PDF Summary:Broken Money, by Lyn Alden

In today's modern monetary landscape, wealth seems concentrated in currencies without tangible backing—the fiat standard has clear flaws that adversely impact developing nations. In Broken Money, author Lyn Alden provides a panoramic view of money throughout history, from early currencies tied to commodity values to our current fiat system.

The book explores Bitcoin as a pioneering solution that could democratize finance, empowering individuals through decentralized digital currency. Alden examines both Bitcoin's potential for positive global impact and challenges like volatility and illicit use—delivering an insightful look at an innovative technology with far-reaching implications.

(continued)...

Other Perspectives

• The evolution of monetary systems may not be linear or universal; some societies may have developed complex trade systems without formal records or precious metals.
• The use of shells, salt, and furs as currency could be seen as a form of decentralized finance that had its own merits and efficiencies, which might be overlooked when focusing solely on their replacement by metals.
• The argument that precious metals are superior due to their stock-to-flow ratios doesn't account for the cultural and social factors that also contribute to the perceived value of these metals.
• The hawala system, while efficient, may not be as secure or reliable as formal banking systems, and could be susceptible to misuse without proper regulation.
• Double-entry bookkeeping and paper money, while transformative, also introduced new complexities and opportunities for financial manipulation and fraud.
• The centralization of banking and the shift towards central banks can be criticized for creating systems that may be more susceptible to systemic risks and less responsive to local needs.
• The Gold Standard had its own set of problems, such as deflationary pressures and constraints on economic growth, which are not addressed in the text.
• The telecommunications revolution has also led to increased financial exclusion for those without access to technology, and has raised privacy and security concerns.
• The abandonment of the gold standard during World War I can be seen as a necessary response to extraordinary circumstances, and not necessarily the beginning of a problematic trend.
• The dominance of the U.S. dollar can be critiqued for creating imbalances in the global economy and for the outsized influence it gives the United States in international affairs.
• Eurodollars and the petrodollar system can be criticized for contributing to global economic imbalances and for perpetuating the reliance on fossil fuels.
• The current fiat currency system allows for more flexible monetary policy and economic management, which can be beneficial in times of crisis.
• Developing nations' debt in foreign currencies can be seen as a result of broader systemic issues in the global financial system, rather than simply poor monetary policy decisions by those nations.
• The IMF and World Bank have been subject to reform and have made efforts to improve their policies and practices in response to criticism, which is not acknowledged in the text.

Innovation and transformation are essential.

The factors leading to the collapse of the current financial framework.

In this section, Alden delves into the core vulnerabilities and questionable intentions that drive the behavior of those in charge of today's fiat currency system. The author emphasizes the system's tendency to inflate and the challenges people face in trying to protect and increase their wealth, as ongoing meddling frequently results in imbalances and intensifies detrimental economic fluctuations.

The tendency for fiat currency systems to depreciate often favors those closer to the source of money creation, to the detriment of savers.

The author highlights the inherent challenges intrinsic to systems dependent on fiat currency. The purchasing power of individual currency units consistently erodes as a result of the ongoing expansion of the money supply. The writer argues that this obscure system subtly redistributes wealth, funneling assets from savers to institutions with more immediate access to the flow of money, including banks and government agencies.

The continuous devaluation of currency creates detrimental motivations within the framework of the economy. People aiming to maintain the value of their savings find themselves driven to seek out riskier investment options, and this behavior encourages borrowers to take on more debt, thereby inflating asset prices and aiding in the creation of financial bubbles.

The Cantillon effect leads to a skewed distribution of newly minted money, benefiting large corporations and well-connected organizations.

The author explores the uneven distribution of freshly minted currency, shedding light on the concept known as the Cantillon effect. The book details the process by which the introduction of new currency into the economy by central banks disproportionately benefits entities such as major banks, large corporations, and politically connected groups, leading to a disparity in the competitive landscape for those who receive this monetary influx last.

Lyn Alden emphasizes how this pattern becomes more pronounced during economic slumps that result in the preferential rescue of certain entities. By directing fresh resources towards favored sectors or institutions, governments inadvertently facilitate significant wealth transfers to these entities. The financial turmoil of 2008 and 2020 demonstrates a recurring cycle where the infusion of fresh capital into the market favors banks and major companies, often to the detriment of smaller enterprises, individuals saving money, and investors relying on fixed income, as it devalues their holdings.

The inclination to incur debt during periods of economic instability frequently leads to the piling up of monetary liabilities and the formation of economic bubbles.

Alden suggests that the persistent decline in the purchasing power of fiat currencies compels both individuals and businesses to amass levels of debt that cannot be sustained. To protect your economic well-being when the currency you earn and save loses its purchasing power, it's prudent to hold less cash and smartly employ debt with low interest rates to allocate funds into investments that either maintain or grow their worth.

The author suggests that the capacity of central bankers to seamlessly lower interest rates and infuse the market with liquidity leads to a growing accumulation of debt, which in turn fosters the creation of financial bubbles. These bubbles are inevitably set to pop, leading to economic downturns that tend to endure.

Central banks intensify economic cycles and encourage unproductive investments through modifications in the money supply and adjustments to interest rates.

Alden suggests that the actions of central bank authorities often intensify economic fluctuations due to their misaligned incentives and a limited grasp of the entire system, rather than serving to temper these economic swings.

The writer emphasizes the actions taken by the Federal Reserve in the 2000s as a crucial example. Following the collapse of the dot-com bubble, they significantly lowered interest rates to levels never seen before, thereby magnifying the ensuing real estate bubble. The rapid escalation of their borrowing expenses contributed to triggering the downfall of the expanding housing bubble. Lyn Alden suggests that measures taken to ensure economic stability after the 2020 health crisis could inadvertently exacerbate inequalities over time.

To mitigate their debt burdens, governments resort to strategies like devaluing their currency and implementing measures to regulate capital movement.

Governments use financial repression as a strategy to reduce their debt by creating inflation, imposing capital controls, and keeping interest rates deliberately low. Alden explains that historically, when faced with overwhelming national debt, governments have deliberately reduced their currency's worth and have put measures in place to control the flow of capital.

During the 1940s, the United States, among other nations burdened with debt, utilized this approach. During World War II, the government kept interest rates low despite ongoing inflation because of the intense requirements of warfare. The policy led to bondholders being compensated with dollars that had greatly lost their value relative to their strength before the war.

Digital ledger technologies and virtual currencies offer a range of new opportunities.

The text explores the potential for cryptocurrencies such as Bitcoin to overcome the inherent limitations of the current financial system. The author demonstrates how individuals can gain empowerment and enhance their privacy, in addition to building a stronger financial foundation, through embracing the concepts of distributed control.

Bitcoin operates as an autonomous, publicly available system that settles transactions with greater speed and ensures more enduring records of those transactions than conventional currencies do, while also maintaining a supply that cannot be altered.

Since its inception in 2009, the Bitcoin network has continuously operated as the first decentralized digital currency without any interruptions. Alden highlights the system's potential to resolve the persistent problem of slow financial transfers, which have been an issue since the mid-1800s, by combining the stability of a solid currency with the speed of electronic transactions.

Fiat currencies, which frequently experience a rise in their supply because of the issuance of new money, contrast with Bitcoin, which was designed with a fixed limit of 21 million coins. The author argues that the distinct combination of limited availability, decentralized structure, and the ability to participate without authorization contributes to the development of a financial tool that is inherently resistant to depreciation and interference, offering a chance to create a steadier economic system.

People struggling with the diminishing buying power of their currency can safeguard and preserve their wealth by investing in universally recognized assets that are readily transportable across national boundaries.

Bitcoin provides a way for individuals to circumvent capital control measures and protect their wealth during times of currency devaluation and stringent fiscal regulation. The book describes a strategy for people to protect their assets and move them across borders by memorizing a specific sequence of twelve words linked to their exclusive private key, thus bypassing the reliance on banking or governmental assurances. Lyn Alden emphasizes the importance of this skill for people in regions suffering from severe inflation, unstable currencies, or social unrest, and also for those who face biased limitations on their financial activities.

The author discusses how Roya Mahboob empowered Afghan women by compensating them with Bitcoin, a currency beyond the reach of their male relatives and within their own management. Additionally, the author describes how Nigerians turned to Bitcoin as a different financial mechanism when their bank accounts were suspended for protesting against police brutality. This highlights how, while Bitcoin may appear niche in developed countries, the technology has potentially transformative implications for billions of people facing unstable currencies or financial censorship.

Assisting champions for human rights in overcoming financial constraints under authoritarian regimes.

Alden highlights how Bitcoin is increasingly becoming a tool to strengthen human rights in countries with authoritarian governments, where financial power is frequently used to suppress dissent and mute opposition. The author argues that the resilience of Bitcoin's network to censorship provides a significant benefit for human rights advocates, enabling them to securely receive funding, move money, and carry out their operations under the watchful eyes of authoritarian governments.

The book cites Gladstein's research, highlighting the trend of individuals adopting Bitcoin in response to stringent governmental fiscal scrutiny. The team led by Navalny in Russia found different ways to maintain their financial support despite restrictions on their banking, while Nigerian protesters adopted Bitcoin to continue their efforts when cut off from the traditional banking system. Bitcoin consistently showcases its potency as a tool for emancipation in scenarios where other financial remedies fall short.

The Lightning Network bolsters the capabilities of Bitcoin by facilitating faster, less expensive, and private transactions, thus rendering it more suitable for everyday monetary transactions.

The Lightning Network serves as an additional layer, constructed to enhance scalability and directly integrated with the underlying Bitcoin framework. Transactions conducted with Bitcoin gain speed, cost-efficiency, and enhanced privacy when executed through a network of interconnected peers. Alden clarifies that this development addresses common criticisms about the limited capacity for transaction processing on Bitcoin's fundamental layer, yet it preserves the network's decentralized essence and its resilience to censorship, in addition to enabling users to maintain possession of their funds.

The author provides detailed insights into the intricate attributes of Bitcoin, highlighting its ability to facilitate large, irreversible, and confirmable transactions, as well as manage regular, small-scale payments, similar to how the banking system depends on Fedwire for major settlements and different levels of credit for lesser transactions, with the added advantage of enabling users to choose their level of interaction with each layer.

Bitcoin's programmability is enhanced by smart contracts, which not only foster financial innovation but also potentially enable traditional assets to be represented in a tokenized manner.

Smart contracts facilitate the creation of tailored rules for interactions on the blockchain that go beyond simple financial transactions. Alden describes how this opens the possibility of automating financial services and collateralized credit, as well as tokenizing traditional assets such as securities or real estate, allowing for a faster and more universally accessible financial system. The author explores the ways in which auxiliary systems such as the Lightning Network augment the fundamental protocol of Bitcoin, and they discuss how platforms like RSK and Stacks introduce capabilities for smart contracts within the Bitcoin network, reducing the need for trust.

Additionally, Alden emphasizes that systems like Fedimint could harmonize Bitcoin's inherent distributed nature with the user-friendliness anticipated from traditional banking and transaction systems. Bitcoin, when integrated with the Lightning Network, fosters the establishment of financial organizations that function autonomously and with discretion, reflecting the core ideals of Chaumian e-cash.

Context

• The Cantillon effect is an economic theory named after Richard Cantillon. It describes how the distribution of newly created money affects different groups in an economy unequally. Essentially, it highlights how those who receive the new money first benefit more than those who receive it later, leading to disparities in wealth distribution. This effect is particularly relevant in analyzing the impact of monetary policy on various sectors of the economy.
• Fedwire is a real-time gross settlement system operated by the U.S. Federal Reserve Banks for financial institutions to transfer funds electronically. It is a critical network for large-value or time-sensitive domestic and international payments, working alongside the CHIPS system. Fedwire processes transfers instantly or on the same business day, providing a highly resilient platform for financial transactions.
• Chaumian e-cash is a concept developed by David Chaum in the 1980s, focusing on anonymous electronic money systems. It involves digital cash stored on a user's device, signed by a bank, allowing transactions without revealing personal information. The system utilizes cryptographic techniques like RSA blind signatures to ensure security and privacy in financial transactions. DigiCash, founded by Chaum, implemented this e-cash system in the 1990s, pioneering the idea of digital currency with privacy features.

The implications for ethics, privacy, and human rights in a world dominated by Bitcoin are significant.

This section contemplates the long-term consequences of a world where Bitcoin or other similar stateless monetary networks achieve widespread adoption. Lyn Alden explores the advantages and challenges that may accompany this shift, emphasizing the moral implications and issues linked to a system that offers people greater authority over their financial affairs, particularly in terms of privacy.

Bolstering liberty, ensuring safety, and safeguarding confidentiality.

Lyn Alden views the broad embrace of Bitcoin and associated platforms as a predominantly positive development. She believes that it enhances individual freedom, strengthens the resilience of financial systems by reducing the power of currency creators, and could spur economic development in developing economies.

By managing their own encryption keys and operating independent network nodes, individuals can reduce their reliance on centralized entities and gain a degree of control over their financial autonomy.

In a scenario where Bitcoin becomes widespread, individuals would have considerably more autonomy over their financial affairs compared to what the current system allows. Alden explains that individuals can maintain complete autonomy over their financial assets by committing a numerical code to memory or keeping it in a secure location, free from the reliance on centralized banks or authorities.

The author argues that this shift has profound implications for freedom and economic stability, especially in light of currency fluctuations, worldwide political unrest, and restrictions on the flow of capital. In a time when transactions are executed with near-instant speed and individuals have the capability to confirm the trustworthiness of the network through personal verification methods, the conventional middlemen who have benefited from the more sluggish and intricate financial transactions might witness a decline in their influence and control. This potentially reduces frictions for small businesses and individuals, since they could send, receive, and store their wealth with greater autonomy, and therefore be less reliant on potentially predatory banks and payment services companies.

The ability to move value freely could stimulate economic expansion in regions plagued by unstable local currencies.

Lyn Alden highlights how Bitcoin's design empowers people worldwide by allowing them to conduct transactions directly, without the need for central supervision or permission. Critics from developed nations often concentrate exclusively on the fluctuating market value of the technology, overlooking its practical uses, while the author emphasizes its importance for emerging economies and those dealing with inconsistent monetary systems and a range of financial challenges.

An African entrepreneur can seamlessly receive payments from customers in North America or Europe, while an Argentinian worker possesses the capability to transfer funds to family members or save money for purchasing a vehicle in a currency that retains its worth, regardless of the local government's policies. Bitcoin, according to Alden, has the potential to create a stronger and more accessible worldwide commerce base with its swift transaction capability, potentially surpassing the current efficiency of a system comprised of 160 separate fiat currencies.

Creating a fixed-record system with a predetermined amount that cannot be expanded, thereby promoting a stable monetary system and reliable economic projections.

A key advantage of a monetary network that is genuinely decentralized and open-source with an immutable supply cap is that it curtails the capacity to generate currency at an expense substantially lower than its prevailing market worth, a concept known as seigniorage. The manipulation of this mechanism has been crucial for the operation of fiat currency, frequently resulting in expanded governmental power at the expense of savers.

Alden anticipates that a decrease in seigniorage might result in less political corruption, improve economic stability, foster the development of extensive strategic planning, and strengthen the reliability of business projections. When governments are unable to discreetly diminish the value of savings by introducing additional currency to manage budget shortfalls or fund defense activities, they are compelled to turn to more transparent and accountable means of generating public revenue.

Proponents of Bitcoin mining support tapping into dormant energy resources, potentially leading to the establishment of essential infrastructure in developing nations.

Alden posits that bitcoin miners contribute positively to the evolution of renewable energy by providing a system that is not bound by location and can adapt to varying levels of demand, thereby monetizing electricity in a way that supports the growth of clean energy, particularly in remote areas lacking established electrical grids.

The author describes a strategy that leverages excess hydroelectric power during wet seasons for economic gain, captures and repurposes natural gas typically wasted in flaring, transforms methane emissions from landfills into a viable energy source, and promotes the growth of renewable energy facilities beyond current demand, with the intention of selling the surplus energy produced to businesses that mine cryptocurrencies. The writer posits that this possibility holds significant promise for transformation, especially in developing nations that are rich in renewable energy sources yet lack efficient ways to harness and distribute them.

Encryption techniques bolster transaction confidentiality, limiting the ability of corporations and authorities to collect data, while still permitting scrutiny by those who are interested.

Bitcoin offers enhanced privacy for transaction details compared to conventional banking and payment systems, which face growing scrutiny and data gathering by corporations. Alden explains that if managed correctly, Bitcoin could restore a degree of transactional privacy similar to that of physical money and simultaneously enhance its global portability.

People looking to increase the confidentiality of their transactions can employ various methods to make it more difficult for external entities to track Bitcoin transactions, such as utilizing mixing services, engaging in coinjoin processes, and leveraging the capabilities of the Lightning Network. The writer argues that the immutable and transparent characteristics of the Bitcoin ledger offer unmatched certainty regarding the current supply of coins and the generation of new ones, while also granting users the autonomy to select varying degrees of confidentiality for their Bitcoin transactions.

Potential Drawbacks and Concerns

Lyn Alden conveys an optimistic view regarding the technological features inherent in Bitcoin, yet acknowledges the potential obstacles and hazards associated with its use and general adoption. She cautions against viewing it as a universal remedy for every economic and social issue, emphasizing the perpetual need for technological progress, enhanced user understanding, and more robust backing from the community to address these difficulties.

Concerns regarding the exploitation of an unrestricted and censorship-proof network have necessitated the enhancement of protective strategies and advanced techniques among police forces.

The decentralized and censorship-resistant nature of Bitcoin presents new challenges for law enforcement in their efforts to limit its utilization for unlawful activities. Alden acknowledges that new technological developments are often manipulated by those with malicious intent, posing a direct threat through their swift adoption and proliferation within illegal markets.

The writer emphasizes that with the network's growth and increased adoption for legitimate activities, it is anticipated that its misuse for malicious intents will diminish in importance. The immutable and transparent nature of Bitcoin's transaction ledger, in contrast to physical currencies or other payment methods, facilitates the development of sophisticated tracking methods that can aid authorities in monitoring illegal activities over time, potentially improving the capacity for various regions to share intelligence and combat organized crime.

The value of Bitcoin, known for its volatility, must be more widely accepted and deeply incorporated to attain stability, in addition to improving the overall understanding of the technology that underpins it.

The rapid increase in Bitcoin's value, surpassing a trillion dollars, presents a considerable barrier to its broad adoption due to its notorious volatility. Alden cautions that the precariousness, largely due to borrowing based on speculation rather than genuine economic exchanges, might deter many potential participants.

The author emphasizes the need to foster a setting that eases the network's use for the average person and underscores the critical need for extensive educational efforts to ensure that users have a clear and ongoing comprehension of Bitcoin's functionality. The growth of Bitcoin's user base and the strengthening of market liquidity are expected to result in decreased volatility in the cryptocurrency's value. Alden notes that with each cycle of price surges and subsequent declines, Bitcoin has exhibited a pattern of reduced volatility, while the overall value of the network progressively increases.

The success of the technology is contingent upon widespread distribution, the creation of a significant network effect, and public awareness of its benefits, particularly considering the possibility of harsh government bans and strict regulatory actions.

Governments, particularly those with unstable economic policies or autocratic leanings, frequently resist the integration of Bitcoin and similar innovations because they challenge the government's control over the facilitation and regulation of financial exchanges. Alden recognizes the genuine possibility that different areas may implement bans, raise taxes, or introduce additional regulations that could decelerate the broad acceptance of Bitcoin.

The author highlights that the decentralized nature of Bitcoin poses a substantial obstacle to implementing widespread regulations among a committed and broad user base. The broader acceptance of Bitcoin by both individuals and corporations, along with its increasing adoption, reduces the capacity of governments to limit its utilization, similar to the difficulties authoritarian regimes encounter in maintaining their financial controls, especially during periods of high inflation.

The United States and other prosperous nations must recognize that the present system's imbalances are unsustainable and work together towards enhancements rather than becoming more deeply embedded in the status quo.

Alden emphasizes the importance for affluent countries, such as the United States, to take the initiative in overhauling the current financial system while they still hold a strong stance, instead of delaying until they are forced to make changes when their strength has waned.

While benefiting from the prevailing economic framework, the United States has found itself deeply entrenched in a massive deficit concerning international investments and has observed a marked downturn in its domestic manufacturing industry. The author proposes that the United States could strengthen its economic stance by enacting reforms that encourage equitable competition both at home and abroad, foster a worldwide financial system characterized by greater clarity and accountability, and advocate for a monetary system with reduced dependence on centralized control.

Context

• Seigniorage is the profit a government makes by issuing currency. It's the difference between the cost of producing money and its face value. Governments can abuse seigniorage by creating more money than needed, leading to inflation and decreased purchasing power. This practice can erode trust in the currency and harm the economy over time.
• Coinjoin processes and the Lightning Network are both technologies used to enhance the privacy and efficiency of Bitcoin transactions. Coinjoin is a method where multiple users combine their transactions into a single transaction, making it harder to trace individual funds. The Lightning Network is a layer-2 scaling solution that enables instant and low-cost transactions by creating payment channels off the main Bitcoin blockchain. Both technologies aim to address some of the limitations of the traditional Bitcoin network, offering users more privacy and faster transaction speeds.
• Bitcoin transactions are recorded on a public ledger called the blockchain, which is transparent and immutable. While Bitcoin transactions are pseudonymous, meaning they are not directly tied to individuals' identities, sophisticated tracking methods can be used to analyze patterns and link transactions to specific addresses. Law enforcement agencies can use blockchain analysis tools to trace the flow of funds and identify potential illicit activities, aiding in investigations and combating criminal behavior. This transparency can help authorities monitor and track suspicious transactions, contributing to efforts to prevent money laundering, terrorism financing, and other illegal activities within the Bitcoin network.
• The network effect in relation to Bitcoin adoption describes how the value and utility of Bitcoin increase as more people use it. As more individuals and businesses adopt Bitcoin, the network becomes more robust, secure, and widely accepted. This increased adoption can lead to greater liquidity, stability, and overall trust in the Bitcoin ecosystem. Essentially, the more users Bitcoin has, the more valuable and functional it becomes as a decentralized digital currency.