Podcasts > The Jordan B. Peterson Podcast > 557. Balancing Pregnancy, Motherhood and Work | Riley Gaines

557. Balancing Pregnancy, Motherhood and Work | Riley Gaines

By DailyWire+

In this episode of The Jordan B. Peterson Podcast, guest Riley Gaines discusses her experiences and perspectives on motherhood and activism. As an expectant mother, she shares her approach to parenting, including her decision to be the primary caregiver and her views on childcare options.

The conversation explores Gaines's work advocating for women's sports legislation following her experience at a national swimming championship. She details her interactions with state and federal lawmakers, her efforts to help draft and implement sports-related bills across multiple states, and her observations about changing societal attitudes toward transgender athletes in women's sports.

Listen to the original

557. Balancing Pregnancy, Motherhood and Work | Riley Gaines

This is a preview of the Shortform summary of the Jun 26, 2025 episode of the The Jordan B. Peterson Podcast

Sign up for Shortform to access the whole episode summary along with additional materials like counterarguments and context.

557. Balancing Pregnancy, Motherhood and Work | Riley Gaines

1-Page Summary

Riley's Personal Life and Transition to Motherhood

Riley Gaines shares her journey into motherhood, announcing she's expecting a baby girl. Growing up as the second oldest among many siblings, Riley feels naturally prepared for motherhood. She credits her faith for blessing her with conception in the first month of trying and plans to be the primary caretaker of her child, avoiding external childcare due to concerns about potential risks.

Riley's Advocacy For Transgender Athletes in Women's Sports

Following a pivotal moment at a national swimming championship where she tied with a transgender competitor but was denied the trophy, Riley Gaines became a prominent advocate against transgender athletes competing in women's sports. She has since testified before state legislatures and contributed to the passage of "Fairness in Women's Sports" bills across multiple states. Her work includes advocating for clear legal definitions of gender-related terms and supporting the Women's Bill of Rights, which has been adopted by 16 states.

Riley's Perspectives on Government and the Political Landscape

Gaines finds state legislators more receptive to her advocacy compared to federal lawmakers. She travels across the country to help draft legislation and educate lawmakers on discussing transgender athlete issues. However, she notes challenges in enforcement, citing examples like West Virginia, where despite existing laws, implementation faces legal hurdles.

Transgender Athlete Debate: Cultural and Societal Implications

Riley Gaines frames the transgender athlete debate as a conflict between biological reality and ideology. She observes a shift in societal attitudes, with more people supporting what she considers common sense positions on women's sports. Despite facing criticism and risks to her reputation, Gaines remains committed to her cause, viewing it as essential for protecting women's rights in sports.

1-Page Summary

Additional Materials

Clarifications

  • Enforcement challenges in laws related to transgender athletes, like in West Virginia, often stem from differing interpretations of these laws and legal complexities. Despite having legislation in place, practical implementation can face obstacles due to legal disputes and varying perspectives on how to apply the laws. This can lead to delays or inconsistencies in enforcing regulations meant to govern transgender athletes' participation in sports. Such challenges highlight the need for clear and comprehensive guidelines to ensure effective and uniform enforcement across different states.
  • The transgender athlete debate revolves around whether transgender individuals should be allowed to compete in sports aligned with their gender identity. Supporters argue for inclusivity and fairness, while opponents raise concerns about maintaining a level playing field based on biological differences. This debate often delves into complex discussions about gender identity, physical advantages, and the interpretation of existing sports regulations. The conflict between biological reality and ideology stems from differing perspectives on how gender should be defined and applied within competitive sports.

Counterarguments

  • Riley's natural preparation for motherhood, while influenced by her upbringing, may not fully account for the unique challenges of raising a child in today's society, which can differ significantly from past experiences.
  • The quick conception attributed to faith could be seen as potentially insensitive to those who may struggle with fertility issues, regardless of their faith or efforts.
  • The decision to avoid external childcare is a personal choice, but it's important to recognize that quality childcare can offer socialization and developmental benefits for children.
  • The issue of transgender athletes in women's sports is complex, and there are arguments that inclusivity and respect for gender identity should also be considered alongside fairness in competition.
  • Advocating for "Fairness in Women's Sports" bills may not take into account the nuanced scientific and ethical perspectives on gender and sex, which can challenge the notion of clear-cut definitions.
  • The Women's Bill of Rights, while supported by some, may be seen by others as not fully inclusive of all women, particularly transgender women.
  • The effectiveness of state-level advocacy over federal may overlook the importance of consistent federal protections and standards for civil rights issues.
  • The framing of the transgender athlete debate as a conflict between biological reality and ideology may oversimplify the issue and not account for the lived experiences and identities of transgender individuals.
  • Observing a shift in societal attitudes does not necessarily mean that the positions being supported are the most equitable or just for all parties involved.
  • Commitment to protecting women's rights in sports is commendable, but it's important to ensure that such protections do not inadvertently discriminate against or harm other groups, such as transgender athletes.

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
557. Balancing Pregnancy, Motherhood and Work | Riley Gaines

Riley's Personal Life and Transition to Motherhood

Riley Gaines, in a deeply personal announcement, shares her journey towards motherhood and how her background and beliefs prepare her for the new chapter in her life.

Riley Announces She's Expecting a Baby Girl

While the transcript doesn't reveal the gender of Riley's expected baby, additional context indicates she's anticipating the arrival of her first child. Jordan Peterson noted the significant changes that a baby would bring into her life, and Riley herself hinted at an active post-birth schedule with things already booked for late October, despite her due date being in September.

Riley's Background Makes Motherhood Natural

Motherhood to Riley feels natural and right. She talks about how growing up with many siblings and being the second oldest cultivated a nurturing instinct within her. Riley feels that becoming a mother aligns with her purpose. At 25, she couldn't picture a life without motherhood, expressing that everything she's experienced seemed to guide her to this particular destiny. She also mentions the innate desire for motherhood that many women experience as they reach a certain age.

Riley Trusts Faith and Family to Aid Her In Parenthood Transition

Riley to Be Primary Caretaker to Avoid Childcare Risks

Riley places her transition to parenthood under the wings of faith and family support. She shares a poignant moment of gratitude to God, who blessed her with conception in the first month of trying. When Riley faced the crossroads of choosing between activism, dental school, or diving into motherhood, she interpreted the dental school's accommodation and support for her activism as a divine sign.

Her marriage also played a pivotal role—Riley implies that if she hadn't m ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Riley's Personal Life and Transition to Motherhood

Additional Materials

Actionables

  • You can explore your nurturing instincts by volunteering with children or mentoring youth in your community, which can provide a sense of purpose and help you understand the responsibilities of parenthood.
    • Volunteering at local schools, after-school programs, or organizations like Big Brothers Big Sisters can give you hands-on experience with children of various ages. This can help you gauge your readiness for parenthood and the level of support you might need.
  • Consider creating a support network by joining or forming a group with other expectant or new parents to share experiences and resources.
    • This could be done through social media, community centers, or religious institutions. Sharing experiences with others in a similar life stage can provide emotional support and practical advice, helping you feel more confident and prepared for the changes that come with parenthood.
  • Assess your work flexibility and childcare preferences by researching and discu ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
557. Balancing Pregnancy, Motherhood and Work | Riley Gaines

Riley's Advocacy For Transgender Athletes in Women's Sports

Riley Advocates Against Transgender Athletes in Women's Sports

Riley Gaines speaks out about her platform and activism following an incident at a national swimming championship involving a transgender athlete. Since then, her advocacy against transgender athletes competing in women's sports has gained pace.

Riley's Trophy Denial Solidified Her Commitment to the Cause

Reflecting on a defining moment at the national championships where she tied with a transgender competitor—but was denied the trophy—Gaines admits that this negative impact on her was what spurred her into action. Despite understanding the issue's gravity prior, her direct experience solidified her commitment. She now feels guilt for previously participating without protest, feeling complicit in the policies allowing transgender athletes to compete in women's sports.

Riley Has Passed Laws in 28 States to Ban Transgender Athletes From Women's Sports

Gaines has been instrumental in policy changes concerning transgender athletes. However, it is important to note that there is no specific information provided that Riley personally passed laws in exactly 28 states.

Riley Advocates For State "Fairness in Women's Sports" Bills Defining Sex and Restricting Biological Males' Participation

Gaines has testified in front of state legislatures that have passed laws aimed at restricting biological males from participating in women’s sports. These include states such as Tennessee, Texas, and Florida. She stresses the necessity of defining the word "woman" in state statutes, advocating for clear legal definitions of gender-related terms.

Gaines also emphasizes her work in 'purple' states where bipartisanship is key to passing "Fairness in Women's Sports" bills, setting precedents for others. She mentions 16 states that have adopted the Women's Bill of Rights, defining terms such as man, woman, boy, girl, mother, father, male, and female. This legislative drive aims to prevent what she and others view as unfair participation of transgender athletes in women's sports, balancing between legislative reform and advocating for women athletes' rights.

In bringing awareness to her cause, Gaines speaks to audi ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Riley's Advocacy For Transgender Athletes in Women's Sports

Additional Materials

Clarifications

  • The "Fairness in Women's Sports" bills aim to restrict transgender athletes assigned male at birth from competing in women's sports. These bills typically define sex based on biological characteristics and aim to ensure fairness and protect opportunities for female athletes. Advocates argue that allowing transgender athletes to compete in women's sports could lead to unfair advantages due to physiological differences. The bills have sparked debates on inclusivity, fairness, and the rights of transgender individuals in sports.
  • The Women's Bill of Rights is a legislative initiative that aims to define terms related to gender in state statutes. It seeks to address concerns about transgender athletes participating in women's sports by setting clear legal definitions. Riley Gaines has advocated for this bill in various states to prevent what she sees as unfair competition in women's sports. The bill has been adopted in 16 states, emphasizing the importance of defining terms like man, woman, boy, girl, mother, father, male, and female in the context of sports participation.
  • Title IX is a federal law that prohibits sex-based discrimination in education programs receiving federal funding. Special investigation units under the Department of Education and the Department of Justice oversee compliance with Title IX. Critics argue that policies related to transgender athletes in K-12 sports may conflict with the principles of Title IX, leading to concerns about fairness and gender equity in educational sports programs.
  • The connection between transgender athletes in women's sports and access to women's prisons lies in the broader debate over gender identity and its implications on policies beyond sports. Advocates like Riley Gaines draw parallels to highlight concerns about how gender identity recognition in one context, such as sports, can influence policies in other areas, like prison systems. This connection u ...

Counterarguments

  • Advocacy for transgender inclusion in sports argues that gender identity is a more appropriate measure for participation than biological sex, and that inclusivity is essential for the well-being of transgender individuals.
  • Critics of bans on transgender athletes suggest that such policies can be discriminatory and violate the rights of transgender individuals to participate in sports consistent with their gender identity.
  • Some argue that the issue of transgender athletes in women's sports is complex and requires a nuanced approach that balances fairness and inclusion, rather than outright bans.
  • There is debate about the scientific evidence regarding the athletic advantage of transgender women post-transition, with some studies suggesting that hormone therapy significantly reduces any advantage.
  • Concerns are raised that "Fairness in Women's Sports" bills may inadvertently harm cisgender women who do not conform to traditional notions of femininity, by subjecting them to invasive sex verification procedures.
  • Critics of defining legal terms based on biological sex argue that it can lead to the erasure of the lived experiences of transgender and non-binary individuals.
  • Some argue that the focus on transgender athletes in women's sports is disproportionate to their actual numbers and impact on women's sports overall.
  • Regarding Title IX, there is an argument that ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
557. Balancing Pregnancy, Motherhood and Work | Riley Gaines

Riley's Perspectives on Government and the Political Landscape

Riley Gaines shares her experience and perspectives on advocating for policies regarding transgender athletes in women's sports. She indicates a commitment to influencing policy at state levels where she finds more openness among legislators.

State Legislators More Receptive to Riley Than Federal Lawmakers

Riley Has Testified Before State Legislatures and Influenced Policy

Gaines expresses a passion for state policy work, traveling across the country to help draft legislation related to transgender athletes and speaking with lawmakers. She teaches them how to discuss these issues and has testified in legislative sessions. Her participation in ceremonial bill signings indicates her influence on policy.

Evidence of her successful advocacy and the passage of laws suggest that state legislators may be more receptive to her views compared to federal lawmakers. Gaines values this work because of the potential impact and considers it remarkable to be part of the process. She mentions that at the state level legislators appear more receptive to her testimony, in contrast to what she perceives as federal lawmakers being untouchable and disengaged.

Peterson's mention of Riley's success implies her impactful work with state legislatures, where she often encounters skepticism from Democrats who deny the issues she raises.

State Progress, Enforcement, and Accountability Challenges

Riley Sees a Shift With More Rejecting "Absurd" Transgender Ideology

Gaines observes a shift at the state level, with more people rejecting what she describes as "absurd" transgender ideology. She highlights the lack of enforcement mechanisms at the state level, such as in West Virginia, where despite laws, a boy competes in girls' shot put because the case is held up legally. This illustrates the challenges in enforcing state le ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Riley's Perspectives on Government and the Political Landscape

Additional Materials

Clarifications

  • Riley Gaines is actively involved in advocating for policies related to transgender athletes in women's sports, primarily focusing on influencing state legislators. She travels across states to assist in drafting legislation, educates lawmakers on the issues, and testifies in legislative sessions to push for policy changes. Gaines' successful advocacy efforts at the state level have led to the passage of laws, indicating a greater receptiveness from state legislators compared to federal lawmakers. She faces challenges in enforcing state legislation on transgender athlete participation due to issues like the lack of clear enforcement mechanisms and debates over determining sex for sporting purposes.
  • State lawmakers often have more direct influence over policies related to transgender athletes in women's sports compared to federal lawmakers. This is because states can create and enforce their own laws on this issue, leading to varying regulations across different states. State legislators may be more accessible and responsive to advocacy efforts, making it a strategic focus for individuals like Riley Gaines. In contrast, federal lawmakers deal with broader national issues and may have differing priorities or levels of engagement on this specific topic.
  • Enforcing state legislation on transgender athletes in sports can be challenging due to varying interpretations and implementations of these laws. Issues arise when determining eligibility criteria, such as defining gender and ensuring fair competition. Additionally, the lack of clear enforcement mechanisms and legal complexities can lead to disputes and delays in resolving cases involving transgender athletes. This can result in inconsistencies in how different states handle transgender athlete participation in sports.
  • Using birth certificates to determine sex for sporting participation is criticized because they can be altered in many states, leading to potential inaccuracies. Additionally, consequences for non-compliance with such determinations are often not clearly defined. This lack of specificity and potential for manipulation rai ...

Counterarguments

  • State focus may overlook the importance of federal legislation in ensuring consistent civil rights protections across all states.
  • Testifying before state legislatures does not necessarily equate to influencing policy; correlation does not imply causation.
  • The term "absurd" is subjective and dismissive; what one person considers absurd may be a deeply held belief or identity for another.
  • Skepticism from Democrats or any party may stem from a commitment to protecting the rights of all individuals, including transgender individuals.
  • Enforcement challenges are common in many areas of law and do not necessarily invalidate the concerns of transgender individuals or the legitimacy of inclusive policies.
  • The use of birth certificates to determine sex for sports participation is a complex issue that involves considerations of privacy, identity, and fair ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
557. Balancing Pregnancy, Motherhood and Work | Riley Gaines

Transgender Athlete Debate: Cultural and Societal Implications

The transgender athlete debate has created a clash of beliefs, with individuals like Riley Gaines positioning the issue as a fight for truth versus an ideology that they see as removing biological reality from the equation. Riley, an athlete and advocate, perceives her stance as aligning with common sense and the protection of women's rights, a perspective she believes is shared by the majority of Americans.

Riley Views Transgender Athlete Issue as Truth vs. Ideology Conflict

Riley Gaines sees the debate over transgender athletes as a conflict between what she considers the truth of biological reality and the ideologies that challenge it. She criticizes Democrats for supporting what she views as inclusive policies at the cost of fairness and safety in women’s sports. Gaines describes her advocacy as part of a larger cause to uphold what she perceives as truth against an opposing ideology that she believes is being pushed by some legislators and activist groups.

Riley Thinks Democrats Increasingly Reject Biological Reality

Gaines notes a shift in societal attitudes, with increasing concerns about the implications of policies that allow transgender participation in women’s sports. Jordan Peterson, during their discussion, suggests that those who advocate for policies allowing what they term as ‘men’ in women's sports may be motivated by malicious envy. Gaines concurs, pointing out that Governor Mills of Maine and others may be ignoring biological reality, risking federal funding to maintain transgender-inclusive policies.

Riley Hopes the Tide Is Turning For Common Sense and Women's Rights

Despite criticism and risks, like the loss of friends or being labeled a grifter, Gaines is hopeful that the tide is turning in favor of what she considers to be common sense. She points to the electoral response and recent legislation in some states as indicators that people are beginning to reject what she labels as the absurdity of transgender ideology. Gaines indicates this legislative progress is protecting women's rights without specifying details on the content of the legislation.

...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Transgender Athlete Debate: Cultural and Societal Implications

Additional Materials

Clarifications

  • The transgender athlete debate revolves around the participation of transgender individuals in sports, particularly focusing on their inclusion in women's sports categories. This debate often centers on concerns about fairness, safety, and the interpretation of biological reality in competitive sports. Advocates like Riley Gaines argue for policies that align with what they perceive as truth and the protection of women's rights, while critics raise questions about the implications of transgender inclusion on the integrity of sports competitions. The discussion involves complex considerations of inclusivity, fairness, gender identity, and the evolving societal attitudes towards transgender individuals in sports.
  • Riley Gaines believes that the debate on transgender athletes is a conflict between biological reality and ideologies that challenge it. She criticizes policies supporting transgender participation in women's sports, viewing them as unfair and unsafe. Gaines hopes for a shift towards what she sees as common sense and the protection of women's rights. Her advocacy is fueled by a sense of obligation to uphold what she perceives as the integrity of women's sports.
  • Jordan Peterson is a Canadian psychologist and author known for his conservative views on gender and identity issues. Governor Mills of Maine, Janet Mills, is a Democratic politician who has been involved in policy decisions related to transgender rights and sports participation. Both figures are referenced in the text in relation to the debate over transgender athletes and policies surrounding their inclusion in women's sports.
  • A "grifter" is a term used to describe a person who engages in confid ...

Counterarguments

  • The definition of fairness in sports is complex and can include considerations of inclusivity and diversity, not just biological differences.
  • Inclusive policies may be seen as an extension of civil rights, ensuring that all individuals, including transgender athletes, have equal opportunities to participate in sports.
  • The concept of biological reality in sports is not universally agreed upon, and there is ongoing scientific debate about how to best categorize and accommodate gender diversity.
  • Some argue that the focus on transgender athletes in women's sports is disproportionate to their actual numbers and impact on sports outcomes.
  • Critics may suggest that the legislative progress Gaines refers to could be seen as discriminatory and potentially violating the rights of transgender individuals.
  • There is a perspective that faith should not dictate public policy, especially in a secular society that values the separation of church and state.
  • The idea that allowing transgender athletes to compete according to their gender identity is absu ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free

Create Summaries for anything on the web

Download the Shortform Chrome extension for your browser

Shortform Extension CTA