What does it take to achieve creative success? In this episode focusing on the long journey to creative fruition, Steven Pressfield shares insights from his decades-long experience as a writer. He underscores the importance of perseverance, patience, and commitment in navigating the twists and turns that often precede mainstream recognition.
Pressfield and host Mark Manson delve into cultivating a "professional" mindset, emphasizing the primacy of hard work, dedication, and refinement over natural talent. They also discuss the role of resistance—the psychological barriers and self-sabotaging tendencies that creatives must learn to confront head-on to realize their ambitions.
Sign up for Shortform to access the whole episode summary along with additional materials like counterarguments and context.
According to Steven Pressfield, success in creative fields often comes after 20+ years of persistence through rejection. Pressfield, who wrote novels and screenplays for over two decades before his breakthrough, suggests young creatives often quit too soon, failing to understand the lengthy journey required.
Pressfield reveals that his key to continuation amidst failures was an inability to find happiness elsewhere. He advocates for patience, managing emotions, and committing through setbacks - viewing the journey as incremental, akin to capturing one trench at a time. Pressfield believes commitment forges deeper passion over time.
Pressfield asserts hard work (75%) far outweighs talent (15%) and skill (10%) in creative success. Manson highlights the importance of editing and revising creative output over initial talent across fields like writing and music.
Pressfield contrasts "professionals" who persevere through challenges with "amateurs" who quit. Professionals show up consistently, focused over the long-term. Creating professional structures like schedules and workspaces reinforces this. Pressfield advises pushing through difficulties relentlessly.
Pressfield cites resistance as an enemy creatives face daily - from procrastination to self-sabotaging completed projects subconsciously. Resistance re-emerges intensely when nearing completion. Manson discusses overcoming emotional overwhelm through logical approaches.
Pressfield and Manson assert engaging resistance is crucial for progress. Self-doubt indicates significance of one's work. Techniques like diving into action or working incrementally help overcome resistance steadily, similar to military training. Recognizing resistance as inevitable encourages persisting.
1-Page Summary
Steven Pressfield's journey to success and the wisdom shared by both him and Mark Manson reveal the challenging yet fulfilling pursuit of creative accomplishment.
Steven Pressfield's career serves as a testament to the fact that success in the creative field often comes after a long and grueling journey marked by persistence. Pressfield himself spent over 20 years writing novels and screenplays before his big break at age 50 with "The Legend of Bagger Vance," which interestingly was drawn from the Hindu scripture, the Bhagavad Gita, and adapted from a war setting to a golf environment.
Manson points out that young people often feel as though they're running out of time after just a few years of effort, which Pressfield suggests is a misunderstanding of the lengthy road that awaits many in their quest for success. Indeed, the difficulty in enduring prolonged periods without recognition or success leads many aspiring creatives to give up too soon.
Steven Pressfield reveals that the key to his continuation in writing, despite repeated failures, was that he couldn't find happiness in any other occupation. Pressfield speaks to the importance of embracing patience, describing the creative journey as an incremental one, akin to an infantryman capturing one trench at a time. Such an approach mitigates pressure by recognizing the process as a marath ...
The long, winding path to creative success
The conversation with Mark Manson and Steven Pressfield reveals that success in creative fields often hinges not just on talent but significantly on a professional mindset and work ethic.
Pressfield shares his pie chart of success, asserting that hard work accounts for 75% of success, with talent at 15% and skill at 10%. He bases this breakdown on his experiences of overcoming creative obstacles and improving over time through dedication and skill development, stating that talent was a less significant factor.
Manson emphasizes the importance of editing and revision in writing, asserting that it surpasses the initial act of simply putting words on paper. Similarly, in music, he suggests that the combined effect of style, creativity, image, energy, vibe, and stage presence often outweighs pure vocal talent in certain genres. This underlines the idea that the ability to edit, revise, and refine creative output is often more crucial than raw talent.
Pressfield makes a stark distinction between professionals and amateurs. He explains that professionals persevere through challenges and the sometimes tedious aspects of creative work, while amateurs tend to quit when faced with adversity. Professionals, he says, endure by showing up every day, staying on time, working through the entire day, and giving their best effort.
According to Pressfield, a true professional approaches their work as a lifelong marathon and not a sprint. This involves adopting patience, being consistent and focused over an extended period, and not being derailed by setbacks. For instance, he shares the anecdote of a friend who approached learning golf with a professional mindset, despite starting as a beginner, which further illustrates his point that adopting this mindset ...
The importance of a "professional" mindset and work ethic
Steven Pressfield and Mark Manson delve into the psychology of resistance that creatives face. They unpack how self-sabotage and mental/emotional obstacles are a consistent threat to creative work.
Steven Pressfield shares from personal experience that resistance is a formidable enemy he faces daily, from the moment he wakes up with an inclination to "fuck off" to profound instances of self-sabotage. For example, he recounts an instance where he cheated on his wife to subconsciously stop himself from finishing his first book, signaling fear and vulnerability around completing a project. Similarly, Manson faced resistance in resolving personal conflicts, finding excuses to avoid confrontation.
Pressfield also notes that resistance continues to emerge at critical junctures, especially at the "second act" or when nearing project completion. He explains the mixed feelings he undergoes when he completes a book or exposes it to the world, experiences he refers to as "real terrors." He acknowledges the tendency to immediately reject new ideas, only to realize upon revisiting them that they're worth exploring.
Mark Manson discusses feeling overwhelmed when tackling a difficult chapter in his book. Instead of becoming emotional or viewing the book as a failure, he suggests accepting the challenge and addressing it logically.
Pressfield discusses resistance as an intelligent, shape-shifting force that beckons perseverance. Both he and Manson opine that engaging with resistance—acknowledging it head-on—is crucial for moving forward. They suggest that feelings of being overwhelmed or racked by self-doubt are positive indicators of the significance of one's work.
Developing techniques to chip away at resistance is key. For example, Pressfield cites Arnold Schwarzenegger's technique for bypassing resistance by not thinking and jumping straight into action ...
The role and management of resistance, self-doubt, and emotional barriers
Download the Shortform Chrome extension for your browser