Podcasts > The Subtle Art of Not Giving a F*ck Podcast > The Surprising Benefits of Working Weird and Awful Jobs (ft. Derek Sivers)

The Surprising Benefits of Working Weird and Awful Jobs (ft. Derek Sivers)

By Mark Manson

Explore the unorthodox career trajectories of Mark Manson and Derek Sivers in the latest episode of The Subtle Art of Not Giving a F*ck Podcast. Journey with them as they delve into the early stages of their professional lives, where they learned to capitalize on every opportunity, no matter how peculiar. They share riveting stories, such as Sivers' transition from a modest gig at a pig show to a circus ringleader MC, illustrating how a simple "yes" can open the door to a decade of success.

Shifting focus to the emotional landscape, the podcast touches upon Mark Manson's experiences as a professional men's dating coach. Addressing the deeper psychological needs of men, Manson sheds light on the crucial demand for emotional guidance in the absence of strong male role models or supportive networks. Hear tales of how offering a day of free work can prove invaluable and learn how big city vibes can inspire one to soar to greater heights. Skirting traditional paths, Manson and Sivers impart their wisdom on forging one's path and the importance of fostering non-judgmental spaces for personal growth.

Listen to the original

The Surprising Benefits of Working Weird and Awful Jobs (ft. Derek Sivers)

This is a preview of the Shortform summary of the Feb 28, 2024 episode of the The Subtle Art of Not Giving a F*ck Podcast

Sign up for Shortform to access the whole episode summary along with additional materials like counterarguments and context.

The Surprising Benefits of Working Weird and Awful Jobs (ft. Derek Sivers)

1-Page Summary

Finding opportunities by saying yes to everything early on

Early in their careers, individuals like Derek Sivers have found great success by embracing every opportunity that comes their way. Sivers took what appeared to be a low-profile $75 gig at a pig show, a move that eventually led him to a decade-long role as a circus ringleader MC, performing across the Northeast. This path showcases the potential rewards of saying "yes" to even the most unexpected opportunities.

Alan Tepper, facing unemployment during the 1992 recession, didn't wait around for an opportunity to present itself. Instead, he actively approached Warner-Chappell Music Publishing with a proposal that brought significant profits to the company. Like Tepper, Sivers created his success by adding guitar tracks to Ryuichi Sakamoto's album without being asked, demonstrating initiative that forged a valuable working relationship. Mark Manson also emphasizes the importance of proving one's value through action, by offering a day’s worth of free work rather than just discussing potential.

Moreover, Sivers and Manson highlight the dynamic atmosphere of big cities like New York City as hubs of inspiration and opportunity. They share how the energy of being surrounded by "greatness" motivates one to set higher standards and work harder. Being in places where key industries are concentrated increases the odds of seizing opportunities, as proven by Sivers' gig with Sakamoto, which came about due to his roommate's chance encounter with the artist in New York City.

Helping men by providing emotional support and a needed perspective

Mark Manson, working as a professional men's dating coach, underscores the critical need for emotional support among men, many of whom lack a strong male role model. He offers guidance that goes beyond superficial dating advice, delving into the psychological aspects that inform men's perceptions of gender, relationships, and self-worth.

Manson notes that most of his clients struggle with unrealistic expectations and a lack of a father figure, leading their needs to be similar to those fulfilled by a male role model or therapist. His work often involves listening to men's insecurities and offering reassurance, highlighting the value of creating a non-judgmental space for them to express and work through their issues. This therapeutic aspect of his coaching addresses the emotional void left by absent family figures and friends who may not provide the necessary support.

1-Page Summary

Additional Materials

Clarifications

  • Mark Manson, a professional men's dating coach, provides guidance that delves into the psychological aspects influencing men's perceptions of gender, relationships, and self-worth. He focuses on addressing unrealistic expectations and the absence of strong male role models in his clients' lives. Manson's work involves creating a non-judgmental space for men to express their insecurities and receive emotional support. He helps men navigate issues related to dating and relationships by offering insights beyond superficial advice.
  • Mark Manson's coaching involves providing emotional support to men who often lack strong male role models. He creates a safe space for men to express their insecurities and struggles, offering reassurance and guidance beyond surface-level advice. By addressing the psychological aspects of their perceptions and self-worth, Manson helps fill the emotional void left by absent family figures or inadequate support systems. This therapeutic approach aims to help men work through their issues and develop healthier perspectives on relationships and self-esteem.

Counterarguments

  • Embracing every opportunity can lead to overcommitment and burnout, and it may not be a sustainable strategy for everyone.
  • Not all opportunities, even if accepted, will lead to significant or beneficial outcomes, and some may be a distraction from more aligned goals.
  • The success stories of individuals like Sivers and Tepper may be exceptions rather than the rule, and not everyone will experience similar outcomes.
  • Adding value without being asked, like Sivers did with Sakamoto's album, could sometimes be seen as overstepping boundaries or could lead to exploitation if not properly acknowledged or compensated.
  • The idea that big cities are hubs of opportunity may not account for the increasing viability of remote work and the success that can be found outside of these traditional centers.
  • The emphasis on big cities might also overlook the challenges they pose, such as high living costs and intense competition, which can be barriers to success for some individuals.
  • While emotional support for men is important, the role of a dating coach should not be conflated with that of a licensed therapist, and there may be limits to the support that can be ethically provided in a coaching context.
  • The narrative that men primarily lack strong male role models could be an oversimplification and may not address the broader societal factors contributing to men's emotional challenges.
  • The approach of offering free work to prove value could potentially devalue one's profession and contribute to a culture where unpaid labor is expected, particularly in creative industries.

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
The Surprising Benefits of Working Weird and Awful Jobs (ft. Derek Sivers)

Finding opportunities by saying yes to everything early on

Saying yes to a variety of experiences and opportunities can lead to unexpected and rewarding career paths, as demonstrated in the stories of Derek Sivers and others who have made bold moves to create their own success.

Taking on any music gig to gain experience

Derek Sivers took what seemed like an insignificant $75 gig at a pig show early in his career. This seemingly trivial choice led to him being noticed by an agent and subsequently offered a role as a ringleader MC of a circus—a role he held for 10 years, performing two to four shows every weekend across the Northeast.

Creating your own job when companies aren't hiring

Alan Tepper's story

In a time of economic difficulty, Alan Tepper found himself without a job during the recession in 1992. Rather than waiting for an opportunity to arise, Tepper approached Warner-Chappell Music Publishing and proposed helping them to get their music into commercials, asking for only a desk and a phone in return. His proactiveness paid off, and within a year, he was making more money for the company than anyone else in the office.

Providing free work samples to show your value

Sivers, without any direct mention of free work samples in the provided content, instead took similar initiative by adding guitar tracks to Ryuichi Sakamoto's album—which initially had none—to secure a working relationship. Mark Manson also talks about the value of offering a day’s worth of free work to prove one’s worth, citing frustration with people who would rather talk about their potential than show their actual work. Manson emphasizes that showcasing one's skills through free work can lead to employment opportunities.

Moving to big cities with more inspiration and opportunities

Feeling surrounded by "greatness" in NYC and other big cities

Derek Sivers reflects on how being in New York City inspired him to set higher expectations for himself and work harder. He describes being around "greatness" and amidst numerous opp ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Finding opportunities by saying yes to everything early on

Additional Materials

Clarifications

  • Derek Sivers' role as a ringleader MC of a circus stemmed from a seemingly insignificant $75 gig at a pig show where he showcased his performance skills. This opportunity led to him being noticed by an agent who recognized his talent and offered him a more prominent role in the entertainment industry. Sivers' experience as a ringleader MC involved hosting and leading the circus performances, showcasing his ability to engage and entertain audiences in a unique and dynamic setting. This unexpected career path highlights the importance of seizing diverse opportunities and making the most of every experience, no matter how small it may seem at first.
  • Alan Tepper proposed to Warner-Chappell Music Publishing to assist them in placing their music in commercials. In return, he requested only a desk and a phone, showcasing his proactive approach to creating an opportunity for himself during a challenging economic period. Tepper's initiative paid off as he was able to demonstrate his value to the company and eventually became a significant contributor to their success. This strategic move by Tepper highlights the importance of thinking creatively and taking proactive steps to carve out opportunities, even in challenging circumstances.
  • Mark Manson emphasizes the value of offering a day's worth of free work to demonstrate one's skills and capabilities to potential employers. By providing tangible examples of one's abilities through practical work, individuals can showcase their value more effectively than just discussing their potential. This approach can help differentiate oneself in competitive job markets and increase the likelihood of securing employment opportunities.
  • Feeling surrounded by "greatness" in big cities like NYC often relates to being in an environment where one is exposed to high achievers, innovative thinkers, and abundant opportunities, which can inspire individuals to aim higher and push themselves further in their pursuits. This sense of being amidst exceptional talent and energy can create a motivating atmosphere that encourag ...

Counterarguments

  • Saying yes to everything can lead to overcommitment and burnout, making it important to be selective and prioritize opportunities that align with one's goals and values.
  • Taking any gig, such as the $75 one at a pig show, may not always lead to significant opportunities and can sometimes result in wasted effort if not strategically chosen.
  • Creating your own job, like Alan Tepper did, requires a certain level of privilege, resources, and networking that may not be accessible to everyone, especially during economic downturns.
  • Providing free work samples can be exploitative and contribute to a culture where people are expected to work for free, potentially devaluing the work of professionals in the field.
  • The inspiration and opportunities in big cities come with high costs of living, which can be prohibitive for many and may not guarantee success.
  • ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
The Surprising Benefits of Working Weird and Awful Jobs (ft. Derek Sivers)

Helping men by providing emotional support and a needed perspective

Manson, a professional men's dating coach, highlights the importance of emotional support for men who often lack a vital male role model in their lives. His experiences reveal the crucial need for reassurance and a healthier perspective on relationships and self-worth.

Gaining insights into human psychology from intense social interactions

In his role, Manson addresses men's skewed perceptions and understanding of women and dating, which often stem not from a lack of knowing what to say or how to dress, but rather from unrealistic expectations about gender, dating, and sex.

Acting as a stand-in male role model and therapist

Listening to men's insecurities and providing reassurance

Manson expresses surprise at how many of his clients lacked a father figure, with about 90% of them needing guidance akin to a male role model. His engage ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Helping men by providing emotional support and a needed perspective

Additional Materials

Clarifications

  • Manson is a professional men's dating coach known for providing emotional support and guidance to men in their relationships. His expertise lies in helping men navigate their perceptions of women, dating, and self-worth, often stemming from societal expectations and personal experiences. Manson's role involves acting as a stand-in male role model and therapist, addressing deep-seated insecurities and providing reassurance to clients who may lack a father figure or male guidance in their lives. His approach goes beyond traditional dating advice, focusing on building healthier perspectives and relationships for his clients.
  • Men lacking a male role model in their lives can face challenges in developing a healthy sense of masculinity and navigating relationships. Without a positive male influence, they may struggle with self-esteem, emotional expression, and understanding boundaries. This absence can lead to difficulties in forming healthy connections and can impact their overall well-being. Manson's work highlights the significant impact of this absence and the importance of providing support and guidance to fill this role.
  • Men's skewed perceptions and understanding of women and dating often stem from societal norms, media influences, and personal experiences. These perceptions can lead to unrealistic expectations and misconceptions about gender roles, relationships, and intimacy. Men may struggle with communication, emotional expression, and vulnerability due to these ingrained beliefs. Addressing and reshaping these perceptions is crucial for fostering healthier and more fulfilling relationships.
  • In Manson's work with clients, the transition from dating advice to therapeutic conversations occurs when he delves deeper into their emotional ...

Counterarguments

  • While Manson's emotional support is valuable, it is not a substitute for professional mental health care, and there may be concerns about the qualifications of dating coaches to handle deep-seated psychological issues.
  • The focus on men's lack of male role models might overlook the positive impact that other figures, such as mothers or other family members, can have on a man's emotional development.
  • The idea that 90% of Manson's clients lack a father figure could be an overgeneralization and may not reflect the broader population of men seeking dating advice.
  • Manson's approach to addressing unrealistic expectations might benefit from incorporating a more diverse range of perspectives, including those from women and non-binary individuals, to provide a more holistic understanding of gender and relationships.
  • The role of a stand-in male role model and therapist could inadvertently reinforce traditional gender roles, suggesting that only men can provide certain types of support to other men.
  • The emphasis o ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free

Create Summaries for anything on the web

Download the Shortform Chrome extension for your browser

Shortform Extension CTA