Gibson speaks about the possibility of asserting one’s own boundaries, treating oneself and the parents as equally important adults.

Gibson addresses the concept of feeling a moral obligation to satisfy the wants of emotionally immature parents, and the importance of recognizing and resisting this dynamic. She emphasizes that maintaining a relati ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Strategies For Setting Boundaries With Emotionally Immature Parents

Additional Materials

Counterarguments

  • While detachment can be a useful tool, it may not always be the most effective approach for everyone; some individuals may find that engaging with empathy and seeking to understand their parents' perspectives can also be beneficial.
  • Mantras can be helpful, but they might not address the underlying emotional needs or the complexity of the relationship; alternative strategies like therapy or open communication might be necessary.
  • Asserting boundaries is important, but it's also crucial to consider the potential impact on family dynamics and the emotional well-being of all parties involved.
  • Treating oneself and parents as equally important adults is a sound principle, but it may not account for cultural or familial expectations that place different values on the roles of parents and children.
  • Setting realistic expectations is key, but what is realistic can vary greatly from one individual or family to another, and some may find that more flexible or open-ended approaches work better for them.
  • Determining the right amount of distance can be helpful, but it may not be a one-size-fits-all solution; some individuals may benefit from closer engagement or more frequent contact, depending on the nature of their relationship.
  • Meeting in neutral locations can help maintain one's sense of identity, but for some, home environments or familiar settings may be more conducive to healing an ...

Actionables

  • Create a personal "emotional safety plan" that outlines steps to take when feeling overwhelmed by others' immaturity. This plan might include a list of calming activities, a set of affirmations to remind yourself of your worth, and contact information for a supportive friend or therapist to call. For example, your plan could start with deep breathing exercises, followed by repeating affirmations like "I am in control of my emotions," and if needed, stepping out to call a friend who understands your situation.
  • Designate a "self-reflection journal" to document interactions with difficult individuals and your responses to them. Use this journal to track patterns in your behavior and feelings, and to brainstorm alternative ways to assert your boundaries or disengage from unproductive interactions. For instance, after a challenging family gathering, you might write down what triggered your stress and how you reacted, then reflect on how you might handle a similar situation differently in the future.
  • Develop a "relationship barometer" tool to help gauge the health of your interactions with emotional ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
4 Signs of Emotionally Immature Parents & How to Heal

Grieving Process of an Emotionally Deprived Childhood

Reflecting on a childhood lacking emotional support can bring about a profound sense of loss. Lindsay C. Gibson speaks to this experience, noting that the journey is marked not by a quest to fix the past, but by self-compassion and embracing an authentic self.

Grieving an Emotionally Deprived Childhood

Many individuals who come to recognize the emotional inadequacies of their upbringing undergo a form of grieving. The realization of what was absent during childhood—a time when emotional support is crucial—can evoke a deep sense of grief and loss.

Grief Often Involves Shame and Blame, Requiring Self-Compassion and Acceptance

Gibson points out that those conditioned not to take their feelings seriously might struggle with self-empathy, which is crucial for processing grief. The grieving process often involves dealing with shame and internalized self-judgment. Trauma can induce shame without active shaming, leading to a misguided belief that one's misfortunes are due to inherent personal flaws. Gibson highlights the importance of compassionate self-attitudes, recognizing that individuals did the best they could with what they knew, and to continue trying rather than rejecting parts of the self.

Grieving For Healing and Authentic Self-Development, Not a "Healed Parent" Fantasy

Rather than pursuing a fantasy where parents are magically healed and p ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Grieving Process of an Emotionally Deprived Childhood

Additional Materials

Actionables

  • Create a personal growth journal to track your emotional development and self-compassion journey. Start by writing down instances where you felt a lack of emotional support, how it made you feel, and how you can show yourself compassion in those moments. Over time, this will help you recognize patterns, celebrate your growth, and reinforce self-empathy.
  • Develop a "Grief and Growth" playlist with songs that resonate with your feelings of loss and those that inspire self-acceptance and growth. Music can be a powerful tool for processing emotions, and curating a playlist allows you to access these therapeutic benefits whenever you need them.
  • Engage in a weekly "Emotional Ma ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free

Create Summaries for anything on the web

Download the Shortform Chrome extension for your browser

Shortform Extension CTA