Podcasts > This American Life > 823: The Question Trap

823: The Question Trap

By This American Life

This American Life delves into the weight questions carry and the assumptions they reveal in "The Question Trap." Specific queries shed light on gender norms and biases against powerful Black women. These hidden implications show how innocuous inquiries can unmask prejudice and disclose perspectives on identity.

The episode also demonstrates how phrasing questions reveals societal attitudes toward those with degenerative conditions like dementia. Rather than inquiring if an individual "recognizes" their loved one, suggesting diminished humanity, the summary proposes respecting the ongoing presence and connections embedded in emotional bonds and habitual care gestures, independent of memory function.

Listen to the original

823: The Question Trap

This is a preview of the Shortform summary of the Feb 4, 2024 episode of the This American Life

Sign up for Shortform to access the whole episode summary along with additional materials like counterarguments and context.

823: The Question Trap

1-Page Summary

Questions Revealing Biases and Assumptions

"Which one is handy?" implies gender role assumptions

For Tobin, questions about which partner handles home repairs in his same-sex marriage hinted at assumptions around traditional gender roles. He felt unease about being perceived as effeminate, tracing back to concealing his identity when closeted.

The "Beyoncé question" tests attitudes toward powerful Black women

Emanuel Berry and BA Parker use Beyoncé as a cultural reference to gauge dates' views on Black women. By noting reactions to Beyoncé, they uncover potential prejudices. Men have caught on to this "trap" and do "homework" beforehand to appear educated on the topic.

Recognizing the Person, Not Just Memories

"Do you recognize her?"

The typical question about someone with dementia still "recognizing" loved ones implies their humanity is diminished without specific memories. Instead, Taylor suggests asking "Do you recognize her?" -- acknowledging the person is still present through emotional connections.

Emotional bonds persist in habits and caring gestures

Despite memory loss, Taylor's mother maintains emotional warmth through smiles, touches, and caring habits like ensuring equal portions -- showing the person remains through actions, not just facts recalled.

Standardized Test Anxiety and Students' Futures

Immense pressure from NYC's SHSAT

For NYC's specialized high schools like Stuyvesant, the Specialized High School Admissions Test (SHSAT) is the sole criterion, putting immense pressure on students to score high and be deemed "good enough" for elite opportunities.

High-stakes questions determine trajectories

Every SHSAT question carries weight -- are you worthy of the best education? This exemplifies how standardized tests can distressingly dictate students' futures based on a single measure, exacerbating inequalities.

1-Page Summary

Additional Materials

Clarifications

  • The SHSAT, or Specialized High School Admissions Test, is an exam used for admissions to specialized high schools in New York City. It is the sole criterion for admission to these schools, creating immense pressure on students to perform well. The test is known for its high stakes as it heavily influences students' educational opportunities and future trajectories. The SHSAT questions are crucial as they determine whether students are considered eligible for elite educational opportunities.
  • Stuyvesant is a reference to specialized high schools in New York City, particularly Stuyvesant High School. These schools have rigorous admissions processes, with the Specialized High School Admissions Test (SHSAT) being a key factor. Stuyvesant High School is known for its academic excellence and competitive environment. The mention of Stuyvesant in the text highlights the intense pressure and high stakes associated with standardized testing in the context of elite educational opportunities in NYC.
  • The Specialized High School Admissions Test (SHSAT) is an exam taken by students in New York City for admission to specialized high schools. It is a significant factor in determining acceptance to these schools, with around 25,000 students taking the test annually. The test has been a subject of debate regarding its fairness and impact on diversity in these schools. The Hecht-Calandra Act of 1971 solidified the SHSAT as the sole criterion for admission to certain specialized high schools in NYC.
  • Elite opportunities typically refer to prestigious or high-level chances for advancement or success that are often limited and highly sought after. These opportunities are usually associated with exclusive institutions, programs, or positions that offer significant advantages or privileges to those who gain access. They can play a significant role in shaping individuals' futures and can be influenced by factors such as academic achievement, standardized test scores, and societal privileges.
  • Homosexual identity concealment involves hiding one's sexual orientation to conform to societal norms or avoid discrimination. This concealment can lead to feelings of unease and internal conflict. Individuals may choose to conceal their identity for various reasons, including fear of judgment or harm. Concealment can impact mental health and relationships.
  • Tobin felt unease about being perceived as effeminate due to societal expectations around traditional gender roles, which led to concerns about how his identity might be judged, especially when he was concealing his same-sex marriage.
  • Beyoncé as a cultural reference: Beyoncé, a prominent Black female artist, is used as a cultural touchstone to gauge attitudes towards powerful Black women. By referencing Beyoncé in discussions or questions, individuals can reveal their views on race, gender, and power dynamics in society. This approach helps uncover potential biases or prejudices that individuals may hold towards Black women in positions of influence. Men may prepare in advance to discuss Beyoncé to appear knowledgeable and avoid revealing negative attitudes during conversations or assessments.
  • In same-sex marriages, gender role assumptions can still exist, such as expectations about who should handle tasks traditionally associated with a specific gender. This can lead to discomfort for individuals who feel pressured to conform to these stereotypes, even within a same-sex relationship. The text highlights how these assumptions can impact individuals like Tobin, who may feel uneasy about being perceived in a certain way due to societal expectations related to gender roles.
  • Emotional connections in dementia patients are highlighted as crucial aspects of their humanity. Despite memory loss, individuals with dementia can still express emotions through gestures, like smiles and touches. These emotional bonds serve as a way to connect with and understand the person beyond their cognitive decline. Recognizing and valuing these emotional connections can help maintain meaningful relationships with individuals living with dementia.

Counterarguments

  • Questions about home repairs do not necessarily imply gender role assumptions; they could be interpreted as practical inquiries about division of labor based on interest or skill rather than gender.
  • The discomfort with being perceived as effeminate may also stem from broader societal stigmas around masculinity and not solely from the experience of concealing one's identity when closeted.
  • Using Beyoncé as a cultural reference might not be a reliable test of attitudes toward powerful Black women, as opinions about her could be influenced by a variety of factors unrelated to race or gender, such as musical taste or media portrayal.
  • People's reactions to Beyoncé or any public figure may not accurately reflect their broader views on a demographic group due to the complexity of individual opinions and the potential for performative responses.
  • The question "Do you recognize her?" in the context of dementia could be seen as a valid way to assess cognitive changes and does not necessarily imply that the person's humanity is diminished.
  • While emotional bonds can persist in dementia through non-verbal communication, it is also important to recognize the significant impact that memory loss can have on personal identity and relationships.
  • The SHSAT and other standardized tests are designed to assess certain academic abilities and may serve as one of the few objective measures available for admissions to competitive schools.
  • The use of standardized tests like the SHSAT can be defended as a means to identify students who are likely to succeed in a rigorous academic environment, even though they may not capture all aspects of a student's potential.
  • Standardized tests are not the sole factor in determining a student's future and worthiness; many educational systems consider a holistic approach that includes grades, extracurricular activities, and personal statements.
  • While standardized tests can contribute to inequalities, they can also provide opportunities for students from underrepresented backgrounds to gain access to educational resources that might otherwise be inaccessible.

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
823: The Question Trap

Questions revealing underlying biases, prejudices, or assumptions

Questions that seem harmless can sometimes reveal deeper societal assumptions about roles, identities, and values. Tobin and Emanuel Berry share their experiences with seemingly simple questions that actually probe into greater biases and prejudices.

"Which one of you is handy?" implies assumptions about gender roles in a same-sex relationship

Tobin and his husband experienced a recurring issue when family members repeatedly asked them which one of them was handy after they moved into a new house. At first, Tobin couldn't pinpoint why the question bothered him. Later, he reflected that the question might be an attempt to assign the "man" role in their same-sex relationship, adhering to traditional gender roles. Tobin felt uncomfortable with this question due to his past experiences in the closet where he was careful not to exhibit any traits that might be perceived as effeminate. He acknowledges that his family might not have intended the bias; however, the question felt charged with underlying assumptions.

When Tobin explained that his husband was the handy one, it seemed to satisfy the inquirers' need to fit them into a traditional gender role schema. Tobin muses on the discomfort arising from these encounters, and fears that relate to his time concealing his identity, where any sign of femininity was hidden.

The "Beyonce question" reveals attitudes toward powerful Black women

Used as a "litmus test" for dating potential partners

Emanuel Berry and BA Parker both use cultural references as a means of uncovering attitudes towards Black women. Emanuel uses what she calls the "Beyonce question" to gauge how her dates view powerful Black women. Similarly, Parker subtly tests her dates based on their reactions to Black female celebrities.

Parker mentioned Beyonce's "Black as King" film during a date to get a sense of her date's viewpoints. The man she was with became aware of the delicacy of the subject and articulated the challenge in responding to the topic, cautious not to be dismissive of Beyonce and what she might represent to Parker.

Men are ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Questions revealing underlying biases, prejudices, or assumptions

Additional Materials

Clarifications

  • The "Beyonce question" is a term used to describe a question or topic related to Beyonce, a powerful Black woman in the entertainment industry, that is used to gauge someone's attitudes towards powerful Black women. It serves as a way to uncover underlying biases or prejudices individuals may hold regarding Black female figures like Beyonce. The response to this question can reveal a person's views on race, gender, and power dynamics, making it a tool to assess someone's perspective on these important societal issues. The term highlights how cultural references can be used to prompt discussions on deeper societal attitudes and beliefs.
  • Beyoncé is a highly influential figure in the music industry, known for her powerful performances and advocacy for social issues. She is celebrate ...

Counterarguments

...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
823: The Question Trap

Questioning whether someone with dementia still "recognizes" others

The typical query about a person with dementia's ability to recognize their loved ones might miss the mark when understanding the true nature of human connection.

The common question implies they are less of a person without specific memories

Taylor suggests that when we ask, "Does she recognize you?" about a person with dementia, there's an inherent implication that their worth or identity is diminished without factual memory. However, Taylor proposes that instead, we should ask ourselves "Do you recognize her?" implying that we acknowledge the person as still present and capable of emotional connections.

But emotional connections remain through smiles, touches, caring habits

Taylor speaks of her mother, who, despite dementia, is able to engage and show emotional warmth. For example, her mother exhibits a beaming affection, as if sharing a conspiratorial joke, through smiles, demonstrating that emotional bonds can survive even as specific memories fade.

The interaction between mother and daughter in a café setting, where they share a scone and partake in gentle conversation, illustrates how emotional connections can persist through actions and the sharing of emotions, rather than through the recall of personal information.

Moreover, Taylor observes that her mother's "impulse to care, the habit of caring" remains deeply ingrained. This endu ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Questioning whether someone with dementia still "recognizes" others

Additional Materials

Clarifications

  • When discussing dementia patients and their ability to recognize loved ones, reframing the question from "Does she recognize you?" to "Do you recognize her?" shifts the focus from the patient's cognitive decline to the observer's perception of the patient's continued presence and emotional connections. This reframing emphasizes the importance of acknowledging the person with dementia as a whole individual beyond just their memory loss, highlighting the enduring emotional bonds that can persist despite the challenges of dementia.
  • In dementia patients, emotional connections can persist through non-verbal cues like smiles, touches, and caring gestures. These non-verbal expressions can convey warmth, affection, and shared emotions even when specific memories are lost. Through actions and gestures, individuals with dementia can still communicate and maintain emotional bonds with their loved ones. Non-verbal cues play a crucial role in sustaining emotional connections and relationships in the face of cognitive decline.
  • In dementia patients, the ability to recall specific memories may decline, but emotional connections can still thrive through non-verbal cues like smiles and ...

Counterarguments

  • While emotional connections may persist, the nature and depth of these connections can change significantly due to the progression of dementia, and it may be important to acknowledge and adapt to these changes.
  • The question "Does she recognize you?" might not imply a diminished worth but rather seeks to understand the cognitive changes and challenges faced by the person with dementia, which is a legitimate concern for caregivers and loved ones.
  • Emotional connections are important, but the loss of recognition can have profound emotional impacts on family and friends that should not be minimized or overlooked.
  • The ability to recognize loved ones is often a key aspect of personal identity and relationships, and its loss can signify a substantial change in the dynamic of the relationship that may require grief and adjustment.
  • The suggestion to ask "Do you recognize her?" could be interpreted as placing the onus on the observer to maintain the relationship's integrity, potentially leading to feelings of guilt or inadequacy if they struggle with the changes in their loved one.
  • While non-verbal cues and caring habits are significant, they may not fully ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
823: The Question Trap

The anxiety around standardized tests determining students' futures

In educational settings, standardized tests have long been a source of anxiety for students, educators, and parents alike. The pressure they put on students is immense, given the high stakes associated with scores that could determine much of a young individual's academic and professional future.

Pressure to get a high SHSAT score to attend elite NYC public schools

In New York City, the anxiety is particularly palpable for those taking the Specialized High School Admissions Test (SHSAT), which serves as the sole criterion for entry into eight of the city's nine specialized high schools. Known for their rigorous academics and competitive atmospheres, schools like Stuyvesant High School and Bronx High School of Science demand excellence from their student bodies. Achieving a high score on the SHSAT can be seen as a ticket to advanced educational opportunities, and for many, a better future. This pressure creates a daunting dynamic that places an enormous amount of stress on students to perform at peak levels on test day.

Questions have stakes behind them: are you "good enough" for the best opportunities?

Every question on the SHSAT carries the weight of this pressure, implicitly asking students whether they are "good enough" for some of the best educational opportunities ava ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

The anxiety around standardized tests determining students' futures

Additional Materials

Clarifications

  • The Specialized High School Admissions Test (SHSAT) is an exam taken by eighth and ninth-grade students in New York City for admission to specialized high schools. It determines entry into schools like Stuyvesant High School and Bronx High School of Science based solely on test scores. The test's significance lies in its role as the primary criterion for admission to these prestigious institutions, shaping students' educational opportunities and futures. The SHSAT has been a subject of debate due to concerns about its fairness and impact on diversity in these specialized schools.
  • The specialized high schools in New York City, such as Stuyvesant High School and Bronx High School of Science, are renowned for their challenging academic programs and competitive environments. These schools require students to ...

Counterarguments

  • Standardized tests provide a uniform metric for assessing student knowledge and skills across diverse backgrounds and schools.
  • The use of a single test like the SHSAT can be seen as a meritocratic approach, offering every student the same set of questions and the same opportunity to succeed based on their abilities.
  • Specialized high schools in NYC are designed to cater to students who excel academically, and the SHSAT could be viewed as an effective way to identify those students.
  • Some argue that the pressure associated with standardized tests can motivate students to achieve their best performance.
  • Standardized tests can serve as a valuable feedback mechanism for educators to understand where students are excelling or need more support.
  • The SHSAT and similar tests can inspire students to set high goals and work diligently towards achieving them, fostering a strong work ethic.
  • Alternative methods of student assessment may also have their own biases and flaws, and no single method is likely to be perfect.
  • The debate on standardized testing can lead to improvements in the tests themselves, making them more fair and reflective of a student's potential.
  • Some believe that the existence of speci ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free

Create Summaries for anything on the web

Download the Shortform Chrome extension for your browser

Shortform Extension CTA