Podcasts > On Purpose with Jay Shetty > Why There’s No Such thing As the Right Person at the Wrong Time & Why Your Ex Was Never The One

Why There’s No Such thing As the Right Person at the Wrong Time & Why Your Ex Was Never The One

By iHeartPodcasts

In this episode of On Purpose with Jay Shetty, Jay investigates the widely-held notion that timing was the primary factor in failed relationships—the idea of "the right person, wrong time." He explores how nostalgia and idealized memories of past partners can cloud judgment, causing people to focus on potential rather than reality when assessing romantic compatibility.

Shedding light on the often-romanticized views that follow heartbreak, Jay emphasizes the importance of realistic expectations when choosing partners. The episode delves into practical factors to consider when evaluating romantic compatibility, such as mutual goals, willingness to heal and support each other's growth, and having alignment on the essential aspects of a shared life.

Listen to the original

Why There’s No Such thing As the Right Person at the Wrong Time & Why Your Ex Was Never The One

This is a preview of the Shortform summary of the Jul 12, 2024 episode of the On Purpose with Jay Shetty

Sign up for Shortform to access the whole episode summary along with additional materials like counterarguments and context.

Why There’s No Such thing As the Right Person at the Wrong Time & Why Your Ex Was Never The One

1-Page Summary

"Right Person, Wrong Time" Scrutinized

According to Jay Shetty, the notion of "right person, wrong time" regarding past relationships is often an idealized view used to cope with heartbreak. Shetty explains that people focus on a partner's potential rather than their reality, and nostalgia activates reward centers in the brain, comforting us but clouding judgment. He suggests this concept reflects romanticized memories, not an objective view of compatibility.

Nostalgia's Power and Pitfalls

Nostalgia plays a role in shaping perceptions, per Shetty's discussion of Bacho's study. Remembering the past fondly, even life's challenges like parenting, provides an evolutionary benefit by supporting optimism and decisions like having more children. However, excessive nostalgia can become an addictive coping mechanism, leading to unrealistic views and decisions based on an idealized past.

Finding the Truly "Right" Partner

Shetty emphasizes being realistic when choosing partners. The "right person" is often an imaginary ideal, not the real individual. Healthy relationships require accepting mutual imperfections and working through joint strengths, flaws, goals, and challenges—not chasing an imagined perfect partner.

Evaluating Practical Compatibility Factors

Shetty advises considering practical factors when judging compatibility. These include relationship readiness, respecting differing ambitions, willingness to support one another's healing from trauma, and maintaining balanced yet achievable mutual standards. Dismissing someone prematurely for not meeting an idealized checklist may mean overlooking genuine compatibility.

1-Page Summary

Additional Materials

Counterarguments

  • The concept of "right person, wrong time" can sometimes be a valid recognition that external circumstances, rather than compatibility issues, were the primary obstacle in a relationship.
  • Focusing on a partner's potential is not always negative; it can be a sign of seeing the best in others and encouraging growth.
  • Nostalgia may not always cloud judgment; it can also provide valuable insights into what one values in a relationship.
  • The evolutionary benefits of nostalgia suggest it has a complex role in human psychology that isn't solely negative or prone to creating unrealistic views.
  • The idea of an "imaginary ideal" partner dismisses the possibility that some individuals have a clear and realistic understanding of what they want in a partner.
  • Emphasizing imperfections might lead to settling for less than one deserves in a relationship if not balanced with a clear understanding of one's needs and boundaries.
  • Practical compatibility factors are important, but they should not overshadow the intangible elements of connection, such as chemistry and shared values.
  • Supporting each other's healing from trauma is important, but it's also crucial to recognize when a relationship might be hindered by unresolved issues that require individual attention.
  • The advice against dismissing someone for not meeting an idealized checklist could lead to overlooking fundamental incompatibilities in the name of being open-minded.

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
Why There’s No Such thing As the Right Person at the Wrong Time & Why Your Ex Was Never The One

The concept of "right person, wrong time" and how it is often a romanticized view of past relationshi

The concept of "right person, wrong time" in the context of past romantic relationships is scrutinized by Jay Shetty, who suggests that it is often a romanticized view used to cope with the loss of a relationship.

The idea of "right person, wrong time" is often used to make ourselves feel better about past relationships that didn't work out

Jay Shetty explains that people often comfort themselves with the idea that someone was the "right person at the wrong time" because it's more palatable to believe in missed opportunities than in fundamental incompatibility. We tend to focus on the potential we saw in a partner, idealizing who we wanted them to be rather than confronting who they truly were.

Nostalgia can provide a comforting escape from current difficulties

Shetty delves into the psychology of nostalgia, noting its addictive nature as it activates the brain’s reward centers, providing a comforting escape from difficulties faced in the present. However, he warns that over-reliance on nostalgic memories can become a coping mechanism that prevents us from facing reality and moving forward, sometimes clouding our judgment.

The "right person, wrong time" concept is usually more about our own perception

The phrase "right person, wrong time" is often a reflection of romanticized memories and unrealistic perceptions ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

The concept of "right person, wrong time" and how it is often a romanticized view of past relationshi

Additional Materials

Clarifications

  • Jay Shetty is a British author, former monk, and motivational speaker known for his insights on personal development and mindfulness. He gained popularity through social media platforms like YouTube and Instagram, where he shares inspirational content and practical advice on topics such as relationships, mental health, and self-improvement. Shetty often combines his experiences as a monk with modern psychology and philosophy to offer unique perspectives on navigating life's challenges and finding inner peace. His work focuses on helping individuals cultivate a positive mindset, improve their relationships, and lead more fulfilling lives.
  • The concept of "right person, wrong time" suggests that sometimes two individuals may be well-suited for each other, but external circumstances or personal issues prevent the relationship from flourishing. It implies that the timing of the relati ...

Counterarguments

  • While the concept of "right person, wrong time" can be a form of self-comfort, it can also be a legitimate reflection of circumstances where external factors, such as career demands, geographical distance, or personal growth stages, genuinely impede a relationship's success.
  • Nostalgia, though potentially addictive, can also serve as a valuable psychological resource, providing individuals with a sense of continuity and identity, and can even foster resilience by reminding them of happier times and the possibility of future joy.
  • The idea that the "right ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
Why There’s No Such thing As the Right Person at the Wrong Time & Why Your Ex Was Never The One

The role of nostalgia in shaping our perceptions and decision-making, including the tendency to remember the past more positively than it was

Amplification of Positive Memories

Nostalgia, as outlined in Shetty's discussion of Bacho's study, explains that looking back with a sense of warmth and affection, particularly on life's challenges such as parenthood, plays an evolutionary role. This tendency to remember the past more positively than it might have been helps in maintaining a brighter outlook, supporting decisions like having more children despite the known challenges of parenthood.

Evolutionary Advantage of Nostalgia

Shetty talks about nostalgia's ability to amplify the positives and diminish the negatives. By triggering the reward centers in the brain, nostalgia can provide emotional protection against present disappointments and anxieties. However, this can sometimes result in decisions that are not well-suited to current realities, as the fondness for past experiences glosses over the stress, overwhelm, and challenges that were also part of those times.

The Pitfalls of Excessive Nostalgia

Nostalgia as an Addictive Coping Mechanism

Nostalgia can turn into an addictive coping mechanism, as Shetty points out, when individuals regularly trigger these feelings by revisiting old media, listening to familiar music, looking at old photos, or revisiting comforting past environments. While nostalgia can offer a temporary break ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

The role of nostalgia in shaping our perceptions and decision-making, including the tendency to remember the past more positively than it was

Additional Materials

Clarifications

  • Nostalgia's evolutionary role in maintaining a brighter outlook stems from its ability to trigger positive emotions and memories, which can counterbalance present-day challenges. This positive bias towards the past can help individuals cope with stress and uncertainty by providing a sense of comfort and familiarity. By focusing on the positive aspects of past experiences, individuals may feel more optimistic and motivated to navigate current difficulties. This tendency to remember the past more positively than it was can influence decision-making, such as choosing to have children despite the known challenges of parenthood.
  • When we experience nostalgia, it can activate the brain's reward centers, such as the ventral striatum, which are associated with pleasure and positive feelings. This activation can lead to the release of feel-good neurotransmitters like dopamine, reinforcing the positive emotions linked to nostalgic memories. Essentially, nostalgia can trigger a neurological response that makes us feel good and can provide emotional comfort and support during challenging times. This mechanism helps explain why revisiting past memories can evoke strong positive emotions and influence our decision-making processes.
  • Nostalgia as an addictive coping mechanism means that individuals may excessively rely on past memories to escape from present difficulties. This behavior can become a habit, where people repeatedly seek out nostalgic experiences to avoid facing current challenges. Over time, this reliance on nostalgia can hinder personal growth and problem-solving in the present moment. It can lead to a cycle where individuals struggle to confront and address their current realities due to their constant retreat into idealized memories from the past.
  • When individuals have an idealized and romanticized view of the past, they tend to remember things as better than they actual ...

Counterarguments

  • Nostalgia may not always amplify positive memories; some individuals may have a more balanced or even negatively skewed recollection of the past.
  • The evolutionary advantage of nostalgia is not conclusively proven; alternative theories suggest that remembering past hardships accurately can be beneficial for learning and future decision-making.
  • Triggering reward centers in the brain is not unique to nostalgia and can be achieved through various other positive experiences and thoughts.
  • Emotional protection provided by nostalgia could sometimes enhance resilience and coping, rather than merely serving as a shield against present disappointments.
  • Decisions influenced by nostalgia are not inherently ill-suited to current realities; they can sometimes lead to positive outcomes by drawing on past wisdom and experiences.
  • Nostalgia as an addictive coping mechanism may be an overstatement for many individuals who engage with nostalgia in a healthy, balanced way.
  • Regularly triggering nostalgic feelings doe ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
Why There’s No Such thing As the Right Person at the Wrong Time & Why Your Ex Was Never The One

The importance of being realistic about relationships and partners, rather than focusing on their potential or imagined qualities

Shetty emphasizes the importance of being grounded in reality when choosing a partner and building a relationship, warning against the allure of potential and imagined qualities.

The "right person" is often an idealized, imaginary person, rather than the real, flawed individual in front of us.

Shetty advises against becoming attracted to someone’s potential or to the person we wish they could be, rather than accepting them as they truly are. He explains that the tendency to be drawn toward an idealized, imaginary version of a person can distract from the reality of the partner standing before us, along with all of their imperfections and human complexities.

Healthy relationships require acknowledging and working through each other's real strengths, weaknesses, goals, and challenges, not just focusing on an imagined "right person."

Instead of chasing the illusion of the "right person" who fits all our preconceived notions, Shetty encourages listeners to reco ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

The importance of being realistic about relationships and partners, rather than focusing on their potential or imagined qualities

Additional Materials

Counterarguments

  • While being realistic is important, having a vision of potential can sometimes inspire both partners to grow and improve together.
  • Focusing solely on current realities might lead to underestimating the value of personal development and the dynamic nature of individuals in a relationship.
  • Attraction to someone's potential isn't inherently negative; it can be a recognition of their capabilities and a belief in their future growth.
  • Idealizing a partner can sometimes be a reflection of one's values and aspirations, which can be important in finding a compatible match.
  • The concept of the "right person" can be subjective and fluid; what is ideal for one person may be different for another, and this can change over time as individuals evolve.
  • Relationships are not only about accepting current realities but also about supporting each other's dreams and aspirations, which may i ...

Actionables

  • Create a "reality check" list for your current or potential relationship where you note down observed behaviors and qualities of your partner, rather than potential traits. This helps you focus on the present reality of who your partner is. For example, if you admire their kindness, write down specific instances where they've shown kindness, rather than just the idea that they could be kind.
  • Start a weekly "relationship review" with your partner where you both discuss what went well and what challenges you faced. This encourages open communication and ensures you're both acknowledging real strengths and weaknesses. During these sessions, you might talk about how you handled a disagreement that week or how you supported each other through a stressful day.
  • Engage in a pe ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
Why There’s No Such thing As the Right Person at the Wrong Time & Why Your Ex Was Never The One

The impact of practical factors like relationship status, goals, trauma, and standards on determining compatibility and the "right" person

Jay Shetty delves into the nuances of what truly determines compatibility and how often practical factors influence the identification of the "right" person in relationships.

Considering Relationship Status

Shetty underscores that timing isn't always the deciding factor in relationships. Instead, both individuals need to be realistic about their readiness for a relationship. He asserts that if neither person is ready to wait, then it’s a matter of fit rather than timing. Being patient and understanding of someone’s current relationship status can prove crucial, rather than simplistically classifying the situation as the "wrong person at the wrong time."

Valuing Differing Goals

In a healthy relationship, identical personal goals aren't a prerequisite. The "right person," Shetty suggests, is not one with the same ambitions; rather, it’s someone who respects, values, and aids in your pursuits while expecting the same support for their goals. Shetty illustrates this using the example of individuals like Taylor Swift and Travis Kelsey, who, while deeply committed, may not always physically attend each other's events due to their demanding careers but still find ways to support each other's passions.

Healing from Trauma

The journey to heal from trauma is a personal one, yet Shetty points out that the "right person" is a partner willing to be supportive and patient. A successful relationship doesn’t necessitate fully healed individuals. Instead, it features partners who are ready to navigate the healing process together. Through the analogy of rocks smoothing each other in a bag, Shetty conveys that a relationship fosters the mutual growt ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

The impact of practical factors like relationship status, goals, trauma, and standards on determining compatibility and the "right" person

Additional Materials

Clarifications

  • Relationship readiness is about being emotionally prepared and available for a relationship, regardless of external factors like timing. It involves understanding one's own needs, desires, and boundaries before committing to a partnership. Timing, on the other hand, relates to external circumstances such as life stages, career demands, or personal growth that can impact the feasibility of a relationship. It's essential for both individuals to align not just in timing but also in readiness to make a relationship work effectively.
  • An idealized checklist in the context of relationships typically refers to a set of rigid criteria or expectations that someone may have for their ideal partner. This checklist can include sp ...

Counterarguments

  • While relationship readiness is important, timing can also be a significant factor, as life circumstances may not always align for two compatible people.
  • Respecting differing goals is important, but having some shared goals can also be fundamental to ensuring long-term compatibility and direction in a relationship.
  • The idea that the "right person" aids in your pursuits assumes that all individuals want or need support in their goals, which might not always be the case.
  • While mutual support in healing from trauma is valuable, it's also important to recognize that some individuals may need to focus on personal healing before they can contribute to a relationship.
  • The analogy of rocks smoothing each other in a bag might oversimplify the complexities and individual needs involved in the healing process.
  • High standards and expectations, when reasonable and reflective of core values, can be a healthy way to ensure that a re ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free

Create Summaries for anything on the web

Download the Shortform Chrome extension for your browser

Shortform Extension CTA