PDF Summary:Leading with Questions, by Michael J. Marquardt and Bob Tiede

In Leading with Questions, Michael J. Marquardt and Bob Tiede argue for the strategic power of inquiry in leadership. The book presents an alternative to the traditional approach of solution-providing. Instead, the authors make a case for fostering a culture of questioning—one that elicits information, spurs collaboration, ignites creativity, and drives transformative change within organizations.

By cultivating a questioning environment, leaders can unlock a wealth of benefits: increased adaptability, improved decision-making, boosted team motivation, and openness to innovation. Marquardt and Tiede provide frameworks for developing questioning skills, integrating inquiry into daily practices, and utilizing questions across leadership domains—from coaching individuals to guiding organizational strategy.

(continued)...

Practical Tips

• Encourage open-ended feedback by starting a "suggestion box" that focuses on improvement and growth rather than criticism. Instead of rating ideas or suggestions, simply collect them and discuss them in a group setting, emphasizing constructive development. This can help shift the focus from assessment to collaborative enhancement.
• Create a "Perspective Playlist" by compiling articles, podcasts, and videos from sources outside your usual preferences. Dedicate time each week to explore these different viewpoints. If you typically read technology news, add some arts and culture pieces to your playlist to broaden your perspective.
• Create a "Learning Exchange" with friends or colleagues where each person teaches something they're passionate about every month. This not only broadens your knowledge base but also exposes you to different teaching styles and subjects you might not have explored on your own.

Recognizing the presence of constraints and the lack of an instant solution.

Humility is a fundamental component of the mindset geared towards learning. The authors emphasize the necessity for leaders to acknowledge their own constraints and accept that they are not omniscient. Leaders cultivate a collaborative atmosphere by demonstrating a willingness to absorb insights from their team members, thereby encouraging open communication and reciprocal sharing of knowledge.

Practical Tips

• Volunteer in a role that is completely outside of your professional expertise, such as helping at a community garden if you're an accountant, or assisting in a soup kitchen if you're a software developer. Engaging in tasks where you're not the expert can help cultivate humility by placing you in situations where you are the learner, not the teacher.
• Create a "Constraint Collaboration" group with peers. Find a small group of colleagues or friends who are also interested in personal growth and set up regular meetings to discuss each other's perceived limitations. By sharing your challenges, you can gain new perspectives and strategies for overcoming them.
• Create a personal "Ignorance Map" where you chart out areas of your job or industry you know little about. Set goals to improve in these areas through research, training, or direct experience. For instance, if you realize you're not well-versed in data analysis, you might set a goal to learn a new data visualization tool within the next quarter.

Fostering a culture that prioritizes and promotes the regular practice of inquiry.

This segment offers actionable advice for leaders to foster an environment of inquiry among their team members and throughout their organizations.

Leaders who habitually engage in the act of posing questions.

Marquardt and Tiede stress the significance of living out the principles they support. Leaders ought to cultivate an environment that values questioning through their regular and transparent engagement in the act of asking questions. It clearly conveys that the act of asking questions is highly valued and encouraged. The book highlights the tactics of various effective leaders who have made questioning the core of their leadership to drive positive change in their organizations.

Practical Tips

• Use storytelling to share experiences where you've lived out your principles. When conversing with friends or colleagues, intentionally incorporate stories that highlight times when you've made decisions based on your values. This not only reinforces your commitment to your principles but also serves as a subtle form of leadership by example.
• Implement a "Reverse-Mentoring" program where you, as a leader, are paired with someone from a different department or a junior employee each month to ask questions about their work and perspectives. This breaks down hierarchical barriers and allows for transparent communication across different levels of the organization. It can lead to valuable insights about parts of the company you're less familiar with.
• Create a personal "Question Diary" where you jot down at least one probing question each day related to your leadership experiences. At the end of the week, review your questions to identify patterns or areas for improvement, and use these insights to guide your decision-making and interactions with your team.

Encouraging an environment that supports challenging existing conventions.

Creating a culture that prioritizes questioning also involves shaping a space where people are comfortable challenging existing norms and presenting alternative perspectives. Leaders should encourage a variety of perspectives, promote stimulating conversations, and embrace mistakes. A culture that encourages productive dissent fosters creativity and leads to the development of innovative solutions.

Practical Tips

• Develop a habit of asking "What else?" or "Who else?" in meetings or discussions to prompt consideration of additional perspectives. For example, if you're discussing a project at work, ask "What other departments might have valuable input on this?" or "Who else might be affected by this decision that we haven't considered?" This practice encourages you and others to step outside the immediate circle of discussion and consider a broader range of impacts and ideas.
• Implement a "No Small Talk" day once a week, where you challenge yourself to only engage in conversations that go beyond the usual pleasantries. This could mean asking more in-depth questions when you interact with people throughout your day, such as asking a coworker about their passion projects instead of just discussing the weather. This practice can improve your conversational skills and make your interactions more meaningful.
• Implement a "Failure Debrief" session with your team or family once a month. During these sessions, openly discuss mistakes made and lessons learned without judgment. This could lead to a shared understanding that errors are a natural part of growth and innovation.
• Use social media to host a weekly "Inquiry Hour" where you pose a complex question and invite your network to share their perspectives. This not only broadens your understanding of different viewpoints but also fosters a community of inquiry among your peers. You might find that this becomes a highlight of the week for both you and your friends or followers.
• Develop a "Norm Busters" game to play with friends or family where participants bring up common norms and discuss the rationale behind them, then propose and debate alternatives. This game can be a fun and engaging way to practice questioning and creatively thinking about why we do things the way we do and how we might do them differently.
• Start a personal journal where you write down decisions from different perspectives. For example, if you're considering a career change, write one entry from the perspective of financial security, another from personal fulfillment, and a third from family responsibilities. This exercise can help you explore various angles and potential impacts of your decisions.
• Organize a monthly "Devil's Advocate Dinner" with friends or family where each person is tasked with arguing a contrarian view on a chosen topic. This social setting makes the practice of dissent more approachable and helps develop the skill of articulating and understanding perspectives that differ from your own.
• Use meal preparation as a canvas for experimentation by picking one day a week to cook something without following a recipe. This encourages improvisation and creative thinking in a low-stakes environment. You might choose ingredients that you wouldn't typically pair together or attempt to recreate a dish you've only tasted once, relying on your senses and intuition to guide the process.

Incorporating a culture and daily routines within the company that prioritize a focus on inquiry.

The authors underscore the necessity of ensuring that a culture of inquiry is deeply integrated with the organization's values and operations. Organizational life must embody values that emphasize education, teamwork, and analytical reasoning in every facet. Encouraging a culture that values the art of inquiry can be strengthened by including assessment standards in performance evaluations that reward and promote the skill of crafting questions.

Practical Tips

• Create a "challenge coin" system in your workplace or social group where individuals earn a token for raising thoughtful questions or providing insights that spark meaningful discussions. This tangible reward system not only makes the process of inquiry fun but also visibly acknowledges and celebrates curiosity as a valued behavior.
• Form a cross-departmental problem-solving group to enhance teamwork and analytical reasoning. Meet monthly to tackle a common challenge, using diverse perspectives to brainstorm solutions. This could involve members from marketing, sales, and product development working together to improve customer retention, thus applying analytical skills to a real-world scenario.

Strategies for crafting impactful inquiries.

This section of the book transitions to honing the particular abilities and methods necessary for formulating impactful inquiries. The authors present a framework that outlines different types of questions, underscoring the importance of formulating inquiries that are impactful.

Distinguishing between questions that bolster empowerment and those that undermine it.

The authors provide concrete examples demonstrating how certain questions can bolster an individual's autonomy or diminish their authority, along with the distinct outcomes that each method produces.

Questions crafted to promote empowerment encourage individuals to delve into self-reflection and discovery.

The authors argue that by asking questions that stimulate deep reflection, individuals are prompted to delve into their own experiences and assumptions, creating a space where they are motivated to develop their own solutions. Inquiries that confer empowerment to others are as follows:

• What do you think about...?

• What potential scenarios can you envision?

• How do you view this specific situation?

Questions that require answers beyond a simple yes or no encourage a deeper exploration of perspectives and stimulate extensive conversation.

Practical Tips

• Start a daily empowerment journal where you write down one question each morning that prompts self-reflection. This could be as simple as "What am I most proud of achieving yesterday?" or "What can I do today to step out of my comfort zone?" The act of writing down these questions helps to internalize their importance and encourages you to think deeply about your personal growth.
• Use open-ended questions as conversation starters in social settings to foster deeper connections. When meeting someone new, instead of asking what they do for a living, ask "How do you feel about your line of work?" or "What aspects of your job do you find most fulfilling?" This can lead to more meaningful discussions.
• During your next book club or group discussion, volunteer to lead the conversation with only open-ended questions. This will challenge you to think on your feet and encourage a richer exchange of ideas among participants. You might, for example, ask "How do the characters' decisions reflect on modern society?" to spark a discussion that goes beyond the plot of the book.

Questions that concentrate on assigning blame or conveying criticism frequently diminish one's trustworthiness.

Questions that undermine empowerment often focus on pinpointing errors, assigning fault, and providing critique. They create a setting that discourages transparent communication and encourages a protective stance. The publication offers illustrations of inquiries that might inadvertently weaken empowerment.

• What influenced your choice of this particular strategy?

• Who is accountable?

• What obstacles are hindering your pursuit of precision?

Questions that diminish one's confidence typically begin with "why" and suggest a critical assessment.

Context

• In some cultures, direct criticism or blame can be particularly damaging to relationships and trust, as they may value harmony and face-saving more highly.
• Over time, a focus on blame can lead to high turnover rates, as employees may seek more supportive and empowering work environments.
• In some cultures, direct questioning can be perceived as confrontational, further inhibiting open dialogue and increasing defensiveness.
• Empowering questions typically encourage exploration and understanding, fostering a culture of learning and growth.
• The tone and context in which "why" questions are asked can significantly influence the emotional response, potentially leading to feelings of inadequacy or self-doubt.

Cultivating the ability to craft and appropriately time questions.

The authors delve into the nuances of context, timing, and delivery, emphasizing that how a question is framed is just as important as the content of the question itself.

Establishing a suitable setting for asking questions.

Marquardt and Tiede highlight the importance of meticulously formulating questions, making sure they are introduced with suitable preambles and contextual information.

• The conversation aims to foster understanding and inquiry rather than to assess blame or find errors.

• Context: Provide background information and relevant details to ensure a shared understanding of the topic or issue being discussed.

• Establish the conversation's objectives to steer the direction of the questioning.

Adjusting the speed of your speech, the tone of your voice, and your body language plays a vital role when you are asking questions.

The writers underscore the significance of nonverbal communication.

• Ensure that you don't overwhelm the person you are questioning with too many inquiries at once. Allow individuals some time to come up with their responses.

• Cultivate an attitude that promotes curiosity and support rather than one that is adversarial or judgmental.

• Maintain a posture that demonstrates attentiveness, using visual cues and discreet nonverbal gestures to show that you are fully engaged.

Practical Tips

• Start a question journal where you record daily interactions and the questions you ask, noting the context and preamble used. This practice will help you become more aware of how you frame questions in different situations. For example, if you asked a colleague about a project, write down the lead-in to your question and any background you provided. Over time, you'll see patterns in your questioning style and can adjust to make your questions more precise and contextually rich.
• Create a habit of writing a one-page primer on a subject before you discuss it in a group setting, focusing on key terms and concepts. Share this with participants ahead of time to facilitate a deeper and more productive conversation.
• Create a set of "goal-oriented question cards" to use in various conversational scenarios. Each card should have a question that serves a specific purpose, such as gathering information, building rapport, or solving a problem. For instance, if your objective is to learn about a person's expertise in a networking event, a card might have the question, "What's the most challenging project you've worked on, and how did you tackle it?" Use these cards to practice or as a quick reference during actual conversations.
• Use a metronome app to practice pacing your speech when asking questions. Set the metronome to a slow, comfortable beat and try to match your speech to the rhythm. This can help you slow down if you tend to speak too quickly, or pick up the pace if you're naturally slow. Adjust the speed as you become more comfortable, aiming for a pace that feels natural and is easy for others to follow.
• Try observing people in a public setting, like a coffee shop, without listening to their conversations, to guess the context based on their nonverbal cues. Pay attention to their gestures, facial expressions, and posture. Later, reflect on what you observed and consider how these nonverbal elements conveyed emotions or intentions. This exercise can sharpen your ability to read nonverbal signals in real-time interactions.
• Implement a personal 'one question rule' in emails and texts where you limit yourself to asking only one main question per message. This encourages you to prioritize your inquiries and gives the recipient a clear focus for their reply. Over time, you'll notice which questions yield the most informative responses, helping you refine your approach to communication.
• Create a 'Supportive Feedback Template' for use in both professional and personal settings, which starts with a genuine question about the other person's thought process or feelings before offering any feedback. This template ensures that your initial approach is one of curiosity and support. For instance, when a friend makes a decision you wouldn't have made, your first response could be to ask them to share more about what led them to this choice, showing interest rather than skepticism.

Developing the skill to attentively listen and actively participate in the ensuing conversation.

This part of the text underscores the importance of active participation and meaningful dialogue as fundamental elements in the inquiry process. The authors offer comprehensive advice on demonstrating engagement and building trust with respondents.

Demonstrating engagement and comprehension using different forms of verbal and non-verbal signals.

Marquardt and Tiede provide practical guidance for demonstrating engagement by listening attentively. To show involvement and encourage further explanation, you might request more information by inquiring, "Could you provide more details on that?" or by restating what the speaker has said in your own words. Demonstrating attentiveness and engagement can also be shown through nonverbal cues such as maintaining eye contact, leaning slightly toward the person you're speaking with, and nodding to signal agreement.

Practical Tips

• Create a feedback habit by asking friends or family to share their thoughts on your listening abilities. After a discussion, simply ask, "How well do you think I listened during our conversation?" This opens the door to constructive criticism and allows you to identify specific areas for improvement.
• Develop the habit of sending follow-up emails after meetings or presentations asking for clarification on points that weren't fully explained. This not only shows your engagement but also ensures you have a complete understanding of the discussion. For example, if a colleague mentions a new project plan, email them asking for a detailed breakdown of the steps involved.
• Try playing the "echo game" with a partner where you take turns sharing a story or opinion, and the other person has to summarize what was said in their own words before responding. This game encourages deeper engagement and ensures that both parties are truly understanding each other. For instance, if your partner tells you about a book they're reading, you would first echo back the plot and their impressions in your own words before adding your thoughts or asking questions.
• You can practice eye contact during everyday transactions, like ordering coffee, to become more comfortable with it. Start by making brief eye contact when you greet the cashier and gradually increase the duration each time you visit. This will help you build the habit in a low-stress environment.
• You can practice mirroring body language during casual conversations with friends to enhance connection. Start by subtly adopting the posture and gestures of your friends when you're chatting. This can make the interaction feel more engaging and show that you're in tune with them.
• Use nodding as a feedback tool when engaging in customer service or client interactions. By nodding at appropriate moments when clients are explaining their needs or concerns, you can convey empathy and understanding, possibly leading to higher satisfaction and trust in the service you provide.

Regularly demonstrating dedication to the investigative process.

The authors stress the importance of maintaining the conversation after starting to ask questions. A commitment to the practice of asking questions, coupled with building trust among participants, enables one to underscore the value of their input by thoughtfully conveying the understanding derived from their feedback. Continuing the conversation might entail exchanging viewpoints, planning future steps, or just conveying gratitude for the contributions received. Failing to circle back to earlier conversations may give the impression that the contributions received are not valued, which can undermine the success of the questioning strategy.

Practical Tips

• Implement a "skill-sharing session" during your group activities where each person teaches something they're good at. This not only showcases the diverse talents within the group but also helps to build mutual respect and trust. For instance, if someone is proficient in Excel, they could give a mini-tutorial to the team, thereby highlighting their value to the group.
• Use visual aids like mind maps to track the evolution of your conversations over time, which can help you circle back to previous points effectively. Create a mind map after each significant interaction, adding branches for each main topic discussed. When preparing for follow-up conversations, review and update the mind map to refresh your memory and identify areas that need further exploration or clarification. This visual approach can make it easier to see connections and ensure that no critical points are neglected over time.

Utilizing inquiry methods to guide individuals, foster team development, tackle challenges, and propel transformation within companies.

The book's final sections delve into how methods of leadership that are centered around questioning can be incorporated across various leadership domains.

Using questions to build empowering relationships and steer team members.

Marquardt and Tiede emphasize the importance of nurturing connections that enable team members to feel empowered. They share strategies for utilizing questions effectively in the context of coaching and professional development.

Fostering individual growth, learning, and the journey of self-exploration through the act of asking questions.

The authors highlight the significance of asking questions to foster reflection, learning, and growth among team members. Artfully formulated questions can energize and propel people forward.

• Discover their innate motivations, acknowledge their talents, and pinpoint prospects that will nurture their development.

• Draw insights from previous encounters, discern the lessons they impart, and utilize these understandings in forthcoming scenarios.

• Encourage the development of new perspectives by challenging conventional wisdom and exploring different options, which promotes growth in personal and professional realms.

Practical Tips

• Create a 'talent exchange' board with friends or colleagues where you can offer skills you're good at and request help in areas you want to develop. This could be a physical board or a digital platform. For instance, if you're skilled in graphic design but want to improve your public speaking, you could offer to design a flyer in exchange for a public speaking lesson.
• Create a "lesson learned" box or digital folder where you can drop notes, artifacts, or even voice memos of insights you've gained from various experiences. Periodically review the contents to refresh your memory and integrate these lessons into your planning for upcoming events or projects.

Assisting team members in pinpointing and accomplishing their objectives.

Questions further assist employees in expressing and formulating plans to reach their objectives. Leaders cultivate a personal commitment and independence among their team by encouraging individuals to establish their own goals and explore different methods to achieve these aspirations while advancing in their careers.

Practical Tips

• You can create a "Question-Storming" session with your team where everyone only asks questions about a project for a set period. This can lead to a deeper understanding of the project's goals and potential strategies for achieving them. For example, during a product development meeting, instead of suggesting ideas, ask questions like "What are the core needs this product addresses?" or "How can we make this product more user-friendly?"
• You can foster independence by assigning a 'mystery project' where team members are given the autonomy to define the problem and solution within a set framework. Explain that the goal is to encourage creative thinking and ownership. Team members will present their projects, highlighting how they identified the issue and developed their solution, which promotes both personal commitment and independence.
• Create a vision board to visually map out your goals, using images and words that represent your desired outcomes. This tactile activity can make your aspirations more tangible and can serve as a daily reminder of what you're working towards. For example, if you aim to travel to Japan, include pictures of landmarks, phrases in Japanese, and images representing the culture.
• Implement a "Weekly Experiment" where you dedicate one week to trying a new method or strategy towards achieving your aspiration. At the end of the week, reflect on the process and results to determine if it's a viable long-term strategy. For instance, if you aspire to run a marathon, you could experiment with different training programs or dietary changes each week to find what works best for your body and schedule.
• Engage in role-playing scenarios with a friend or mentor to practice for future career opportunities. For example, if you aim to become a manager, simulate challenging leadership situations and practice your response. This hands-on approach can enhance your problem-solving skills and prepare you for real-world challenges in your desired career path.

Utilizing inquiry as a method to strengthen team unity and elevate collective performance.

Marquardt and Tiede offer practical guidance on using questions to build teams that work together effectively and operate smoothly.

Creating a setting that encourages open communication and a variety of viewpoints.

Exceptional team performance hinges on engaging in constructive dialogues that are crucial for addressing problems and making choices. Inquiries play a pivotal role in cultivating significant dialogues. By asking questions that encourage team members to share their perspectives, challenge assumptions, and respectfully disagree, leaders can foster a more collaborative and productive work environment.

Revitalizing group discussions and surmounting challenges.

The authors suggest that posing questions can significantly boost the energy and productivity of team meetings. Leaders can encourage more active involvement and elicit input from their team by starting meetings with questions that lack preconceived solutions. They recommend employing inquiries as a strategy to navigate teams through challenges or to break impasses that arise while addressing issues.

Practical Tips

• Rotate the role of "Question Master" among team members for each meeting. The designated person is responsible for preparing thought-provoking questions related to the meeting's agenda. This gives each team member a chance to contribute to the meeting's dynamics and ensures a variety of questioning styles and topics, keeping meetings fresh and productive.

Employing questions to deepen understanding of the intricate aspects of various challenges.

This section of the book delves into the application of questioning techniques for problem-solving, emphasizing the concepts of challenges that are either technical or require adaptation.

Differentiating adaptive challenges from technical issues.

The authors reassess the distinctions between adaptive challenges and those of a technical nature.

• Conventional skills and methods are equipped to address technical issues. Many issues can be addressed by adhering to proven best practices or by consulting with specialists for guidance.

• Adaptive challenges require the development of new solutions and the learning of new knowledge. They frequently require a substantial transformation in deeply entrenched convictions, along with changes in both perspectives and behaviors.

Context

• Common examples include software bugs, mechanical failures, or compliance with regulatory standards, where solutions are well-documented and can be implemented by following specific procedures.
• Adaptive challenges can be seen in situations like digital transformation, where organizations must not only adopt new technologies but also shift their business models and workforce skills.

Innovative solutions emerge through the process of posing questions that stimulate deep thinking.

Marquardt and Tiede stress the significance of honing one's skill in posing incisive questions as a means to effectively address complex problems. Creating questions that probe deeply into underlying causes and explore new possibilities is crucial for generating innovative solutions. The authors provide practical guidance on crafting questions that exert influence during different stages of problem-solving. They emphasize the importance of consistently seeking the root causes and exploring a wider array of potential resolutions.

Other Perspectives

• Incisive questions alone do not guarantee innovative solutions; the ability to listen, interpret, and act on the answers is equally crucial.
• Innovation can also be driven by market demands or user feedback, which may not require an in-depth exploration of underlying causes but rather a focus on practical functionality and user experience.
• Some innovations come from accidental discoveries or serendipity, rather than from the deliberate process of crafting questions.
• Focusing solely on root causes might overlook the importance of addressing symptoms that are causing immediate harm or disruption.
• The pursuit of a wide array of potential resolutions might overlook the value of expertise and specialized knowledge that can lead to breakthroughs within a narrower field.

Employing inquiries as tools to mold company strategy and facilitate transformation.

This final part explores how the practice of posing inquiries can strengthen the organization as a whole, steer its strategic decisions, and support its thorough transformation.

Collaborating with clients and partners to influence the strategic course.

Marquardt and Tiede highlight the importance for organizations to expand their focus and interact proactively with individuals and entities outside the company, such as clients, allies, and local inhabitants. Organizations can unearth critical knowledge about market movements, changing consumer demands, and prospective collaborative ventures through a methodical approach to inquiry. Regularly questioning stakeholders helps to ensure that strategic decisions are well-informed and aligned with real-world needs and expectations.

Other Perspectives

• Proactive interaction with a wide range of external parties can lead to information overload, making it difficult to discern actionable insights from the noise.
• Over-reliance on external input can dilute an organization's core vision and lead to a lack of clear strategic focus.
• Engaging with external individuals and entities may not always yield accurate or actionable insights, as these sources may have biases or their own agendas that could skew the information they provide.
• Stakeholders may have conflicting interests or perspectives, which could complicate the decision-making process rather than clarify it.

Utilizing questions as a tool to shape a vision, embed values, and cultivate an environment that embraces change.

Questions are not only instrumental in guiding the strategic direction but also play a crucial role in shaping a vision, defining core values, and creating a culture that embraces change. By initiating dialogues with team members that center on shared objectives, core principles, and mutually agreed-upon strategies, leaders can cultivate an environment that is adaptable and reactive.

By emphasizing questioning rather than clinging to predetermined solutions, leaders can unleash the complete potential of individuals, groups, and the whole organization. The ability to craft thought-provoking inquiries is essential for leaders navigating the complex and challenging landscape of today's business world.

Practical Tips

• Create a 'values jar' where you and your family or friends can contribute questions that reflect your shared values. Each week, draw a question from the jar and use it as a conversation starter during a meal. This could be as simple as, "How did we help someone this week?" which reinforces the value of helping others within your social circle.
• Use a shared digital dashboard to track progress towards objectives. Utilize project management software or a simple spreadsheet that all team members can access and update. This dashboard should include your shared objectives, the strategies you're employing to reach them, and a progress tracker for each goal. Regularly review and update the dashboard together to maintain a clear view of your team's direction and achievements.