5 Signs Of An Incompatible Relationship & 3 Signs You’ve Found “The One”
In this episode of The Mel Robbins Podcast, Robbins explores the signs that a relationship may be incompatible—or on track to becoming "The One." She discusses recognizing when fundamental values or visions for the future no longer align, emphasizing that sometimes ending an unfulfilling relationship is the most compassionate choice. The episode also provides strategies for having productive conversations about difficult topics, such as using empathy to understand your partner's perspective or discussing potential scenarios involving major life changes.
Additionally, Robbins delves into determining dealbreakers in relationships. She highlights the importance of identifying your core values and needs, as well as accepting your partner for who they are rather than trying to change them. Ultimately, Robbins affirms that having the courage to end a relationship, though painful, may sometimes be necessary if it no longer enhances the lives of both people.
This is a preview of the Shortform summary of the Dec 2, 2024 episode of the The Mel Robbins Podcast
Sign up for Shortform to access the whole episode summary along with additional materials like counterarguments and context.
1-Page Summary
Identifying and overcoming relationship challenges
Recognizing incompatibility
Mel Robbins emphasizes the importance of accepting when a relationship is no longer a good fit. Key indicators include feeling unable to be yourself, lacking shared values or vision for the future. While working through issues is advisable when both partners are willing, sometimes ending an unfulfilling relationship is the most loving choice.
Addressing personal growth
Robbins suggests the "ABC loop": apologize, back off, celebrate small changes. This indirect approach allows change to occur through acceptance rather than pressure. If partners diverge in self-improvement or core values emerge as incompatible, compatibility must be reassessed.
Strategies for productive conversations
Communicating with empathy
Rather than criticism, Robbins recommends using empathy and open-ended questions to understand your partner's perspective without judgment. This creates an environment for honest sharing.
Discussing difficult topics
For complex issues like children or lifestyle changes, have open conversations exploring potential scenarios. Allow your partner space to fully express their stance. Observe whether compromise is possible or if the difference is irreconcilable.
Determining dealbreakers
Identifying core values and needs
Understand and honor your own dreams, goals and non-negotiable values, according to Robbins. Compromising these leads to resentment. Attempting to alter your partner based on their potential undermines the relationship.
Accepting your partner
Change arises naturally, not through pressure. Embrace your partner for who they truly are now, not who you wish them to become. Exerting influence often creates resistance.
Ending relationships with courage
Although painful, Robbins affirms ending an incompatible relationship is sometimes necessary. Have difficult conversations to face truths about inadequacies. A relationship should enhance both people - consistent negativity signals it may not be right.
1-Page Summary
Additional Materials
Counterarguments
- Acceptance of incompatibility might be premature without thorough communication and effort to resolve differences.
- Some relationships may benefit from professional help such as couples therapy before deciding on incompatibility.
- The "ABC loop" might not be effective in all situations, especially if the issues are deep-rooted and require more direct intervention.
- Communication with empathy is important, but it should be balanced with assertiveness to ensure that one's own needs are also expressed and met.
- Open discussions about difficult topics are crucial, but they should be accompanied by actionable steps and willingness to compromise from both sides.
- Identifying core values and needs is essential, but flexibility in a relationship can also be important as people grow and change over time.
- Accepting your partner as they are is important, but mutual growth and support for personal development can also be a key part of a healthy relationship.
- Ending relationships requires courage, but it is also important to ensure that all other avenues for resolution have been explored.
- While a relationship should enhance both people, it is also normal for relationships to go through challenging periods where this may not always feel the case.
Actionables
- You can create a "relationship roadmap" by drawing a visual representation of where you see yourself and your partner in the future, including personal and shared goals. This visual tool helps you assess whether your paths align or diverge, making it easier to see if your relationship is enhancing both individuals or if it's time to reassess compatibility. For example, use different colors for individual goals and shared visions, and notice if there's more of one color than the other.
- Develop a "values inventory" by listing your core values and needs, then rank them in order of importance to you. Regularly update this list and compare it with your partner's to ensure ongoing alignment. This can be as simple as writing them on sticky notes and rearranging them on a board as your priorities shift.
- Initiate a monthly "dreams and goals" session with your partner where you both share and discuss your aspirations. This creates a dedicated time for honest sharing and can help you both understand if you're supporting each other's dreams or if the relationship is becoming a hindrance. Keep a shared journal to track these sessions and reflect on your growth and compatibility over time.
Get access to the context and additional materials
Identifying and overcoming common relationship challenges
Relationships can bring immense joy and fulfillment, but like any complex dynamic, they may also face challenges. Mel Robbins offers insights into identifying when a relationship is no longer a good fit and addresses issues of compatibility and personal growth.
Recognizing when a relationship is no longer a good fit
Accepting that not all relationships are meant to last forever is essential, even if the person is generally "good" or the relationship was once fulfilling. Mel Robbins advises to consider whether you can truly be yourself around your partner and if they bring out the best in you. Feeling insecure, ignored, or unable to voice concerns is a strong indicator that the relationship may not be the right fit. Compatibility requires attraction, commitment, and a shared vision of the future. If your relationship lacks these elements, there may be more tension and dissatisfaction than necessary.
Mel Robbins emphasizes the importance of acknowledging when the dynamic feels off and the value in working on these issues if both partners are willing. One should not cling to the potential of a partner or a fantasy over accepting them as they truly are. Furthermore, Robbins highlights that sometimes the most loving action might be to end a relationship if it’s no longer conducive to personal happiness.
Addressing issues with a partner's health, lifestyle, or personal growth
Influencing your partner's behavior can be approached using the ABC loop (apologize, back off, celebrate small changes). This method allows change to be nurtured indirectly, encouraging acceptance and giving space for the partner to make changes of their own volition, rather than under pressure.
If one partner is focused on self-improvement and the other is not, this can create tension and raise questions about compatibility. Robbin ...
Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary
Identifying and overcoming common relationship challenges
Additional Materials
Clarifications
- Differences in core values and long-term goals can be dealbreakers in relationships because they represent fundamental beliefs and aspirations that shape a person's identity and life direction. When partners have conflicting core values, such as views on family, religion, or ethics, it can lead to ongoing disagreements and a lack of alignment in decision-making. Similarly, disparities in long-term goals, like career ambitions, lifestyle preferences, or desired living locations, can create significant challenges in building a shared future together. Resolving these differences often requires deep reflection and compromise to ensure both individuals feel fulfilled and supported in the relationship.
- Scrutinizing shared vision in a relationship involves closely examining whether both partners have similar goals, values, and aspirations for the future. Reconciling differences means finding ways to address and ...
Counterarguments
- Not all relationships are meant to last forever, but sometimes perseverance through difficult times can strengthen a bond.
- Being able to be oneself around a partner is important, but relationships also involve compromise and growth, which might mean not always feeling 100% at ease.
- A partner might not always bring out the best in you, but they could challenge you to address your own issues and weaknesses.
- Feeling insecure or unable to voice concerns might indicate personal areas of growth as much as issues within the relationship.
- Compatibility is complex and might not always manifest as a clear shared vision of the future; it can also be about navigating differences and growing together.
- Acknowledging when a relationship feels off is important, but it's also crucial to distinguish between temporary challenges and fundamental incompatibility.
- Clinging to the potential of a partner or a fantasy can be problematic, but having hope and working towards a common goal can sometimes lead to positive change.
- Ending a relationship can be the most loving action for personal happiness, but it's also important to consider the commitment and the possibility of reconciliation.
- The ABC loop might not be effective in all situations, and direct communication can sometimes be necessary to address behavioral issues.
- If one partner is focused on self-improvement and the other is not, it doesn't necessarily mean they are incompatible; people grow at different rates and in different ways.
- Sha ...
Get access to the context and additional materials
Strategies for having productive relationship conversations
Approaching conversations with empathy and a willingness to listen
Knowing how to communicate effectively in relationships is a key part of maintaining a healthy partnership. Robbins suggests that rather than applying pressure or criticizing a partner, it is more effective to approach them with empathy. This entails providing encouragement and creating an environment that motivates them to want to change on their own.
Asking open-ended questions to understand your partner's perspective
By asking open-ended questions, you can create space for your partner's honest thoughts and feelings. Robbins recommends beginning interactions with an apology for any past behavior, such as being pressuring or passive-aggressive, and then moving forward by asking questions that facilitate understanding without judgment.
Avoiding judgment or criticism and focusing on finding common ground
Understanding your partner's perspective is about truly listening, not guiding them to a specific answer. Robbins emphasizes the importance of owning up to your side of any pressures in the relationship and apologizing authentically. Her approach focuses on a desire to genuinely understand your partner, rather than judging or pushing them toward an outcome you seek.
Communicating about difficult topics like the desire for children or major lifestyle changes
When dealing with complex issues such as life goals or major decisions, it's vital to walk the fine line between influence and pressure. Robbins suggests using open-ended questions to engage in a meaningful conversation about sensitive topics like the desire for children, considering various future scenarios and their implications.
Giving your partner space to share their honest thoughts and feelings
It's important to allow your partner to express themselves fully in response to these discussions. Communicating honestly—and seeing whether your partner is willing to engage and work on the relationship together—is central to understa ...
Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary
Strategies for having productive relationship conversations
Additional Materials
Counterarguments
- While empathy is important, it's also necessary to maintain personal boundaries and not always prioritize a partner's feelings over one's own needs.
- Encouragement and motivation can be helpful, but individuals are ultimately responsible for their own change, and one cannot always influence another's desire to change.
- Open-ended questions are useful, but there are times when direct communication and clear expectations are necessary to resolve issues.
- Apologizing for past behavior is important, but it should be sincere and not used as a strategy to manipulate the conversation.
- Finding common ground is ideal, but it's also important to acknowledge and respect differences rather than always seeking to find a compromise.
- Owning up to pressures in the relationship is good, but it's also crucial to address the root causes of those pressures and not just the symptoms.
- Discussing difficult topics requires sensitivity, but avoiding pressure does not mean avoiding assertiveness or failing to express one's own needs and concerns.
- Giving space for a partner to share thoughts and feelings is important, but there should also be a balance where both ...
Actionables
- Develop a "conversation journal" to reflect on your interactions, noting moments where empathy was successfully integrated or could be improved. Use this journal after conversations to self-assess and plan how to better approach future discussions with empathy. For example, if you noticed you were defensive during a talk about household chores, write down how you could have acknowledged your partner's efforts or frustrations instead.
- Create a "motivation map" for your partner, where you identify their goals and aspirations, and find ways to support them without imposing your own agenda. This could be a visual board or a digital document where you list their expressed interests and brainstorm ways you can encourage their growth in these areas, like signing them up for a newsletter related to their hobby or sharing an inspiring story relevant to their goals.
- Initiate a monthly "relationship checkpoint" where you and your ...
Related Shortform Content
Get access to the context and additional materials
Determining dealbreakers and making difficult relationship decisions
In a candid discussion, Mel Robbins delves into how to manage change in a partner and how to address dealbreakers within relationships.
Identifying your core values, needs, and dealbreakers
Robbins emphasizes the need to understand deeply one's core values and dealbreakers. She suggests using the ABC loop to help determine whether an issue, like a partner neglecting their health, is a non-negotiable dealbreaker. She clarifies that dealbreakers arise when one's non-negotiables lead to ongoing complaints and resentment.
Reflecting on core values, Robbins highlights that recognizing and honoring your dreams, goals, and values is pivotal. If you find yourself compromising these to stay in a relationship, or continuously trying to change your partner, it might be time to consider whether the relationship aligns with who you are. Robbins implies that such sacrifice can lead to resentment, suggesting, "If you have to give up your dreams in order to stay with this person, this is not going to work."
Honoring your truths vs. altering for acceptance
Robbins firmly believes that attempting to mold your partner or yourself to fit a perceived potential only leads to mutual dissatisfaction. Embracing who they are at present, rather than who you would like them to be, is crucial for a relationship to thrive authentically.
Accepting your partner as they are, not chasing their potential
Emphasizing acceptance, Robbins points out that individuals change on their own initiative and not due to pressure from a partner. If your desires for your partner's change stem from your fears or a projection of their potential, it risks undermining the relationship's foundation. You should thus regard who your partner is right now, instead of an imagined ideal.
The risks of pressured transformation
By trying to exert influence or pressure for change, you risk creating resistance. Robbins advises on the strategy of leading by example, making desired behaviors appealing and effortless in the hope of inspiring natural change.
Having the courage to end a relationship that is no longer working, even if it's painful
Robbins states that ending a relationship, although emotionally difficult, is sometimes the necessary course of action. Robbins underscores the importance of aligning with one’s truth and not merely clinging to a relationship out of fear of being alone. She promotes the idea of fighting for what is true to you and that it is essential to be with a partner who respects and is kind to you.
Face tough questions with integrity
Instead ...
Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary
Determining dealbreakers and making difficult relationship decisions
Additional Materials
Counterarguments
- While understanding core values is important, it's also necessary to recognize that values can evolve over time, and a rigid adherence to a set list of dealbreakers might prevent personal growth or the deepening of a relationship.
- The ABC loop might not be a comprehensive tool for everyone; some individuals may require more nuanced strategies to understand their feelings and relationship dynamics.
- Compromise is often a key component of successful relationships, and while it's important not to lose oneself, finding a balance between personal values and shared goals can be healthy.
- Attempting to change a partner can be problematic, but relationships often involve growth and development, which can sometimes be facilitated by partners who encourage and support change in each other.
- Accepting a partner as they are is important, but it's also natural to desire growth and improvement in a relationship, which can include supporting a partner through changes they wish to make.
- While individuals change on their own initiative, relationships are partnerships where mutual support can play a critical role in facilitating positive change.
- The advice to avoid pressuring a partner for change is sound, but there can be situations where discussing and working on issues together is necessary for the health of the relationship.
- Ending a relationship can be the right decision, but it's also important to consider the potential for reconciliation and repair, especially when both partners are willing to work through difficulties.
- Facing tough questions with integrity is crucial, but it ...
Actionables
- Create a personal values vision board to visually affirm what's important to you; gather images, quotes, and symbols that represent your core values and dealbreakers, and display them in a space where you'll see them daily to reinforce your commitment to these principles.
- Develop a "relationship journal" where you document your feelings, experiences, and reflections on your interactions with your partner; use this as a tool to track patterns that either align with or contradict your values and dealbreakers, helping you to make informed decisions about your relationship.
- Design a "truth alignment" ritual where you s ...
Get access to the context and additional materials
Create Summaries for anything on the web
Download the Shortform Chrome extension for your browser
