PDF Summary:The Last Castle, by Denise Kiernan

The Last Castle explores the opulent Biltmore Estate, a grand endeavor by George Vanderbilt in the late 1800s to create a self-sustaining, European-inspired domain. Denise Kiernan weaves together the stories behind the estate's inception, the unlikely union between George and Edith Dresser, and the family's legacy of philanthropy and perseverance amid challenges.

Kiernan delves into the architectural brilliance and stately grandeur of Biltmore House, designed to evoke the splendor of French Renaissance castles. She details the contrasts between the privileged Vanderbilt family and Edith's modest beginnings, the estate's evolution alongside shifting cultural trends, and its descendants' efforts to preserve this American landmark.

(continued)...

At the Biltmore wedding where he was the best man, he began developing romantic feelings for Lila, a relative of George.

Field found himself romantically drawn to Lila, a relative of George Vanderbilt. Their romantic endeavors unfolded at the Biltmore Estate, where they engaged in horseback riding, hunting expeditions, and deep conversations under the stars. The estate served as a romantic backdrop for the honeymoons of Adele, another niece of George's who once harbored feelings for Pinchot, and naturally, for Lila as well.

Practical Tips

• Explore your family history to understand the socioeconomic dynamics that shaped your ancestors' relationships. By researching your genealogy through online databases or interviewing older relatives, you can uncover stories similar to George and Edith's that may have influenced your family's culture and values. This can provide insight into how past financial disparities and romantic connections have shaped your own perspectives on relationships and wealth.
• Create a fictionalized account of a historical romance in your own family. Use the contrasting backgrounds of your ancestors as a basis for a short story or novella. This exercise can help you engage creatively with your heritage and consider the societal impacts of wealth disparities in a personal context, much like the public's fascination with George and Edith's story.
• Reflect on your relationships and consider how socioeconomic differences have played a role. Write down your thoughts or discuss with a partner how differences in background have influenced your relationship dynamics, challenges, and perceptions. This can lead to a deeper understanding of each other and the external factors that may affect your connection.

The philanthropic activities of the Vanderbilts, their substantial impact on the surrounding Asheville area, and the estate's capacity to adapt through various eras.

The story explores the dynamic engagement of the Vanderbilts with Asheville's residents and highlights the crucial role Edith played in launching and maintaining forward-thinking social reforms. Economic challenges and natural calamities, such as floods, threatened the existence of the majestic estate, even as emerging cultural trends, such as the movement focused on handcraftsmanship and artistic design, offered opportunities for innovative rejuvenation.

George's reserved nature was markedly different from Edith Vanderbilt's charitable activities.

Kiernan depicts Edith Vanderbilt with a welcoming and outgoing nature, which stands in stark contrast to George's more introverted disposition. She was instrumental in bolstering the surrounding community of the estate by delivering aid to families during sickness, supplying necessary items to pregnant women, and working together to organize celebrations for the local residents. She steadfastly advocated for the enhancement of educational and employment opportunities for women and children, a stance that defied the expected societal roles for women of her social standing in that era.

Edith dedicated herself to improving the lives of neighboring families, advancing educational opportunities for the offspring of those employed on her property, and was deeply involved in efforts to uplift the overall welfare of the surrounding populace.

Edith's commitment to improving the lives of others extended well beyond the typical charitable acts expected of the wealthy during her time. She championed the cause of enhancing educational opportunities for the children of dairy farmers, established a facility focused on imparting sewing skills to women, and supported various projects designed to strengthen community growth. She demonstrated her dedication to the community by fervently advocating for women's suffrage and supplying medical necessities to soldiers in the First World War.

Under Edith's stewardship, the Biltmore Estate Industries flourished.

Edith's philanthropic efforts were instrumental in the creation of Biltmore Estate Industries. The program provided hands-on instruction and employment opportunities in traditional Southern Appalachian crafts such as carpentry and fabric weaving, aimed at enhancing the skills and future of the region's youth. Edith's steadfast support and sharp business insight played a pivotal role in advancing the business to a distinguished level, showcasing their handcrafted products in prestigious magazines that focused on lifestyle and fashion trends.

The Biltmore Estate faced numerous challenges due to ecological and economic hardships.

From the outset, Biltmore faced a multitude of challenges that threatened its existence. The estate and its surrounding region suffered greatly from a series of calamitous incidents, notably the devastating deluge that occurred in 1916. George's economic stability suffered due to downturns, particularly the failure of the Shipbuilding Trust and the monetary turmoil of 1907. Cornelia took the reins of the estate amidst economic turbulence after the stock market collapse in 1929.

Edith's efforts to assist those impacted by the hurricanes and floods in the surrounding area, as well as the consequential harm to her property, were of considerable consequence.

The twin storms of 1916 unleashed a torrent that caused significant destruction throughout Asheville and the surrounding areas. The story describes the dire situation of the inhabitants, overwhelmed by rising floodwaters that destroyed not only homes and businesses but also essential structures like bridges. After the disaster, Edith took charge of providing support to those impacted, offering food, shelter, and comfort, while also assessing and initiating the restoration of the extensive damage to the agricultural output, equipment, and gardening projects of the property.

The financial crisis, coupled with its effects on tourism and the wider economic environment, as well as the measures George implemented to maintain the integrity of the property,

The financial crisis of the Depression also impacted the secluded community of Asheville, severely damaging the tourism industry that was vital for the region's fiscal stability. George, facing diminishing returns from his own investments and a dwindling inheritance, took steps to cut estate expenditures even as he sought buyers for vast acres of his forested land. The philanthropic efforts of the Vanderbilt lineage persisted with unwavering determination despite numerous challenges.

The estate's overhaul was crucial to maintaining its economic viability as the American landscapes changed.

As the landscape of American industry, architecture, and culture shifted, Edith found herself embracing new approaches while simultaneously clinging to traditional values. During the Progressive Era, characterized by practicality and social transformation, the Biltmore Estate underwent a significant transition from its initial period of extravagant origins, which occurred during the era of economic boom and lavish lifestyles. Edith's patronage of the Biltmore Estate Industries and her role in establishing the neighboring Grove Park Inn, a resort realized through the monetary backing derived from the earnings of a popular medicinal tonic, highlighted her appreciation for the unadorned elegance inherent in the Arts and Crafts movement.

The Biltmore Industries and the neighboring Grove Park Inn both exemplify the subtle elegance associated with the Arts and Crafts movement.

In the United States, there was an increasing admiration for goods made from natural materials and shaped by the meticulous work of artisans. The trend's impact is evident in the handcrafted products of Biltmore Estate Industries and the design preferences and embellishments that characterized the recently built Grove Park Inn, which is celebrated for its utilization of indigenous stone and the simplicity of its handcrafted furnishings. The inn's understated sophistication and the deliberate grandeur of Biltmore House both embodied important manifestations of this nascent cultural ideology, despite their contrasting designs.

Edith's decision to sell off segments of the property, including the Biltmore village and its related businesses, had a significant and enduring impact on her family's legacy.

Edith undertook a series of difficult measures to liquidate assets due to the financial difficulties faced by the estate. The pact ensured that a substantial part of George's original concept was encompassed by Pisgah National Forest, thus affirming its value as a beloved national treasure. The community, which George meticulously planned and which now flourished independently, was transferred to a new proprietor under Edith's promise to preserve its unique essence. Edith secured the jobs of numerous craftsmen she had mentored from a young age by handing over the operational oversight of Biltmore Estate Industries to Fred Seely. Edith adeptly safeguarded the legacy of her lineage and secured the prosperity of future generations with these dealings and careful management.

Other Perspectives

• The philanthropic work of Edith Vanderbilt, while commendable, may have been facilitated significantly by the wealth and social position she inherited, which could be seen as an unequal starting point when compared to the beneficiaries of her charity.
• The success of Biltmore Estate Industries, while partly due to Edith's efforts, may also have been influenced by broader economic and social trends of the time, as well as the work of other individuals within the organization.
• The narrative may overemphasize the role of individual philanthropy in social reforms and understate the collective efforts of community organizers and other reformers in Asheville.
• The focus on Edith's contributions to the community could overshadow the contributions of George Vanderbilt and other family members or staff in the philanthropic and economic activities associated with the Biltmore Estate.
• The decision to sell off parts of the property, while portrayed as a strategic move to preserve the estate's legacy, could also be critiqued as a loss of the original vision for the estate and a necessary compromise due to financial mismanagement.
• The portrayal of the Biltmore Estate's adaptation to changing American landscapes might gloss over the potential negative impacts of such changes on local traditions and the environment.
• The emphasis on the Arts and Crafts movement's elegance in relation to Biltmore Industries and Grove Park Inn may neglect the broader cultural and economic contexts that influenced these design choices.

The Vanderbilt descendants have continuously worked to maintain and enhance the estate, securing its link to their family heritage.

Descendants of the Vanderbilt family initiated updates to the Biltmore Estate, ensuring it kept pace with modern trends. Cornelia embraced modernity while she administered the affairs of the property. Confronted by ongoing economic difficulties, Edith Stuyvesant Dresser, alongside her spouse Jack Cecil, resolved to make Biltmore House accessible to visitors, a move that would both safeguard its future and generate essential income. Subsequent generations further developed the concept, diversifying the economic activities on the property, which solidified Biltmore's status as a unique and enduring point of interest.

Cornelia Vanderbilt Cecil managed the estate, fulfilling her role as her mother's heir.

Cornelia Vanderbilt Cecil, who came into possession of Biltmore at the age of twenty-five, displayed a spirited independence that echoed her mother's. Cornelia fostered relationships among the staff of the estate and the surrounding Asheville populace. In an age characterized by transformative social norms and evolving viewpoints, particularly in relation to the expectations of women, she epitomized the spirit commonly known as the Roaring Twenties. She oversaw the operations of the estate while pursuing her artistic and literary goals, often traveling to New York City and Europe without her husband's company.

Opening the Biltmore Estate to visitors was a tactic employed to offset costs and increase the number of guests.

In order to address financial difficulties and the expenses involved in maintaining their large estate, the Cecils decided to open Biltmore House to the public. The approach, though not typical for a private residence, generated income and simultaneously showcased the property's unique architecture and artistic features. The Biltmore House's purpose evolved as it became a place that attracted visitors.

Cornelia faced individual challenges and ultimately parted ways with the estate.

Cornelia encountered personal challenges, even with her advantages and accomplishments. Cornelia's story illustrates her efforts to uphold her responsibilities at Biltmore, simultaneously seeking a life brimming with artistic fulfillment. Cornelia's union with Jack Cecil eventually ended, leading her to depart from Biltmore and pursue a fresh existence as an artist on the European continent. She concluded her oversight of the property, choosing a path divergent from New York's societal conventions, much like her father had done before, to adopt a lifestyle that was uniquely their own.

Advancements and modernizations within the Biltmore Company.

The creation of the Biltmore Company in 1932 marked a significant shift in the management and care of the property. Cornelia, with financial backing and guidance from Edith as well as additional advisors, focused on ensuring the lasting stability of Biltmore. Cornelia's sons, George and William, broadened Biltmore's business ventures and incorporated modern amenities.

The property broadened its economic pursuits, including the establishment of viticulture at Biltmore.

George and William Cecil developed various approaches to enhance the economic resilience of their lineage, thereby lessening reliance on income derived from those touring their estate. They broadened their dairy operations and incorporated modern innovations like solar power, while also initiating new projects such as a vineyard situated within the grounds of the Biltmore Estate. The approach to diversify aimed at strengthening the Biltmore estate's financial self-sufficiency, ensuring its enduring success without relying extensively on the diminishing inheritance bequeathed to Cornelia.

Cornelia's descendants continued to honor the heritage of their ancestor, a legacy that remains a significant factor in contemporary tourism.

Cornelia's descendants dedicated themselves to preserving their ancestor's heritage by taking on significant roles within the Biltmore Company. They revitalized the estate by introducing new activities and features that were consistent with George's original principles of preserving the land and forests, making sure these enhancements were attractive to visitors. Their efforts transformed the Biltmore from a simple historical landmark into a thriving modern enterprise.

The philanthropic legacy that the Vanderbilt family initiated continues to endure.

The Vanderbilt and Dresser family heritage involved more than just financial contributions, as they devoted their time and resources to improving educational prospects and supporting those in need. Edith's considerable impact on her surroundings was evident through her proactive engagement and the founding of entities such as the School of Domestic Science, which left a lasting legacy for subsequent generations. Cornelia's creation of a charitable fund under the pseudonym Mrs. Smith, designed to assist the less fortunate, underscores the enduring and often understated generosity of the affluent.

Cornelia established a secretly funded initiative known as the Mrs. Smith Fund to offer support to those dealing with difficult circumstances.

Cornelia Vanderbilt Cecil established a charitable foundation known as the Mrs. Smith Fund, which primarily focuses on supporting a range of programs, particularly those designed to assist the underprivileged. Kiernan highlights Cornelia's deep-seated selflessness, evident in her inclination to help others quietly without any desire for recognition of her deeds. She adopted a caring method that mirrored her mother's commitment to societal change.

Edith's steadfast commitment to uplifting disadvantaged groups and her enduring influence on educational and social change through philanthropic deeds.

Edith's charitable activities, as underscored by Kiernan, extended far past the customary donations and elite social gatherings often associated with wealthy families. Her dedication to the local populace was evident as she established schools, ensured students had access to transportation for their education, and improved the quality of life for employees and their relatives. Her dedication to charitable endeavors and her advocacy for women's right to vote cemented her status as more than just the caretaker of a grand property. Edith Vanderbilt gained widespread acclaim for her compassionate advocacy and protection of those less fortunate.

Other Perspectives

• While the Vanderbilt descendants have worked to maintain and enhance the Biltmore Estate, it could be argued that the need to open the estate to the public and diversify economic activities suggests a departure from purely preserving family heritage to a more commercial and tourist-oriented approach.
• The management of the estate by Cornelia Vanderbilt Cecil and her embrace of modernity might be seen as a reflection of broader societal changes rather than individual innovation or leadership.
• The decision to open Biltmore House to visitors, while financially necessary, could be critiqued as a commodification of private history and heritage for public consumption.
• The narrative of Cornelia facing personal challenges and leaving the estate could be viewed as a simplification that overlooks the complex interplay of personal choice, societal pressures, and family expectations.
• The creation of the Biltmore Company in 1932 and subsequent modernizations may have shifted the focus from a family home to a corporate enterprise, potentially diluting the personal connection to the Vanderbilt legacy.
• The diversification of economic pursuits, such as viticulture, while innovative, might also be seen as a move away from traditional estate management, raising questions about the balance between preservation and profit.
• The emphasis on honoring the ancestor's heritage through modernization could be critiqued for potentially overshadowing the original historical and cultural significance of the estate with new, commercial ventures.
• The philanthropic legacy of the Vanderbilt family, while commendable, could be contrasted with the broader societal context of wealth inequality and the role of philanthropy in addressing systemic issues.
• The establishment of the Mrs. Smith Fund by Cornelia might be subject to criticism regarding the effectiveness and reach of such private charitable efforts compared to broader social welfare programs.
• Edith Dresser's philanthropic deeds, while impactful, could be seen within the larger context of the era's social reform movements, suggesting that her contributions were part of a wider societal trend rather than solely individual efforts.