Can You Be Friends with Your Ex?
In this episode of the On Purpose with Jay Shetty podcast, Shetty explores the complex issue of remaining friends with an ex-partner after a breakup. He examines the common motivations for pursuing this, including a desire for security, comfort, or the hope of reconciliation. The podcast also delves into the signs that indicate one may not yet be ready for a platonic friendship with an ex, such as lingering intense emotions or a failure to address the core issues that led to the relationship's end.
Shetty then provides guidance on establishing a healthy friendship dynamic with a former romantic partner. He emphasizes the need for ample healing time, the importance of setting clear boundaries, and strategies for navigating external factors like shared connections, children, or pets. Throughout the discussion, Shetty aims to help listeners determine whether pursuing friendship with an ex is advisable for their unique situation.
This is a preview of the Shortform summary of the Nov 8, 2024 episode of the On Purpose with Jay Shetty
Sign up for Shortform to access the whole episode summary along with additional materials like counterarguments and context.
1-Page Summary
Motivations for Staying Friends with an Ex
Individuals stay friends with exes for reasons like security, comfort, civility, or unresolved romantic feelings, Jay Shetty and a 2017 study suggest.
Sense of Safety and Stability
Some view staying friends as providing security, even from an unhealthy romance, Shetty notes. The study indicates this desire for a false sense of safety is common.
Comfort and Convenience
Shetty discusses how friendship offers ease and comfort, despite being suboptimal, as people "follow the path of least resistance."
Avoiding Awkwardness
Another motivation is averting public awkwardness when encountering an ex, as Shetty points out.
Unresolved Romantic Desires
Shetty explains some believe remaining close will lead to reconciliation, thinking "they'll finally realize what they're missing."
Signs You're Not Ready for a Friendship with an Ex
If emotions are raw or motivations misguided, you're likely unprepared for a platonic relationship with an ex.
Strong Lingering Feelings
Having intense, conflicted feelings about an ex indicates more time and space is needed before attempting friendship. Struggling to move on is a key sign.
False Hope of Reconciliation
Using friendship solely to rekindle romance means you haven't addressed the relationship's core issues, preventing true readiness.
Alleviating Guilt
Forcing friendship only to ease guilt or be the "good guy" prioritizes self-interest over mutual wellbeing, Shetty warns.
Establishing a Healthy Friendship with an Ex
For an ex-romantic relationship to evolve into a stable friendship takes significant effort and considerations.
Ample Healing Time Needed
Experts recommend 6 months to a year for both people to heal before trying friendship. This time apart allows processing and objectivity.
Boundaries Crucial
Creating clear boundaries defines communication rules. Consistent respect for those boundaries by both parties is vital.
Navigating External Factors
Shared connections like friends, family, and pets create complications requiring compromise and care when ending a romance.
Loss of Mutual Connections
The separation often leads to losing once-shared social circles, a major loss to navigate.
Pet Custody
Pet custody and visitation must be thoughtfully negotiated through compromise.
Considering Children's Interests
If children are involved, putting their interests first is paramount when transitioning the coparenting relationship.
1-Page Summary
Additional Materials
Counterarguments
- While the text suggests that individuals stay friends with exes for security, comfort, civility, or unresolved romantic feelings, it's also possible that some individuals maintain a friendship with an ex due to mature recognition of mutual respect and shared history, without any underlying romantic or self-serving motives.
- The sense of safety and stability gained from staying friends with an ex could be argued as not always false; for some, a continued friendship might provide genuine emotional support and a healthy form of stability post-breakup.
- Friendship with an ex for comfort and convenience might be criticized for overlooking the potential for personal growth that can come from stepping out of one's comfort zone and building new relationships.
- Avoiding awkwardness might not be a strong enough foundation for a lasting friendship, and it could be healthier in some cases to face and overcome the discomfort rather than maintain a friendship to avoid it.
- The belief that staying friends could lead to reconciliation might not always be misguided; there could be instances where time apart and friendship help both parties grow and eventually lead to a healthy reconciliation, although this is likely the exception rather than the rule.
- The recommendation of 6 months to a year of healing time before attempting friendship is arbitrary and may not apply to everyone; some individuals might be ready sooner or may require more time, depending on the context of the breakup and personal emotional resilience.
- Setting clear boundaries is crucial, but the text does not acknowledge that boundaries can also evolve over time as individuals heal and their relationship dynamics change.
- Navigating external factors like shared connections and pet custody is essential, but the text does not consider that some ex-partners might choose to completely disentangle their lives, including giving up shared connections or pets, as a healthier alternative for moving on.
- Putting children's interests first in coparenting is paramount, but the text does not address the complexity of blending new families or partners into this dynamic, which can significantly affect the nature of the friendship and coparenting relationship.
Actionables
- You can create a personal "Friendship Readiness" journal to reflect on your emotions and readiness for a friendship with an ex. Start by writing down your feelings towards your ex and assess if they align more with friendship or unresolved romantic feelings. If you find strong romantic feelings, acknowledge them and consider if more healing time is needed. Use this journal to track your emotional evolution over time, which can help you decide when or if you're ready to pursue a healthy friendship.
- Develop a "Boundary Blueprint" for any future friendships with exes, which includes non-negotiable limits and expectations. Write down what behaviors are acceptable and which ones are not, like late-night calls or discussing new romantic interests. Share this blueprint with your ex if you decide to be friends, to ensure you're both on the same page and to minimize misunderstandings.
- Engage in a "Social Circle Assessment" to understand how a friendship with an ex might impact your mutual connections. List out shared friends, family ties, and any potential complications like pet custody or children. Then, create a plan on how to manage these relationships in a way that respects everyone's feelings and minimizes conflict. This might include setting up specific guidelines for group gatherings or discussing how to handle shared responsibilities.
Related Shortform Content
Get access to the context and additional materials
Motivations and reasons for wanting to be friends with an ex
Individuals have various motivations for wanting to maintain a friendship with an ex-partner. Jay Shetty and a 2017 research study delve into the complexities behind this modern social trend.
Individuals may choose to remain friends with an ex for reasons of security, practicality, civility, or unresolved romantic desires.
Staying friends can provide a sense of safety and stability, even if the romantic relationship was unhealthy.
The 2017 research study and Shetty suggest that one common reason people stay in touch with an ex is the desire for security. Shetty elaborates, "It's not necessarily love or romance, it's a sense of safety and security which humans desire so deeply." Even if a relationship was bad for us, humans sometimes cling to these situations for a false sense of safety.
Maintaining a friendship with an ex can be driven by a desire for comfort and ease, even if the relationship is no longer optimal.
Shetty discusses how staying friends could offer a sense of comfort or convenience, pointing out people's tendency to follow the path of least resistance. He remarks, "How many of you have stayed in a job, a relationship, at a family gathering for far too long because it was comfortable and it was easy, even though it wasn't good for you?"
Some people want to remain friends to avoid awkward or confrontational encounters with their ex in public.
Another motive for remaining friends with an ex is the desire to avoid awkward social interactions, as Shetty notes. "If you're walking down the street and you see your ex coming your way, you don't want to have to dart across the street to avoid having an awkward encounter," he ...
Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary
Motivations and reasons for wanting to be friends with an ex
Additional Materials
Counterarguments
- Individuals may choose not to remain friends with an ex because maintaining a healthy boundary is crucial for emotional recovery and moving on.
- Staying friends for a sense of safety and stability might prevent individuals from addressing underlying issues and hinder personal growth.
- Seeking comfort and ease in a friendship with an ex can sometimes be a form of denial or avoidance of the pain that comes with a breakup, which can delay healing.
- Avoiding awkward or confrontational encounters is not always a sufficient reason to maintain a friendship, as it may no ...
Actionables
- Create a personal "friendship litmus test" to evaluate your motivations for staying friends with an ex. Write down a list of non-romantic qualities you value in friendships, such as trust, mutual support, and shared interests. Compare this list with your current dynamic with your ex to see if the friendship genuinely aligns with these values or if other motivations are at play.
- Develop a "social navigation map" for handling public encounters with an ex. Think about places you both frequent and plan alternative routes or backup plans to minimize discomfort. For example, if you both go to the same gym, consider adjusting your workout times or finding a new class to join that doesn't overlap with your ex's schedule.
- Journal your feelings about the ex regular ...
Related Shortform Content
Get access to the context and additional materials
Signs you're not ready for a friendship with an ex
When a relationship ends, the thought of remaining friends with an ex may be appealing but not always realistic or beneficial. The indicators you're not ready for a friendship with an ex are apparent if emotions are still raw or motivations are misguided.
Strong, conflicted feelings about the ex indicate the need for more time and distance before attempting a friendship.
If you still have strong and conflicted feelings, this is a clear sign that you are not ready to transition into a platonic friendship. Lingering romantic feelings or excessive thoughts about your ex are key indicators that you need more time to heal. Postpone any attempts at establishing a friendship until these feelings have simmered down or passed. Continuing to stalk your ex on social media and playing music you associate with them are signs you haven't moved on.
Moreover, if you're considering reestablishing a friendship because it seems the mature thing to do but are struggling with moving on, this is another sign of unreadiness.
Using a friendship as a means to get back together
If there’s an underlying hope to rekindle the romance through friendship, you’re not ready. Secretly using friendship as a means to get back together will not address the issues that led to the relationship's end. Being friends with an ex can lead to false hopes of reconciliation and can cause you to ignore the important reasons why the relationship ended in the first place.
Attempting a friendship solely to alleviate guilt or to be perceived as the "good guy"
Attempting to form ...
Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary
Signs you're not ready for a friendship with an ex
Additional Materials
Counterarguments
- Some individuals may have the emotional maturity to separate their romantic feelings from platonic ones and can maintain a healthy friendship with an ex.
- Staying connected on social media or enjoying shared music doesn't necessarily mean someone hasn't moved on; it could simply be a sign of appreciating the good memories without desiring to rekindle the relationship.
- The desire to maintain a friendship with an ex for mature reasons, even if one is struggling to move on, could be part of a personal growth process and not necessarily a sign of unreadiness.
- In some cases, friendships between exes can evolve into a healthy space that allows both parties to address and resolve past issues, potentially leading to a better understanding and closure.
- Forming a friendship out of guilt or to be seen as the "good guy" might not always be selfish; it could stem from a genuine concern for the ex-partner's feelings and a desire ...
Actionables
- Create a 'nostalgia-free' playlist with songs that are new to you or unrelated to past relationships to redefine your music listening habits and avoid emotional triggers.
- By curating a playlist of fresh tunes or songs that don't carry any emotional baggage from your past relationship, you can create a new soundtrack for your life that helps you move forward. For example, explore different genres or artists you've never listened to before, and make it a point to listen to this playlist when you're feeling nostalgic.
- Set up a social media detox plan where you unfollow or mute your ex for a set period, replacing that time with a new hobby or self-care activity.
- Temporarily removing your ex from your social media feeds can prevent the temptation to check up on them. During the time you would have spent scrolling through their profiles, engage in a new activity like learning a language, practicing meditation, or starting a fitness challenge to redirect your focus and energy toward personal growth.
- Journal your feelings post-breakup and ...
Related Shortform Content
Get access to the context and additional materials
Practical considerations and steps for establishing a healthy friendship with an ex
After a breakup, moving from a romantic relationship to a stable friendship with an ex-partner involves significant considerations to increase the chances of a successful transition.
It's important to allow significant time, at least 6 months to a year, for both parties to heal and gain perspective before considering a friendship.
Experts recommend a significant healing period, often anywhere from six months to a year, before attempting to establish a friendship with an ex. This time isn't just about the days passing on a calendar but about readiness, recovery, and self-awareness following the end of the romantic relationship. Rushing into a friendship can undermine this process, as both individuals must have moved on and be able to view the relationship objectively before a meaningful platonic relationship can take root.
Rushing into a friendship before both people have fully processed the end of the relationship is unlikely to succeed.
Establishing clear boundaries and expectations is crucial as it defines the method and frequency of communications and interaction. Without mutual understanding and agreement, there's a risk of misunderstandings or crossing lines that could reignite old conflicts or emotions.
Both individuals need to have done the necessary work to move on and view the relationship objectively before a friendship can be viable.
Both parties must be willing to respect the established boundaries consistently; otherwise, the new friendship becomes untenable. Personal growth and perspective are vital at this stage, and boundary-setting is a critical component of that growth.
The impact of external factors, such as mutual friends and family, pets, etc., must be carefully navigated.
When transitioning from a romantic to a platonic relationship, the loss of shared connections, including friends and family, can significantly impact both individuals. It's not uncommon for friends and family members to be inadvertent casualties of a breakup, and the situation can lead to tough choices and the need to navigate mixed allegiances.
The loss of shared connections can be a significant obstacle to overcome when transitioning from a romantic to a platonic relationship.
Pets shared between partners present another complication. I ...
Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary
Practical considerations and steps for establishing a healthy friendship with an ex
Additional Materials
Clarifications
- Transitioning from a romantic relationship to a platonic friendship with an ex involves establishing a new type of connection based on mutual respect, clear boundaries, and emotional detachment. It requires both individuals to have processed the end of the romantic relationship, gained perspective, and be willing to redefine their relationship in a non-romantic way. This transition often involves a period of healing and self-reflection to ensure that both parties are ready to navigate a new dynamic that prioritizes friendship over romantic involvement. Setting clear boundaries, managing external factors like shared friends, family, and pets, and prioritizing the well-being of any children involved are crucial aspects of successfully transitioning to a healthy, platonic relationship.
- In the context of a breakup, pet custody can be emotionally challenging as it involves deciding on visitation or ownership rights for shared pets. This can lead to feelings of loss and sadness, especially for the partner who does not retain custody. Negotiating these arrangements requires sensitivity and compromise to address the emotional attachment and well-being of both parties and the pets involved. The emotional bond with pets can be strong, and navigating pet custody post-breakup may require careful planning and understanding to minimize distress for all parties.
- When transitioning from a romantic relationship to a friendship with an ex-partner, managing the impact of exte ...
Counterarguments
- The recommended healing period of 6 months to a year is not a one-size-fits-all solution; some individuals may require more or less time to heal.
- Some ex-partners may find that maintaining a distance is healthier than attempting a friendship, regardless of the time passed.
- Clear boundaries are important, but they can also evolve over time as individuals grow and their circumstances change.
- The possibility of a successful friendship without having fully moved on suggests that sometimes the process of building a friendship can also contribute to the healing process.
- While respecting boundaries is crucial, it's also important to acknowledge that friendships can sometimes naturally involve a renegotiation of those boundaries.
- External factors like mutual friends and family can sometimes act as a support system rather than an obstacle in transitioning to a platonic relationship.
- Shared connections, such as friends and family, may not necessarily be lost but can be maintained independe ...
Related Shortform Content
Get access to the context and additional materials
Create Summaries for anything on the web
Download the Shortform Chrome extension for your browser
