PDF Summary:Horses Don't Fly, by Frederick Libby

In the autobiographical book Horses Don't Fly, Frederick Libby shares his experiences growing up in the American West, where he became an expert horseman and developed strong values like self-sufficiency and resilience. The book follows Libby's transition from cowboy life to serving as a pilot in World War I.

Libby offers personal insights into aerial combat during the war, detailing advancements in aircraft technology and tactics. He reflects on the physical and psychological impacts of warfare, as well as the profound relationships that shaped his journey through life and conflict. Libby's story illuminates one man's evolution amidst a pivotal era of history.

(continued)...

• In some cases, the need for a clear command structure might outweigh the benefits of mutual support, particularly in high-stakes or time-sensitive scenarios.
• The notion of lasting support, while commendable, does not necessarily equate to the most effective form of teamwork in every situation; sometimes, critical or challenging partnerships can push individuals to perform better and should not be undervalued.

Frederick Libby's combat achievements, which included receiving honors such as the Military Cross, were also distinguished by his profound sense of brotherhood among his fellow pilots.

Frederick Libby exhibited exceptional courage and skill in both flying and intelligence collection, achieving numerous aerial victories and a distinguished military career. His extraordinary courage and proficiency in aerial battles earned him the distinguished Military Cross. He participates in pivotal battles like the Somme offensive, witnessing the horrific realities of combat, including the dire circumstances within the trenches, while noting the substantial casualties endured by both infantry and airmen.

Throughout his service, Libby forges strong bonds with his comrades in the sky, underscoring the camaraderie and mutual support that defined the British air force during the conflict. He fondly remembers his time collaborating with a distinguished officer during battles and has great admiration for Albert Ball, a skilled pilot whose proficiency was instrumental in saving his life on multiple occasions. The bonds formed during periods of conflict profoundly influenced his life's path.

Context

• Frederick Libby was one of the first American aces in World War I, which means he was among the first to achieve five or more aerial victories.
• Aerial victories were crucial during World War I as they helped establish air superiority, which was vital for reconnaissance and supporting ground troops.
• The Military Cross is a British military decoration awarded for exemplary gallantry during active operations against the enemy on land. It was established in December 1914 during World War I.
• The Somme Offensive resulted in over a million men wounded or killed, highlighting the brutal nature of World War I and the immense human cost of the conflict.
• The conflict referred to is World War I, which lasted from 1914 to 1918. It was characterized by trench warfare and significant technological advancements in military aviation, leading to high casualty rates.

Other Perspectives

• Strong bonds with comrades are important, but they do not necessarily guarantee effective military strategy or success in combat, which also relies on leadership, tactics, and resources.
• The intensity of wartime relationships may not always translate to peacetime, potentially leading to a diminished long-term impact on one's life trajectory.

The writer's narrative encompasses his choice to engage in battle, his encounters during combat, and his post-war tribulations.

The narrative delves into the way the conflict molded the author's perspective and its lasting impact on his life. Libby's initial naivety is shattered as he faces the harsh truths of warfare, grappling with the horrors he witnessed and the personal losses he suffered. He also emphasizes the difficulties he encountered while transitioning back to life outside the military, which had an impact on him both physically and mentally.

Frederick Libby joined the armed forces without a complete understanding of the implications his participation in the conflict would bring.

Initially, Libby did not fully comprehend the significance of the global conflict. Eager to explore new horizons and embark on exciting exploits, he joined the military forces of Canada, unaware of the grim realities that combat would present.

Frederick Libby's naivete is amusingly evident when he remarks on his recruitment, observing, "They initiated the conflict at a time that matched exactly with our state of readiness. Events are perpetually unfolding. Excitement was a constant companion in life. Numerous youths, fueled by energy and hope, enlisted without fully grasping the substantial consequences that lay ahead.

Frederick Libby's perspective on the war evolved as he personally witnessed its sorrow and loss.

As Libby confronts the harsh truths of combat, his early eagerness is replaced by a profound comprehension of the atrocities of war and their significant impact on individuals. Witnessing the harm and loss experienced by his fellow soldiers, particularly the infantry, profoundly shaped Libby's viewpoints. He recognizes the immense courage and altruism displayed by the soldiers enduring the severe conditions of trench warfare.

Libby struggles to comprehend the significance of the conflict, as he finds it challenging to rationalize the extensive loss of life and the justification for fighting a war under the banner of Democracy. He reflects on the war's pointlessness, particularly when he recalls the Somme offensive, which resulted in countless casualties for what amounted to a negligible gain in position. Frederick Libby's evolving perspective on the conflict reflects the disillusionment and mental stress that many fighters faced when faced with the brutal truths of war.

Other Perspectives

• It is possible that Libby's eagerness was not solely based on naivety but also on a sense of duty or belief in the cause, which might have remained intact even as he grew to understand the war's brutal realities.
• The impact of witnessing harm and loss can vary greatly depending on an individual's pre-existing beliefs, psychological resilience, and support systems.
• The focus on courage and altruism might inadvertently minimize the psychological trauma and moral injuries that soldiers can suffer from, which can be as debilitating as physical wounds.
• The concept of a 'just war' posits that war can be morally justified if it meets certain criteria, such as being a last resort, having a just cause, and being waged with the right intentions.
• The concept of fighting for Democracy, despite the tragic losses, could be seen as an effort to protect and promote a set of values and a way of life that was threatened by opposing forces.
• It is possible that some fighters, instead of becoming disillusioned, may have had their beliefs in the cause they were fighting for strengthened by their experiences on the battlefield.

Upon his return, Libby encountered numerous psychological and physical challenges as he navigated his injuries and adjusted to civilian life once again.

After his return to the United States, Libby faced ongoing challenges, both mental and physical, as a result of his wartime experiences. His service-related spinal injuries continue to cause him ongoing pain and limit his range of motion. He manages his pain through medication and alternative treatments, such as iodine baths, which serve as evidence of the lasting physical impact from his time in military conflict.

Libby also emphasizes the difficulties he encountered while readjusting to life outside of military service after being involved in prolonged warfare. He discovers that his experiences in the conflict have resulted in a divide with his family and friends, who are unable to fully understand the extent of his ordeal. He finds comfort solely among other veterans who grasp the silent truths of combat, frustrated by their insistence on exaggerated tales of wartime horrors.

Context

• The transition from a structured military life to a more fluid civilian lifestyle can be jarring, requiring significant adjustments in daily routines and personal identity.
• Such injuries can significantly affect daily activities, making tasks that require bending, lifting, or prolonged sitting and standing challenging.
• During the time, there was a growing interest in alternative medicine as people sought more holistic approaches to health, reflecting a broader cultural trend.
• There can be a stigma associated with seeking mental health support, which may prevent veterans from accessing necessary care.
• As a coping mechanism, some veterans may develop emotional numbness, which can hinder their ability to connect with loved ones on an emotional level.
• Many veterans experience post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD), and being around others who have similar experiences can help in processing and managing symptoms.
• Veterans may struggle with PTSD and other mental health issues, which can affect how they perceive and recount their experiences. Exaggeration might be a way to externalize internal struggles.

The writer imparts his understanding of the dogfights that occurred in the French heavens during the First World War

In this part of the narrative, Libby offers his distinctive insights into the aerial conflict over France, detailing his views on the strategies, advancements in equipment, and the characters that played a role. He elaborates on the constantly evolving nature of flight technology, underscoring its pivotal influence in determining the trajectory of the conflict.

Frederick Libby offers a deep understanding of the tactics, advancements in technology, and personality studies related to the British Royal Flying Corps and their counterparts in Germany.

Libby offers an insightful examination of how strategies for combat in the skies evolved during the First World War. He narrates the evolution of air battles from simple reconnaissance missions to complex operations that included bombardment missions, dogfights in the sky, and low-flying attack runs. He underscores the pivotal importance of aerial surveillance and photography, recounting his experiences in mapping key targets like Valenciennes, a crucial railway hub for the German forces that was of immense importance to the Allied effort.

He also highlights the rapid advancements in aviation technology, noting the significant contrast between the capabilities of the initial aircraft and the improved maneuverability and speed of later models like the Albatros, Sopwith Triplane, and the Airco D.H.4. Libby discusses the various capabilities and limitations of aircraft, underscoring the importance of ongoing advancements to secure a tactical advantage against adversaries.

Frederick Libby narrates the dangers and challenges faced by the Royal Flying Corps, which saw a substantial number of its airmen and reconnaissance personnel perish.

Frederick Libby's narrative powerfully depicts the dangers and challenges faced by individuals who served in the capacities of pilots and observers within the Royal Flying Corps. He recounts his experiences in multiple aerial combats, highlighting the intense pressure and constant risk of being singled out and shot down by enemy aircraft. He narrates a harrowing incident where a jammed rudder control almost led to a deadly outcome for himself and his observer during a flight above enemy lines.

He also recognizes the significant loss among the British aviators engaged in aerial combat, frequently contemplating the harsh realities of conflict, underscored by the dwindling number of familiar faces at group meals. Libby emphasizes the deep emotional impact of these losses, highlighting the constant fear of death and the uncertainty that hung over even the most experienced pilots.

Context

• The RFC faced challenges such as limited training, inadequate equipment, and the psychological toll of constant danger.
• Aerial combat tactics were still developing, with pilots learning through trial and error. This experimental phase meant that strategies were often untested and could lead to high casualty rates.
• Libby’s experiences would have included navigating the challenges of early aviation technology, such as unreliable engines and limited instrumentation, which added to the peril of aerial missions.
• Poor weather could severely impact visibility and aircraft performance, making it easier for enemy planes to gain an advantage.
• A jammed rudder would make it difficult to maintain a straight flight path, potentially causing the aircraft to spin or veer uncontrollably, which is particularly dangerous during combat or when flying at low altitudes.
• The life expectancy of a new pilot in the RFC during World War I was notoriously short, often just a few weeks, due to the high-risk nature of early aerial warfare.
• The RFC eventually became part of the Royal Air Force (RAF) in 1918, reflecting the growing importance and recognition of air power in military strategy.
• The loss of comrades in such a close-knit environment would have had a profound emotional impact on the surviving members, affecting morale and mental health.
• The Royal Flying Corps played a crucial role in reconnaissance and support, making the loss of personnel a significant blow to military operations.
• Once in the air, pilots were isolated from their comrades, relying solely on their skills and instincts, which heightened the sense of vulnerability.

Frederick Libby greatly admired the camaraderie, skill, and sportsmanship of the pilots in the Royal Flying Corps and also held esteem for some German aces.

Libby's narrative communicates a deep admiration for the camaraderie and common values that bonded the pilots within the Royal Flying Corps. He consistently praises the bravery and skill of his fellow aviators, highlighting their unwavering dedication and tireless contributions to the military campaign. He describes a culture of mutual support and respect both within and between squadrons, emphasizing the importance of teamwork in achieving success and survival.

Libby expresses respect for some aviators from Germany, such as the renowned Oswald Boelcke. He recognizes the skill and bravery displayed in battle, emphasizing the honorable way in which all parties participated in the aerial engagement. He describes how the RFC paid homage to Boelcke, their departed aviation ally, by solemnly flying a floral homage over the area where his squadron operated.

Practical Tips

• Volunteer for a local sports team or club to experience and contribute to an environment of sportsmanship and camaraderie. By helping out with events, coaching, or even just cheering on the team, you'll immerse yourself in a community that values fair play and mutual respect.
• Enhance your decision-making skills by adopting principles from admired historical figures. Identify key strategies or principles that figures like Oswald Boelcke used in their fields, and brainstorm ways to integrate similar approaches into your daily life. For example, if Boelcke was known for his tactical decisions, you might create a decision-making framework for yourself based on his approach, applying it when you face complex choices.
• Create a personal ritual to reflect on the values and lessons from influential figures in history. Set aside a day each year to engage in an activity that aligns with their values or contributions. If you're inspired by someone who championed education, you might spend that day visiting a library, donating books to schools, or volunteering to read to children.

Other Perspectives

• The sense of camaraderie and shared values that Libby describes could be idealized, potentially overlooking the complexities and varied individual experiences within the Corps.
• The focus on bravery and skill could inadvertently glamorize war, overshadowing the tragic losses and the harsh realities of aerial combat.
• Recognizing the dedication and contributions of the pilots should not negate the fact that there were likely instances of dissent or reluctance within the ranks, which is a natural aspect of any large group dynamic, especially in high-stress situations like war.
• The concept of mutual support and respect might have been more of an aspirational goal than a consistently realized practice, with actual dynamics being more complex and less uniformly positive.
• In some cases, the dynamics of teamwork could lead to groupthink, where the desire for harmony or conformity in the group results in an irrational or dysfunctional decision-making outcome.
• Respect for enemy combatants can sometimes be seen as controversial, especially among those who may have suffered directly under the actions of the opposing side.
• The narrative of honorable conduct may overlook or underrepresent instances of misconduct, war crimes, or other actions by pilots that would not be considered honorable, as historical accounts often focus on the more positive aspects of participants' behavior.

The author's life was deeply influenced by the relationships and connections established during the periods before the war, throughout the conflict, and after its conclusion.

The book provides an in-depth look at the pivotal figures and connections that shaped his character and guided him through the challenges of war and the time that followed. He reveals the importance of familial bonds, the enduring strength of wartime friendships, and the impact of individuals who crossed his path, offering kindness and support during crucial moments.

Frederick Libby's growth and support network were significantly influenced by his close relationships with his father, brother, and aunt.

Frederick Libby cherishes the memories of his father, his sibling Bud, and his beloved Aunt Josephine, who he fondly refers to as Aunt Jo. He credits his father for instilling in him the core values of honesty and integrity, as well as the ability to appreciate humor. His involvement was crucial in enhancing his abilities as a horse rider, offering steadfast guidance and support.

Frederick Libby fondly remembered the time he was nurtured by his Aunt Jo in Massachusetts, highlighting the importance of family ties in his formative years and the lasting impact she had on his life. Frederick Libby finds solace and a sense of belonging in the relationships he builds, providing a steadfast companion amid the chaos and uncertainty of war.

The connections and interactions that Frederick Libby had with his fellow soldiers and superiors within the Royal Flying Corps greatly shaped his experiences during and after the war.

While serving with the British aerial military unit, Libby developed deep connections with his fellow aviators. The connection they established was vital for providing each other with support and camaraderie, particularly when facing ongoing dangers and a considerable number of aviator deaths. He depicts his partnership with Captain Price as a prime example of effective teamwork and loyalty, underscoring the importance of trust and mutual reliance during combat scenarios.

Libby was profoundly affected by the deaths of his comrades, including Albert Ball and Babe Cattell, which underscored the mental toll of war and the enduring impact such relationships had on his life. Frederick Libby's character and understanding of human relationships were profoundly shaped by the powerful connections forged during times of warfare.

Practical Tips

• Start a "flight log" journal to document your daily interactions and the qualities you appreciate in the people you meet. Just as aviators might keep detailed logs of their flights, you can keep a record of your personal interactions, noting what you learned from each person and how they've impacted your day. This practice can deepen your appreciation for your connections and help you reflect on the value of each relationship.
• Write a letter to the departed individual expressing the impact they had on your life. This can be a cathartic exercise to articulate your feelings and acknowledge the profound effect they've had on you. You don't need to send it; it's for your personal reflection and to help process your grief.
• Create a personal reflection journal focused on the relationships in your life. Dedicate time each week to write about how your interactions with friends, family, and colleagues shape your character. Reflect on moments of conflict, support, and growth to better understand the enduring impact of these connections.

Frederick Libby's worldview and personal experiences were influenced by his engagements with a varied assembly of individuals hailing from the United States as well as the United Kingdom.

Throughout his time in the military and his journeys through various countries, Libby encountered numerous individuals who profoundly influenced his life. He expresses deep appreciation for the kindness and hospitality shown to him by people across the United States and in the major urban areas of Britain and Ireland.

Libby expresses gratitude for the support he received from various individuals throughout his adventures, including a London tailor who supplied him with his first military uniform and allowed him to pay later, a compassionate Chinese restaurant owner in Calexico who helped him financially during a gambling stint, and inspiring figures such as Ambassador Page and Raymond B. Price. These encounters speak to the resilience of human kindness amidst difficult circumstances and showcase the interconnectedness of individuals across geographical boundaries and during wartime.

Context

• Interactions with diverse individuals often lead to a rich exchange of cultural perspectives, which can broaden one's understanding of different societal norms and values.
• The early 1900s were a time of economic fluctuation, and acts of kindness, such as financial assistance, were crucial for many individuals navigating uncertain times.
• The period was marked by significant global upheaval, with World War I fostering a sense of unity and shared purpose among the Allied nations, which often extended to personal relationships and interactions.
• This interaction highlights the cultural exchanges between Americans and Britons during the war, where acts of kindness helped bridge national and cultural divides.
• Chinese restaurants have historically served as community centers for both Chinese immigrants and locals, providing not just food but also social support and financial assistance to those in need.
• Walter Hines Page was the U.S. Ambassador to the United Kingdom during World War I. He played a significant role in strengthening U.S.-UK relations and was known for his diplomatic efforts to support the Allied cause.
• Wartime often spurs advancements in communication technology, enabling faster and more efficient interaction between people across different regions.