304: Heretics Podcast Summary with Ira Glass, Carlton Pearson, Russell Cobb, Jeff Voth, Martin Brown, Steve Palmer, Teresa Reed

304: Heretics

1-Page Summary

Carlton Pearson's early life and rise to evangelical megastar status

Carlton Pearson climbed from a rigorous Pentecostal background to prominence in the evangelical world. Raised in a church environment that banned smoking, drinking, and dancing, Pearson began demonstrating charismatic spiritual practices, including speaking in tongues and casting out demons as a teenager. At Oral Roberts University, he connected with the institution’s founder, Oral Roberts, a significant figure in televangelism, who came to consider Pearson like a son.

Carlton's impact expanded after he co-founded the racially integrated Higher Dimensions church in South Tulsa with Gary McIntosh. The church quickly grew into a megachurch, drawing thousands each Sunday and establishing Pearson as a prominent figure who engaged with political figures and presidents, guest preached alongside well-known evangelicals, and hosted shows on major religious networks.

The theological shift that turned Carlton into a heretic

Pearson's theological views dramatically shifted following a personal reflection inspired by a news report on Rwandan children's suffering. This led him to reject the traditional Christian doctrine of hell for the non-saved and develop the "Gospel of Inclusion," asserting that all people, regardless of their faith, are saved and will go to heaven. This view challenged the belief that only Christians could achieve salvation, suggesting that Jesus' sacrifice was sufficient for all humanity. Despite opposition, Pearson embraced this inclusive message, influenced by profound acts of love and a new understanding of God's nature.

Reactions from the evangelical community and fallout

Carlton Pearson's new teachings led to a significant rupture with the evangelical community. As he began preaching inclusion, his church congregation shrank from thousands to hundreds. He was formally declared a heretic by African-American Pentecostal bishops and was abandoned by mentors and peers, including T.D. Jakes and Oral Roberts. Financial struggles ensued with the foreclosure of Higher Dimensions Church, and Pearson suffered emotionally, particularly when his pastoral team resigned and hosted their own church. The personal and financial fallout from Pearson's shift was tremendous, leaving him isolated from the community that once celebrated him.

Carlton's theology resonating with more liberal Christian groups

Carlton Pearson's inclusive theology found a more receptive audience among progressive Christian denominations. His message of universal salvation and acceptance aligned with the beliefs of groups like the United Church of Christ and Fellowship International in San Francisco. A United Church of Christ minister preached at Pearson's church, while Bishop Yvette Flunder invited Pearson to speak and performed a ceremonial foot washing, symbolizing support for his mission. Pearson eventually established his ministry at All Souls Unitarian Church in Tulsa, which embraced his leadership and inclusive message, demonstrating the appeal and recognition of his theological perspective within more liberal Christian circles.

1-Page Summary

Additional Materials

Clarifications

In a Pentecostal context, practices like speaking in tongues involve speaking in a language unknown to the speaker, believed to be a spiritual gift. Casting out demons is the act of expelling evil spirits from individuals, often through prayer and spiritual authority. These practices are rooted in the belief in the active presence and power of the Holy Spirit in the lives of believers. Pentecostalism emphasizes a personal, experiential relationship with God and the manifestation of spiritual gifts as seen in the early Christian church.
Oral Roberts University is a prominent charismatic Christian university in Tulsa, Oklahoma, founded by evangelist Oral Roberts. Oral Roberts was a well-known televangelist and faith healer who played a significant role in the rise of the charismatic movement in Christianity. He founded the university in 1963 with a vision to integrate faith into education and to train students to impact the world spiritually and professionally. The university has a strong emphasis on Christian beliefs and practices, and it has produced many influential Christian leaders and figures over the years.
Televangelism is the use of media, like television and radio, to spread religious messages, particularly within Christianity. Televangelists are ministers who focus on broadcasting their teachings through these mediums, reaching a wide audience beyond traditional church settings. This form of outreach gained popularity in the United States due to the accessibility of television networks and funding from Christian supporters. While some countries have regulations on religious broadcasting, televangelism has expanded globally through international networks.
A megachurch is a large church with a significant congregation, often drawing thousands of attendees to its services. These churches typically have extensive facilities and resources to accommodate their large membership. Megachurches are known for their influential role in the community and their ability to host various programs and events.
Carlton Pearson's theological shift involved rejecting the traditional Christian belief in hell for the non-saved. He developed the "Gospel of Inclusion," which asserts that all people, regardless of their faith, are saved and will go to heaven. This departure from mainstream Christian doctrine challenged the idea that only Christians could attain salvation. Pearson's new perspective emphasized universal salvation through Jesus' sacrifice, regardless of one's religious affiliation.
The "Gospel of Inclusion" is a theological concept introduced by Carlton Pearson that challenges traditional Christian beliefs about salvation. It asserts that all individuals, regardless of their faith or background, are ultimately saved and will go to heaven. This perspective emphasizes universal love and acceptance, suggesting that Jesus' sacrifice extends to all humanity, not just to those who identify as Christians. Pearson's embrace of this inclusive message marked a significant departure from mainstream evangelical teachings on salvation and sparked controversy within the religious community.
Carlton Pearson faced strong backlash from the evangelical community after he embraced the "Gospel of Inclusion," which challenged traditional beliefs about salvation. This led to him being labeled a heretic by some African-American Pentecostal bishops and being abandoned by influential figures in the evangelical world. The rejection from his community resulted in a significant decline in his church congregation and financial struggles, ultimately leading to the foreclosure of his megachurch. Pearson's theological shift caused a rupture in his relationships and support network within the evangelical community, causing him to face isolation and personal challenges.
Financial struggles and the foreclosure of Higher Dimensions Church occurred as a result of dwindling congregation numbers following Carlton Pearson's shift in theological beliefs. With fewer attendees and declining financial support, the church faced challenges in maintaining its operations and meeting financial obligations, ultimately leading to the foreclosure of the church property due to an inability to sustain its expenses. This financial strain was exacerbated by the departure of key members and leaders, impacting the church's stability and ability to continue functioning as it had before. The loss of financial stability and resources contributed to the overall decline and eventual closure of Higher Dimensions Church.
The United Church of Christ is a liberal Protestant Christian denomination in the United States known for its progressive stance on social issues and inclusive theology. Fellowship International is an organization based in San Francisco that supports LGBTQ individuals and promotes a welcoming environment for all people, regardless of sexual orientation or gender identity. Both the United Church of Christ and Fellowship International align with Carlton Pearson's inclusive theology, which emphasizes universal salvation and acceptance for all individuals. Pearson found support and acceptance from these more liberal Christian groups as his theological views evolved.
A ceremonial foot washing is a symbolic act often performed in religious or spiritual contexts. It represents humility, service, and purification. In Christianity, it can symbolize forgiveness, cleansing, and preparation for a new role or mission. The act is typically carried out by one person washing another's feet as a gesture of love, respect, and solidarity.
All Souls Unitarian Church is a Unitarian Universalist congregation in Tulsa, Oklahoma, known for its liberal and inclusive approach to spirituality. Founded in 1921, it has a rich history of promoting progressive values and social activism. The church has been led by influential figures like John Wolf, who played a key role in shaping its growth and impact within the community. All Souls Unitarian Church is recognized for its commitment to diversity, social justice, and open-minded theological exploration.

Counterarguments

The concept of speaking in tongues and exorcisms is controversial and not universally accepted within Christianity; some denominations question the validity and interpretation of these practices.
The rapid growth of megachurches like Higher Dimensions can be criticized for focusing on numbers and spectacle over deep spiritual growth and community.
Pearson's "Gospel of Inclusion" can be seen as a departure from orthodox Christian theology, which traditionally emphasizes the necessity of faith in Jesus Christ for salvation.
Some theologians argue that the concept of universal salvation undermines the significance of moral choices and the transformative power of accepting faith.
Labeling someone a heretic is a serious accusation that can be viewed as uncharitable and contrary to the Christian ethic of love and forgiveness.
The decline in Pearson's congregation after his theological shift could be interpreted as a failure to communicate his new beliefs effectively or as a natural consequence of challenging deeply held religious convictions.
The financial struggles faced by Pearson's church after his theological shift could be criticized as a result of poor financial planning or management rather than solely as a result of his changed theology.
While Pearson's theology found acceptance among more liberal Christian groups, some might argue that this alignment indicates a drift from traditional evangelical values and beliefs.
The support from progressive groups does not necessarily validate Pearson's theological views but rather reflects a broader spectrum of beliefs within Christianity.
Pearson's move to All Souls Unitarian Church might be seen as a shift away from evangelical Christianity to a more pluralistic or universalist approach, which some Christians would argue is not in line with biblical teachings.

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.

Get access for free

304: Heretics

Carlton Pearson's early life and rise to evangelical megastar status

Carlton Pearson’s journey from a strict Pentecostal upbringing to becoming an influential figure in the evangelical world is one of intense faith, strategic mentorship, and groundbreaking integration efforts in the racially divided South Tulsa.

Growing up in strict Pentecostalism and casting out demons as a teen

Pearson's childhood was deeply embedded in strict Pentecostal practices which prohibited smoking, drinking, cursing, or dancing. However, the church culture he was brought up in also actively engaged in speaking in tongues and what is called being "slain by the Holy Spirit." His first experience casting out demons occurred at the age of 16 or 17 during a youth revival at a tiny storefront church involving his girlfriend, an event after which he was regarded as a hero. He recalls this period when he cast out the devil over three consecutive nights. Growing up believing in the omnipresence of devils and demons was a significant element of his life.

Becoming a protege of Oral Roberts at Oral Roberts University

Seeking freedom from his restrictive religious environment yet desiring to maintain his path to heaven, Pearson found his solution in attending Oral Roberts University (ORU). Oral Roberts, the university’s founder, was a renowned televangelist and a significant influence on Pearson; he was known for his healing claims and "The Hour of Healing" show. As a member of the World Action Singers at ORU, Pearson performed Christian-themed shows worldwide and, during his freshman year, he appeared on an Oral Roberts special aired on NBC, which reached 37 million viewers.

Pearson described Oral Roberts as someone who brought a new dignity to his Pentecostal faith. Their closeness became evident when Carlton was called into Oral's office to discuss a conflict involving Oral's son, Richard. At this time, Oral expressed his emotional need for a "black son," signifying his deep value and support for Pearson, and subsequently, Pearson was appointed to the Board of Regents at Oral Roberts University.