In this episode of The Jordan B. Peterson Podcast, Peterson analyzes the fairy tale of Snow White, exploring the psychological and evolutionary dynamics at play in the story. He examines the Evil Queen's character through the lens of pride and envy, drawing parallels between her behavior and patterns observed in female social hierarchies among primates.
Peterson delves into the symbolic significance of the tale's key elements, from the dwarfs' representation of productive masculinity to the prince's role in Snow White's protection. The analysis extends beyond the surface narrative to address universal themes about power dynamics, competition, and fertility suppression, connecting these ancient storytelling elements to modern social behaviors and relationships.
Sign up for Shortform to access the whole episode summary along with additional materials like counterarguments and context.
Jordan Peterson analyzes the Evil Queen's character through the lens of pride and envy. He explains that the queen's identity is deeply rooted in her beauty and youth, leading to destructive behavior when these attributes are threatened. When her enchanted mirror reveals Snow White's superior beauty, the queen's jealousy drives her to plot against her own daughter. Peterson compares her pride to Lucifer's downfall, noting how she inverts the maternal role from nurturing to consuming, ultimately leading to her own destruction.
Peterson draws fascinating parallels between the Evil Queen archetype and behavior observed in higher-status female primates. He explains how dominant females often suppress subordinates' fertility through social stress, gossip, and exclusion. This pattern extends to modern contexts, where Peterson notes that powerful women may indirectly influence younger women's reproductive choices through workplace expectations and social pressure.
In Peterson's analysis, the dwarfs represent ordinary, productive masculinity, offering Snow White protection in exchange for domestic help. While they provide initial safety, their protective capacity has limits. The prince, however, represents a higher form of masculinity, seeking an individualized relationship with Snow White. Peterson suggests that the dwarfs' respectful treatment of Snow White sets the stage for the prince's arrival and their eventual marriage, which ultimately defeats the Evil Queen's schemes.
Peterson interprets Snow White as a tale rich in psychological and evolutionary dynamics. He connects the story's symbols to universal themes, such as the struggle between youth and age, and fertility suppression. The queen's use of items like the corset and apple symbolize attempts to eliminate Snow White's fertility, while the story's color palette of black, white, and red carries deep cultural significance. Peterson emphasizes that the tale's enduring appeal stems from its reflection of timeless human truths about power, competition, and the human condition.
1-Page Summary
The Evil Queen's tale is a complex narrative of pride, envy, and terror at the prospect of losing her cherished identity as the fairest of all.
Peterson analyzes the Evil Queen's pride, which he identifies as the root of her nefarious behavior. He equates her pride with the downfall of Lucifer, a spirit attempting to usurp the divine. The queen does not use her beauty, a gift of Providence, graciously or self-sacrificingly but for her own vanity. Her identity is deeply intertwined with her beauty and youth, to the destructive exclusion of other virtues.
When her enchanted mirror reveals that Snow White has surpassed her beauty, the Evil Queen's heart turns black with envy, leading her to plot the death of her own daughter. Her feeling of envy is so overpowering that she is willing to go to great lengths, including disguising herself as a peddler, to accomplish her malicious plans. The mirror's confirmation of Snow White’s superior beauty fuels the Evil Queen’s hatred and motivates her horrific actions.
Peterson describes the Evil Queen's worship of her own beauty, which leads her to take extreme measures to preserve her image as the fairest. Her actions reflect the inversion of the maternal nourishment paradigm, symbolizing a mother who consumes rather than nurtures her child. The queen's vanity and her obses ...
The Psychology and Motivations of the Evil Queen
Jordan Peterson discusses the complex dynamics between dominant and subordinate females in social hierarchies, drawing parallels between human behavior and that observed in higher status female primates.
Peterson plans to explore the topic of the Evil Queen, a symbol possibly reflecting the fertility suppression seen in higher status female primates. He delves into the psychological significance of this archetype, explaining that high-status females may employ tactics to undermine the reproductive success of subordinate females. This strategy might maximize the high-status females' chances of mating success and genetic propagation. According to Peterson, social stress deployed by these dominant individuals can cause an increase in stress hormones among their subordinates, disrupting their hormonal cycles, which can, in turn, lead to reduced fertility. Dominant females may use tools such as gossip, social isolation, and reputation savaging to achieve these ends.
In certain human societies, Peterson notes that older women or those with high social standing often exercise influence over the reproductive choices of younger, lower-status women. This control might manifest in decisions about when and whom these younger females marry, thereby delaying or restricting their reproductive opportunities, often dictated by mothers-in-law or other older women within the social structure.
Extending the discussion to modern contexts, Peterson points out that dominant figures, such as corporate leaders or tenure ...
Dominant and Subordinate Females in Social Hierarchies
The timeless tale of Snow White has deep-seated implications regarding protection and alliance between ordinary men and young women, as highlighted by Jordan Peterson.
Peterson suggests that Snow White represents young women who seek refuge from the toxicity of older women, such as the Evil Queen, and finds protection with the dwarfs. The story portrays the dwarfs' dwelling as tidy and well-maintained, which indicates their capability to maintain order and take care of themselves. When Snow White arrives, she discovers a place ready with food and drink, showcasing masculine provision and hospitality.
Snow White runs away from her malevolent mother and finds shelter with the dwarfs, who embody a stable, ordinary, productive patriarchy. The dwarfs then offer her protection in exchange for household services like cooking, cleaning, and knitting. When she is tricked by the Evil Queen, the dwarfs come to her aid by cutting a lace that the queen had tied too tightly. Peterson regards the dwarfs as protectors and allies against destructive elements. Snow White's role as the helpmeet for the dwarfs illustrates a symbiotic relationship with ordinary masculinity.
However, the dwarfs' protective capacity has its limits; they represent ordinary, hardworking men rather than individualized saviors. They were unable to shield Snow White from the Evil Queen's poison—their valiant efforts to revive her following her bite of the poisoned apple prove unsuccessful. Despite this failure, the dwarfs pay tribute to Snow White by placing her in a glass coffin, continuing to value and respect her even in her dormant state.
The prince’s entry into the narrative is significant. He represents a higher form of masculinity, one that seeks an individualized relationship with Snow White and desires to take active responsibility for her wellbeing. The prince is willing to honor her as his be ...
Dwarfs and Prince's Role In Protecting Snow White
In a discussion led by Jordan Peterson, the intricate symbolism of the fairy tale "Snow White" is unraveled to reveal its deep psychological and evolutionary dynamics, uncovering themes of fertility suppression, female competition, and power struggles, all of which are argued to embody profound truths about consciousness, morality, and the human condition.
Peterson compares themes in "Snow White" with primate behavior, such as how dominant females may suppress the fertility of others, which he likens to broader human power struggles. He reveals that the tale echoes a battle between youth and age where the Evil Queen's battle against her stepdaughter is not just familial but symbolizes a universal struggle of aging against youth, particularly amid fertility and sexual attractiveness. This theme crystallizes in the queen's envy that drives her to suppress Snow White's burgeoning beauty and potential instead of stepping back as the wise mother.
Peterson also connects this to extreme cultural practices, such as female genital mutilation, where older women carry out the act, symbolizing age's attempt to stamp out youth's fertility and attractiveness. Delving deeper, he examines the queen's behavior as a pathology, a deviation in human development where parents feel threatened by their child's potential, often leading to discouragement and harm. This form of fertility suppression and power struggle is mirrored in the queen's inability to let Snow White take precedence due to her youth.
Peterson dissects the symbolic elements within the narrative, such as the corset and apple used by the queen, which simultaneously connote attractiveness and fertility suppression, advancing the tale's depiction of female competition. He suggests the colors black, white, and red, used in the story, have a universal symbolic significance across cultures, with red representing youth and fecundity. He critiques modern interpretations of the story that fail to adhere to these lessons, arguing that they deviate from universal truths about power struggles, reproductive pathology, and the oppression represented by the Evil Queen archetype. The ...
Symbolic Meaning and Significance of Fairy Tale
Download the Shortform Chrome extension for your browser