Podcasts > The Subtle Art of Not Giving a F*ck Podcast > How to Stop Letting Fear Control Your Life (ft. Dr. Julie Smith)

How to Stop Letting Fear Control Your Life (ft. Dr. Julie Smith)

By Mark Manson

In this episode of The Subtle Art of Not Giving a F*ck Podcast, Mark Manson welcomes Dr. Julie Smith, a therapist and online mental health influencer. They explore strategies for managing negative thoughts and building resilience through self-compassion and a growth mindset. Dr. Smith shares her journey navigating the challenges that came with her social media following and provides insights on aligning one's efforts with core values.

The conversation also touches on the impact of modern life's digital connections and lack of community spaces on genuine human interaction. Dr. Smith advocates for focusing relationships on shared values rather than social comparisons, emphasizing the importance of assertive communication in fostering healthier bonds.

Listen to the original

How to Stop Letting Fear Control Your Life (ft. Dr. Julie Smith)

This is a preview of the Shortform summary of the Mar 5, 2025 episode of the The Subtle Art of Not Giving a F*ck Podcast

Sign up for Shortform to access the whole episode summary along with additional materials like counterarguments and context.

How to Stop Letting Fear Control Your Life (ft. Dr. Julie Smith)

1-Page Summary

Online Mental Health Influencer's Well-Being Challenges

Mark Manson spotlights Dr. Julie Smith, a therapist who created a "positive corner" on social media to counter poor mental health advice by sharing accurate, evidence-based information. Though initially skeptical, Smith learned to set boundaries, say no, and practice self-care as her online fame persisted.

Strategies for Managing Negative Thoughts and Building Resilience

Julie Smith empowers clients to reframe negative self-talk using self-compassion and a growth mindset. She distinguishes emotions from objective facts, encouraging thoughtful responses. Smith stresses aligning one's efforts across life areas with core values over perfection.

Emotions, Self-Compassion, and Not Treating Feelings As Facts

Smith explores how emotions like guilt or approval needs may stem from past experiences no longer relevant. She emphasizes self-compassion, citing her approach during challenges like her cancer diagnosis and TV appearances. Avoiding self-criticism by accepting imperfections allows Smith to build resilience.

Modern Life's Impact on Connection and Loneliness

Julie Smith argues modern life's decline of community spaces and increase in digital connections hinder genuine human interaction. She advocates focusing relationships on shared values rather than social comparisons or approval-seeking. Clear communication of personal needs through assertiveness fosters healthier bonds.

1-Page Summary

Additional Materials

Counterarguments

  • While Dr. Julie Smith's "positive corner" on social media is commendable, it's important to recognize that social media can also be a source of misinformation and can contribute to mental health issues due to its addictive nature and the potential for cyberbullying.
  • Setting boundaries and practicing self-care are essential, but some individuals may find it challenging to implement these strategies without additional support or resources, especially in the face of systemic issues or personal circumstances.
  • Reframing negative self-talk is beneficial, but it may not be sufficient for individuals with severe mental health conditions who might require more intensive therapy or medical intervention.
  • Aligning efforts with core values is important, but it can be difficult for individuals to identify their core values, particularly if they are influenced by societal pressures or have not had the opportunity for self-reflection.
  • Distinguishing emotions from facts is a useful strategy, but emotions themselves can provide valuable information about one's needs and boundaries, and should not be dismissed entirely.
  • Self-compassion is a powerful tool, but some individuals may struggle with internalized stigma or deeply ingrained self-critical thoughts that make it difficult to practice self-compassion without professional guidance.
  • Accepting imperfections is a healthy approach, but there may be cultural or personal expectations that make this challenging for some individuals, and it's important to acknowledge the role of external pressures in shaping self-perception.
  • The decline of community spaces and the rise of digital connections are concerning, but digital platforms can also provide access to support and resources for those who are isolated or have mobility issues.
  • Focusing relationships on shared values is ideal, but it may not always be feasible, especially in professional settings where individuals must interact with a diverse range of personalities and beliefs.
  • Assertive communication is key to healthy relationships, but it requires a level of confidence and skill that some individuals may need to develop over time, and there may be cultural or social barriers that make assertiveness more challenging for certain groups.

Actionables

  • Create a "values vision board" to visually remind yourself of your core values and encourage daily alignment with them. Start by identifying your top five values and find images, quotes, or items that represent these values to you. Place your vision board somewhere you'll see it every day, like your bedroom or workspace, to serve as a constant reminder to make decisions and take actions that resonate with your values, rather than striving for perfection.
  • Develop a "self-talk switch" routine to transform negative thoughts into compassionate and growth-oriented ones. Whenever you catch yourself engaging in negative self-talk, pause and write down the thought. Then, next to it, write a more compassionate and growth-focused version of the same thought. For example, if you think, "I always mess things up," you could write, "I'm learning from my experiences and growing every day." This practice can help rewire your thought patterns over time.
  • Initiate a "digital detox challenge" with friends or family to enhance genuine human interaction. Set a collective goal to reduce screen time for a week, and replace it with in-person activities that reflect shared values, such as volunteering, outdoor adventures, or crafting sessions. This can help strengthen bonds through shared experiences and reduce the tendency to seek validation through digital connections.

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
How to Stop Letting Fear Control Your Life (ft. Dr. Julie Smith)

Online Mental Health Influencer's Well-Being Challenges

Mark Manson spotlights Dr. Julie Smith, an online mental health influencer, who is navigating the complexities of social media’s influence on mental health while fostering a community grounded in positive, evidence-based information.

Balancing Social Media's Mental Health Impact With Julie's Positive, Evidence-Based Content

Julie Countered Skepticism By Creating a "Positive Corner" on Social Media to Share Accurate Mental Health Information

Julie Smith disclosed that entering the social media space was against the professional norm for therapists and psychologists at the time she began. She saw an opportunity to counter the poor mental health advice online by creating a helpful and positive online space with decent information for people who were scrolling on social media.

"Internet Famous" Julie Sets Boundaries, Says No, and Prioritizes Self-Care For Public Exposure Discomfort

Julie faced difficulties in setting boundaries and saying no when her online fame seemed fleeting. Realizing her visibility was there to stay, she eventually learned to operate sustainably. Early on, she sacrificed sleep to produce content nearly daily, manage household responsibilities during the lockdown, and work on a book. Now, her detachment from fame allows her to say no more ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Online Mental Health Influencer's Well-Being Challenges

Additional Materials

Counterarguments

  • While creating a "Positive Corner" on social media is commendable, it's important to acknowledge that the platform's algorithms might still expose users to negative or harmful content, potentially undermining the positive impact.
  • Skepticism towards therapists entering social media could be rooted in concerns about maintaining professionalism and client confidentiality in an informal online environment.
  • Setting boundaries and saying no is crucial, but it can also lead to missed opportunities for engagement and growth, which might be necessary for an influencer to maintain relevance.
  • Sacrificing sleep to produce content and manage responsibilities could be seen as setting a poor example for followers regarding work-life balance and self-care.
  • Using fear as a driver for action can be effective, but it's also important to recognize that not everyone may be able to channel fe ...

Actionables

  • You can create a digital wellness corner in your personal blog or website to share insights on maintaining digital health. Start by researching credible sources on digital wellness and write weekly posts or create infographics that help your audience navigate the complexities of digital life, such as managing screen time or protecting privacy online.
  • Develop a personal mantra or affirmation that reinforces your right to set boundaries in any situation. Repeat this mantra when you feel pressured to overcommit or when you're about to enter a potentially stressful scenario. For example, before attending a social event, you might tell yourself, "I have the power to choose how I engage and when I leave."
  • Initiate a personal project that channels a challenging expe ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
How to Stop Letting Fear Control Your Life (ft. Dr. Julie Smith)

Strategies for Managing Negative Thoughts and Building Resilience

In an enlightening episode, Mark Manson, Julie Smith, and Drew Birnie delve into strategies for reframing negative thoughts and self-criticism, distinguishing between emotions and facts, and fostering the resilience needed to move forward.

Reframing Negative Self-Talk and Self-Criticism Through Self-Compassion

Julie Empowers Clients To Self-Coach, Offering Support and Perspective Over Judgment

Julie Smith talks about changing her inner monologue from harsh to supportive, much like a coach's guidance. She equips her clients to manage their own setbacks confidently and with the right perspective, rather than spiraling into self-judgment.

Cultivating a Growth Mindset to View Setbacks As Opportunities

Smith promotes a growth mindset, encouraging her clients to see setbacks not as failures but as opportunities for growth. She explains that therapy focuses on helping clients recognize destructive cycles, especially in relationships, and develop strategies to break free from them. The transformation desired is one from feeling overwhelmed to confidently facing challenges.

Distinguishing Emotions From Facts

Helping Clients See Emotions Aren't Objective Truth

During the session, Julie Smith stresses that emotions are not an embodiment of our identity but an experience we navigate. She educates her clients that emotions do not necessarily convey the objective truth. Smith and Manson agree that recognizing emotions as a normal part of human experience allows individuals to observe their feelings without getting overwhelmed by them.

Encouraging Clients to Assess Emotion Proportionality and Respond Thoughtfully

Smith underscores the importance of not fully believing emotions every time they emerge since they are influenced by various factors. Drew Birnie adds that equating fleeting emotions with the entirety of one's life can be misleading. Smith li ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Strategies for Managing Negative Thoughts and Building Resilience

Additional Materials

Actionables

  • Create a "Setback-to-Opportunity" journal where you document challenges and brainstorm potential opportunities they could lead to. This practice helps reframe your mindset to see difficulties as chances for growth. For example, if you didn't get a job you interviewed for, use the journal to explore new career paths or skills you can develop.
  • Develop a "Coat for Emotions" toolkit with personalized strategies to manage intense feelings, similar to choosing the right coat for the weather. This could include a playlist of calming music for anxiety, a stress ball for anger, or a list of affirmations for sadness. When you feel overwhelmed, select a tool from your kit to help process your emotions.
  • Design a "Values Alignment" board, visually mappi ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
How to Stop Letting Fear Control Your Life (ft. Dr. Julie Smith)

Emotions, Self-Compassion, and Not Treating Feelings As Facts

In a discussion led by Julie Smith, the podcast explores why emotions are reflections from the past, the importance of self-compassion, and building resilience without treating feelings as facts.

Recognizing Emotions as Past Echoes, Not Present Facts

Julie Smith delves into how our emotions are influenced by a variety of factors, including past experiences, and emphasizes that these feelings are not necessarily reflective of current realities. She suggests that when individuals experience emotions like guilt or shame, or feel lost in approval needs, these may stem from past experiences. For instance, behaviours aimed at pleasing others that were necessary in one's childhood to avoid danger might no longer serve a purpose in adulthood. Smith encourages listeners to approach such emotions with curiosity and openness, allowing an understanding of what genuinely matters to emerge.

Clients May Struggle With Guilt, Shame, or Approval Needs Due to Past Experiences

During the podcast, Smith touches on the complexity of emotions in relationships and the vulnerability that can emerge from an externally oriented judgment. She explains how such an orientation can lead to difficulties in advocating for oneself and increase the risk of exploitation and abuse. Furthermore, Julie suggests that the constant barrage of external influences, such as marketing, can contribute to feelings of disconnection and raise issues stemming from past conditioning and needs.

Importance of Self-Compassion and Self-Care In Building Resilience

Julie Smith stresses the vital role of self-compassion and self-care in weathering the challenges of life.

Julie's Experiences Highlight the Need For Self-Support and Avoiding Self-Criticism

Smith commits to being self-supportive, especially during high-pressure situations like live television appearances. She elaborates on how nurturing a supportive inner dialogue and preparing to be compassionate to herself, even in the face of mistakes or shame, is key. Julie reflects on how focusing on the things that matter most—such as close relationships—can provide a foundation for resilience.

Julie goes on to discuss her approach to her career and identity, highlighting the significance of not pl ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Emotions, Self-Compassion, and Not Treating Feelings As Facts

Additional Materials

Counterarguments

  • While emotions may be influenced by past experiences, they can also be valid reactions to present situations and should not be dismissed entirely.
  • Some emotions like guilt or shame can be appropriate and constructive when they reflect current ethical or moral standards and lead to positive change.
  • External influences are not solely negative; they can also provide valuable information, inspiration, and connection to the broader community.
  • Self-compassion and self-care, while important, should be balanced with accountability and responsibility to avoid self-indulgence or avoidance of growth opportunities.
  • Being self-supportive in high-pressure situations is beneficial, but seeking and accepting support from others can also be a valuable strategy.
  • Focusing on close relationships is important, but it's also necessary to maintain a sense of individuality and personal goals.
  • While it's important not to base self-worth entirely on external success, achievements and recognition can still play a role in personal fulfillment and motivation.
  • Striving for high standards, when balanced with realism, can lead to excellence and improvement.
  • Accepting imperfections is healthy, but continuous self-improveme ...

Actionables

  • You can create an "Emotion Timeline" journal where you track your emotional responses to daily events and note any past experiences that may be influencing them. This practice helps you identify patterns and triggers, allowing you to consciously separate past conditioning from your current reality. For example, if you feel anxious during work presentations, you might link this to a past public speaking failure and work on reframing your mindset with positive experiences.
  • Develop a "Self-Worth Portfolio" that includes achievements, positive feedback, and personal milestones unrelated to external success. This portfolio serves as a tangible reminder of your intrinsic value, especially when you find yourself equating self-worth with professional achievements. You might include thank-you notes, photos of happy moments with family, or a list of skills you've learned for personal enrichment. ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
How to Stop Letting Fear Control Your Life (ft. Dr. Julie Smith)

Modern Life's Impact on Connection and Loneliness

Modern life significantly affects how people connect with each other, leading to challenges in maintaining meaningful human relationships and potential increases in loneliness.

Decline of Traditional Community Spaces and Social Interaction

Julie Smith notes that in England, traditional community spaces like pubs, which once served as hubs for congregation and conversation, are rapidly disappearing. She reminisces about her own childhood experiences of playing and talking outside in communal green spaces, emphasizing how such interactions seem to become increasingly rare.

Digital Connections Haven't Filled the Void of Meaningful Human Interaction

She argues that modern life puts up barriers to connecting with people. To overcome these barriers, individuals must make extra efforts, such as reaching out and creating opportunities for interactions and addressing social anxiety.

The Need For Effort to Maintain Healthy Relationships

Julie Smith discusses the negative impact of social comparison on personal relationships. She argues that when comparison involves friends and family, it can damage these relationships by bringing in a competitive dynamic. She notes that comparing oneself to others based on external success can transform relationships from supportive to threatening, hindering genuine connections.

Helping Clients Shift From Approval-Seeking to Focusing On Values and Desired Relationships

Smith emphasizes the importance of focusing on what truly matters to the individual and the role of values in recalibrating these focuses. She suggests that self-comparison in unwanted situations is unconstructive and introduces her values exercise to help individuals understand their own values and goals better. This understanding can guide individuals to focus on relationships and objectives that align with their values rather than seeking approval or comparing themselves to others with different values and lives.

Advocating Needs in Relationships Through Assertive Communication Skills

Moreover, Smith talks about the futility of trying to make sure others think you are helpful, kind, and worthwhile to feel accepted. She explains that this purs ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Modern Life's Impact on Connection and Loneliness

Additional Materials

Counterarguments

  • While traditional community spaces are declining, new forms of community spaces, such as coworking spaces, community centers, and online forums, are emerging and can foster a sense of community and interaction.
  • Digital connections can offer meaningful interaction, especially for those who are physically isolated or have niche interests, allowing them to connect with like-minded individuals globally.
  • Some individuals may find that modern life has actually facilitated connections through increased mobility, social media, and communication technologies.
  • Social comparison is not inherently damaging; it can sometimes motivate self-improvement and provide a benchmark for personal growth when approached healthily.
  • Focusing solely on personal values without considering social norms and expectations can lead to isolation or conflict with others who may not share the same values.
  • Assertive communication is important, but it must be balanced with empathy and understanding of others' perspectives to maintain harmonious relationships.
  • Seeking approval from others is a natural human desire for social validation and can ...

Actionables

  • Create a "No Approval Needed" jar where you write down decisions you've made based on your values, not others' opinions. This tangible reminder helps you see the accumulation of value-driven choices, reinforcing your commitment to personal values over external approval.
  • Start a "Human Interaction Challenge" where you commit to one face-to-face conversation with someone new each week. This could be a neighbor, a local shopkeeper, or someone at a community event. The goal is to foster genuine connections outside of digital spaces and to practice assertive communication in a low-stakes setting.
  • Develop a "Personal Relationship Charter" that outlines the qualities you seek in relat ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free

Create Summaries for anything on the web

Download the Shortform Chrome extension for your browser

Shortform Extension CTA