In this episode of The Subtle Art of Not Giving a F*ck Podcast, Drew Birnie and Mark Manson explore the biology and psychology of friendship, explaining how social connections evolved as survival strategies and continue to affect physical health. The hosts examine research showing that strong friendships improve immune function and longevity, while chronic social isolation can be as harmful as smoking.
The discussion covers how friendships form and change throughout different life stages, from childhood to middle age. Birnie and Manson address the obstacles to friendship in modern life, including work demands and the decline of community spaces, while offering practical approaches to building lasting relationships. They outline specific strategies for making and maintaining friendships, including the time investment needed to form genuine connections and the importance of moving past transactional relationships.

Sign up for Shortform to access the whole episode summary along with additional materials like counterarguments and context.
Drew Birnie and Mark Manson explore friendship as a complex biological and psychological phenomenon. They discuss how friendship evolved as an adaptive strategy for survival, with Manson describing friendships as "original information networks" that enable information sharing, risk pooling, and collective action. The hosts explain that friends even display similar neural responses to stimuli, a phenomenon known as neural synchrony.
The conversation reveals that social connections significantly impact health outcomes. Strong friendships improve immune function, reduce inflammation, and lower mortality rates. Particularly noteworthy is the hosts' discussion of loneliness: chronic social isolation can be as harmful as smoking a pack of cigarettes daily, highlighting the critical importance of maintaining social connections.
Friendships evolve distinctly across different life stages. In childhood, they center around proximity and play. During adolescence, they become crucial for identity formation and emotional support. Young adults rely on friendships for practical and emotional support during independence, while middle-aged adults struggle to maintain friendships amid increasing responsibilities. Manson and Birnie note that men typically bond through shared activities, while women often connect through emotional sharing, though these patterns aren't universal.
Modern life presents significant challenges to friendship formation and maintenance. Manson observes that work and family demands often relegate friendships to an afterthought. The hosts discuss how the decline of "third places" like cafes and civic institutions has eroded traditional friendship hubs. They also examine how digital technology, while expanding connection possibilities, often creates shallow relationships. Birnie points out that increasing social polarization and mistrust make it harder for people to form new connections.
The hosts offer concrete advice for building and maintaining friendships. Manson advocates joining groups based on values rather than convenience, while both hosts emphasize the importance of patience—noting it can take up to 90 hours to form a true friendship. They suggest practical approaches like using calendar systems to maintain regular contact and becoming a "connector" who facilitates introductions between others. The hosts stress that dropping the "scorecard" mentality and embracing vulnerability are crucial for developing genuine, lasting friendships.
1-Page Summary
Drew Birnie and Mark Manson explore the intricate nature of friendship, pointing out that its complexity lies in our biology and neural functioning.
Friendship is examined from an evolutionary perspective, identifying its role as an adaptive strategy for survival.
Darwin feared that behaviors like helping creatures who are not genetically related could undermine his theory of evolution because they seemed inconsistent with the principle of survival of the fittest. This puzzle vexed scientists for over a century until game theory and political science in the 1980s introduced the concept of iterative prisoner's dilemmas, where mutual cooperation can lead to better outcomes for both parties in the long term.
Mark Manson describes friendships as the "original information networks," with cooperation leading to the sharing of information, pooling of risk, and collective action. These aspects of friendships act as an insurance policy, enabling individuals to take risks, knowing they are supported by others. If one person succeeds in a high-risk task, they can share the rewards with the group.
The hosts discuss neural synchrony in friendships, where friends display similar neural responses to the same stimuli. Neurohomophily refers to the attraction towards others with similar brain functions. The conversation also touches on homophily, the tendency to like people who are similar to oneself in terms of appearance, interests, and other attributes.
Friendship offers protection against various health issues and acts as a stress buffer.
Social connections lower mortality rates, improve immune function, and reduce inflammation, leading to decreased chronic health risks. As people age, a robust social network becomes critical for managing health issues and other medical needs.
The Science and Psychology of Friendship
The dynamics of friendships follow a distinctive path, evolving with life stages, and the quality of these friendships changes as individuals grow and their circumstances alter.
Friendships progress through recognized stages from childhood to old age, each with its requisite features and complexities.
From birth to 12 years old, friendships revolve around activities, play, and proximity. Attachment systems form, setting the stage for how children engage with friends—whether securely, anxiously, or avoidantly. Around 5 to 7 years, children typically find their first "best friend" and begin to identify their social standing as they join peer groups. It's a time for learning social skills, including sharing, cooperation, and how to belong in a group.
Adolescent friendships become central to emotional life, as these young individuals start distancing themselves from their parents and relying more on peers for identity and emotional support. This stage marks an intensified peer influence, increased pressure, and the inception of risk-taking behaviors. Friendships are a stage for bonding, with a lot of attention given to social hierarchy and status games that are superficial and sometimes toxic. This maturing process eventually leads to a realization of what true friendship is not.
In young adulthood, Birnie points out the importance of deeper friendships. These relationships offer vital emotional and practical support as individuals venture further from their family circle. Young adults experience transitions that can lead to significant changes in their social groups, often causing jarring emotional experiences.
Middle adulthood introduces more responsibilities, such as parenting and career focus, which can impede friendship formation. The "infrastructure" for making friends like in school or college no longer exists, and friendships often get pushed aside for these responsibilities. Friend groups may shrink but also become more intentional as individuals realize the effort needed to maintain friendships.
Older adults prioritize relationships and friendships, realizing their importance and often focusing on them over career pursuits. Friendships at this stage give life meaning and are embraced as sources of resilience.
The Stages and Dynamics of Friendship
Modern life, with its fast pace and evolving demands, has altered the landscape of friendship. Various societal trends and psychological biases have compounded the challenges in forming and maintaining meaningful friendships.
In a world where work, mobility, and family demands capture most of our waking hours, forming and nurturing friendships becomes exceedingly challenging.
Mark Manson and his wife observed their different standards for friendship and noted how personal criteria greatly affect one’s social circle. Manson points out that balancing work and family in modern adulthood often leaves friendships as an afterthought. The rise of time poverty due to career-focused lifestyles, long working hours, and intensive parenting limits opportunities for social interaction and the nurturing of friendships. This results in an alarming increase in solo time and a significant decrease in socializing over the past few decades.
Birnie acknowledges how parenthood, with its increased responsibilities, particularly swallows up time that once went into friendships. Peak life experiences and spontaneous adventures, which can cement friendships, are all too rare amidst adult obligations.
Manson and Birnie lament the loss of "third places" such as cafes and libraries and note the decline of civic institutions that once brought communities together. The collapse of traditional community hubs, like churches and various clubs, has stripped away much of the social structure previous generations relied on. Increases in geographic mobility and frequent life transitions disrupt the continuity required for friend relationships to flourish.
With the advent of digital technology, the avenues for making and keeping friends have greatly expanded, yet the depth of these connections is often questioned. The privatization of life through smartphones creates scenarios where people can be physically close yet emotionally distant, as they remain absorbed in their digital worlds. Birnie and Manson delineate the pitfalls of a society that celebrates isolation, epitomized by the trend of "cansellation," and the performative nature of social media that fosters transactional rather than genuine interactions.
Expectations and biases shape our approach to friendships in ways that may not always be conducive to their longevity and quality.
The lofty expectations people have for friendships can stunt their growth. Manson proposes that n ...
Cultural/Societal Factors Impacting Modern Friendships
Understanding the complexities of human connection, Mark Manson and Drew Birnie engage in an insightful conversation on the intricacies of forming and maintaining friendships. They explore practices that could lead to stronger, more genuine bonds.
Friendship, at its core, is about shared experiences and interests. Proximity forms the "container" of potential friendships, with exposure and disclosure being key practices in forming those friendships.
Manson advocates for joining groups based on deep personal interests rather than convenience, suggesting that longevity in friendships comes from shared values. For instance, engaging in volunteer work at an animal shelter could lead to friendships with people who are compassionate and open to new connections.
Manson and Birnie stress the importance of consistent efforts to grow friendships. Initiating contact, following up, and being patient are fundamental. Patience is encouraged, with an emphasis on the time it takes to move from acquaintances to friends, which can be as much as 50 hours to become an acquaintance and 90 hours to become a friend.
Friendships thrive on mutual effort and investment. By dropping the "scorecard" mentality and fostering vulnerability, individuals can cultivate long-standing, non-transactional friendships.
Discussing the toxic tendencies in some relationships, Manson highlights the importance of healthy boundaries to avoid being enmeshed in a friend's drama. Ending toxic relationships, particularly the "scorecard" behavior, can lead to more genuine connections.
The conversation explores the notion that deep connections are fostered through shared emotional experiences and vulnerability. Continuous communication and shared experiences, such as overcoming hardships together or ...
Practical Strategies For Making and Keeping Friends
Download the Shortform Chrome extension for your browser
