In the latest episode of "Unexplainable," listeners are taken on an investigative journey into the enigma of human tears with insights from Ad Vingerhoets, an expert delving into the emotional aspect of crying. What sets our tears apart from our primal need for survival? Vingerhoets's research, involving emotional inductions through films, seeks to unveil whether weeping genuinely alleviates pain or stress, shedding light on the physical and emotional responses that follow a good cry. He also explores how societal interactions and receptions of crying influence its benefits, asserting that empathy plays a crucial role in the cathartic experience of shedding tears.
The podcast further explores the societal and personal implications of crying—or the lack thereof—with a captivating narrative from Benjamin Perry, a seminary student striving to reintegrate the act of crying into his life and ministry. Perry's conscious effort to welcome tears uncovers the profound impact emotional expression has on connecting with oneself and others. His experience illustrates how crying fosters understanding and support within a community, challenging the stigmas and promoting a culture of empathy and vulnerability. The episode peers into the fascinating, yet still largely uncharted, intersection of science, sociology, and human emotion surrounding the simple, yet complex act of crying.
Sign up for Shortform to access the whole episode summary along with additional materials like counterarguments and context.
Ad Vingerhoets spearheads research to decipher why humans shed emotional tears and how it influences them. He employs films in experiments to trigger emotions and examines the consequent effects on pain perception. Vingerhoets uncovers that while sources suggest that crying might expel stress hormones or release endorphins or oxytocin, his study concludes that crying does not significantly alter pain perception. Furthermore, his multicultural study of over 5,000 individuals reveals that only about half feel better after crying. The benefits of crying appear closely tied to how others respond to it, emphasizing the importance of empathy in the crying experience.
The scientific community has a limited understanding of the biological and emotional roles of crying. Despite Charles Darwin’s view that emotional tears are functionless, modern scientists are exploring this phenomenon, but there's still a lack of comprehensive neural studies and real-life observations. Concerns over not crying enough reflect broader societal implications, as it can affect personal dynamics. Vingerhoets's research finds that people who cry are perceived as more empathetic and connected, and receive more social support. Nevertheless, it also indicates that not crying does not necessarily impact well-being unless it results from suppressed emotions.
Benjamin Perry, a seminary student, realizes that he has not cried in years, viewing it as detrimental to his emotional expression and community connection. By intentionally triggering tears daily, Perry re-engages with a diverse range of emotions and cultivates a deeper sense of authenticity. This reconnection with crying disrupts the norm, giving permission to others to display their emotions and promoting empathy. Perry shares an episode from a worship service where a choir member's crying led the congregation to pause and show compassion. His personal journey echoes in his ministry, highlighting that embracing vulnerability enriches community ties and opens space for emotional expression, previously stifled by societal norms.
1-Page Summary
Ad Vingerhoets has been leading pioneering research to better understand why humans cry and the impact it has, through extensive experiments and a multicultural study with more than 5,000 participants.
Vingerhoets conducted experiments to explore the reasons for human tears, utilizing films to provoke emotional responses in participants and studying the effects on their pain perception. Participants also provided detailed descriptions about their mental state and the circumstances surrounding the last instance they cried.
Research in this area has yielded various hypotheses. William H. Frey's theory likens tear glands to kidneys, suggesting that crying may serve as a detox mechanism that expels stress hormones from the body. Another idea posits that crying might trigger the release of endorphins or oxytocin—hormones linked to positive feelings—that could improve one's emotional state. However, Vingerhoets's research on whether crying affects pain perception indicated that there was no significant impact.
Vingerhoets's international study revealed that only around 50% of participants actually felt better after crying. This inconsistency triggers questions about the conditions that make crying cathartic for some but not for others.
Why humans cry emotional tears
The podcast highlights the general lack of understanding surrounding the biological purpose and emotional significance of human crying. Reference is made to Charles Darwin's opinion that emotional tears serve no function, while mentioning that current researchers are attempting to prove otherwise. Nevertheless, the scientific grasp on emotional tears remains scant, with a paucity of laboratory studies, surveys, or extensive research into the matter. There is particularly little known about the neural activity that occurs during crying and what long-term effects it may have on individuals.
Additionally, the research on crying in daily life, outside of controlled laboratory environments, is sparse. This lack of knowledge has societal implications; people worry about their emotional expression through tears and how it affects their personal relationships. Crying researcher Ad Vingerhoets noted that he used to receive phone calls from individuals concerned about not crying enough or at expected times. This included a woman who had not cried in over 22 years and questioned whether this lack of crying was harmful to her well-being. A study showed that there was no difference in well-being between people who did not cry and regular criers—those who cried from zero to four times a month.
Despite this, the absence of tears was more problematic for interpersonal relationsh ...
Lack of scientific knowledge and neural studies about emotional crying
Benjamin Perry, a minister and student at Union Theological Seminary, came to a personal realization about the significance of crying in emotional expression and connection with his community.
Benjamin Perry, in preparing to become a minister, realized during a class exercise that he hadn't cried in over a decade and saw this as a personal failing. He felt his inability to cry impeded his emotional integrity and the fullness of his humanity, potentially affecting his connection with his future congregation.
Conducting an experiment to cry every day, Perry aimed to reconnect with his emotions. Initially, he focused on pain and trauma to induce tears but discovered over time that beauty and other profound feelings could evoke crying too. This exploration allowed Perry to experience a broader spectrum of emotions deeply, thereby improving his authenticity and strengthening his relationships.
Reflecting on his past, Perry recalls how, as a child, he cried frequently but began to suppress his tears because of internalized shame regarding his sexuality and societal associations of crying with femininity and queerness. In his quest for a stereotypically masculine identity and to avoid acknowledging his attraction to men, Perry chose to repress his emotions. However, when he embraced crying again, he found a renewed emotional depth in his life, describing it as feeling fully alive, enabling him to forge more meaningful connections.
Perry acknowledges the disruptive nature of crying, with its loudness and messiness. He found that when someone cries, especially during a time of silenced issues, it has the power to disrupt the quiet and give others permission to recognize and manifest their own emotions. This act challenges onlookers to choose between adhering to social ...
A minister trying to relearn crying and impacts on connecting with himself and community
Download the Shortform Chrome extension for your browser