In this episode of The Peter Attia Drive, neurosurgeon Edward Chang traces the evolution of neurosurgery from its pioneers to modern practices. He explains how early innovators like Harvey Cushing and Wilder Penfield shaped the field through their work on pituitary tumors and brain mapping, while discussing how contemporary neurosurgery combines traditional techniques with advanced technologies like laser probes and focused ultrasound.
Chang details his research on brain-computer interfaces (BCIs) that help restore speech and movement in paralyzed patients, including clinical trials where patients communicate with 95% accuracy through surgically placed arrays. He outlines the future of neurosurgery, describing how the integration of computer science, electrical engineering, and genetic approaches could transform treatment for conditions like Parkinson's disease and Alzheimer's through less invasive BCI systems and organoid technology.
Sign up for Shortform to access the whole episode summary along with additional materials like counterarguments and context.
In this episode, Edward Chang explores the transformative journey of neurosurgery, highlighting two pioneering figures: Harvey Cushing and Wilder Penfield. Chang explains that Cushing, known as the father of modern neurosurgery, revolutionized the field through his exceptional surgical abilities and groundbreaking work on pituitary tumors. Penfield, working at the Montreal Neurological Institute, advanced our understanding of brain mapping and developed the concept of awake brain surgery.
Chang notes that while some techniques, like craniotomy, remain largely unchanged since Cushing's era, modern neurosurgery has evolved to embrace less invasive approaches using advanced technologies like laser probes and focused ultrasound.
Chang and Attia discuss how awake brain surgery is possible because the brain lacks pain receptors. During these procedures, patients are lightly sedated with medications like [restricted term], becoming fully conscious only when necessary for critical brain mapping. This mapping process, Chang explains, helps preserve essential functions like language and movement, even during extensive procedures like tumor removal or treating seizures.
Chang's research focuses on brain-computer interface (BCI) systems that can interpret neural signals to restore speech and movement in paralyzed patients. His team uses electrocorticography (ECoG), placing sensors over specific brain regions to map neural activity. In clinical trials, they've achieved remarkable success, including helping a paralyzed patient communicate with 95% accuracy through a surgically placed array.
Chang's work demonstrates how BCIs might help treat various neurological conditions, including ALS and paralysis, by bypassing damaged motor pathways. The field is advancing through biocompatible brain implants, machine learning algorithms, and potential stem cell therapies, offering hope for conditions like Parkinson's disease and Alzheimer's.
Looking ahead, Chang envisions neurosurgery becoming increasingly multidisciplinary, incorporating computer science, electrical engineering, and materials science. He anticipates less invasive BCI systems, advancements in organoid technology, and genetic approaches that could transform the treatment of neurological diseases. Chang emphasizes that artificial intelligence and machine learning will play crucial roles in developing these innovative solutions.
1-Page Summary
Edward Chang delves into the rich history and evolution of neurosurgery, highlighting the contributions of its pioneers, Harvey Cushing and Wilder Penfield, and the transformation of surgical techniques from highly invasive to minimally invasive procedures using advanced technologies.
Edward Chang speaks glowingly of Harvey Cushing, marking him as a clear inflection point in the domains of medicine, neuroscience, and neurosurgery. Cushing, considered the father of modern neurosurgery, made profound contributions through his exceptional surgical abilities and observations. Beyond his surgical prowess, Cushing was an astute internist, being the first to diagnose pituitary tumors and their effects on the endocrine system. Chang acknowledges that Cushing's era introduced the brain's modern tools of craniotomy to access tumors.
Wilder Penfield emerges as another titan in the field, renowned for his work at the Montreal Neurological Institute and his significant advancements in modern epilepsy surgery. Penfield's work popularized the homunculus—a depiction of the brain regions controlling each muscle in the body—and greatly enhanced the understanding of language. He was also a forerunner in developing the concept of awake brain surgery, which profoundly influenced Chang's own neurosurgical career.
Chan ...
The Evolution of Neurosurgery and Its Key Pioneers
Attia and Dr. Edward Chang delve into the intricacies of brain surgery, with a particular focus on surgeries where the patient is awake, enabled by the brain's lack of pain receptors.
The brain itself doesn’t have pain receptors, which enables the possibility of awake brain surgery. Pain receptors are present in nerves and the scalp, as well as throughout the body, but brain tissue is devoid of them. Sensitivities can exist around the blood vessels and the dura membrane on top of the brain, but these can be numbed, making surgery on the brain itself pain-free for the patient.
During an extensive conversation about awake brain surgery, Attia and Chang discuss that patients are lightly sedated with a much lower dose of sedation than that used for general anesthesia. A medication like [restricted term] is administered at a very light dosing and can be stopped when necessary, such as when the surgery requires the patient to be fully awake for critical function mapping of the brain.
Chang notes that patients are only awake for an hour or two during a surgery that could last several hours, primarily for brain mapping while fully conscious. This meticulous process allows surgeons to map and preserve crucial areas of the brain responsible for language or motor abilities while intermittently sedating the patient for comfort.
Chang explains that brain ma ...
Technical Aspects of Brain Surgery, Including Awake Procedures
Edward Chang's research in the field of neural engineering aims to decode and interpret neural signals, potentially restoring speech and movement for paralyzed patients through brain-computer interface (BCI) systems.
Chang's work bridges the operating room, the research lab, and the engineering bench. His focus is on using BCI systems for interpreting brain signals, which can then be used to move a computer cursor or restore speech for someone who's paralyzed and cannot talk.
Edward Chang acknowledges that the restoration of function in conditions like paralysis hasn't been possible until recently due to advancements in brain-computer interfaces (BCI). The use of electrocorticography (ECoG), where sensors are placed over the speech area, allows dense sampling across that region, and is leveraged to restore communication for paralyzed patients like a patient named Anne, who communicates through devices tracking her eye movements.
Chang and his team have spent over a decade using methods like ECoG to map the "mini-homunculus" in the brain that corresponds to parts of the vocal tract. Their research has identified neural signals for every consonant and vowel in English, which they've used to help restore communication for Anne, who could vocalize a little but was otherwise unintelligible.
Chang's clinical trial involves a surgically placed array connected via a port anchored to the skull to decode brain activity. The BCI decodes brain signals for a woman trying to speak but cannot because her lips, jaw, and larynx are paralyzed, rendering her unintelligible. In an experiment, they could decode words and display them as text with about 95% accuracy after a week of testing.
The discussion includes decoding brain activity associated with the volitional intent to speak, rather than inner monologues or reading. The patient's intent to speak sentences displayed on a screen is critical for training the BCI decoder. Initially, the system mapped brain signals to a simple vocabulary of 27 words translated into text with about 50% accuracy a ...
Brain-Computer Interfaces For Restoring Speech and Movement
Recent discussion with experts, like Edward Chang and Peter Attia, reveals the growing potential for brain-computer interfaces (BCIs) and other technologies to provide novel treatments for neurological conditions.
Chang’s work illustrates the possibility of using BCIs to treat patients with paralysis due to neurodegenerative conditions such as ALS, where damaged motor pathways prevent speech.
Chang’s team has shown how BCI technology, specifically ECoG sensors implanted on a patient’s brain, might bypass damaged motor pathways and restore communication abilities. This suggests potential for BCIs to address conditions resulting in paralysis, like ALS and spinal cord injuries.
Advances in fields like material science could lead to biocompatible brain implants, and genetic understanding may custom-treat glioblastoma. Though Chang does not expressly mention the role of machine learning algorithms for Parkinson's or glioblastoma, the implication is that such advances, like ECoG implants and immunotherapies, are on the horizon, offering hope for managing these illnesses.
Potential of Brain-Computer Interfaces and Other Technologies For Treating Neurological Conditions
Dr. Edward Chang offers insights into the rapidly evolving field of neurosurgery, shedding light on the shift towards biological and genetic solutions, less invasive procedures, and a multidisciplinary approach.
Chang discusses new therapies focusing on brain circuitry and how this understanding could lead to treating diseases like glioblastoma as a chronic condition rather than a terminal one. For instance, he describes dissociation syndrome, which results from seizures rapidly spreading across the brain and indicates a need to control brain cell synchrony. Historically, the corpus callosomnium procedure disconnects brain hemispheres to stop seizure propagation, showing the emphasis on modifying brain circuitry to tackle such conditions.
Chang envisions a future where neurosurgery involves high-bandwidth wireless connections to brain circuitry and less invasive brain-computer interfaces (BCIs). He anticipates that advancements in organoid technology and genetics will provide better models for diseases and new approaches for treatments such as Parkinson's. Additionally, in the context of organoid advancement within UCFS trials, combining BCI systems with organoid technology for neurological disease treatment is anticipated.
Chang foresees a future where neurosurgery will incorporate disciplines like computer science, electrical engineering, materials science, and medicine. He mentions tha ...
Future of Neurosurgery: Biological and Genetic Approaches
Download the Shortform Chrome extension for your browser