Podcasts > The Subtle Art of Not Giving a F*ck Podcast > Keeping the Weight Off, Rewiring Your Brain with Psychedelics, and Finding Strong Male Role Models

Keeping the Weight Off, Rewiring Your Brain with Psychedelics, and Finding Strong Male Role Models

By Mark Manson

In this episode of The Subtle Art of Not Giving a F*ck Podcast, host Mark Manson explores the challenges of long-term habit change, particularly regarding weight loss and the psychological factors involved.

Manson reflects on his own journey with achieving fitness goals, then struggling to maintain a healthy relationship with food and sustain behavioral changes. He discusses how deeply ingrained narratives of shame and self-worth can intensify negative emotions surrounding setbacks. The episode delves into the role of accountability, support systems, and addressing underlying thought patterns in overcoming obstacles to lasting habit formation.

Listen to the original

Keeping the Weight Off, Rewiring Your Brain with Psychedelics, and Finding Strong Male Role Models

This is a preview of the Shortform summary of the Oct 16, 2024 episode of the The Subtle Art of Not Giving a F*ck Podcast

Sign up for Shortform to access the whole episode summary along with additional materials like counterarguments and context.

Keeping the Weight Off, Rewiring Your Brain with Psychedelics, and Finding Strong Male Role Models

1-Page Summary

Mark's Journey with Weight Loss and Maintenance

Initial Success and Subsequent Struggles

As Mark Manson recounts, after years of diligent effort to achieve his fitness goals by age 40, he found it challenging to maintain his healthy habits when attempting to relax his regimen. Old patterns like mindlessly eating ice cream emerged, signaling the difficulty of long-term habit change.

The Ongoing Challenge

Manson expresses frustration with the realization that for some, including himself, issues like compulsive eating require lifelong management akin to addiction. While changing other habits was relatively easy, maintaining a healthy relationship with food and weight demands sustained vigilance and accountability.

The Psychological and Emotional Challenges

Negative Emotions as Natural Signals

Manson reassures that experiencing negative emotions like guilt and shame after a setback is natural and valuable, as they indicate misalignment with goals and prompt course correction. However, the narratives built around these failures can amplify emotions destructively.

Narratives of Shame and Hopelessness

As Manson discusses, deeply rooted narratives of shame, self-worth, and hopelessness can intensify negative feelings and pressure, ultimately becoming self-defeating and hindering real change. Breaking habits requires addressing both emotional responses and underlying thought patterns.

The Role of Accountability and Support

Manson acknowledges the need for ongoing external support systems like health coaches and accountability structures to sustain healthy eating habits, as relying solely on willpower may prove insufficient. His initial success benefited from such support, and reimplementing it could prevent reverting to old patterns, underscoring its importance for lifelong habit maintenance.

1-Page Summary

Additional Materials

Counterarguments

  • While lifelong management of eating habits is often necessary, comparing it to addiction might not always be accurate or helpful for everyone, as it could pathologize normal eating behaviors.
  • The idea that negative emotions are always natural signals for misalignment with goals can be oversimplified; sometimes, guilt or shame may be disproportionate to the situation and could be a result of unreasonably high standards or external pressures.
  • The narrative that changing habits requires sustained vigilance and accountability might not acknowledge the role of flexibility and self-compassion in a balanced approach to lifestyle changes.
  • The emphasis on the need for external support systems could underplay the importance of developing intrinsic motivation and self-reliance in maintaining healthy habits.
  • The text suggests that willpower is insufficient for maintaining healthy habits, but some research indicates that strengthening self-control can be an important factor in long-term habit maintenance.
  • The focus on shame and hopelessness might not consider that some individuals may benefit from a more positive and strengths-based approach, focusing on resilience and the ability to learn from setbacks without significant negative self-judgment.

Actionables

  • Create a habit-tracking mural on a prominent wall in your home to visually reinforce your commitment to healthy habits. Use different colors of sticky notes or markers to represent various habits, and each day you adhere to a habit, add a symbol or note to the mural. This public display serves as a constant reminder and can help you stay accountable, while also turning habit tracking into a creative and engaging activity.
  • Develop a "habit swap" routine with a friend where you both commit to replacing a specific unhealthy habit with a healthier alternative for a month. For example, if you tend to eat ice cream when stressed, you might agree to go for a walk or do a quick meditation session instead. Regular check-ins with your friend can provide mutual support and accountability, making it easier to stick to the new routine.
  • Organize a monthly "emotional potluck" with close friends or family where each person brings a healthy dish and shares stories about their journey with maintaining healthy habits. This gathering creates a supportive community where you can discuss challenges, celebrate successes, and explore the emotional aspects of habit formation without judgment. It also reinforces the idea that maintaining health is a shared, ongoing process rather than an individual struggle.

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
Keeping the Weight Off, Rewiring Your Brain with Psychedelics, and Finding Strong Male Role Models

Mark's personal journey with weight loss and maintenance

Mark's Initial Success and Subsequent Struggles

Mark Manson recounts his personal experience of achieving his fitness goals by age 40, only to find himself struggling to maintain his healthy habits afterwards. He had spent years focused on diet and exercise, but when he tried to relax his regimen and lead a more "normal life," he found it difficult to sustain his new habits.

Re-emergence of Unhealthy Patterns

Mark noticed old patterns creeping back into his daily routine, such as reflexively grabbing ice cream after meals, a sign that his former unhealthy behaviors were resurfacing even after his earlier success in curbing them. He shares an insightful moment when he caught himself mindlessly enjoying an ice cream cone, realizing that he was slipping back into his previous lifestyle. These experiences act as a red flag for Mark, suggesting the difficulty of long-term habit change.

The Ongoing Challenge of Eating and Weight

Realizing the Need for Lifelong Management

Mark expresses a sense of frustration and even resignation concerning the ongoing struggle of managing his eating habits and weight. He recognizes that for some, including himself, issues like compulsive eating may be akin to an addiction; such issues demand sustained attention and cannot simply be "fixed" over a few months. This realization is a critical turning point, as Mark understands that lifelong vigilance and accountability ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Mark's personal journey with weight loss and maintenance

Additional Materials

Counterarguments

  • While Mark struggles with maintaining his habits, it's important to note that lapses are a normal part of the behavior change process, and not necessarily indicative of failure.
  • The idea that Mark cannot trust himself without external accountability might be overly pessimistic; self-efficacy and internal motivation can also be powerful tools for maintaining healthy habits.
  • The comparison of compulsive eating to addiction is a complex one; while there are similarities, there are also significant differences, and not all experts agree on the addiction model for food-related issues.
  • The notion that food-related habits are uniquely challenging to break may not account for the fact that difficulty in changing habits can be highly individual and context-dependent.
  • The text implies a somewhat static view of hab ...

Actionables

  • You can create a visual eating habit tracker to monitor your food intake and identify patterns. Start by drawing a simple grid for the week on a whiteboard or paper, and use color-coded markers to represent different types of food or eating behaviors. For example, use green for vegetables, red for sweets, and blue for mindless eating. At the end of each day, reflect on your choices and look for trends over time, which can help you pinpoint triggers for unhealthy habits.
  • Develop a personal reward system that incentivizes healthy eating behaviors without involving food. Choose activities or items you enjoy, such as watching an episode of your favorite show or buying a small non-food-related treat, and allow yourself to indulge in these rewards when you meet specific eating goals. For instance, if you avoid mindless snacking for a week, reward yourself with a new book or a relaxing bath. ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
Keeping the Weight Off, Rewiring Your Brain with Psychedelics, and Finding Strong Male Role Models

The psychological and emotional challenges of changing entrenched habits

Mark Manson delves into the complex emotional landscape involved in changing long-standing habits, tackling the natural but challenging emotions that accompany the effort to break away from our ingrained patterns.

Negative emotions like guilt, shame, and failure are a natural part of the process when we fail at something

Manson reassures us that experiencing negative emotions such as anxiety, regret, and failure after a lapse is a part of the human experience. These feelings act as indicators and are valuable in their own right; they signal to us that our actions weren't aligned with our objectives, with the intention that we don't repeat the same errors.

These negative feelings are not the problem - they serve as signals to help us avoid repeating the same mistakes

When we struggle to change a habit and find ourselves relapsing, it's integral to understand that these setbacks are not only natural but also part of the recovery journey. They offer a moment of reflection and an opportunity for correction.

The bigger issue is the narratives and beliefs we build around those failures

The crux of the matter lies not just in the emotional responses but also in the narratives we create in their wake. Manson discusses these conceptions with a man who struggled with his weight and binging.

Deeply embedded narratives of shame, self-worth, and hopelessness can amplify the negative feelings and become self-defeating

Manson highlights how narratives of shame, self-worth, and hopelessness, when intertwined with failure, can magnify our negative emo ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

The psychological and emotional challenges of changing entrenched habits

Additional Materials

Clarifications

  • Entrenched habits are deeply ingrained behavioral patterns that have become automatic and subconscious through repetition over time. These habits often shape our daily routines and actions without conscious effort. Changing entrenched habits can be challenging due to the strong neural pathways they have formed in the brain. Breaking free from these habits requires conscious effort, awareness, and a willingness to disrupt familiar routines.
  • Negative emotions like guilt, shame, and failure are common when trying to change habits. These emotions act as signals, indicating when our actions don't align with our goals. Understanding and accepting these emotions can help us learn from setbacks and progress towards lasting change.
  • When discussing narratives and beliefs around failures in the context of changing habits, it involves the stories and interpretations individuals create about their setbacks. These narratives can include feelings of shame, self-worth, and hopelessness, which can significantly impact how one perceives and responds to failures. By recognizing and reshaping these narratives, individuals can reduce the negative emotional impact of failures and improve their ability to successfully change long-standing habits. This process involves addressing not just the surface-level emotions but also the underlying thought patterns that influence behavior.
  • When individuals experience failures or setbacks in changing habits, the narratives they construct around these events can deeply impact their self-perception. Narratives of shame, self-worth, and hopelessness can intensify negative emotions by reinforcing feelings of inadequacy and un ...

Counterarguments

  • While negative emotions can serve as signals, they can also be disproportionate to the situation and may require management or therapy to ensure they don't become overwhelming or counterproductive.
  • Not all negative feelings are constructive; some can be maladaptive or stem from unhealthy societal expectations, and distinguishing between the two is important.
  • The emphasis on personal narratives might overlook external factors that contribute to habit formation, such as environmental cues, social pressures, or economic circumstances.
  • The idea that changing narratives alone can facilitate change may be overly simplistic, as it may not ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
Keeping the Weight Off, Rewiring Your Brain with Psychedelics, and Finding Strong Male Role Models

The role of accountability, coaching, and external support in developing sustainable health habits

Mark Manson acknowledges the need for ongoing external support systems to sustain healthy eating and weight management habits, recognizing that willpower alone may not be sufficient for long-term discipline.

Mark understands that he cannot rely solely on his own willpower and self-discipline to maintain healthy habits. He suggests adopting a pattern of alternating periods of structured accountability with periods without it, or incorporating tracking and accountability as a permanent part of his daily routine.

Having a health coach and a support system was pivotal for Mark’s initial success in weight loss, and he admits that reimplementing these supports may be necessary to prevent reverting to old patterns. The implication is that the battle with food and nutrition requires cons ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

The role of accountability, coaching, and external support in developing sustainable health habits

Additional Materials

Counterarguments

  • While external support systems can be beneficial, some individuals may find success through self-motivation and personal accountability without the need for external structures.
  • The idea that willpower is not enough might be too generalized, as there are cases where individuals have successfully maintained long-term discipline through willpower and intrinsic motivation.
  • Alternating periods of structured accountability could potentially lead to inconsistency and confusion, making it harder for some individuals to maintain healthy habits.
  • The integration of tracking and accountability into daily routines might not be suitable for everyone, as it could lead to an overemphasis on monitoring that may result in stress or an unhealthy relationship with food and exercise.
  • The necessity of a health coach or support system for initial success is not universal; some people may find that they can achieve and maintain healthy habits independently.
  • The assertion that constant vigilance is required in the battle with food and nutrition might not resonate with everyone, as some individuals may prefer a more relaxed approach ...

Actionables

  • You can create a habit-building buddy system by pairing up with a friend who has similar health goals and regularly checking in with each other.
  • Pairing up with someone creates a mutual support network that can help both of you stay on track. For example, you could agree to send each other daily or weekly updates on your progress, share tips and recipes, or even exercise together virtually if you're not in the same location.
  • Develop a personalized reward system that encourages you to stick to your health habits when external support isn't available.
  • By rewarding yourself for meeting certain milestones, you create an internal motivation system. For instance, if you complete a week of healthy eating, you might treat yourself to a movie night or a small purchase you've been wanting. This can help maintain discipline during periods without structured accountability.
  • Use social media to create a public commitment ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free

Create Summaries for anything on the web

Download the Shortform Chrome extension for your browser

Shortform Extension CTA