Podcasts > The Mel Robbins Podcast > Trust Your Gut: How to Make a Hard Decision

Trust Your Gut: How to Make a Hard Decision

By Stitcher

In this episode of The Mel Robbins Podcast, Robbins explores the role of intuition in decision-making, explaining how it functions as an internal guidance system that responds to energetic signals around us. She examines the relationship between gut instincts and analytical thinking, highlighting how each approach serves different purposes in the decision-making process.

The episode delves into strategies for handling difficult decisions, particularly when choices feel painful despite being right. Robbins discusses how emotional responses like fear and guilt can delay necessary actions, and offers approaches for building self-trust while making choices aligned with personal values. She presents frameworks for determining when to rely on intuition versus when to employ more careful analysis.

Listen to the original

Trust Your Gut: How to Make a Hard Decision

This is a preview of the Shortform summary of the Apr 28, 2025 episode of the The Mel Robbins Podcast

Sign up for Shortform to access the whole episode summary along with additional materials like counterarguments and context.

Trust Your Gut: How to Make a Hard Decision

1-Page Summary

The Nature and Power of Intuition

Mel Robbins explores how intuition serves as an internal guidance system, explaining its function and importance in decision-making. She describes intuition as an inherent compass that operates like a GPS, responding to energetic signals around us to guide our choices. According to Robbins, this system requires no conscious analysis, leading to instant "just know" moments. She warns that ignoring these intuitive signals can result in feeling stuck and disconnected from our true path.

When to Trust Your Gut Vs. Analyze Decisions

While Robbins strongly advocates for trusting gut instincts, she acknowledges that decision-making isn't always straightforward. She explains that gut decisions tap into a deeper wisdom that already knows what's best for us, and overthinking can lead to paralysis and inaction. However, Robbins also recognizes that high-stakes decisions may require more careful consideration. She suggests using intuition to decide what to do while employing analytical thinking to determine when and how to execute the decision.

Robbins addresses the challenge of making decisions that feel painful even when they're right. She explains that the fear of disappointing others can prevent people from acting on their intuition, and emotional responses like fear and guilt can delay necessary actions. To handle these situations, Robbins suggests separating the decision-making process from its execution. She encourages viewing decisions as data points for personal growth, emphasizing that building self-trust and acceptance is crucial for making choices aligned with personal values.

1-Page Summary

Additional Materials

Counterarguments

  • Intuition may not always be reliable as it can be influenced by biases and past experiences that may not be relevant to the current situation.
  • The concept of "energetic signals" is not scientifically proven and may not be a valid explanation for how intuition works.
  • Instant "just know" moments could sometimes lead to impulsive decisions that haven't been fully thought through.
  • Feeling stuck and disconnected could be due to a variety of factors, not just ignoring intuitive signals.
  • Gut decisions might sometimes conflict with ethical considerations or long-term goals that require more rational deliberation.
  • Overthinking is not the only alternative to intuition; there can be a balanced approach that involves both intuition and critical thinking.
  • Some high-stakes decisions might benefit from intuition, especially when there is not enough information for a fully analytical approach.
  • Analytical thinking can also play a role in deciding what to do, not just when and how to execute decisions.
  • The fear of disappointing others can sometimes be a valid consideration, especially in situations where relationships and social responsibilities are important.
  • Emotional responses are part of being human and can provide valuable information about our values and priorities, not just obstacles to decision-making.
  • Separating decision-making from execution might not always be practical or possible in fast-paced or emergency situations.
  • Viewing decisions solely as data points could lead to a lack of accountability for the outcomes of those decisions.
  • Building self-trust and acceptance is important, but so is being open to feedback and willing to adjust one's course based on new information or perspectives.

Actionables

  • You can enhance your intuition by keeping an intuition journal where you jot down every time you have a "gut feeling" about a decision. Note the outcome of each situation where you followed or didn't follow your intuition. This practice will help you recognize patterns in your intuitive thinking and validate its effectiveness over time.
  • Develop a "decision pause" habit by setting a timer for two minutes before making any significant choice, using this time to check in with your gut feelings. This brief pause allows you to balance your analytical mind with your intuitive insights, ensuring that you're not overthinking to the point of inaction.
  • Create a personal "values map" that outlines your core values and use it as a reference when making decisions. Whenever you're faced with a choice, consult your values map to ensure the decision aligns with what's truly important to you. This tool can help you overcome the fear of disappointing others by providing a clear framework for decision-making based on your personal values.

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
Trust Your Gut: How to Make a Hard Decision

The Nature and Power of Intuition

Robbins delves into the significance of intuition in our lives, how it functions as an internal guidance system, and the consequences of ignoring it.

Intuition Is a Hardwired System That Guides Decision-Making

Robbins is set on unraveling the enigma of intuition and emphasizes the need to comprehend its workings to trust its signals.

Intuition Acts Like a Compass, Reading Energy and Signals to Guide Us

Mel Robbins explains that intuition is an inherent compass within us, serving as an intelligent mechanism aiding our daily decision-making process, much like GPS helps in making the right turns throughout the day. This internal compass operates on scientific principles, comparable to a magnetic compass which aligns with the Earth’s magnetic field; intuition similarly senses the magnetic energy around us, responding to the vibrational energy that guides us towards or away from people and situations.

Instant Intuitive Decisions Require No Conscious Analysis

Intuition requires no deliberate reasoning as it spontaneously leads us to 'just know' moments. Robbins draws upon her personal experience when she immediately sensed that a corporate law firm job was not the right fit for her. She stresses the value of noting physical and emotional reactions as indicators of whether something aligns with our true selves, thus helping us make decisions that do not need conscious deliberation.

Ignoring Intuition Leads To Feeling Stuck, Disconnected, and Dissatisfied

Robbins shares her former struggle with i ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

The Nature and Power of Intuition

Additional Materials

Counterarguments

  • Intuition may be subject to cognitive biases and past experiences that can lead to flawed decision-making.
  • The metaphor of intuition as a compass suggests infallibility, but unlike a compass, intuition is not always reliable and can be influenced by emotions and irrational thoughts.
  • Some decisions, especially complex ones, benefit from conscious analysis and critical thinking rather than solely relying on intuition.
  • The concept of reading energy and signals could be seen as pseudoscientific, as there is no empirical evidence to support the idea that humans can sense magnetic energy in a way that guides decision-making.
  • The notion that ignoring intuition invariably leads to negative outcomes is an oversimplification; sometimes, rational deliberation can prevent impulsive decisions that might lead to regret.
  • The idea that intuition is a complex ...

Actionables

  • You can sharpen your intuition by keeping a decision journal where you note gut feelings about decisions and the outcomes. This practice will help you recognize patterns in your intuitive thinking and learn when your intuition tends to be right or wrong. For example, if you feel uneasy about a project at work, write it down and revisit the entry after the project concludes to evaluate the accuracy of your intuition.
  • Develop a daily habit of 'intuitive meditation' where you sit quietly for a few minutes, focusing on your breath, and then pose a question or decision you're facing to your inner self. Pay attention to the immediate feelings or thoughts that arise without judgment. This could be as simple as deciding which task to prioritize in your day or as complex as considering a career change.
  • Create an 'intuition board' in a visible pla ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
Trust Your Gut: How to Make a Hard Decision

When to Trust Your Gut Vs. Analyze Decisions

Mel Robbins dives into the intricacies of decision-making, exploring when to rely on intuition and when to take a more analytical approach.

Going With Your Gut Instinct Is Best

Robbins emphasizes learning to trust our gut instincts, suggesting that intuition can guide us toward decisions aligned with our values and vision.

Gut Decisions Tap Into Deeper Wisdom

Robbins asserts that your internal compass can indicate whether your life is headed in the right direction, tapping into a deep, intuitive wisdom. She describes this as an inner GPS system that already knows the best decision for you. Robbins shares a personal anecdote where she felt something was wrong with her son and in another case with a career choice, showing that gut feelings are connected to our deep-seated knowledge and understanding.

Overthinking Leads To Paralysis and Prevents Necessary Action

In her guidance, Robbins warns against overthinking, which can lead to second-guessing and inaction. She encourages trusting your intuition and gut, underscoring that it is exhausting and paralyzing to constantly question yourself. Robbins addresses moments when it's crucial to go with your gut to prevent idleness and putting your potential life on hold.

Weighing Pros and Cons Is Prudent

While advocating for the power of gut instinct, Robbins recognizes that not all decisions should be made impulsively.

High-Stakes Decisions Require Careful Consideration

Robbins hints at the necessity of careful consideration, especially under stress and fear, which can lead people to choose the path of least resistance or to avoid decisions altogether. These situations, hinting at high stakes, likely need a more thoughtful approach. She acknowledges that some decisions need planning and it's acceptable to take time to execute a decision responsibly. Through personal examples, Robbins shows that engaging in anal ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

When to Trust Your Gut Vs. Analyze Decisions

Additional Materials

Counterarguments

  • Trusting gut instincts may not always be reliable as they can be influenced by biases and emotions that may not reflect the best decision.
  • Gut decisions, while tapping into intuition, may overlook important information that could be critical to making a well-informed choice.
  • Overthinking can indeed lead to paralysis, but a certain level of critical thinking is necessary to avoid making hasty decisions that have not been fully considered.
  • While high-stakes decisions do require careful consideration, not all decisions categorized as high-stakes are clear-cut, and sometimes a blend of intuition and an ...

Actionables

  • Develop a "gut check" journal to record and reflect on instinct-driven decisions. Start by jotting down every time you make a decision based on your gut feeling. Note the context, what your intuition told you, and the outcome. Over time, review your journal to identify patterns in your instinctual decision-making and how often it aligns with your values and vision.
  • Create a "decision balance sheet" for complex choices to weigh intuition against analysis. When faced with a high-stakes decision, draw a two-column table. In one column, list the insights from your gut instincts, and in the other, write down the results of your analytical thinking. This visual aid can help you balance emotional and rational elements before making a final decision.
  • Practice the "five-minute rule" to ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
Trust Your Gut: How to Make a Hard Decision

Navigating Difficult, Conflicted Decisions

Navigating difficult decisions can be an emotionally taxing experience. Mel Robbins delves into how individuals can approach conflicted decisions that may feel wrong or painful even when they are the correct choices for personal growth and alignment.

Difficult Decisions Can Feel Wrong or Painful, Even When Right

Discomfort From Disappointing Others Can Hinder Acting On Intuition

Robbins talks about the struggle of making difficult decisions, such as breakups, leaving jobs, and telling the truth. She explains that emotions can keep people in situations for too long, especially when fearing the disappointment of others. This discomfort from potentially upsetting others can hinder acting on one's intuition. Robbins acknowledges that some decisions have a delayed response due to emotional storms like fear and guilt, which can stop people from taking the action they intuitively feel is right.

Differentiating Decision-Making and Its Execution Fosters Clarity and Courage

Robbins discusses the importance of distinguishing what decision to make from when and how to execute it. This differentiation fosters clarity and courage because while intuition informs the decision, the brain figures out its implementation. She suggests that understanding this distinction is crucial in decision-making and provides the clarity and resoluteness needed to carry out tough decisions.

Trusting Our Ability to Handle Outcomes

Viewing Decisions as Data Points For Growth Reduces Fear Of Making "Wrong" Choices

Robbins encourages listeners to view each decision as a data point for growth, which can significantly reduce the fear of making "wrong" choices. Recognizing that making no decision is itself a decision to stay where you are is crucial. She implies that every decision, regardless of outcome, shapes the future self and is an opportunity for progre ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Navigating Difficult, Conflicted Decisions

Additional Materials

Counterarguments

  • While differentiating decision-making from execution can provide clarity, it may also lead to overthinking and procrastination if one becomes too focused on the "perfect" way to execute a decision.
  • Viewing decisions as data points for growth is a positive mindset, but it may not fully acknowledge the real and sometimes severe consequences that can result from certain decisions.
  • The concept of making no decision being a decision in itself can be overly simplistic, as some situations may require time and reflection before a clear path forward emerges.
  • Trusting oneself to handle outcomes is important, but it is also important to recognize that seeking help and advice from others can be a valuable part of the decision-making process.
  • Emphasizing self-trust and intuition might sometimes lead to ignoring empirical evidence or expert advice that could inform better decision ...

Actionables

  • You can create a "Decision Diary" to track and reflect on your choices, noting the emotions and outcomes associated with each decision. This practice helps you see patterns in your decision-making process and understand how past decisions have contributed to your growth. For example, after deciding to take on a new project at work, write down how you felt making that decision, any fears or discomforts, and revisit the entry later to see how the decision played out.
  • Develop a "Discomfort Scale" to quantify your feelings when facing tough choices. Rate your discomfort on a scale from 1 to 10 and describe the emotions you're experiencing. This can help you recognize when discomfort is influencing your decisions and encourage you to push through the discomfort when it's aligned with your values. For instance, if considering a career change makes you feel at a discomfort level of 8 due to fear of the unknown, you might decide to explore this option further rather than immediately dismissing it.
  • Engage in "Future-Self Visualiza ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free

Create Summaries for anything on the web

Download the Shortform Chrome extension for your browser

Shortform Extension CTA