In this episode of The Joe Rogan Experience, Joe Rogan and guests explore the current state of combat sports, focusing on challenges in the UFC heavyweight division and the contrasting financial landscapes of MMA and boxing. The discussion examines how the shallow talent pool in heavyweight MMA affects the sport, while also addressing the impact of promoter rivalries and wealthy backers on boxing matchmaking.
The conversation delves into the physical toll of fighting careers, with insights about career longevity, retirement timing, and the difficulties fighters face when transitioning between boxing and MMA. Matt Serra shares personal experiences with post-career injuries, while the speakers also address the presence of performance-enhancing drugs in combat sports and the challenges of maintaining effective testing protocols.
Sign up for Shortform to access the whole episode summary along with additional materials like counterarguments and context.
Joe Rogan and John Rallo discuss the current challenges facing the UFC heavyweight division, noting its shallow talent pool and lack of marketable fighters. They suggest this might be due to potential athletes choosing other sports like football or basketball instead. Despite these concerns, there are promising fighters like Aspinall and Gane on the horizon. The division faces additional uncertainty regarding its champions, with questions surrounding both Francis Ngannou and Stipe Miocic's futures.
The discussion shifts to boxing's financial landscape, where Joe Rogan points out the stark contrast between superstar boxers' earnings and undercard fighters' pay. According to Rogan, the UFC maintains a more equalized pay distribution. The speakers highlight how promoter rivalries and fighters' concerns about losses often prevent exciting matchups from happening. They also note the growing influence of wealthy Saudi backers in boxing, with Rogan comparing their casual spending on the sport to ordering pizza, given their vast oil wealth.
The physical demands of MMA fighting take center stage as Matt Serra shares his personal struggles with chronic pain and multiple surgeries. Rogan and the speakers discuss how injuries can drastically shorten a fighter's prime years and impact their daily lives. The conversation explores the challenging transition from being an active fighter to retirement, with Din Thomas praising Jose Aldo's self-awareness in knowing when to step away. According to Rogan, fighters typically have about nine good years in their prime before performance decline sets in.
Rogan explains the significant hurdles boxers face when transitioning to MMA, particularly in adapting to kicks, wrestling, and grappling. The speakers reference examples like Ray Mercer and James Toney to illustrate these challenges. Matt Serra notes his preference for MMA's variety over boxing, though the conversation emphasizes the steep learning curve for boxers attempting the switch.
The episode concludes with Matt Serra and Joe Rogan examining the prevalence of performance-enhancing drugs in combat sports. They discuss the challenges of effective drug testing and how massive payouts for top fighters can incentivize PED use. Serra shares insights about blood monitoring, highlighting the complexities of maintaining adequate testing protocols.
1-Page Summary
The UFC's heavyweight division currently faces critiques about its depth and marketability, while also dealing with the uncertainty surrounding its champions.
Joe Rogan and John Rallo express concerns about the current state of the UFC heavyweight division, referring to it as "so shallow" at the moment. Rallo suggests that part of this shallow talent pool may be due to potential athletes opting for careers in football or basketball instead. Rogan echoes the sentiment, stating the division's need for "good guys," and suggesting there's a lack of talent and excitement overall.
The speakers analyze the marketability of the fighters, noting that while appearances do not always align with effectiveness, it can impact a fighter’s promotion. They point out examples of fighters who may not look the part but are nonetheless successful, drawing parallels between an unnamed but effective fighter "who looks like shit" and legendary athletes like Fedor Emelianenko in his prime and Roy Nelson, known for his knockouts despite not fitting the typical athletic aesthetic.
Despite current criticisms, there are promising fighters on the horizon poised to inject new energy into the heavyweight d ...
Current State and Dynamics of UFC Heavyweight Division
Joe Rogan and guests discuss the financial challenges and political complications that affect match-making in the sport of boxing.
Joe Rogan notes that boxing superstars like Canelo and Floyd Mayweather make a substantial amount of money compared to other fighters, particularly those on the undercard. He points out that undercard boxers earn significantly less than their superstar counterparts and even less than undercard fighters in UFC matches. Rogan suggests that the UFC's pay distribution is more equalized, creating a larger middle class of earners, as opposed to boxing, where most of the income is concentrated at the top.
In addition, Rogan expresses confusion as to why boxers like Pantoja don't get more attention, suggesting weight class plays a role in a boxer's star power. Din Thomas and John Rallo add to this by discussing how a limited number of boxers earn exceptional amounts like $25 million, while the rest are speculated to earn much less.
Rogan suggests that the structure and culture of boxing prevent many eagerly anticipated matchups from occurring, as promoters and fighters can't always agree. Rallo and Rogan touch on the impact of a loss in boxing, which can be more significant than in MMA. As a result, matchmakers might be overly cautious in arranging fights.
The importance of the promoters' priorities and the event structure contribute to the challenges of matchmaking in boxing. Rogan muses on whether Dana White's potential involvement in boxing could create changes akin to those in the UFC, possibly making matchups more appealing throughout the entire card. Thomas speculates on the idea of a boxing league where losses don't matter as much, which could prevent the fear of losing from detracting big fights.
The hosts lament the difficulty in making significant fights happen, highlighting examples like the highly anticipated but delayed match between Manny Pacquiao and Floyd Mayweather. When f ...
The Business, Politics, and Matchmaking Challenges In Boxing
Joe Rogan and various speakers including Din Thomas, John Rallo, and Matt Serra discuss the extreme physical tolls of MMA fighting, the challenge of maintaining peak performance, the difficulties in transitioning away from the sport, and the long-term health consequences fighters may face from their careers.
The physical toll on fighters is a major theme, with Joe Rogan referencing Chad Mendez’s fight at UFC 189 and Conor McGregor's grappling obstacles due to a knee injury. These injuries not only affect performance but can also shorten a fighter's prime. Rogan and other speakers, such as John Rallo, note that intense fights like those between Eddie Alvarez and Michael Chandler could take years off a fighter's life due to the severity of the beatings endured. Another unidentified speaker acknowledges the sport’s suitability for younger athletes, hinting at the inevitable wear and tear as one ages.
Matt Serra discusses how injuries, notably to the back, can drastically limit not only a fighter's career but their daily life as well, mentioning personal struggles with back pain that interfered with simple tasks like walking or brushing teeth. Rogan shares his experience with sciatica, further highlighting the commonality of back issues within the sport.
The transition from being at the height of competitive fighting to retirement is another challenge addressed. Rogan speaks of fighters having difficulty relinquishing the drive to compete, using Conor McGregor’s calmness in the octagon as an example of traits hard to leave behind. Discussing Jose Aldo, Rogan describes Aldo's decision to lay down his gloves as symbolic, potentially signaling retirement.
John Rallo talks about older fighters' decisions to move down weight classes, hinting at the complications of making career choices later in life. Even as Aldo performed impressively close to retirement, Din Thomas commends Aldo's self-awareness in determining the right time to retire, pointing out the importance of knowing when one no longer meets their own standards.
Joe Rogan touches on the struggles fighters like John Jones face with retirement, suggesting a difficulty letting go and a need to reevaluate identity and purpose during transitional periods, regardless of past achievements.
Rogan poi ...
Mma Fighters: Careers, Legacies, Physical Tolls
The conversation among Joe Rogan, Matt Serra, and other speakers dives into the complicated nature of athletes moving between the worlds of boxing and mixed martial arts (MMA), illustrating the considerable challenges and occasional successes faced when crossing disciplines.
Rogan explains that an MMA fighter must balance training in jiu-jitsu, wrestling, and boxing with elite practitioners of each to gain competency. This diverges significantly from boxers, where the skill level in pure boxing, as Rogan notes, is higher due to dedicating their entire life to perfecting that particular craft. Transitioning boxers struggle with the new set of skills needed in MMA, particularly adapting to kicks, wrestling, and grappling.
The speakers specifically mention the struggles of boxers transitioning to MMA who can't handle leg kicks – a fundamental part of MMA fighting strategy. They recall Ray Mercer's fight in an MMA setting where he appeared baffled by a head kick, showcasing his unfamiliarity with the standard techniques used in MMA.
Discussing the career choices, Rogan and Thomas highlight that few boxers have stepped into MMA, with James Toney and Ray Mercer as prime examples. The transition to MMA is seen as challenging, largely because boxers might be hesitant to risk their established careers for the unpredictable outcomes in MMA. Unlike MMA, where different types of champions can ...
The Challenges of Transitioning Between Boxing and MMA
Matt Serra and Joe Rogan delve into the issue of performance-enhancing drugs (PEDs) in combat sports, discussing the challenges and motivations behind their use in the arena.
The hosts imply fighters in less regulated promotions are continuously seeking any possible advantage, which often leads them to experiment with banned substances. Matt Serra touches on personal experiences related to blood monitoring, highlighting the lengths to which athletes may go to enhance their performance while attempting to stay within legal boundaries.
The conversation around blood tests suggests that ongoing monitoring is a critical part of effective drug testing in combat sports. However, Serra’s blood checks every six weeks indicate that adequate drug testing protocols are difficult to implement and maintain. The reality that not everyone responds to performance-enhancing substances in the same way further complicates the effectiveness of drug tests. ...
The Use of Performance-Enhancing Drugs in Combat Sports
Download the Shortform Chrome extension for your browser