Podcasts > The Diary Of A CEO with Steven Bartlett > THE FEMINISM DEBATE: Is Feminism Betraying Women? The Hidden Risk Of Casual Sex!

THE FEMINISM DEBATE: Is Feminism Betraying Women? The Hidden Risk Of Casual Sex!

By Steven Bartlett

In this episode of The Diary Of A CEO, Steven Bartlett explores the impacts of sexual liberation and technological advances on modern relationships, gender dynamics, and family structures. The discussion examines how birth control and shifting cultural values have influenced women's roles in society, while also addressing the challenges young men face in education and employment.

The conversation delves into debates around feminism's interaction with capitalism, particularly regarding work-life balance and caregiving roles. The speakers address the effects of modern pornography on intimate relationships, consider the biological differences between men and women in nurturing contexts, and examine how current policies and social structures shape relationships between genders. The discussion includes multiple perspectives on these societal changes, from celebrating increased freedoms to questioning their broader implications.

THE FEMINISM DEBATE: Is Feminism Betraying Women? The Hidden Risk Of Casual Sex!

This is a preview of the Shortform summary of the Jun 19, 2025 episode of the The Diary Of A CEO with Steven Bartlett

Sign up for Shortform to access the whole episode summary along with additional materials like counterarguments and context.

THE FEMINISM DEBATE: Is Feminism Betraying Women? The Hidden Risk Of Casual Sex!

1-Page Summary

Impact of the Sexual Revolution on Women's Autonomy, Relationships, Family Life

Louise Perry discusses how technological advancements like the washing machine and the birth control pill revolutionized women's roles in society. While Deborah France-White celebrates these changes for offering women greater freedom, Perry notes they represent a broader cultural shift away from traditional values.

The revolution has led to increased acceptance of casual sex, though this comes with complications. Erika Komisar points out that many young women experience depression and anxiety after casual sexual encounters, while Perry explains that college campus dynamics often favor men's sexual preferences. France-White advocates for sexual freedom, but Komisar emphasizes the importance of emotional connections and family building in sex education.

Changing Dynamics, Masculinity, and Challenges Facing Young Men

Perry argues that modern society isn't effectively channeling young men's energy into productive roles. Komisar and France-White discuss how men feel marginalized, particularly in education where women now make up 60% of college students. The "manosphere" has emerged as a reaction to these changes, though Perry attributes this more to economic changes that have devalued traditionally male jobs.

Komisar explains that biological differences between men and women affect their responses to nurturing, with boys being neurologically more fragile and sensitive to stress. While France-White advocates for shared values in education, Komisar suggests that separate educational structures might better serve each gender's unique needs.

Feminism, Capitalism, and Policy In Shaping Societal Norms

Perry and Komisar discuss how some feminist ideologies may have inadvertently pressured women to adopt masculine models of success, potentially devaluing caregiving roles. Komisar suggests that some women feel pressured by feminist narratives to pursue lifestyles that don't bring them happiness.

The speakers criticize how capitalist systems exploit women's workforce participation while neglecting family structures. Perry specifically challenges government policies that exclusively support daycare, arguing they limit women's choices. Both Perry and France-White advocate for more comprehensive support measures that validate unpaid caregiving work.

The Influence of Pornography on Intimacy and Relationships

Perry describes modern pornography as a "super stimulus" that can lead to dissatisfaction with normal sexual encounters and has been linked to erectile dysfunction. Komisar notes the evolution from less harmful two-dimensional pornography to more addictive modern video formats.

The debate over pornography regulation reveals complex ethical considerations. Perry argues that the porn industry is fundamentally unethical, citing high suicide rates among performers. While France-White advocates for regulatory discussions, particularly regarding violent content, Perry takes a stronger stance, suggesting that given the chance, she would end pornography completely.

1-Page Summary

Additional Materials

Counterarguments

  • While technological advancements have changed women's roles, some argue that these changes have not necessarily led to greater autonomy but have instead increased the pressure on women to perform both in the workforce and at home.
  • The increased acceptance of casual sex may also be seen as a reflection of individual freedom and agency, with some arguing that it can be empowering when engaged in consensually and safely.
  • The link between casual sex and mental health issues like depression and anxiety is complex and may not be directly causal; other factors such as societal stigma and personal expectations can also play significant roles.
  • The dynamics on college campuses are diverse, and while some may favor men's sexual preferences, others are actively working towards more equitable sexual norms and consent cultures.
  • The idea that modern society isn't effectively channeling young men's energy could be countered by pointing to various successful youth engagement and mentorship programs that focus on positive development for young men.
  • The marginalization of men in education could be challenged by highlighting the success of many men in higher education and professional fields, and by noting that educational attainment does not necessarily equate to marginalization.
  • The emergence of the "manosphere" can be critiqued as not solely a reaction to economic changes but also as a response to evolving gender norms and the challenge to traditional male privilege.
  • While there are biological differences between men and women, it is argued that socialization plays a significant role in nurturing responses, and that both genders can be equally responsive to nurturing with the right support.
  • The suggestion for separate educational structures for different genders can be criticized for potentially reinforcing gender stereotypes and not addressing the root causes of educational disparities.
  • Some feminist ideologies emphasize the value of caregiving roles and seek to redefine success to include diverse life choices beyond traditional masculine models.
  • The pressure women may feel to pursue certain lifestyles can also be seen as a broader societal issue, not limited to feminist narratives, and one that affects all genders.
  • Capitalist systems can be defended by arguing that they provide opportunities for women to achieve financial independence and success, and that the issue lies more with societal values than with capitalism itself.
  • Government policies supporting daycare can be seen as providing essential support for working families, and the argument for more comprehensive support measures can be seen as an addition to, rather than a replacement for, existing policies.
  • The effects of modern pornography are debated, with some arguing that it can be consumed responsibly without negative impacts on intimacy or relationships.
  • The ethical considerations of the porn industry are complex, and some argue that the focus should be on improving industry standards and worker protections rather than on banning pornography outright.
  • Discussions on regulating pornography can also include the perspective that adult individuals should have the freedom to choose what they consume, as long as it is legal and consensual.

Actionables

  • You can create a personal reflection journal to explore how societal changes have impacted your views on gender roles and sexual behavior. Start by writing down your thoughts on how technology has influenced gender dynamics in your life. Reflect on your attitudes towards casual sex and how they align with your emotional well-being. Consider the pressures you may feel to conform to certain gender expectations and how they affect your happiness. This practice can help you understand your values and make more informed choices that align with your personal fulfillment.
  • Develop a mentorship program at your workplace that focuses on channeling young men's energy into productive roles. Identify male colleagues who may feel marginalized and pair them with mentors who can provide guidance on career development, education, and personal growth. This initiative can help create a supportive environment that recognizes the unique challenges men face and promotes their engagement in positive and constructive ways.
  • Advocate for comprehensive support measures in your community that validate unpaid caregiving work. Start by organizing a local group of caregivers to discuss the challenges and rewards of their roles. Together, you can draft proposals for local government policies that recognize and support unpaid caregiving, such as tax credits, respite care programs, or community recognition events. By taking action, you contribute to a societal shift that values all forms of work, including the often-invisible labor of caregiving.

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
THE FEMINISM DEBATE: Is Feminism Betraying Women? The Hidden Risk Of Casual Sex!

Impact of the Sexual Revolution on Women's Autonomy, Relationships, Family Life

Sexual Revolution Empowered Women's Reproductive Choices and Workforce Equality

Freedom's Consequences Heighten Emotional Distress in Young Women

Louise Perry discusses the transformative social impact of the sexual revolution, particularly through technological advancements like the washing machine and inventions like the pill, which created an illusion of consequence-free sex. The pill, safe abortion access, and the decriminalization of abortion, Perry notes, have revolutionized women's roles in society. Domestic technologies decreased the time required to run a home, facilitating women's foray into the labor force.

Deborah France-White champions the sexual revolution for offering women emotional and reproductive freedom, citing new choices in life beyond the expectations of settling down with a partner. She sees the advent of the pill and increased sexual autonomy as enabling women to explore multiple partnerships and their sexuality. At the same time, Louise Perry suggests the revolution brought a broader cultural shift away from traditional Christian views on sex.

Sexual Revolution Shifted Norms, Increasing Acceptance of Casual Sex and Non-traditional Relationships

Disproportionate Impact on Women in Hookup Culture

Steven Bartlett observes that societal acceptance of casual sex has surged since 1999. Deborah France-White values play in relationships, evidenced by her festival experience that embraced casual sex. However, Erika Komisar provides a counterpoint, highlighting the emotional toll the hookup culture can have, with many young women experiencing depression and anxiety post-casual sexual encounters. She critiques apps like Tinder that normalize transient sexual experiences, potentially resulting in emotional and physical danger.

Louise Perry states that the structure of college campuses can influence sexual culture, with a surplus of women leading to more prevalent hookup culture. She argues this culture favors men's preferences for multiple sexual partners and can lead to women navigating a tightrope of avoiding slut-shaming while not being considered frigid.

Sexual Freedom Emphasis Can Overshadow Women's Emotional and Relational Needs For Starting Families

Many Women Aspire To Traditional Caregiver Roles Despite Societal Shift

Every woman should want free sex and yet 82% of young women are depressed and anxious after casual sexual encounters. Each woman should want to go out to work and leave their Children in daycare, but we are doing terrible damage to our children by putting them in daycare.

Louise Perry and Erika Komisar offer nuanced views on the sexual revolution. While acknowledging its benefits, they also consider its potential negative impact on emotional and relational needs. France-White speaks to the struggle for emotional balance, suggesting ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Impact of the Sexual Revolution on Women's Autonomy, Relationships, Family Life

Additional Materials

Counterarguments

  • The empowerment of women through the sexual revolution is not universally seen as positive; some argue that it has led to the commodification of sex and the body, which can be detrimental to women's self-esteem and societal value.
  • The cultural shift away from traditional Christian views on sex is not universally accepted as positive; some argue that these traditional values provide structure and meaning that are beneficial to individuals and society.
  • The increase in acceptance of casual sex may not necessarily be disproportionately impacting women; some argue that men also experience emotional distress related to casual sexual encounters.
  • The notion that the structure of college campuses favors men's preferences for multiple sexual partners can be challenged by the argument that women also have agency in their sexual choices and may also prefer non-monogamous arrangements.
  • The aspiration for traditional caregiver roles among many women could be seen as a result of societal pressure rather than genuine desire, and some argue that more women might choose different paths if there were no societal expectations.
  • The idea that modern sex education overlooks emotional connections and family building can be countered by pointing out that many sex education programs do address these topics, though perhaps not to the extent some would prefer.
  • The importance of a primary attachment figure in early childhood ...

Actionables

  • You can create a personal values chart to clarify your stance on relationships and family roles. Start by listing values that are important to you, such as emotional connection, family, career, and independence. Rate each value on a scale from 1 to 10 based on its importance to you. This exercise helps you understand your priorities and can guide your decisions in relationships and career paths, ensuring they align with your core values.
  • Develop a family-oriented book club with friends or community members to explore themes of caregiving and emotional bonds. Choose books that delve into the complexities of modern relationships, the role of caregivers, and the impact of societal changes on family dynamics. Discussing these topics in a group setting can provide diverse perspectives and support as you navigate your own life choices.
  • Volunteer for a mentorship program that supports you ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
THE FEMINISM DEBATE: Is Feminism Betraying Women? The Hidden Risk Of Casual Sex!

Changing Dynamics, Masculinity, and Challenges Facing Young Men

Louise Perry and guests on the panel discuss the complexities of masculinity and the challenges that young men face today in light of societal changes and biological differences.

Impact of Sexual Revolution: Men Feel Marginalized, Uncertain of Role

Louise Perry suggests that it's crucial for society to channel young men's energy into pro-social behaviors, as modern society isn't doing a great job at this. She contends that, while porn and video games have pacified men, making them less dangerous, their talents are not being well utilized, and they are not encouraged to become good husbands and fathers. Instead, society should encourage men to embrace "Dad Mode", aspiring to be providers and protectors.

Erika Komisar and Deborah France-White discuss the fear and powerlessness that young men experience in society's current climate. They mention the imbalance in society, where women now dominate over men, reflected in education with 60% of college and graduate students being women, leading to young men feeling marginalized.

Komisar highlights that men feel threatened by women's power over them, especially with the possibility of being accused within universities. Perry discusses the economic devaluation of men, which contributes to a sense of inadequacy among men who can't fulfill traditional provider roles. Women, on the other hand, feel resentful because fewer men can step up and care for a family.

France-White addresses the rise of messaging to young men that women are taking their place, causing them to feel lost. She argues that nurturing young boys is the solution, rather than asking girls to step back.

"Manosphere" Rise: Anti-Feminist, Misogynistic Ideologies React To Loss of Traditional Masculine Power

France-White comments on the concept of being a "high value woman," an idea stemming from anti-feminist ideologies in the manosphere, affecting both women's self-perception and men's perception of their roles. The term "manosphere" has been at the forefront of the conversation, as a reaction against changing gender dynamics and the perceived loss of traditional masculine power. Perry attributes the rise of the manosphere more to technological and economic changes that have devalued traditionally male jobs.

The Centre for Social Justice's report "Lost Boys" indicates that young men in the UK struggle in school and with mental health, lacking positive role models, leading them to the manosphere. This rise in male mental health issues, along with educational and employment setbacks, could be a contributing factor to the manosphere's growth.

The manosphere desires the privileges of masculinity without its responsibilities. Perry points out that gender roles come with both, such as men potentially dying for their country or family.

Biological and Neurological Differences Challenge Young Men In Adapting To Environments Favoring Feminine Traits

Erika Komisar states that men and women respond differently to nurturing due to hormonal differences and different brain activations. She explains that [restricted term] makes mothers more empathic and fathers more playful and risk-encouraging with their babies. Komisar suggests that boys are neurologically more fragile than girls, prone to aggression and behavioral problems, and are more sensitive to stres ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Changing Dynamics, Masculinity, and Challenges Facing Young Men

Additional Materials

Counterarguments

  • While society should encourage pro-social behaviors, it's also important to recognize that masculinity can be expressed in diverse ways, and not all men may aspire to traditional roles such as being providers and protectors.
  • The feeling of marginalization among men may not solely be due to the sexual revolution but also to broader economic and technological changes that have altered the job market.
  • The idea that women dominate over men in education could be reframed to emphasize the importance of equal access to education for all genders, rather than a competition between them.
  • The notion that men feel threatened by women's power could be challenged by promoting healthy, non-competitive interactions between genders and emphasizing mutual respect.
  • Economic devaluation affects all genders, and the focus could be on creating economic opportunities for everyone rather than framing it as a gender-specific issue.
  • The rise of the manosphere may be a complex phenomenon influenced by various factors, including social isolation and lack of community, not just a reaction to changing gender dynamics.
  • Biological and neurological differences between genders do not necessarily dictate learni ...

Actionables

- You can mentor a young man in your community to foster pro-social behaviors by volunteering at local youth organizations or schools, where you can provide guidance, support, and positive role modeling that emphasizes empathy, responsibility, and community engagement.

  • Encourage boys to explore a wide range of interests by gifting books, games, or activities that challenge traditional gender roles and promote emotional intelligence, such as storytelling games that require cooperation and understanding, or books with male characters who display a range of emotions and strengths.
  • Start conversations with boys and youn ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
THE FEMINISM DEBATE: Is Feminism Betraying Women? The Hidden Risk Of Casual Sex!

Feminism, Capitalism, and Policy In Shaping Societal Norms

The speakers discuss the complex relationship between feminism, capitalism, and policy, considering the impact of these forces in shaping societal norms and women's choices about family and professional lives.

Feminism's Role In Prioritizing Sexual Freedom Over Caregiving Needs

Critics argue that some feminist ideologies may have unintentionally pressured women into adopting a masculine model of success. Louise Perry and Erika Komisar discuss concerns that feminism has sometimes aspired to make women emulate men in both professional and sexual realms, potentially devaluing traditional caregiving roles.

Erika Komisar asserts that some women feel bullied by the narrative of freedom that has come with the feminist movement, which sometimes leads to lifestyles that don't bring happiness, such as lives without intimate partners or children. Deborah France-White raises concerns about any element of feminism that induces guilt or shame in women or takes away their autonomy, suggesting criticism of feminist ideologies that may insist too much on sexual freedom at the expense of caregiving roles.

Komisar suggests that feminism has swung too far in some respects, pushing women out of traditional roles and contributing to a narrative that devalues motherhood and caregiving. Meanwhile, Louise Perry brings up the idea of "maternal feminism," which seeks to balance the valuing of both professional life and motherhood equally.

The discussants are receptive to feminist progress but also highlight that certain feminist agendas may overlook essential aspects of women's roles, such as caregiving, potentially leading to adverse effects on society and individual happiness.

Capitalist Forces Exploit Women's Workforce Participation to Boost GDP, Affecting Family and Caregiving Structures

The conversation also reveals concerns about how capitalist systems exploit women's workforce participation to the detriment of family structures and caregiving needs. Erika Komisar implies that governments, under the cover of feminism, boost GDP by urging women into the workforce, often neglecting the importance of their roles as caregivers.

Deborah France-White highlights the struggles faced by professional women, who despite contributing to the economic system, still face financial instability, emphasizing the failure of capitalism to provide for basic needs and the need for sufficient government support for caregiving roles.

Louise Perry criticizes government policies, such as support exclusively for daycare, that co ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Feminism, Capitalism, and Policy In Shaping Societal Norms

Additional Materials

Counterarguments

  • Feminism has evolved to include a variety of perspectives, and many feminists actively work to value and uplift caregiving roles alongside professional achievements.
  • The narrative of freedom associated with feminism is also about giving women the choice to live as they please, which can include the choice to pursue motherhood, caregiving, or a career, or a combination of these.
  • The concept of "maternal feminism" may not resonate with all women, as it still implies a focus on motherhood that may not be central to every woman's identity or aspirations.
  • Feminist agendas are diverse and many do focus on caregiving and domestic work, advocating for their recognition and fair valuation in society.
  • The exploitation of women's labor in capitalist systems is a complex issue, and some argue that women's workforce participation has led to greater economic independence and societal progress.
  • Government policies encouraging workforce participation can be seen as supporting women's economic empowerment and providing more choices, rather than coercing them into work.
  • Financial instability faced by professional women can also be attributed to systemic issues beyond capitalism, such as gender discrimination and unequal pay.
  • Policies supporting daycare are not necessarily intended to limit choices but to provide options for families where both parents choose or need to work.
  • The norm of dual-income households reflects broader economic realities and societal changes, and some argue it has provided mo ...

Actionables

  • You can start a personal journal to reflect on your own definitions of success and happiness, focusing on how they align with your values rather than societal expectations. Write down what success means to you in both professional and caregiving roles, and consider how your current lifestyle aligns with these definitions. This can help you make more informed decisions about balancing work and family life.
  • Create a "choice map" to visualize the different paths your life could take, factoring in career, family, and personal fulfillment. On a large sheet of paper, draw branches representing different life choices, such as pursuing a career, focusing on family, or combining both. Add smaller branches for the potential outcomes of each choice, and use this map to guide your decisions and discussions with family or mentors about your future.
  • Engag ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
THE FEMINISM DEBATE: Is Feminism Betraying Women? The Hidden Risk Of Casual Sex!

The Influence of Pornography on Intimacy and Relationships

Louise Perry and Erika Komisar delve into the controversial topic of pornography’s influence on society with a focus on men, women, and the relationships they form.

Modern Pornography Proliferation Linked To Negative Effects: Unrealistic Expectations, Erectile Dysfunction, Objectification

Contemporary pornography is burdened with accusations of eroding healthy relationships.

Contemporary Pornography Erodes Healthy Relationships

Louise Perry describes modern pornography as a "super stimulus," noting its compelling nature, particularly for visually stimulated men. She criticizes pornography for training the brain to prefer heightened experiences, leading to dissatisfaction with normal sexual encounters. Perry also mentions a link between compulsive porn use and erectile dysfunction during actual sex. Porn use is even anecdotally tied to a rise in erectile issues among men when engaging with a partner.

Deborah France-White adds that activities done in isolation, like viewing pornography, can contribute to addiction and breakdowns in communication, underscoring the potential damage to societal norms and relationships.

Erika Komisar laments the evolution from less harmful two-dimensional pornography to the more addictive modern video formats, drawing a symbolic line from the days of Playboy magazines to today's explicit content.

Both Perry and Komisar allude to the harmful effects of pornography's unrealistic expectations on real-life intimacy and relationships.

Debate: Ban vs. Regulate Pornography—Freedom Infringement or Harm Reduction?

The complex debate over whether to ban or regulate pornography encapsulates issues of freedom, ethics, and harm reduction.

Feminist and Moral Views Clash: Is the Pornography Industry Incompatible With Women's Interests, or Should Consenting Adults Have Freedom?

Louise Perry suggests that pornography poses a severe ethical dilemma, particularly impacting women involved in its production, alluding to high suicide rates among performers and calling the industry hideously unethical. She argues the porn industry is one of the "least feminist" sectors and criticizes feminists who prioritize sexual liberalism over the welfare of women in the industry.

Perry also contrasts mild ancient erotic art, like that found in Pompeii, with modern pornography, sparking debate over the suitabili ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

The Influence of Pornography on Intimacy and Relationships

Additional Materials

Counterarguments

  • Pornography can be a safe way for individuals to explore their sexuality and fantasies without engaging in physical acts.
  • Some research suggests that pornography does not have a uniform negative effect on everyone and can even have positive effects on sexual health and relationships when used responsibly.
  • The ethical concerns in the porn industry can be addressed through better regulation and working conditions, rather than outright bans, which could drive the industry underground and exacerbate existing problems.
  • The argument that pornography leads to unrealistic expectations can be countered by the idea that adults are capable of distinguishing fantasy from reality, and that open communication between partners can mitigate misunderstandings.
  • The link between pornography and erectile dysfunction is not conclusively proven, with some studies suggesting other factors such as stress or lifestyle may play a more significant role.
  • The claim that pornography is inherently anti-feminist is contested by some feminists who argue that it can be empowering for women, both as consumers and as performers who choose to work in the industry.
  • The idea that pornography consumption leads to addiction and communication breakdowns does not take into account the complex psychological factors that contribute to addiction, nor does it recognize that many individuals consume pornography without these negative outcomes.
  • The ...

Actionables

  • You can foster healthier relationship dynamics by initiating open conversations with your partner about the impact of pornography on expectations and intimacy. Start by setting aside time for a candid discussion, focusing on how each of you feels about the role of pornography in your personal lives and its potential effects on your relationship. This can lead to setting mutual boundaries or seeking educational resources together to understand and navigate these challenges.
  • Develop a personal media consumption plan that prioritizes content promoting realistic and ethical portrayals of relationships. Begin by evaluating the types of media you consume, including movies, books, and online content, and actively seek out alternatives that highlight consent, communication, and realistic intimacy. This might involve subscribing to platforms that vet their content for ethical standards or joining online forums that recommend media with positive relationship models.
  • Engage in self-reflection to understand your o ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free

Create Summaries for anything on the web

Download the Shortform Chrome extension for your browser

Shortform Extension CTA