#2296 - Big Jay Oakerson
This episode of The Joe Rogan Experience features a discussion with comedian Big Jay Oakerson about the changing landscape of the comedy industry. They explore the evolution of comedy, from traditional styles and venues to modern platforms like podcasts and digital distribution channels. Rogan and Oakerson examine the challenges comedians face in navigating the transition and audience expectations.
The conversation also delves into building a successful comedy career, touching on potential paths such as television deals, movies, and developing a unique voice with a loyal fanbase. Oakerson shares personal experiences and encounters in the tightly-knit comedy world, including interactions with well-known performers and industry figures. While reflecting on the unpredictable nature of the industry, the comedians emphasize maintaining perspective and embracing their individual comedic styles.
This is a preview of the Shortform summary of the Mar 28, 2025 episode of the The Joe Rogan Experience
Sign up for Shortform to access the whole episode summary along with additional materials like counterarguments and context.
1-Page Summary
Evolution and Changing Landscape of the Comedy Industry
Big Jay Oakerson and Joe Rogan discuss comedy's shift from traditional styles and venues like improv clubs to modern mediums like podcasts and digital distribution. Oakerson notes how comics once adapted to specific audiences, like wearing urban attire for the "black circuit." Rogan recalls a "comedian costume" expected for TV like wacky shirts. But now, shows like Oakerson's "Legion of Skanks" on Gas Digital reflect the growing independence.
Challenges Of Changing Industry and Audience Expectations
Rogan warns against losing creative edge by only playing to friendly crowds. Oakerson agrees on the value of diverse settings. They parallel comedy's evolution to the music industry's digital transition faced. Oakerson says patience is key as styles persist despite criticism. Rogan suggests social justice pressures in comedy have waned.
Building a Comedy Career In Entertainment
Success Through Sitcoms, Tv Deals, and Movies
Oakerson shares his manager's past advice to aim for a sitcom. Rogan says that was once the pinnacle goal, along with hosting late night TV. Rogan details his accidental acting path, while Oakerson cites doing "Z Rock."
However, they note sitcom pitfalls like network interference and advise balancing acting with stand-up. Oakerson prefers stand-up over acting roles like "Hustlers."
Developing a Unique Voice and Loyal Fanbase
Oakerson believes in staying true to one's style over chasing trends, pointing to comedians like Bargatze who succeeded that way. Rogan praises Oakerson's consistent performing to build his fanbase for "Legion of Skanks" and Skankfest.
Personal Experiences and Encounters in the Comedy World
Navigating Comedy Community Dynamics
Oakerson feels big names like Chappelle are reluctant to engage lesser-known comics. Rogan Similarly wasn't with the manager of other famous comics his level. Oakerson and Rogan discuss boundary challenges in the tight-knit industry.
Unexpected Encounters With Celebrities and Industry Figures
Oakerson recounts Rob Zombie not remembering him, contrasting Rogan's positive Axl Rose interaction. Rogan shares his sobering experience meeting a struggling Chris Farley. Oakerson talks about Jim Carrey's intense Kaufman biopic method acting.
They underline managing audience expectations, with Oakerson removing himself from some shows if he won't fit the expected style. Rogan and Oakerson emphasize perspective and humor amid the industry's unpredictable nature.
1-Page Summary
Additional Materials
Clarifications
- The "black circuit" in comedy refers to a network of venues and events that primarily cater to African American audiences. Comedians who perform on the black circuit often tailor their material to resonate with this specific demographic. It has been a significant platform for many black comedians to hone their craft and build a following within their community. This circuit has its own unique dynamics and expectations, influencing the style and content of the performances showcased within it.
- Gas Digital is a podcast network and streaming platform that hosts various shows, including "Legion of Skanks" featuring Big Jay Oakerson. It provides a platform for comedians and other content creators to produce and distribute their shows online. Gas Digital has gained popularity for its uncensored and independent approach to comedy content. The platform allows comedians like Oakerson to reach a wider audience beyond traditional media outlets.
- "Legion of Skanks" is a comedy podcast hosted by comedians Big Jay Oakerson, Luis J. Gomez, and Dave Smith. The show features uncensored and unfiltered discussions on various topics, often pushing boundaries with its humor. "Legion of Skanks" has gained a dedicated fanbase for its raw and unapologetic comedic style. The podcast is known for its live shows and events, including the annual Skankfest comedy festival.
- Social justice pressures in comedy refer to the expectations and criticisms related to how comedians address social issues, diversity, and inclusivity in their humor. Comedians may face backlash or scrutiny for jokes that are perceived as offensive, insensitive, or perpetuating stereotypes. This dynamic reflects the broader societal conversations around representation and the impact of comedy on shaping attitudes and beliefs. Balancing creative freedom with social responsibility is a key challenge for comedians navigating these evolving expectations.
- "Z Rock" is a comedy television series that aired on IFC from 2008 to 2009. The show follows the fictional band ZO2 as they try to make it big in the music industry while working as kids party entertainers. The series combines elements of scripted comedy with real-life rock stars making guest appearances. "Z Rock" explores the challenges and humor of balancing a rock 'n' roll lifestyle with more mundane gigs.
- Jim Carrey's intense Kaufman biopic method acting refers to his immersive approach to portraying comedian Andy Kaufman in the film "Man on the Moon." Carrey fully embodied Kaufman's persona both on and off set, blurring the lines between reality and performance. This method involved Carrey staying in character as Kaufman, even when the cameras were not rolling, to authentically capture Kaufman's eccentricities and mannerisms. Carrey's dedication to method acting for this role was notable for its intensity and commitment to bringing Kaufman's character to life.
Counterarguments
- While Rogan suggests that social justice pressures in comedy have waned, it could be argued that these pressures have not diminished but rather evolved, with comedians needing to be more aware of the impact of their jokes on diverse audiences.
- The idea that sitcoms and TV deals were once the pinnacle of a comedy career might overlook the fact that for some comedians, creative control and the freedom to perform their material without censorship have always been more important than mainstream success.
- The notion that staying true to one's style is crucial for success could be challenged by pointing out that adaptability and the ability to evolve one's comedic voice can also lead to longevity and relevance in a rapidly changing industry.
- The comparison of comedy's evolution to the music industry's digital transition might be oversimplified, as the two industries have unique challenges and dynamics that may not be directly comparable.
- The suggestion that big names like Chappelle are reluctant to engage with lesser-known comics could be countered by examples of established comedians who actively mentor and support up-and-coming talent.
- The advice to balance acting with stand-up might not be applicable to all comedians, as some may find greater fulfillment and success focusing exclusively on one or the other.
- The emphasis on perspective and humor amid the unpredictable nature of the comedy industry might not acknowledge the real financial and emotional struggles that comedians can face, which can't always be mitigated by a positive outlook.
Get access to the context and additional materials
Evolution and Changing Landscape of the Comedy Industry
Big Jay Oakerson and Joe Rogan dissect the comedy industry's evolution from traditional norms to modern styles and mediums, highlighting a landscape that is now drastically different from the one they entered.
Shift From Traditional to Modern Comedy Styles and Mediums
Comedy's Evolution: From Improv to Podcasts and Digital Distribution
Oakerson and Rogan reminisce about their early days and how adapting one's style and presentation to specific audiences was once a more significant part of a comedian's career. Oakerson discusses his own experience performing in the black circuit, adapting his attire to fit in by wearing FUBU and jerseys. He also touches on the expectation to adapt to a certain comedic mold to appeal to audiences, referencing his wearing of a big silver chain with a cross, despite being Jewish.
Rogan recalls a time when there was a 'comedian costume,' and parallels were drawn to acts from shows like "Evening at the Improv," where a blazer and a wacky t-shirt were worn to emphasize a comedic style conducive to getting comics into sitcoms. This expectation has shifted, with Oakerson observing the insanity of comedy's evolution. For example, "Legion of Skanks," a show created independently and distributed on the less censored platform of Gas Digital, reflects the growing independence within the industry.
Challenges Of Changing Industry and Audience Expectations
Comedians Must Adapt to Connect With Diverse Audiences
The conversation between Oakerson and Rogan indicates there has been a shift in industry standards and expectations. Comedians now present themselves in a way that resonates with a broad and diverse audience. This could also extend to their choice of venues and the variety of performances. Rogan warns of the dangers comedians face when they lose their edge by performing solely for their own crowds in theaters with a lame opening act. He suggests that comedians need to maintain a routine that includes performing in multiple settings to keep their creativity and skills sharp. Oakerson concurs, underscoring the value of this approach.
Social Media and Internet's Impact on Comedy Spread and Reception
The duo also discuss the parallel between the music industry's evolution and the transformation in the comedy sector. Just as art ...
Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary
Evolution and Changing Landscape of the Comedy Industry
Additional Materials
Counterarguments
- While the text suggests that the pressure to be "woke" in comedy has decreased, it's possible that the demand for socially conscious comedy is still significant, and that there is a substantial audience that appreciates and supports comedians who address social justice issues in their work.
- The idea that comedians must adapt to a broad and diverse audience could be challenged by the notion that niche comedy, which caters to specific audiences, is also thriving and allows comedians to build a dedicated fan base without necessarily conforming to mainstream expectations.
- The text implies that adapting to digital media is essential for success, but there may be comedians who find success through traditional mediums or live performances without a significant digital presence.
- The comparison between the spread of content on the internet and the impact of Napster and LimeWire on the music industry might overlook the unique challenges and opportunities that the comedy industry faces, which may not directly parallel those of the music industry.
- The emphasis on the need for comedians to perform i ...
Actionables
- You can explore your comedic voice by recording a daily one-minute joke or observation and sharing it on social media. This practice helps you refine your style and receive immediate feedback from a diverse audience, fostering resilience and adaptability in your humor.
- Start a virtual comedy book club with friends where each month, you focus on a different comedian's work, analyzing their approach to connecting with audiences. This will help you understand the nuances of comedic styles and the importance of persistence in finding your unique voice.
- Create a personal challenge to perform in a varie ...
Get access to the context and additional materials
Building a Comedy Career In Entertainment
In the dynamic realm of comedic entertainment, Joe Rogan and Big Jay Oakerson delve into various aspects of a comedian's journey towards success. They share insights on how comedians have adapted, balanced different opportunities, and maintained their unique voice while growing their fanbase.
Success Through Sitcoms, Tv Deals, and Movies
Securing Sitcom or Late-Night Tv Spot: Fame, Fortune, and Challenges
Oakerson's manager once advised him to create a set that could transition into a sitcom as a traditional route to success in comedy. Joe Rogan adds that in the past, a comedic act that could morph into a sitcom was central to a comedian's rise. This trajectory was reflected in the industry-wide ambition to headline a sitcom or host the Tonight Show, considered the pinnacle of success and financial reward in comedy.
Rogan shares his own accidental entry into the acting world that resulted from a chance discovery by his manager, leading to roles in "Hardball" and "News Radio" and Oakerson speaks about his experiences on the IFC show "Z Rock." However, Rogan also illustrates the potential pitfalls of sitcoms, such as network interference and long hours.
Both Rogan and Oakerson discuss the antiquated idea of chasing sitcoms and note that some comedians would boast about holding deals with networks despite their shows never coming to fruition.
Balancing Stand-Up Comedy and Acting Careers
Oakerson discusses his preference for the stand-up circuit over commercial roles and stresses the importance of maintaining ties with stand-up comedy, even when acting opportunities arise. He reflects on how some comedians have drifted from stand-up after moving to LA for acting, then struggled to return to the comedy scene.
Rogan relates to this, citing how his work on "News Radio" led him to neglect his stand-up routines. He planned to move back to New York to resume stand-up but wound up staying in LA due to his lease and inadvertently securing his role on "News Radio."
Oakerson shares his experience filming "Hustlers," highlighting the vastly different nature of a comedy set compared to a movie set. He contrasts his experiences with that of Dan Soder, who enjoys not only acting but also the processes on set. Rogan emphasizes how regular stand-up can bolster a comedian's comfort on stage in contrast to the sporadic rhythm of acting.
Developing a Unique Comedic Voice and Loyal Fanbase
The Value Of Staying True to Your Style Over Chasing Trends
Oakerson believes in staying true to his comedic voice, even when it doesn't perfectly align with shows like on the History Channel, suggesting fidelity to one's style trumps chasing trend ...
Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary
Building a Comedy Career In Entertainment
Additional Materials
Clarifications
- Joe Rogan and Big Jay Oakerson are established comedians in the entertainment industry. They have experience with sitcoms, acting, and stand-up comedy, showcasing the challenges and rewards of each avenue. Their insights emphasize the importance of maintaining a unique comedic voice and building a loyal fanbase through consistent performance and engagement.
- Transitioning from stand-up comedy to acting careers involves comedians navigating the shift from performing live on stage to acting in television shows or movies. This transition can present challenges such as balancing time between stand-up gigs and acting roles, adjusting to the different dynamics of a film or TV set compared to a comedy club, and maintaining their unique comedic voice while embodying various characters on screen. Comedians like Joe Rogan and Big Jay Oakerson have shared their experiences with this transition, highlighting the importance of staying connected to their stand-up roots even as they explore opportunities in the acting world.
- Balancing acting with stand-up comedy can be challenging as commitments to one can sometimes detract from the other, leading to difficulties in maintaining a consistent presence in both fields. Pursuing sitcoms can come with pitfalls such as network interference and demanding schedules, which may impact a comedian's ability to focus on their stand-up career. Comedians like Joe Rogan and Big Jay Oakerson have shared experiences where their acting roles inadvertently affected their stand-up routines, highlighting the delicate balance required to navigate both worlds effectively. It's essential for comedians to carefu ...
Counterarguments
- While headlining a sitcom or hosting the Tonight Show has been historically considered a pinnacle of success, the rise of digital platforms and social media has diversified what success can look like for comedians.
- The traditional route of transitioning a set into a sitcom may not be the best path for all comedians, especially those whose style may not fit the sitcom format.
- Network interference and long hours in sitcoms are not unique to comedy and can be found in many areas of the entertainment industry.
- Boasting about network deals may reflect a deeper issue within the industry, where the appearance of success is sometimes valued over actual accomplishments.
- While maintaining ties with stand-up comedy is important, some comedians have successfully transitioned to full-time acting or other entertainment roles without returning to stand-up.
- The idea that regular stand-up enhances comfort on stage more than acting assumes that the skills are directly transferable and undervalues the unique challenges and skills developed through acting.
- Staying true to one's comedic voice is important, but adaptability and evolution in response to changing times and audiences can also be a key to longevity and relevance in the industry.
- Continuous touring and never stepping away from stand-up could lead to burnout ...
Get access to the context and additional materials
Personal Experiences and Encounters in the Comedy World
Big Jay Oakerson and Joe Rogan share insights and anecdotes about the unique dynamics of the comedy scene, interactions with high-profile performers, and the difficulties of comedic growth in a rapidly changing environment.
Navigating Comedy Community Dynamics
Discussions centered on the comedy community dynamics often reveal the subtle challenges and social navigation required by comedians as they interact with audiences and each other.
Famous Comedians' Reluctance to Engage With Lesser-Known Performers
Oakerson highlights the hesitance he observes with high-profile comedians like Dave Chappelle and Chris Rock, noting that despite meeting them multiple times, they still seem unfamiliar with him. He feels this reflects a broader trend of established comedians possibly being reluctant to engage with up-and-coming performers. This was also touched upon by Joe Rogan, who mentions being with the same manager since his early days and not a client of Barry Katz—a well-known figure who managed multiple other comedians who frequently worked at a particular comedy club.
Challenges Of Maintaining Relationships and Boundaries In a Tight-Knit Industry
Oakerson and Rogan discuss the pitfalls of navigating a tight-knit industry where maintaining relationships and boundaries can be tricky, especially for newer comics who might invite experienced comedians like Oakerson to their shows, unintentionally highlighting the disparities in how performers are valued at different stages of their careers.
Unexpected Encounters With Celebrities and Industry Figures
The conversation between Oakerson and Rogan often veers towards their various run-ins with other celebrities and the diverse scenarios that arise from these interactions, ranging from awkward encounters to heartening anecdotes.
Surprising Interactions With High-Profile Individuals: Pleasant Surprises to Awkward Moments
Oakerson notes that despite touring with Rob Zombie, Zombie does not seem to remember him, and recounts a time when his group couldn’t get into a Zombie movie despite having passes. In another vein, Rogan recounts a positive interaction with Axl Rose who recognized him and invited him to a Guns N' Roses concert, contrasting sharply with Oakerson's awkward attempt to engage with Jennifer Lopez during a performance.
Keeping Perspective and Humor In Entertainment
Discussions around experiences with celebrities often reveal underlyi ...
Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary
Personal Experiences and Encounters in the Comedy World
Additional Materials
Clarifications
- Barry Katz is a prominent figure in the comedy industry known for managing and representing various successful comedians. He has worked with a wide range of comedians, helping to shape their careers and secure opportunities in the entertainment world. Katz's influence extends to comedy clubs and industry connections, making him a significant player in the development and promotion of comedic talent. His managerial expertise and industry relationships have contributed to the success of many comedians under his guidance.
- In the comedy world, different comedy clubs have their own unique audiences and preferences for comedic styles. Comedians often tailor their performances to suit the expectations and tastes of the specific audience at a particular club. Understanding the audience's preferences and adjusting one's material accordingly can greatly impact a comedian's success and reception at a comedy club. Comedians may choose to opt out of certain shows if they feel their comedic style doesn't align well with the audience's expectations.
- Setting the price for comedy shows can be challenging as it involves determining how much audiences are willing to pay based on the perceived value of the comedians performing. Established comedians with a strong reputation and fan base often command higher ticket prices due to their track record and popularity. In contrast, newer or lesser-known comedians may struggle to justify higher prices as audiences may not be as familiar with their work or comedic style. This disparity in perceived value can influence how comedians navigate pricing their shows to attract audiences while also reflecting their standing in the comedy industr ...
Get access to the context and additional materials
Create Summaries for anything on the web
Download the Shortform Chrome extension for your browser
