The Surprising Psychology Behind the Secrets Everyone Keeps | The Mel Robbins Podcast
Join Mel Robbins and guest Dr. Michael Slepian in an episode of "The Mel Robbins Podcast," as they delve into the mysterious realm of secrets. Explore the intricate psychology of secrets, the emotional toll they harvest, and their impact on self-esteem, health, and relationships. Armed with his personal experiences and comprehensive research, Slepian uncovers the truth about the average individual's spectral collection of secrets, shining a light on how secrets form, their nature, and the burden they impose on the beholders.
In the latter part of the podcast, Robbins and Slepian grapple with the long-term effects of family secrets, particularly on children. They scrutinize the emotional harm that stems from secret-keeping, including feelings of shame, isolation, and falseness. With their personal regrets and lessons learned presented openly, they propose strategies for coping with past and present secrets, emphasizing the power and importance of open communication.
This is a preview of the Shortform summary of the Aug 31, 2023 episode of the The Mel Robbins Podcast
Sign up for Shortform to access the whole episode summary along with additional materials like counterarguments and context.
1-Page Summary
Understanding Secrets
The Psychology and Impact of Secrets
In an episode of "The Mel Robbins Podcast," guest Dr. Michael Slepian delves into the psychology behind secrets and the impact they have on individuals. His discussion is informed by his personal experience when he learned during a family phone call that his father was not his biological parent. This poignant revelation prompts a deeper exploration into the nature of secrets, how they are perceived as a physical burden, and the potential harm they can inflict on the self-esteem, health, and relationships of those who harbor them.
The Nature and Formation of Secrets
Slepian's comprehensive research suggests that the average individual has around thirteen secrets at any given time, five of which have never been shared. These secrets span a spectrum of topics, from serious lies, undisclosed romantic desires, and financial struggles to hidden family stories, personal dissatisfaction, mental health issues, and breaches of trust. Interestingly, human secrecy mirrors behavior observed in other species like chimpanzees and developmentally emerges in childhood once children cultivate an understanding of their cognitive individuality from others.
The act of keeping secrets often encapsulates more than mere concealment. The intention behind hiding something forms the basis of a secret, regardless of whether it remains successfully hidden or not. Instances of positive secrets do exist - such as surprise events or measures taken to safeguard relationships - but most secrets teeter towards negativity and can exert an emotional toll.
Personal Experiences with Secrets
Personal Secrets in Relationships and Families
Mel Robbins offers her perspective by sharing personal experiences of infidelity from her past and the immense relief that accompanies the revealing of secrets. Drawing from Slepian's research findings, she discusses the emotional harm that secret-keeping can incur, which include feelings of shame, isolation, and falseness that resurge every time the secret enters one's thoughts.
Slepian contends the importance of sharing these burdens, not just for relief but to elicit empathy or reassurances from others. He observes that even thoughts or feelings can evolve into burdensome entities if perceived as secrets. A crucial distinction they both make is the difference between secrets and privacy. While privacy involves information that simply hasn't come up in conversation, a secret necessarily involves deliberate withholding of information in relevant discussions.
Secrets and their Impact on Children
Significant moments in the episode involve the discussion of family secrets, their particular emotional weight, and their impacts on children. Slepian and Robbins strongly advise against certain secretive practices that lead to problems like children equating loyalty and compliance with love. Emphasis is placed on the long-term effects of harboring family secrets, as it can propagate a problematic problem-solving strategy - secrecy, which often aggravates an already strained situation.
Consequences and Coping Strategies
Making Sense of the Past: Regrets and Lessons Learned
In a segment dedicated to past regrets, both speakers open up about their own mistakes and oversights. Slepian confessed to infidelity in past relationships, a regret that he still grapples with. He recounted a time where he revisited previous correspondences with an ex-partner which led him to reassess his actions at the end of that relationship. This encounter was confronting for him, as he had to come to terms with recurring patterns of behavior even in his current relationship.
Mel, on her part, shared her experience of a distressing breakup during her college years, which was complicated by the recent suicide of her then-boyfriend's father. Mel expressed regret for not recognizing how her untreated childhood trauma had influenced her relationships and wished she had sought professional help earlier.
Both speakers took their past experiences as opportunities for personal evolution and introspective learning.
The Power of Open Communication Versus Secrecy
In Slepian and Robbins's conversation, they continually underscored the value of open discussion over secrecy. Guided advice was given in hypothetical situations including a teenager confessing to underage drinking or situations of exclusion among friends, emphasizing the importance of supportive responses over punitive reactions.
Seeking Help and Sharing Burdens: Finding Support Systems
As they neared the conclusion of their discourse, both Slepian and Robbins endorsed the consultation with a neutral third party before deciding to reveal a secret. Robbins proposed a 'Coping Compass' as a means of identifying the right support. Their mutual agreement underscored the importance of choosing a confidant carefully, being mindful of not burdening them further. Mel wound up, in a heartfelt move, by offering to become a potential support system for listeners facing challenges with their personal secrets.
1-Page Summary
Additional Materials
Clarifications
- The "Coping Compass" is a concept introduced by Mel Robbins as a tool to help individuals identify the right support when dealing with personal challenges or secrets. It involves considering different directions or options for seeking help, akin to navigating with a compass. By using this metaphorical compass, individuals can assess their support network and choose a confidant who can provide the necessary understanding and assistance without feeling overwhelmed. The idea is to guide individuals towards finding the most suitable person to share their burdens with, ensuring a positive and constructive outcome.
- Dr. Michael Slepian's research indicates that the average person typically holds around thirteen secrets at any given time, with approximately five of these secrets never having been shared. These secrets cover a wide range of topics, from personal dissatisfaction to undisclosed romantic desires and financial struggles. Slepian's work also highlights that the act of keeping secrets can have emotional consequences, impacting self-esteem, health, and relationships. Additionally, he notes that the intention behind hiding something forms the essence of a secret, regardless of whether it remains concealed or not.
- Childhood trauma can impact adult relationships by influencing how individuals form attachments, communicate, and handle conflict. Unresolved trauma may lead to difficulties in trusting others, setting boundaries, and managing emotions within relationships. Individuals with childhood trauma may unknowingly seek out relationships that replicate past negative experiences, perpetuating harmful patterns. Therapy and self-awareness can help individuals recognize and address how their past trauma affects their present relationships.
- Family secrets can lead to problematic problem-solving strategies by fostering a culture of secrecy within the family. This can create an environment where children equate loyalty and compliance with love, potentially distorting their understanding of healthy relationships. The long-term effects of harboring family secrets can exacerbate existing issues by promoting secrecy as a primary coping mechanism. Encouraging open communication within families can help address these challenges and prevent the perpetuation of harmful secretive behaviors.
- The distinction between secrets and privacy lies in the intent behind withholding information. Privacy involves information not shared due to lack of relevance, while secrets involve deliberate concealment in relevant contexts. Privacy is about personal boundaries, while secrets often carry emotional weight and can impact relationships.
Counterarguments
- While the average individual may hold around thirteen secrets, this number can vary greatly depending on cultural, personal, and situational factors, and not everyone may experience the same level of burden from their secrets.
- The comparison of human secrecy to that observed in other species like chimpanzees may oversimplify the complex cognitive and emotional aspects of human secret-keeping.
- The assertion that most secrets teeter towards negativity could be challenged by considering that some secrets may have neutral or even positive effects on individuals, depending on the context and the nature of the secret.
- The idea that sharing secrets is always beneficial for relief and eliciting empathy might not apply in all cases; some individuals may find that sharing secrets leads to unintended consequences or exacerbates their problems.
- The impact of secrets on children and the association of loyalty with love may not be universally applicable, as children's responses to family secrets can be diverse and influenced by a multitude of factors.
- The discussion of past regrets and personal growth may not resonate with everyone, as some individuals may view their past actions differently or may not believe in dwelling on regrets.
- The emphasis on open communication over secrecy does not account for situations where secrecy might be necessary or beneficial, such as in cases of personal safety or professional confidentiality.
- The recommendation to seek help and share burdens with a confidant assumes that a suitable and trustworthy confidant is available, which may not be the case for everyone.
Learn more
Related Shortform Content
Get access to the context and additional materials
Understanding Secrets
The Psychology and Impact of Secrets
In an episode of "The Mel Robbins Podcast," guest Dr. Michael Slepian delves into the psychology behind secrets. He focuses on their prevalence in personal relationships, particularly suspected infidelity.
The discussion is informed by his personal experiences. His emphasis is on approaching suspected infidelity not as an accusation but as a call for transparency, trust, and mutual effort to resolve issues.
Robbins extends the conversation to include the impact secrets can have on individuals. She discusses 'self-estrangement' that can occur when secrets are suppressed. The individuals disconnect from their self-identity, leading to a deterioration of self-trust pertaining to their life experiences.
The Nature and Formation of Secrets
Slepian's comprehensive research suggests that the average individual has around thirteen secrets at any given time, five of which have never been shared. These secrets span a spectrum of topics, from serious lies, undisclosed romantic desires, and financial struggles to hidden family st ...
Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary
Understanding Secrets
Additional Materials
Clarifications
- When individuals suppress secrets, they may experience 'self-estrangement,' a sense of disconnect from their true selves due to hiding important aspects of their lives. This can lead to a breakdown in self-trust and a feeling of being disconnected from their authentic identity. Self-estrangement can result in internal conflict and a lack of alignment between one's hidden truths and their outward persona. It can contribute to feelings of isolation and a fragmented sense of self.
- The comparison of holding onto secrets to carrying a physical weight suggests that the emotional burden of keeping secrets can feel heavy and oppressive, impacting one's mental and phys ...
Counterarguments
- While suspected infidelity might be approached with a call for transparency, it's important to consider that accusations can sometimes stem from insecurities or misunderstandings, and addressing these underlying issues might be as important as discussing the suspicions themselves.
- The concept of 'self-estrangement' due to secrets is compelling, but it's also possible that some individuals may compartmentalize or rationalize their secrets without experiencing a significant impact on their self-identity or self-trust.
- The claim that the average individual has around thirteen secrets is based on research, but this number could vary widely among different populations and cultures, and the methodology for determining such a statistic could be challenged.
- Comparing the burden of secrets to carrying a physical weight is a metaphor that may not resonate with everyone, as some people might find that keeping certain secrets can also provide a sense of control or protection.
- While human secrecy is compared to behavior in other species like chimpanzees, it' ...
Learn more
Related Shortform Content
Get access to the context and additional materials
Personal Experiences with Secrets
Personal Secrets in Relationships and Families
Mel Robbins offers her perspective by sharing personal experiences of infidelity from her past, the immense relief of revealing secrets, and the emotional harms secret-keeping can incur.
Building on Slepian's research findings and his own experiences, Robbins discusses how secrecy induces feelings of shame, isolation, and falseness that resurge every time the secret enters one's thoughts.
One profound instance she references is a family secret from Michael Slepian about his grandparents not being genetically related to him. This revelation significantly altered his understanding of family bonds.
Slepian stresses the importance of initial discussions on charged issues, such as infidelity. He emphasizes that these discussions should be presented not as an accusation but as a desire for transparency and mutual effort to resolve issues.
Secrets and their Impact on Children
Significant moments in the episode involve discussions on family s ...
Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary
Personal Experiences with Secrets
Additional Materials
Clarifications
- Slepian's research findings focus on the psychological impacts of keeping secrets, particularly how secrecy can lead to feelings of shame, isolation, and inauthenticity. His work highlights the emotional toll that secrets can take on individuals and the importance of open communication in relationships. Slepian's research underscores the significance of addressing sensitive topics like infidelity openly and honestly to promote transparency and trust. By studying the effects of secrecy, Slepian sheds light on how hidden information can affect individuals' well-being and relationships.
- Secrecy can lead to feelings of shame because individuals may believe that their secrets are inherently bad or wrong. Isolation can result from keeping secrets as individuals may feel disconnected from others due to the need to hide aspects of themselves. Falseness can arise as individuals may feel inauthentic or like they are living a lie by concealing important information. These emotions can intensify each time the secret resurfaces in their thoughts.
- Secrecy can lead to emotional harm by triggering feelings of shame, isolation, and inauthenticity. Keeping secrets can create a sense of inner turmoil and distress, as individuals may constantly worry about the repercussions of their hidden truths. The burden of maintaining a secret can weigh heavily on one's mental and emotional well-being, impacting relationships and self-perception. When secrets are kept, individuals may struggle with feelings of disconnection from others and a lack of trus ...
Counterarguments
- While revealing secrets can provide relief, it can also lead to new complications and hurt feelings, suggesting that the context and manner of revealing secrets are critical.
- Some secrets may be kept to protect individuals from harm or to wait for a more appropriate time for disclosure, indicating that secrecy is not always associated with negative feelings.
- The idea that all family secrets are harmful can be challenged by the notion that some secrets may actually protect family bonds or individual members.
- Discussions on sensitive issues like infidelity are important, but the approach to these discussions can vary greatly depending on cultural norms and individual personalities.
- The impact of family secrets on children can be complex, and in some cases, children may be resilient or unaffected by certain secrets.
- The assertion that involving children in family secrets is always detrimental may not account for situations where children are included in a way that is age-appropriate and help ...
Learn more
Related Shortform Content
Get access to the context and additional materials
Consequences and Coping Strategies
Making Sense of the Past: Regrets and Lessons Learned
In a segment dedicated to past regrets, both speakers open up about their own mistakes and oversights. Slepian confessed to infidelity in past relationships, a regret that he still grapples with. Slepian shared a time where he revisited previous correspondences with an ex-partner which led him to reassess his actions at the end of that relationship. Revisiting the past helped him recognize troubling patterns of behavior persisting even in his current relationship.
Mel, on her part, shared her experience of a distressing breakup during her college years, which was complicated by the recent suicide of her then-boyfriend's father. Mel expressed regret for not recognizing how her untreated childhood trauma had influenced her relationships and wished she had sought professional help earlier.
Both speakers took their past experiences as opportunities for personal evolution and introspective learning.
The Power of Open Communication Versus Secrecy
Slepian and Robbins continually emphasize the power of open discussion over secrecy. Robbins adds to this by emphasizing the need to openly discuss personal insecurities to ensure a conducive environment for dialogue.
One intriguing takeaway from Slepian's research unveils how significant secrets can cast a daunting shadow over our environment, revealing how openness can effect transformative change.
Narratives surrounding non-matriculation demonstrate that actual reactions are often more benign, and sometimes even positive, countering the fear of imagined negative reactions.
Seeking Help and Sharing Burdens: Finding Support Systems
As they near the conclusion of their discourse, Slepian explained how children who grow up around family secrets often adopt a problem-solv ...
Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary
Consequences and Coping Strategies
Additional Materials
Clarifications
...
Counterarguments
- While personal growth and introspection are valuable, it's important to consider that not everyone may have the resources or support to use their past experiences in this way.
- Open communication is generally beneficial, but there may be circumstances where maintaining privacy is necessary for safety or emotional well-being.
- The idea that actual reactions to secrets are often more positive than feared might not always hold true, as some individuals may face severe repercussions or judgment upon disclosure.
- The strategy of maintaining secrets, as adopted by children in families with secrets, could sometimes be a protective mechanism rather than a maladaptive one, depending on the context.
- While discussing the complexity of darker family secrets is important, it's also crucial to provide clear guidance or resources for individuals facing such situations, as acknowledgment alone may not be sufficient.
- Offering support to listeners is ...
Learn more
Related Shortform Content
Get access to the context and additional materials
Create Summaries for anything on the web
Download the Shortform Chrome extension for your browser
