Podcasts > The Jordan B. Peterson Podcast > 507. Anti-Semitism and the Fall of Trudeau's Canada | Terry Glavin

507. Anti-Semitism and the Fall of Trudeau's Canada | Terry Glavin

By DailyWire+

In this episode of The Jordan B. Peterson Podcast, Terry Glavin discusses the concerning rise of antisemitism in Canada, often stemming from self-described progressive activists and influenced by anti-Zionist ideologies. The guests explore how Canada's alignment with an increasingly anti-Israel United Nations has shaped its foreign policy and permeated society under Trudeau's government.

Glavin and Peterson also examine the breakdown of Canada's traditional political system, alleging Trudeau's "post-national" vision undermined nation-building efforts. The conversation touches on issues threatening Canadian unity, including identity politics, efforts to highlight Indigenous grievances, and an immigration policy seen as fostering disunity rather than a common identity.

Listen to the original

507. Anti-Semitism and the Fall of Trudeau's Canada | Terry Glavin

This is a preview of the Shortform summary of the Dec 19, 2024 episode of the The Jordan B. Peterson Podcast

Sign up for Shortform to access the whole episode summary along with additional materials like counterarguments and context.

507. Anti-Semitism and the Fall of Trudeau's Canada | Terry Glavin

1-Page Summary

Antisemitism and anti-Zionism in Canada

Jewish Canadians are experiencing a surge in antisemitic incidents, including violent attacks, according to Glavin. This 670% increase alarms the Jewish community, who feel abandoned by the government.

Surprisingly, Glavin notes, antisemitism now stems primarily from self-described progressive activists imbued with anti-Zionist, anti-colonialist ideologies. He suggests this left-wing antisemitism arises from a victim-victimizer narrative casting Israel and Jews as oppressors.

External influence on Canadian politics

Chinese Communist Party Influence

Glavin reveals the federal Liberal government's embrace of China, citing concerns of CCP interference in Canadian elections. Figures like Dominic Barton brought pro-China experiences to Trudeau's team, while scandals around Chinese entities raised foreign influence worries.

United Nations Anti-Israel Stance

Peterson and Glavin explore how Canada's alignment with an increasingly anti-Israel UN has shaped its foreign policy. The UN's post-Soviet anti-Zionist rhetoric has permeated Canadian society and politics under Trudeau.

Breakdown of the traditional Canadian political system

Trudeau's "Post-National" Vision

Critics accuse Trudeau of rejecting traditional nation-building efforts. His reliance on consultants and multicultural vision are seen as undermining stability. High-profile resignations and near-collapses have marred his tenure.

Potential Conservative Realignment Under Poilievre

In contrast, Poilievre's populist working-class rhetoric signals a potential shift. However, Peterson cautions he may inherit dire economic issues if unable to address Trudeau-era problems quickly.

Fragmentation of Canadian national identity and unity

Canada's diversity has historically challenged unity, but Glavin and Peterson argue Trudeau's "post-national" vision further erodes a shared identity and purpose.

The rise of identity politics, like branding Canada racist and colonialist, has strained social cohesion. Glavin criticizes uncritically adopting divisive equity narratives from international bodies.

Efforts to prioritize Indigenous sovereignty and highlight grievances impact perceptions of Canadian history and legitimacy. Meanwhile, increasing religious diversity adds complexity.

Glavin sees immigration policy fostering disunity rather than the federal role of uniting the nation under a common identity.

1-Page Summary

Additional Materials

Counterarguments

  • The increase in antisemitic incidents is alarming, but it may not be accurate to attribute the rise primarily to left-wing activists without considering other sources of antisemitism, including those from right-wing extremists or other ideologies.
  • Anti-Zionism and antisemitism, while they can overlap, are not necessarily the same, and criticism of Israel's policies does not inherently equate to antisemitism.
  • Concerns about Chinese Communist Party influence in Canadian politics should be balanced with the recognition of the importance of engaging with China, one of the world's largest economies, in a nuanced and strategic manner.
  • The United Nations' stance on Israel is the result of complex international relations and may not directly influence Canadian domestic policy or society as much as suggested.
  • Trudeau's "post-national" vision could be seen as an attempt to embrace a modern, inclusive approach to nationhood that reflects the reality of a globalized world.
  • Poilievre's populist approach might resonate with certain voters, but populism can also oversimplify complex issues and may not always lead to effective governance.
  • While diversity can present challenges to national unity, it can also be a source of strength and innovation, contributing to a more dynamic and resilient society.
  • Identity politics and equity narratives can be part of a necessary conversation to address historical injustices and present inequalities within a society.
  • Prioritizing Indigenous sovereignty and addressing historical grievances can be seen as a step towards reconciliation and a more equitable society.
  • Immigration policy aimed at fostering diversity can enrich Canadian culture and society, and it is possible to maintain a common national identity that is inclusive of diverse backgrounds.

Actionables

  • You can deepen your understanding of antisemitism by reading literature from Jewish authors to gain insight into their experiences and perspectives, which can foster empathy and awareness of the challenges they face.
  • By exploring books, articles, and memoirs written by Jewish writers, you'll get a personal view of their history and struggles, helping to counteract feelings of abandonment by promoting solidarity and understanding within your community.
  • Engage in conversations with individuals from diverse backgrounds to explore the complexities of national identity and unity.
  • Initiating open dialogues with friends, colleagues, or neighbors from different cultural or political backgrounds can provide a broader perspective on what unity and national identity mean to various groups. This can help you appreciate the nuances of Canada's diversity and the impact of current policies on social cohesion.
  • Volunteer with organizations that support Indigenous communities to learn about their history and sovereignty directly from the source.
  • By working alongside Indigenous-led initiatives, you can gain firsthand knowledge of their culture, history, and the significance of sovereignty. This experience can shape a more informed view of Canadian history and contribute to a more nuanced understanding of the country's identity.

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
507. Anti-Semitism and the Fall of Trudeau's Canada | Terry Glavin

Antisemitism and anti-Zionism in Canada

Jewish Canadians feel abandoned and unsafe due to a rise in antisemitic incidents across the country

Jordan Peterson reviews Terry Glavin's article, which addresses the alarming rise of antisemitism in Canada, echoing a sentiment of fear among Jewish Canadians. They feel forsaken by a government that appears blind to their protection.

Antisemitic attacks have surged 670% since October 2021, including drive-by shootings at Jewish schools, synagogue firebombings, and attacks on Jewish businesses

Glavin reports a harrowing 670% surge in antisemitic incidents since the Simchat Torah pogrom and subsequent events in southern Israel. This includes severe cases like drive-by shootings at Jewish schools, synagogue firebombings, and smashing of Jewish business windows. Jewish Canadians report feelings of abandonment, fearing that the state is failing to keep them safe.

The growth of left-wing antisemitism poses a greater threat than traditional right-wing antisemitism

Peterson and Glavin examine how antisemitism in Canada is primarily associated with left-wing activists, departing from the historically right-wing origins of this prejudice.

Antisemitic incidents are primarily perpetrated by self-described progressive activists, recent immigrants, and those operating within an anti-Zionist, anti-colonialist ideological framework

These antisemitic acts are mostly carried out by self-proclaimed progressives and recent immigrants who view Israel and its supporters as imperialist constructs. Peterson finds it surprising that despite the left's victim-victimizer narrative, which often casts Jews in the role of oppressors, Jewish support for progressive parties remains high.

Glavin describes antisemitism as more than bigotry; it is a conspiracy theory. He suggests that those influenced by Marxist thought may conflate Jews with the international bourgeoisie, fueling anti-Semitic blame for broader societal issues. This twist in logic leads to increased accusations of Jews for societal ills.

The podcast delves into Canada's historical support of UN propositions, aligning with anti-Israel and anti-Western sentiments, thereby reflecti ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Antisemitism and anti-Zionism in Canada

Additional Materials

Counterarguments

  • Antisemitism is a complex issue that can manifest across the entire political spectrum, not exclusively within left-wing politics.
  • The rise in antisemitic incidents could be influenced by a variety of factors, including economic downturns, social unrest, or the spread of misinformation, rather than solely being attributed to left-wing ideologies.
  • Some argue that criticism of the state of Israel, or anti-Zionism, can be distinct from antisemitism and does not inherently imply hatred towards Jewish people.
  • It is possible that the perception of left-wing antisemitism being more prevalent is influenced by media coverage and reporting biases.
  • The increase in antisemitic incidents could also be a result of a rise in overall hate crimes or a more vigilant reporting system rather than a specific increase in left-wing antisemitism.
  • The characterization of recent immigrants as a group contributing to antisemitism may overlook the diversity of immigrant communities and their varied perspectives on Israel and Jewish people.
  • The claim that support for ...

Actionables

  • Educate yourself on the history and nuances of antisemitism by reading books and articles from a diverse range of perspectives to develop a well-rounded understanding of the issue.
  • Understanding the historical context and the various forms of antisemitism can help you recognize and challenge misconceptions. For example, you might read works by authors from both Jewish and non-Jewish backgrounds that discuss the evolution of antisemitic beliefs and how they manifest in different political ideologies.
  • Foster open dialogues with friends and family about the complexities of antisemitism and its impact on Jewish communities.
  • By initiating conversations in your personal circles, you can contribute to raising awareness and dispelling myths. Share personal stories or case studies that illustrate the real-world consequences of antisemitism, emphasizing the importance of empathy and solidarity with those affected.
  • Support Jewish creators, busin ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
507. Anti-Semitism and the Fall of Trudeau's Canada | Terry Glavin

External influence on Canadian politics

External forces are playing a significant role in shaping Canadian politics, with various international entities exerting influence over its federal government and policy direction.

The Chinese Communist Party has exerted significant influence over the federal Liberal government

Terry Glavin and Jordan Peterson delve into the impact of the Chinese Communist Party (CCP) on the political landscape of Canada.

The Trudeau Liberals have embraced a close relationship with China, including the appointment of pro-China figures to key positions

Glavin uncovers the deep ties between the federal Liberal government and China, pointing out the influence of pro-China figures like Dominic Barton, who before his appointment brought his experiences from China to add gravitas to Trudeau's candidacy. Justin Trudeau's campaign centered on the idea that Canada's future prosperity depended on strong ties with China. Glavin notes that Trudeau's actions, including supporting the CNOOC acquisition of Nexen, suggest an openness to collude with the CCP. These actions are set against a backdrop of accumulations of wealth and power through associations with corporations like the Demeré Corporation and Power Corporation, which are connected to China.

There are concerns about Chinese interference in Canadian elections and the manipulation of Canadian political discourse

They also discuss the scandals involving the Trudeau Liberals’ relations with entities like the United Front Work Department and the Chinese Communist Party's Organization Department. Glavin highlights concerns about election interference and manipulation during the 2019 and 2021 elections in Canada, the full scope of which is still not fully understood.

The United Nations has become increasingly dominated by anti-Israel, anti-Western sentiment

Peterson and Glavin explore how the United Nations (UN) has affected Canadian politics and foreign policy through its anti-Israel and anti-Western ideologies.

Canada's historical alignment with the UN has shaped its foreign policy in an unquestioning manner, especially under Trudeau

The dialogue implies that Canada's political left and federal liberals have followed the path of the UN, which has adopted a more anti-Israel and anti-Western stance. ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

External influence on Canadian politics

Additional Materials

Counterarguments

  • The extent of the Chinese Communist Party's influence on Canadian politics may be overstated, as Canada has its own robust democratic institutions and processes that are designed to resist undue foreign influence.
  • The appointment of individuals with experience in China could be seen as an attempt to foster better diplomatic and trade relations, rather than an indication of undue influence.
  • Allegations of election interference should be substantiated with evidence, and it is important to distinguish between influence and interference.
  • The United Nations is a complex organization with a diverse membership, and its policies and positions are the result of negotiations and compromises among member states, not the dominance of any single ideology or group.
  • Canada's foreign policy is influenced by a variety of factor ...

Actionables

- You can educate yourself on the political process by enrolling in a free online course about government structure and international relations to better understand how foreign policies are shaped and the role of international organizations.

  • By gaining a foundational knowledge of political science, you'll be better equipped to critically analyze the influence of international bodies on national policies. For example, websites like Coursera or edX offer courses taught by university professors that can provide insights into the dynamics between countries and international institutions.
  • Start a reading group focused on books about global political ideologies and their impact on local politics to foster informed discussions within your community.
  • This encourages a deeper understanding of how global ideologies can permeate local politics and societal values. You might select books that explore the history of Zionism, the evolution of the United Nations, or the rise of China as a global power, facilitating conversations on their relevance to Canadian politics.
  • Engage with your local repr ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
507. Anti-Semitism and the Fall of Trudeau's Canada | Terry Glavin

Breakdown of the traditional Canadian political system

The tenure of Justin Trudeau and the growing influence of Pierre Poilievre highlight a fundamental shift in Canadian politics from its traditional moorings toward a new, uncertain future.

The rise of the progressive left and the Trudeau Liberals has fundamentally transformed Canadian politics

Under Prime Minister Justin Trudeau’s leadership, the Canadian political system is undergoing significant changes.

Trudeau's leadership represents a rejection of traditional efforts to unite and govern Canada as a coherent nation

Trudeau is often labeled a "poster boy for progressives worldwide" and perceived as narcissistic by his critics. Filings by Peterson discuss how Trudeau’s vision for Canada is viewed as “post-national” and multicultural, with suggestions that this philosophy contributes to a fracturing of Canada's national unity.

Trudeau's reliance on management consultants and embrace of a post-national, multicultural vision for Canada have undermined the country's stability

Trudeau’s government has been regarded as unstable, especially after narrowly escaping a government collapse and experiencing the resignation of a key cabinet member, labeled a "dead man walking." Critics like Terry Glavin point out Trudeau's reliance on management consultants, such as McKinsey and Associates, to present himself as a leader. This reliance on outside advisories is seen as a divergence from conventional political practices. There are further criticisms of Trudeau's inability to work with strong-willed women in his cabinet, leading to high-profile resignations.

The Conservative opposition under Pierre Poilievre represents a potential shift away from the progressive agenda

Pierre Poilievre’s emergence in conservative politics signals a potential realignment in the approach to the nation’s governance.

Poilievre's populist, working-class appeal and rejection of Trudeau's policies suggest the potential for a major political realignment

Poilievre’s political stance has been compared to populist left-wing rhetoric, as Terry Glavin explains. Despite being from the conservative spectrum, Poilievre speaks on ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Breakdown of the traditional Canadian political system

Additional Materials

Counterarguments

  • Trudeau's leadership may be seen as an evolution rather than a rejection of traditional efforts to unite Canada, aiming to reflect the country's growing diversity.
  • Some may argue that Trudeau's global progressive image is a positive representation of Canadian values on the world stage.
  • The concept of a "post-national" Canada could be interpreted as an attempt to embrace a more inclusive identity that acknowledges the country's multicultural reality.
  • The use of management consultants like McKinsey could be defended as a means to bring in external expertise and modernize government operations.
  • The perceived instability of Trudeau's government might be viewed as a consequence of navigating complex political challenges rather than a fundamental weakness.
  • High-profile resignations in Trudeau's cabinet could be attributed to the natural turnover and internal dynamics common in any political administration.
  • Poilievre's appeal to traditionally non-conservative voters might be seen as a healthy democratic process where political parties evolve to meet the changing needs of the electorate.
  • Poilievre's adoption of issues typically associated with the left could be interpreted as ...

Actionables

  • You can deepen your understanding of political leadership styles by comparing the approaches of different leaders in your own country or others. Look at how they interact with various groups and manage national issues, then reflect on what leadership qualities you value and why. For example, observe a local politician's public addresses and policy proposals, and consider how they align with your own vision for your community.
  • Enhance your cultural awareness by exploring the concept of a "post-national" society in your local context. Engage with community members from diverse backgrounds to learn about their experiences and perspectives. You might volunteer at a cultural festival or join a language exchange meetup to gain firsthand insights into the multicultural fabric of your own community.
  • Prepare for potential political shif ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
507. Anti-Semitism and the Fall of Trudeau's Canada | Terry Glavin

Fragmentation of Canadian national identity and unity

Terry Glavin and Jordan Peterson address the fragmentation of Canadian society and the challenges to national unity, from historical grievances to current government policies.

Canada's decentralized federal system and linguistic/cultural diversity have always posed challenges to national unity

The decentralized nature of Canadian federalism and the country’s linguistic and cultural diversity have historically presented challenges to fostering a strong national identity. For example, the Quebec separatist movement remains a notable threat to Canada's territorial integrity, but Glavin and Peterson suggest that it is not the central focus at present.

Trudeau's post-national vision has further eroded a shared sense of Canadian identity and purpose

Trudeau's articulation of Canada as a post-national state with no core identity to a New York Times reporter after his election has drawn critique from Glavin and Peterson. They argue that this vision undermines the idea of a unified Canadian identity and purpose, potentially affecting national security and interests. Peterson notes that this post-national stance dispensed with what was approximated as a national identity, while Glavin criticizes Trudeau for not emphasizing the traditional role of uniting the country under a shared identity.

The rise of identity politics and competing ideological narratives have fractured Canadian society

The rise of identity politics and the portrayal of Canada as an inherently racist, colonialist state have strained social cohesion and challenged the country's historical values. Glavin and Peterson argue that Trudeau liberals are guilty of intellectual slovenliness and an uncritical adoption of ideas from international bodies like the United Nations. These include discourses on diversity, equity, and inclusion that align with anti-Semitic and anti-Zionist ideologies.

Efforts to cast Canada as an inherently racist, colonialist state have undermined social cohesion and the country's historical values

Glavin speaks about the problematic framing of Canada as a racist, colonial settler state, and the demonization of Israel as the epitome of what the progressive movement loathes. The introduction of terms like "residential schools denial" into criminal law, which aim to silence dissent, is another example of the polarizing effects of identity politics. These developments foster an atmosphere of fear and contribute to ideological fracturing within society.

The uncovering of mass graves in Kamloops and the subsequent national disc ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Fragmentation of Canadian national identity and unity

Additional Materials

Counterarguments

  • Canada's decentralized federal system and cultural diversity can be seen as a strength, promoting regional representation and protecting minority rights.
  • The Quebec separatist movement has diminished significantly in recent years, indicating a possible shift towards greater national cohesion.
  • Trudeau's post-national vision could be interpreted as an attempt to embrace Canada's multicultural reality rather than undermining national unity.
  • Identity politics can also be a means for marginalized groups to gain recognition and address historical injustices, potentially leading to a more inclusive society.
  • The adoption of ideas from international bodies may reflect a commitment to global standards of human rights and equality.
  • Acknowledging past injustices, such as racism and colonialism, can be part of a process of reconciliation and nation-building.
  • Discussing terms like "residential schools denial" can be part of a broader conversation about historical truth and reconciliation with Indigenous peoples.
  • Indigeno ...

Actionables

  • You can deepen your understanding of Canada's cultural and linguistic diversity by learning a new Canadian language, such as French or an Indigenous language. This personal endeavor not only enriches your own cultural literacy but also fosters a sense of unity through shared language skills. For example, you might start with an online course or app dedicated to language learning, setting a goal to have a basic conversation in the new language within a few months.
  • Engage in a personal project to document the stories and histories of diverse Canadian communities in your area. By interviewing neighbors, attending cultural events, or visiting local historical sites, you create a personal archive that reflects the multifaceted nature of Canadian identity. This could take the form of a blog, video diary, or even a scrapbook, highlighting the unique contributions of different groups to Canada's social fabric.
  • Volunteer with ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free

Create Summaries for anything on the web

Download the Shortform Chrome extension for your browser

Shortform Extension CTA