"They Know" | Chapter 5

Dive into the chilling intersection of true crime and beauty with Bailey Sarian's unique podcast, 'Murder, Mystery & Makeup.' In this gripping episode, Bailey unveils the shocking case from Green Bay that left a community reeling. With her distinctive approach, Sarian discusses the chilling details of a grizzly murder amidst her captivating makeup tutorial, crafting an unforgettable narrative that holds listeners spellbound.

From the harrowing discovery of a severed head to the arresting courtroom drama, Bailey narrates the disturbing tale of Taylor Coronado, aka Taylor Schabusiness, and her tragic life trajectory. As Sarian paints both her face and a vivid picture of methamphetamine's dark influence on lives, she delves into the depths of human behavior, touching upon the role of mental health in criminal responsibility. The listeners are left with a haunting reflection on the complexities behind the brutal acts and a call to engage in a broader conversation about the intersection of crime, punishment, and psychological issues.

Media are rife with haunting stories of true crime, but some accounts are more chilling than others—particularly those that involve torture and murder. In If You Tell, Gregg Olsen recounts the story of notorious abuser and murderer Shelly Knotek, who, along with her husband Dave, abused and tortured their daughters, nephew, and two boarders—resulting in three deaths. Olsen is a best-selling true crime author and novelist who was asked to write this story by the Knotek daughters themselves.

In our guide, we'll discuss the ways in which Shelly abused her victims along with Dave’s help. We’ll also look specifically at how she lured two friends to become boarders at her home and then killed them, and we’ll look at the events leading up to Shelly and Dave’s arrests and convictions. Additionally, we’ll add information about the psychology of abuse and psychopathy, compare it to similar stories of child abuse, and add context about the legal system and its responsibilities in cases like these.

Immerse yourself in the gripping world of Bailey Sarian's 'Murder, Mystery & Makeup' podcast. This unique blend of chilling crime narrative and light-hearted beauty routine make for a complex, riveting listening experience. In this episode, Sarian presents the baffling mystery surrounding a woman named Stacey Ruth Daniels, linking the ordinary and the extraordinary, the homely and the horrific, in a tale filled with unexpected twists and turns. On the one hand, the audience is held captive by the grave mystery of Stacey's two deceased spouses; on the other, Sarian invites listeners into her personal space with playful segments about her life and hobbies.

Balancing the severity of the crime tale with a lighter touch, Sarian excels at drawing listeners into her world. This episode goes beyond just recounting the gruesome facts of the case, providing a comprehensive exploration of the narrative that includes an investigation into Stacey's ordinary suburban upbringing and her transformation into a suspected murderer. In addition, Sarian dives into the psychological aftermath of the crimes on Stacey's daughters, underscoring the far-reaching impact of such heinous acts. Keeping listeners engaged until the very end, the episode concludes with a dive into the cultural relevance of Stacey's disturbing acts on popular culture. Tune in to Sarian's 'Murder, Mystery & Makeup' podcast to take part in this compelling journey through the darker aspects of human nature.

Dive into the chilling intersection of true crime and beauty with Bailey Sarian's unique podcast, 'Murder, Mystery & Makeup.' In this gripping episode, Bailey unveils the shocking case from Green Bay that left a community reeling. With her distinctive approach, Sarian discusses the chilling details of a grizzly murder amidst her captivating makeup tutorial, crafting an unforgettable narrative that holds listeners spellbound.

From the harrowing discovery of a severed head to the arresting courtroom drama, Bailey narrates the disturbing tale of Taylor Coronado, aka Taylor Schabusiness, and her tragic life trajectory. As Sarian paints both her face and a vivid picture of methamphetamine's dark influence on lives, she delves into the depths of human behavior, touching upon the role of mental health in criminal responsibility. The listeners are left with a haunting reflection on the complexities behind the brutal acts and a call to engage in a broader conversation about the intersection of crime, punishment, and psychological issues.

In Murder, Mystery & Makeup, speaker Bailey Sarian dives into a spine-chilling narrative of a neighborhood tragedy from 1998. The story takes a deep look into the disappearance of young Maddie Clifton and the revelation of her body hidden under the waterbed of 14-year-old Joshua Phillips. Balancing the harrowing account of this crime with looking at Joshua's household circumstances, Sarian offers listeners a nuanced perspective of a horrific event.

Not only does Sarian share the chilling details of the crime and the subsequent investigation, she even explores the complex environments that might have shaped such a distressing scenario. Moreover, this episode challenges listeners to scrutinize the evidence, contemplate Joshua's life behind bars and communicate their thoughts on a justice system that presents a life sentence to a minor. Fans of true crime and psychological complexities will find this unnerving tale a compelling listen.