Podcasts > Jocko Podcast > Jocko Underground: When You Give, Should You Really Not Expect Anything In Return?

Jocko Underground: When You Give, Should You Really Not Expect Anything In Return?

By Jocko DEFCOR Network

In this episode of Jocko Podcast, Jocko addresses parenting challenges and strategies for developing mental toughness in children. The discussion explores how parents can help children manage emotional outbursts and build resilience by allowing them to face appropriate challenges while modeling positive responses to setbacks. The episode also examines the relationship between parents and children regarding financial support and future care.

Building on topics like teaching good manners and handling disappointments, Jocko emphasizes the importance of avoiding transactional relationships between parents and children. He suggests that parents should provide support without expecting anything in return, while raising children who are guided by values rather than obligation. The conversation includes practical strategies for teaching children coping mechanisms and building their confidence over time.

Listen to the original

Jocko Underground: When You Give, Should You Really Not Expect Anything In Return?

This is a preview of the Shortform summary of the Aug 18, 2025 episode of the Jocko Podcast

Sign up for Shortform to access the whole episode summary along with additional materials like counterarguments and context.

Jocko Underground: When You Give, Should You Really Not Expect Anything In Return?

1-Page Summary

Parenting Advice and Strategies

A caller seeks advice on developing mental toughness and resilience in his five-year-old daughter. He's already taken steps to instill good manners, teaching her polite phrases like "Yes, sir" and "Thank you." Building on this foundation, parents can foster resilience by allowing children to face manageable challenges and disappointments while modeling positive responses to setbacks in their own lives.

Parental and Child Financial Support Expectations

When discussing financial support and future care expectations between parents and children, Jocko emphasizes the importance of avoiding transactional relationships. He suggests that parents should provide support, such as college tuition, selflessly and without expecting future care in return. Instead, parents should plan for their own independence in old age while raising children who are driven by values and who will naturally want to help their parents out of love rather than obligation.

Building Mental Toughness and Resilience in Children

The discussion addresses how parents can handle children's emotional outbursts, which are a normal part of development. Using a caller's experience with his daughter becoming upset over a spoiled surprise, the episode explores how parents should respond calmly and compassionately to overwhelming emotions. Rather than trying to control emotions, the focus should be on teaching coping strategies like deep-breathing exercises or counting to ten. Additionally, celebrating successes and encouraging perseverance helps build children's confidence and resilience over time.

1-Page Summary

Additional Materials

Counterarguments

  • While allowing children to face challenges is important, it's also crucial to ensure that these challenges are age-appropriate and that the child has the necessary support to learn from them rather than becoming overwhelmed.
  • Positive modeling by parents is beneficial, but children also need direct instruction and practice to develop their own coping mechanisms and resilience.
  • Coping strategies like deep-breathing exercises are useful, but they may not be suitable for every child, and it's important to personalize strategies to fit individual needs and temperaments.
  • Celebrating successes is important, but it's also necessary to teach children that self-worth isn't solely based on achievements and that failure is a natural part of learning.
  • Providing financial support without expecting anything in return is an ideal, but it's also important to teach children about financial responsibility and the value of reciprocity in relationships.
  • Planning for independence in old age is wise, but there should also be open communication about potential future scenarios where parents might need support, to avoid misunderstandings or unmet expectations.
  • Good manners are important, but they should be part of a broader education on empathy, respect, and understanding the reasons behind polite behavior, rather than just rote learning of polite phrases.

Actionables

  • Create a "Challenge Jar" for your children with slips of paper describing age-appropriate challenges they can draw from weekly, such as trying a new food, solving a puzzle, or writing a letter to a relative. This encourages them to face new situations and learn to manage disappointments if the challenge doesn't go as planned, while also giving them a sense of accomplishment when they succeed.
  • Start a family "Coping Skills Toolbox" where each family member contributes ideas for managing stress or emotional moments, like drawing, listening to a specific song, or going for a walk. This not only teaches children various ways to handle their emotions but also reinforces the idea that everyone, regardless of age, has to find ways to cope with difficult feelings.
  • Implement a "Manners Mission" where you and your children set a goal to use a specific polite phrase or act of kindness each day, such as holding the door for someone or giving a compliment. Track these acts on a calendar to visually reinforce the habit of good manners and discuss how these actions make others feel, linking politeness to emotional resilience and the impact it has on relationships.

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
Jocko Underground: When You Give, Should You Really Not Expect Anything In Return?

Parenting Advice and Strategies

Parenting comes with a range of challenges and goals. One caller shares a specific aim: to develop mental toughness and resilience in his young child.

Develop Mental Toughness and Resilience in Children

The caller has already taken steps to teach his five-year-old daughter good manners, encouraging her to use polite phrases like "Yes, sir," "No, sir," and "Thank you." He seeks advice on how to further enhance her mental toughness and instill resilience at her young age.

Instill Manners and Respectful Responses in Children, Even When Emotional

Good manners are an excellent starting point for instilling respect and discipline in children. Teaching kids to maintain polite and respectful communication, even when they are emotional, can serve as a foundation for resilience. It can help children navigate difficult situations calmly and with respect toward others.

Opportunities For Children to Handle Challenges and Disappointments

Allowing children to face challenges and disappointments is a crucial step in developing their mental toughness. By providing opportunities for kids t ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Parenting Advice and Strategies

Additional Materials

Counterarguments

  • While teaching good manners is important, focusing too much on polite phrases might not directly contribute to mental toughness or resilience; these qualities are more about internal coping mechanisms than external expressions of politeness.
  • Overemphasis on manners might suppress a child's ability to express their emotions freely, which is also an important aspect of developing resilience.
  • Providing challenges and disappointments for the sake of it could potentially lead to unnecessary stress or anxiety in children if not carefully managed and tailored to the child's individual needs and temperament.
  • There is a fine line between encouraging resilience and pushing a child too hard, which could lead to adverse effects like diminished self-esteem or aversion to trying new things.
  • Modeling positivity is beneficial, but it's also important for children to see adults navigate a range of emotions, including sadness and frustration, to understand that these feelings are normal and can be dealt with constructively.
  • Resilience can sometimes be misunderstood as a need to be self-reliant, which might discourage children from seeking help when it's needed; it's important to balance the ...

Actionables

  • Create a "Manners Menu" for mealtime where each dish or course corresponds with a specific manner to practice, such as saying "please" when asking for food to be passed or "thank you" when receiving it. This turns learning manners into a fun and interactive experience for children during a daily routine.
  • Design a "Challenge Passport" for your child, where each page represents a different challenge they can complete, ranging from trying a new food to solving a puzzle without help. Once they complete a challenge, they get a stamp or sticker, encouraging them to face and overcome small disappointments or difficulties in a controlled, rewarding way.
  • Start a family "Resilience ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
Jocko Underground: When You Give, Should You Really Not Expect Anything In Return?

Parental and Child Financial Support Expectations

The discussion revolves around parental support for children's education and the expectations of future care for parents, guided by Jocko's insights on the matter.

Avoid Relationships Where Financial Support Hinges on Future Care

It is understandable that parents want the best for their children, and part of that involves ensuring their educational success. However, Jocko emphasizes that this should not cultivate a sense of obligation for children to provide for their parents in later years.

Support Children Selflessly

Jocko points out that when providing financial support, such as paying for college tuition, it should be a selfless act. He suggests that the focus should be on helping children get on a successful path, regardless of what they choose to do in life.

Ensure Independence In Old Age to Avoid Burdening Children

By supporting their children's education, parents are not creating a debt to be repaid but are instead helping their children become independent. Parents should plan for their own independence in old age to avoid creating a financial or emotional burden on their children.

Raise Value-Driven Childr ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Parental and Child Financial Support Expectations

Additional Materials

Counterarguments

  • While parents should not expect financial support as a transaction for education costs, it is culturally and traditionally normal in many societies for children to support their parents in old age.
  • Selfless financial support for education is ideal, but it may not always be feasible for families with limited resources, where mutual financial support is a necessity.
  • Planning for independence in old age is important, but not all parents may have the means to do so, which could necessitate reliance on children for support.
  • Raising value-driven children is a goal, but children's values may evolve differently from their parents', and they may prioritize other forms of support over financial assistance.
  • The ...

Actionables

  • Create a "Future Independence" savings account to ensure your own financial stability in old age. Start by setting up a dedicated savings account with automatic transfers from your main account each month. This will help you build a nest egg that's specifically earmarked for your retirement years, ensuring you won't need to rely on your children financially. For example, if you receive a bonus or tax refund, consider putting a portion directly into this account.
  • Develop a family values charter that emphasizes mutual respect and support without financial expectations. Gather as a family to discuss and write down the core values that you all believe in, such as kindness, self-reliance, and generosity. This charter can serve as a moral compass for your children, guiding them to help others, including you, out of love rather than obligation. You might celebrate the completion of this charter with a family dinner, reinforcing the importance of these values.
  • Volunteer together with your children at community service events to instill the value of ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
Jocko Underground: When You Give, Should You Really Not Expect Anything In Return?

Building Mental Toughness and Resilience in Children

Developing mental toughness and resilience is a critical aspect of a child's growth. A caller's recent experience highlights common challenges parents face in this process.

Children's Emotional Outbursts Are Part of Normal Development

Children's emotional outbursts are indeed part of their normal development. These moments, though challenging, are opportunities for learning and growth.

Respond Calmly and Compassionately When Children Become Overwhelmed

For instance, the caller described a situation where his daughter became extremely upset over what seemed to be a minor issue: she was crying and hiding because her surprise was spoiled when her father saw her new dress before it was meant to be shown. In such scenarios, it's crucial for parents to respond calmly and compassionately. Trying to talk to a child in the midst of a high emotional point may intensify their feelings, as the caller discovered.

It’s important for parents to recognize that children may not always have the words to express their feelings or the ability to navigate their emotions. Waiting until the child has calmed down before discussing the situation can often lead to a more productive conversation.

Teach Coping Strategies, Not Emotion Control

To help children like the caller's daughter become mentally tougher, teaching coping strategies rather than attempting to control emotions is key. Coping strategies help children handle their emotions and reduce the intensity and duration of emotional outbursts over time. Strategies such as deep-breathing exercises, counting to ten, or talking about their feelings once they’re calm can be beneficial.

Celebrate Successes, Encourage Pers ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Building Mental Toughness and Resilience in Children

Additional Materials

Counterarguments

  • While emotional outbursts are part of normal development, it's important to differentiate between typical behavior and signs of underlying issues that may require professional attention.
  • Responding calmly is ideal, but parents are human and may sometimes react emotionally; it's important to acknowledge this and have strategies for parents to manage their own emotions.
  • Children vary in their emotional development, and some may be more adept at using words to express their feelings; the approach should be tailored to the child's individual capabilities.
  • Immediate discussion of emotions, even during an outburst, can sometimes be beneficial if done in a supportive way, as it can validate the child's feelings and model emotional regulation.
  • Coping strategies are useful, but overemphasis on them without addressing the root causes of emotional distress might lead to suppression of emotions rather than healthy management.
  • Not all coping strategies work for every child, and it's important to explore a variety of tools to find what works best for an individual child.
  • Celebrating successes and encouraging perseverance is important, but it's also crucial to ensure that children do not feel pressured to suppress their em ...

Actionables

  • Create a "feelings journal" for your child to draw or write about their emotions when they're upset. This can be a private space where they express themselves without the pressure of finding the right words. For example, they might draw a stormy cloud when they feel angry or a sun when they're happy, helping them visually communicate their feelings.
  • Develop a "calm down" kit with your child that includes items they find soothing, such as a stress ball, a favorite book, or a soft blanket. When they feel overwhelmed, they can go to their kit and choose an item to help them self-soothe. This empowers them to take control of their emotions and learn what works best for them.
  • Introduce a family "emotion charades" game where ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free

Create Summaries for anything on the web

Download the Shortform Chrome extension for your browser

Shortform Extension CTA