Balds Don't Lie: Tart/Becton latest, Sheldon Rankins interview, free agency lessons with Mo Egger
On The Growler podcast, discussions cover Ted Karras' inspiring fundraising efforts for his foundation, the Cincinnati Bengals' conservative approach to free agency, and lingering questions about their defensive tackle and right tackle positions. In addition, the podcast evaluates the Bengals' need for successful offensive line draft picks to retain offensive stars long-term.
The episode also delves into speculation surrounding the role of 2022 first-round pick Dax Hill. With minimal impact as a rookie safety and the signings of Vonn Bell and Geno Stone, the podcast explores the possibility of Hill moving to slot corner or being traded.
This is a preview of the Shortform summary of the Mar 18, 2024 episode of the The Growler
Sign up for Shortform to access the whole episode summary along with additional materials like counterarguments and context.
1-Page Summary
Ted Karras' Community Impact and Fundraising Efforts
Ted Karras has mobilized thousands to support his foundation's causes, as evidenced by the overwhelming turnout and tattoo endorsements at his St. Taddy's Day event. According to Paul Dehner Jr., Karras has sparked conversation about the village of Murci through apparel sales, raising significant funds through these initiatives. Quarterback Joe Burrow even donated $25,000 to Karras' foundation at a free-agent dinner, highlighting the team's camaraderie and charitable spirit.
Bengals Free Agency Approach
The Cincinnati Bengals have adopted a more conservative, value-driven approach to free agency this year. Dehner Jr. notes the lack of splashy signings, with the team focusing on potentially beneficial pickups like Geno Stone and Zach Moss instead.
Bengals Still Have Questions at Defensive Tackle and Right Tackle
Defensive tackle
Sheldon Rankins admits needing to improve as a run defender to fill the void left by DJ Reader's departure. While offering pass-rush skills, Rankins recognizes the need for more run-stopping presence. The Bengals are considering draft options and Rankins' versatility to address this need.
Right tackle
With Jonah Williams gone, the Bengals are weighing stopgap veteran options like Mekhi Becton to buy time for developing rookies into the role, according to Paul Dehner Jr.
Future Importance of Hitting on Offensive Line Draft Picks
The Bengals must excel at drafting and developing offensive linemen to retain their offensive stars long-term, having struggled in this area recently.
Intrigue Around Dax Hill's Role
Despite being a 2022 first-round pick expected to start at safety, Dax Hill made minimal impact as a rookie while appearing frustrated with his role. With Vonn Bell re-signed and Geno Stone added, speculation surrounds Hill potentially moving to slot corner or being traded, as Egger notes.
1-Page Summary
Additional Materials
Clarifications
- DJ Reader's departure from the Cincinnati Bengals created a gap at the defensive tackle position. Reader was a key player known for his ability to stop the run effectively. His absence left a significant role to be filled in the Bengals' defensive line.
- Dax Hill, a 2022 first-round pick for the Bengals, had a limited impact in his rookie season. Speculation has arisen about his future role due to his dissatisfaction and the team's recent signings at his position. There are discussions about potentially moving him to play as a slot cornerback or exploring trade options to maximize his potential impact on the team.
Counterarguments
- While Ted Karras' fundraising efforts are commendable, it's important to ensure that the funds are used effectively and transparently for the intended causes.
- Joe Burrow's donation, while generous, should not overshadow the need for a collective team effort in charitable endeavors.
- A conservative approach to free agency by the Bengals could be seen as a lack of ambition to strengthen the team aggressively, potentially missing out on key talent.
- Focusing on pickups like Geno Stone and Zach Moss may not address all the team's needs or match the impact of more established players.
- Sheldon Rankins' acknowledgment of the need to improve as a run defender is a step in the right direction, but it may not be sufficient to compensate for the loss of DJ Reader.
- Considering draft options to address the defensive tackle need is a long-term strategy that might not provide immediate results for the Bengals.
- Exploring stopgap veteran options for the right tackle position could be a short-sighted solution that may not offer stability to the offensive line.
- Excelling at drafting and developing offensive linemen is crucial, but the Bengals must also ensure they have the right coaching and development programs in place to maximize player potential.
- Dax Hill's potential move to slot corner or being traded might not be the best use of his talents, and it could be more beneficial to find ways to utilize his skills within the safety position.
Related Shortform Content
Get access to the context and additional materials
Ted Karras' Community Impact and Fundraising Efforts
Ted Karras has significant influence and has been successful in his recent fundraising efforts, which have engaged the community and attracted substantial donations, including a notable contribution from Joe Burrow.
Karras mobilizing thousands to support his foundation and raising significant funds
At the St. Taddy's Day event hosted by Ted Karras, the community displayed overwhelming support. Thousands gathered at the Fowling Warehouse, and every major sponsor in the city was present. To demonstrate their support, many attendees received tattoos featuring Ted Karras' Cincy Hat logo. This mobilization served as a testament to the positive impact sports figures can have within their communities.
Karras, who was nominated as the Bengals Walter Payton Man of the Year and won the online challenge, has sparked considerable conversation about the village of Murci through the sales of hats. His ability to engage and mobilize the public for his foundation's cause has been admired by many.
During his event, it was remarkable to see not only the turnout but also how many people chose to get the Cincy logo tattooed on their bodies. Through the sales of various items, significant funds were raised to support his foundation's initiatives. ...
Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary
Ted Karras' Community Impact and Fundraising Efforts
Additional Materials
Clarifications
- The St. Taddy's Day event hosted by Ted Karras was a significant gathering that showcased community support for his foundation. It attracted thousands of attendees and major sponsors, emphasizing the impact of sports figures in their communities. The event featured the sale of items like hats with Karras' logo, which helped raise substantial funds for his foundation's initiatives. The turnout and engagement at the event highlighted the community's enthusiasm and backing for Karras' philanthropic efforts.
- The Walter Payton NFL Man of the Year Award is given annually to recognize an NFL player's outstanding community service activities, as well as excellence on the field. Nominees are selected by each team for their philanthropic efforts and positive impact on society. Being nominated for this prestigious award highlights a player's commitment to making a difference off the field.
- The playful challenge involving Karras getting a tattoo was a part of a ...
Counterarguments
- While Ted Karras has been successful in his fundraising efforts, it's important to consider whether the funds are being allocated and used in the most effective way possible to benefit the intended causes.
- The act of getting tattoos to show support for a cause may raise concerns about impulsivity and the permanence of such a decision, especially if it becomes a trend driven by the moment rather than long-term commitment to the cause.
- The nomination of Karras as the Bengals Walter Payton Man of the Year and winning an online challenge is commendable, but it's worth noting that such accolades are not the sole indicators of community impact and should be complemented by ongoing, tangible community work.
- The conversation sparked by Karras about the village of Murci through hat sales is positive, but it's essential to ensure that the conversation translates into meaningful action and long-term benefits for the community.
- The significant funds raised are a positive outcome, but transparency and accountability in how those funds are managed and distributed are crucial to maintain public trust and ensure the foundation's integrity.
- Joe Burrow's donation is generous, but it's important to recognize that individual don ...
Related Shortform Content
Get access to the context and additional materials
Bengals Free Agency Approach
The Cincinnati Bengals have taken a different route in free agency this year, opting for a more conservative and strategic method.
More calculated and conservative compared to big spending last year
Paul Dehner Jr. illustrates that the Bengals’ free agency approach this season is less about making the big splashes seen in previous years. He suggests that the team is operating under the radar, and Mo Egger agrees, noting the absence of any splashy moment or signing.
Focus on value signings that could pay dividends
The Bengals are concentrating on attainable signings that promise to yield benefits in the future.
Geno Stone
The signing of Geno Stone serves as an embodiment of their value-driven strategy. Paul Dehner Jr. considers this pickup as potentially astute and one that might look smart come the fall. Mo Egger sings Stone's praises, citing his improved performance the more responsibility he’s given—a trait likely honed during his time in Baltimore. Stone was also present at the free agent dinner alongside Joe Burrow and Ted Karras, indicating his importance within the team's consideration.
Zach Moss
Similarly, Dehner Jr. refers to the acquisition of Zach Moss as ...
Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary
Bengals Free Agency Approach
Additional Materials
Clarifications
...
Counterarguments
- While focusing on value signings can be beneficial, it may also mean the Bengals are missing out on top-tier talent that could make an immediate and significant impact on the team.
- A conservative approach in free agency could be perceived as a lack of ambition or willingness to invest in the team's immediate success, potentially frustrating fans who want to see a more aggressive pursuit of improvement.
- Depending on value signings to pay dividends in the future is inherently risky, as it assumes that these players will develop as expected, which is not always the case.
- The strategy of not making splashy signings assumes that last year's big investments were not effective or necessary, which may not be true; those signings could have contributed significantly to the team's performance.
- Building depth is important, but if the Bengals have specific areas of weakness, not addressing them with high-quality signings could be detrimental to their overall competi ...
Related Shortform Content
Get access to the context and additional materials
Bengals Still Have Questions at Defensive Tackle and Right Tackle
The Cincinnati Bengals are in a period of transition as they look to bolster their defensive line and tackle positions with the departure of key players, targeted signings, and considering future draft picks.
Defensive tackle
Lost standout DJ Reader in free agency
Mo Egger emphasizes the significant impact of losing DJ Reader in free agency, a setback for the team’s defensive strength. Sheldon Rankins, the new Bengals player, acknowledged his expectation of Reader's return due to his strong performance and was surprised by his departure.
Signed Sheldon Rankins but still needs more run stopping
Sheldon Rankins admits that there have been times when he's been "really beat up," including two Achilles surgeries within a year. With better health recently, he’s focused on refining his techniques and contributing more dominantly, especially in run defense. Rankins specifically mentions wanting to grow as a run defender by improving leverage, hand use, and finding more efficient ways to win one-on-ones, suggesting his readiness to take on Reader's responsibilities in run defense. However, there is an acknowledgment that while Rankins brings notable pass-rush skills and run-stopping efforts from his time with previous teams, there remains a need for more run-stopping presence to fulfill the Bengals’ defensive strategy.
Could find answers in draft and with Rankins' versatility
The possibility of Rankins' versatility offering a part of the solution for the defensive tackle dilemma is highlighted. Additionally, the Bengals are considering their options in the draft to identify players who can balance the skill sets of DJ Reader and Josh Tupou, aiming to enhance their run defense.
Right tackle
Did not retain former first rounder Jonah Williams
The Bengals have decided not to keep Jonah Williams, their former first-rounder, leaving questions about who will fill the role at ...
Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary
Bengals Still Have Questions at Defensive Tackle and Right Tackle
Additional Materials
Clarifications
- DJ Reader was a standout defensive tackle for the Cincinnati Bengals. His departure in free agency was seen as a significant loss for the team's defensive strength. Sheldon Rankins, a new addition to the Bengals, expressed surprise at Reader's departure and aims to step up in his absence.
- Sheldon Rankins has faced significant injury challenges, including two Achilles surgeries within a year. Despite these setbacks, he is now focused on improving his techniques and performance, particularly in run defense. The injuries have not only tested his physical resilience but also shaped his determination to contribute effectively to the Bengals' defensive line. His recent focus on health and skill development indicates his commitment to overcoming past injury obstacles.
- Defensive tackles in football are key players on the defensive line responsible for stopping the run and pressuring the quarterback. They need to be strong, agile, and have good technique to shed blocks and disrupt plays. In run defense, they aim to clog running lanes and tackle ball carriers. In pass-rushing situations, they try to penetrate the offensive line to sack the quarterback or disrupt passing plays.
- Run-stopping in football defense is crucial for preventing the opposing team from gaining significant yardage on running plays. It involves defenders effectively tackling or disrupting the ball carrier to halt their progress. Strong run-stopping can force the offense into unfavorable down-and-distance situations, increasing the likelihood of a defensive stop. It is a fundamental aspect of a well-rounded defense, complementing pass cov ...
Counterarguments
- The loss of DJ Reader may not be as impactful if the Bengals' defensive scheme is adaptable and other players step up to fill the void.
- Signing Sheldon Rankins is a positive move, but relying on one player to replace Reader's production could be seen as putting too much pressure on Rankins, especially given his injury history.
- While Rankins is focused on improving his run defense, it's uncertain whether he can match Reader's level of play in that area.
- The Bengals' need for more run-stopping presence might be overstated if the team can improve their linebacker play or overall defensive scheme.
- Rankins' versatility is beneficial, but it may not be a complete solution if the team lacks depth at the defensive tackle position.
- Drafting to enhance run defense is a sound strategy, but rookies often have a learning curve and may not contribute immediately.
- Not retaining Jonah Williams could be a strategic decision if the Bengals believe they can find a better fi ...
Related Shortform Content
Get access to the context and additional materials
Future Importance of Hitting on Offensive Line Draft Picks
The discussion underscores the significance of the Cincinnati Bengals' need to excel in selecting offensive line prospects in the NFL draft. This strategic move is essential to foster a robust team for upcoming seasons and to guarantee the retention of the team's offensive stars.
Struggled to draft and develop linemen recently
The Bengals have faced recent challenges in drafting and cultivating talent along the offensive line. Correcting this trajectory is a critical component of their team-building strategy.
Must build pipeline for future to retain offense stars
The success of incoming draft picks, specifically at pivotal positions like right tackle, is consid ...
Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary
Future Importance of Hitting on Offensive Line Draft Picks
Additional Materials
Clarifications
- The right tackle position in football is crucial as it typically protects the quarterback's blind side, especially in passing situations. Right tackles are responsible for blocking defensive players to create openings for the offense to advance the ball. They play a significant role in both pass protection and run blocking schemes. A skilled right tackle can greatly impact the team's offensive success by providing stability and protection on the field.
- Building a pipeline of offensive linemen in NFL team-building involves consistently drafting and developing young players for these positions to ensure a steady supply of talent for the team. This strategy is crucial because offensive linemen play a vital role in protecting the quarterback and creating opportunities for the offense to succeed. By investing ...
Counterarguments
- While drafting offensive linemen is important, it is not the only factor in building a robust team; other positions and strategies also play critical roles.
- The retention of offensive stars may depend on factors beyond just the offensive line, such as salary cap management, player health, and individual career decisions.
- Recent struggles in drafting and developing linemen do not necessarily predict future outcomes; with changes in scouting, coaching, or management, the Bengals could improve in this area.
- A focus on drafting offensive linemen could lead to neglecting other areas of need on the team, potentially creating imbalances in the roster.
- The success of the team's offense is not solely reliant on the offensive line; skill positions, coaching strategies, and defensive performance are also vital components.
- The long-term preservation of key players is influenced by a variety of factors, including the team's overall success, the competitive market for players, and the individual aspirations of the players themselves.
- Drafting well at pivotal positions like right tackle is important, but developing and ...
Related Shortform Content
Get access to the context and additional materials
Intrigue Around Dax Hill's Role
As the Cincinnati Bengals navigate their roster configuration, considerable attention is paid to the role of Dax Hill, their recent first-round pick.
First round pick last year expected to start at safety
Last season, expectations were high for Dax Hill, a first-round pick who was anticipated to start at safety for the Bengals. However, the season unfolded with less impact from Hill than many had hoped for.
Made minimal impact as a rookie
Struggled on defense
Notably, Dax Hill struggled on defense and didn't have the substantial effect on the field that was expected of him in his rookie year. Egger highlights Hill's minimal impact and notes his apparent frustration with the role he was given.
Frustrated with role
As a first-round pick, Dax Hill had a challenging first year, characterized by his frustration over limited playtime and having to learn a variety of positions behind the scenes. This frustration was compounded by the Bengals' moves in the offseason.
Team instead re-signed starter Vonn Bell and signed standout Geno Stone
Rather than solidifying Hill's starting position at safety, the Bengals re-signed Vonn Bell, their seasoned starter, and brought on Geno Stone, a noticeable defensive talent. These moves have intensifi ...
Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary
Intrigue Around Dax Hill's Role
Additional Materials
Clarifications
- A slot corner in football is a defensive back position that typically covers the receiver who lines up in the "slot," which is the area between the offensive tackle and the wide receiver. Slot corners need to be versatile, as they often face quicker and shiftier receivers who run routes closer to the line of scrimmage. They require strong coverage skills and the ability to defend against both the pass and the run effectively. Moving Dax Hill to slot corner would involve shifting his position on the field to cover these specific responsibilities.
- Vonn Bell is an American football safety who currently plays for the Cincinnati Bengals in the NFL. He previously played college football at Ohio State and was drafted by the New Orleans Saints in 2016. Bell is known for his skills as a defensive player and has ...
Counterarguments
- Dax Hill's minimal impact could be due to the typical adjustment period rookies face when transitioning to the NFL, rather than a lack of talent or effort.
- Struggling on defense in the first year doesn't necessarily predict future performance; many players improve significantly with more experience.
- Frustration with a role can be a sign of a competitive spirit and a desire to contribute more significantly, which could be positive if channeled correctly.
- The decision to re-sign Vonn Bell and sign Geno Stone might be part of a broader strategy to bolster the team's defense, rather than a reflection on Hill's abilities.
- The possibility of Hill moving to slot corner could be an opportunity for him to showcase versatility and find success in a different positio ...
Related Shortform Content
Get access to the context and additional materials
Create Summaries for anything on the web
Download the Shortform Chrome extension for your browser
