Podcasts > The Diary Of A CEO with Steven Bartlett > Moment 208: The Dumbest Financial Advice Everyone Weirdly Follows That’s Keeping Them Poor!

Moment 208: The Dumbest Financial Advice Everyone Weirdly Follows That’s Keeping Them Poor!

By Steven Bartlett

In this episode of The Diary of a CEO, Morgan Housel shares insights on the unpredictable nature of life and world events. Drawing from personal anecdotes and examples, he underscores how seemingly inconsequential decisions can have profound consequences, challenging the utility of forecasting.

Rather than chasing predictions, Housel advocates investing in resilience and preparedness for unforeseen circumstances. Through strategies like building cash reserves, owning a home, and index fund investing, he emphasizes creating wealth via steady, compounded returns over decades of patience—a path exemplified by the likes of Warren Buffett and an unassuming janitor millionaire.

Moment 208: The Dumbest Financial Advice Everyone Weirdly Follows That’s Keeping Them Poor!

This is a preview of the Shortform summary of the Apr 11, 2025 episode of the The Diary Of A CEO with Steven Bartlett

Sign up for Shortform to access the whole episode summary along with additional materials like counterarguments and context.

Moment 208: The Dumbest Financial Advice Everyone Weirdly Follows That’s Keeping Them Poor!

1-Page Summary

Fragility and Unpredictability of Life and World

Morgan Housel shares personal experiences and insights on the inherent uncertainties that shape our world. He recounts nearly dying in an avalanche as a teenager, separated from friends who perished by a seemingly inconsequential decision, underscoring life's unpredictability. Housel questions forecasting's utility, citing how impactful, unforeseen events like 9/11 and COVID consistently blindside the world.

Embracing Uncertainty Fosters Humility In Predictions

Housel embraces the unpredictable nature of life, positing that truly impactful risks and biggest future events likely remain unforeseen. He argues against forecasting's credibility, as minor, random occurrences can cascade into transformative change. Housel questions economic forecasts' usefulness, advocating for humbly accepting our limited foresight.

Invest In Strategies For Endurance and Survival, Not Prediction

Rather than market outperformance, Housel advocates investing for resilience and longevity through preparedness - ample cash reserves, home ownership, and diversified index funds - strategies enabling survival through shocks. He cites long-term, steady returns compounding over decades as the true key to wealth creation.

Examples of Warren Buffett and a Janitor Show Patience and Endurance Trump Investment Skills

Housel illustrates the power of patience and compounding using Warren Buffett, whose wealth stems from decades of diligent investing rather than market-beating returns, and Ronald Read, a janitor who amassed $8 million through 70 years of prudent stock investment.

Limits of Foresight and Dangers of Overconfidence In Forecasting

Bartlett and Housel discuss the seductive appeal of forecasts offering false certainty and control over the future. Investors gravitate towards predictions confirming biases rather than accuracy. True wisdom, per Housel, recognizes future unpredictability and knowledge limits, leading to humble, resilient investing over overconfident market timing.

1-Page Summary

Additional Materials

Counterarguments

  • While embracing uncertainty is important, forecasting and predictions can still provide valuable insights and help in planning and risk management.
  • Economic forecasts, while not always accurate, can be based on rigorous analysis and historical data, and dismissing them entirely may lead to missed opportunities for informed decision-making.
  • Overemphasis on endurance and survival might lead to overly conservative investment strategies that could result in missed growth opportunities.
  • Diversified index funds are not the only or necessarily the best strategy for all investors; individual circumstances and goals should dictate investment choices.
  • The examples of Warren Buffett and Ronald Read may not be representative of the average investor, as they both may have had unique skills, opportunities, or circumstances that contributed to their success.
  • Some level of confidence in forecasting is necessary for making any investment, as complete humility could result in indecision or a failure to act.
  • While biases in predictions should be acknowledged, not all forecasts are created equal, and some may have a track record of higher accuracy.
  • Recognizing the limits of foresight does not preclude the possibility of improving forecasting methods and tools over time through technology and research.
  • Patience and endurance are important, but so are adaptability and the ability to respond to changing market conditions.
  • The idea that true wisdom lies in recognizing unpredictability may undervalue the role of expertise and analysis in navigating complex financial landscapes.

Actionables

  • You can create a "What If" financial plan to prepare for unexpected life events. Start by listing potential emergencies, like job loss or health issues, and then outline a financial response to each, such as setting aside a monthly amount into an emergency fund or obtaining insurance policies that cover these risks. This proactive approach helps you build a safety net that aligns with the concept of prioritizing endurance and survival.
  • Develop a habit of reflective journaling to cultivate humility in the face of uncertainty. Dedicate time each week to write down instances where outcomes defied your expectations, whether in personal life or global events. This practice encourages recognition of the limits of your knowledge and the unpredictability of the future, fostering a mindset that values resilience over the illusion of control.
  • Engage in a "bias audit" with a trusted friend or advisor to counteract the tendency to seek confirming information. Share your investment decisions or predictions with them and ask for honest feedback on where you might be exhibiting confirmation bias. This collaborative exercise can help you identify blind spots in your thinking and encourage a more balanced, accuracy-focused approach to decision-making.

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
Moment 208: The Dumbest Financial Advice Everyone Weirdly Follows That’s Keeping Them Poor!

Fragility and Unpredictability of Life and World

In a candid examination of unpredictability and life's fragility, Morgan Housel uses personal experiences such as a near-death encounter and major historical events to illustrate the inherent uncertainties that shape our existence.

Avalanche Near-Death Experience Reveals World's Fragility and Unpredictability

Narrator's Choice to Skip Second Ski Run Saved Life After Fatal Avalanche

Morgan Housel shares a harrowing story from his teenage years, when a seemingly inconsequential decision spared him from a fatal avalanche. While skiing out of bounds with friends Brendan Allen and Brian Richmond, they inadvertently triggered a small avalanche. Unscathed, they celebrated with high-fives. Later, when Brendan and Brian opted for a second ski run, Housel chose to leave and offered to pick them up. Separated from his friends, his decision not to ski again proved life-saving; Brendan and Brian were later found buried under six feet of snow, victims of a much larger avalanche. Housel, meanwhile, had been awaiting their return at a pickup spot. Initial indifference turned to worry which eventually led to the grim discovery. Housel's choice, made without deep contemplation, saved his life, underscoring the randomness with which life-altering events unfold.

The Narrator Saw Major Life Risks and Events Like 9/11, the 2008 Crisis, and Covid-19 As Unpredictable

Housel reflects on the unpredictable nature of life, citing unpredictable major events, such as Pearl Harbor, 9/11, COVID, and the 2008 financial crisis, that blindsided the world and brought rapid and significant consequences. Recognizing that the most impactful and significant risks tend to be the ones no one sees coming, Housel underscores the unforeseen nature of life's most transformative episodes.

Embracing Uncertainty Fosters Humility In Predictions

Future Is Unpredictable Due to Chaotic, Unforeseeable Events

Embracing the unpredictable nature of life, Housel points out the futility of forecasting, given the chaotic and unforeseeable nat ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Fragility and Unpredictability of Life and World

Additional Materials

Clarifications

  • Chaotic and unforeseeable events altering the future highlight how unexpected and uncontrollable occurrences can significantly impact what lies ahead. These events often disrupt the expected course of events, leading to outcomes that were not predicted or planned for. The unpredictability stems from the complex interplay of various factors, making it challenging to anticipate or prepare for such disruptions. Embracing this uncertainty underscores the limitations of forecasting and emphasizes the need to adapt to unforeseen changes in the future.
  • When discussing the concept of risk remaining after accounting for known factors, it implies that even after considering and preparing for all the identifiable risks and variables, there are still unforeseen or unanticipated elements that can impact outcomes. This highlights the inherent unpredictability and complexity of certain situations, where factors beyond our current understanding can influence results. It underscores the limitations of traditional risk assessment methods that may not fully capture all potential risks. This concept emphasizes the importance of acknowledging and managing uncertainty in decision-making processes.
  • Forecasting credibility is questioned due to the unpredictable nature of events, as minor occurrences can lead to significant changes. The argument suggests that impactful events often stem from small and random incidents, making it challenging to accurately predict outcomes. This uncertainty highlights the limitations of forecasting, emphasizing the importance of acknowledging the unforeseen elements that shape the future. Embracing humility in predictions becomes essential wh ...

Counterarguments

  • While major events like 9/11 and COVID-19 were unpredictable in their specifics, experts in various fields often warn about the types of risks that lead to such events, suggesting that some level of prediction or preparedness is possible.
  • The idea that forecasting is futile might be too absolute; while precise predictions are challenging, probabilistic forecasting and scenario planning can help organizations and individuals prepare for a range of possible futures.
  • The narrative that impactful events are often small and random might overlook the role of systemic issues and the accumulation of small warning signs that, if heeded, could mitigate the impact of such events.
  • Risk management strategies often involve accounting for both known and unknown factors, suggesting that while unpredictability is a significant challenge, it is not entirely undefinable or unmanageable.
  • The emphasis on unpredictability and the futility of forecasting could pot ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
Moment 208: The Dumbest Financial Advice Everyone Weirdly Follows That’s Keeping Them Poor!

Invest In Strategies For Endurance and Survival, Not Prediction

Morgan Housel promotes an investment methodology concentrating on resilience and longevity in contrast to attempting to outperform the markets, a principle he believes fosters greater prosperity.

Narrator Advocates an Investment Focus on Longevity and Resilience Over Market Outperformance

Housel advocates investing in preparedness rather than prediction, urging individuals to maintain ample financial buffers—abundant cash, liquidity—and to approach debt with prudence, equipping oneself to survive unforeseen events like 9/11 or the COVID-19 pandemic. He emphasizes that having cash reserves that seem excessive could be the precise measure needed to withstand such shocks.

Narrator Favors Simplicity: Mainly Cash, House, Index Funds For Market Stability

Morgan Housel champions a straightforward investment approach involving cash, home ownership, and index funds. He embraces these instruments for the stability they provide over protracted periods. Referring to the contemporary ease of investing in low-cost index funds compared to 20 years prior, Housel has personally adopted this simple, dependable strategy and encourages others to do the same, eschewing stock picking in favor of broader market exposure.

Long-Term Returns Lead To Greater Wealth Than Market Timing or Stock Picking

Housel asserts that the real key to wealth creation lies not in short-term gains but in the returns sustained over extensive periods. He preaches the significance of persistence and compounding, suggesting that the ordinary investor's success is largely due to endurance. He underscores long-term, consistent investment without divestment as a method that could surpass the achievements of many professional investors.

Examples of Warren Buffett and a Janitor Show Patience and Endurance Trump Investment Skills

Housel identifies the importance of patience and the power of compounding by presenting the stories of Warren Buffett and Ronald James Read.

Buffett's Wealth Comes From Consistent Returns Over an 80-year Investing Career, Not Market Outperformance

Buffett's substantial net worth, which ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Invest In Strategies For Endurance and Survival, Not Prediction

Additional Materials

Counterarguments

  • While long-term investing is generally a sound strategy, it may not be suitable for everyone, as individual financial goals and circumstances vary.
  • The emphasis on cash reserves and liquidity might not account for the opportunity cost of not investing those funds, especially during times of low interest rates where cash savings could lose value due to inflation.
  • Simple investment strategies like index funds are not without risk, and market downturns can still significantly impact these investments.
  • The narrative that endurance always leads to wealth accumulation may not consider the impact of systemic risks or the changing nature of the economy and financial markets.
  • Warren Buffett's success, while heavily attributed to long-term investing, also involves a high degree of skill in selecting undervalued companies, which may not be replicable by the average investor.
  • The story of Ronald James Read, while inspiring, may not be representative of the typical investor's experience and could be an outlier rather than a standard case.
  • The strategy of avoiding debt may not consider the potential benefits of leverage in wealth creation when used responsibly and strategically.
  • Th ...

Actionables

  • You can start a "Resilience Fund" by setting aside a small percentage of your monthly income into a separate savings account. This fund acts as a financial buffer, growing over time, and is only to be used in case of emergencies or unexpected opportunities that align with your long-term goals. For example, if you save $50 from a monthly paycheck over 20 years, you'll have a substantial amount set aside that can provide stability during economic downturns or allow you to invest in a promising venture without risking your regular finances.
  • Create a "Longevity Portfolio" by allocating a portion of your investment into a diversified mix of index funds that track various sectors and markets. Instead of trying to time the market or pick individual stocks, this portfolio is designed to be held for the long term, benefiting from the compounding effect. You might start with a small investment each month, gradually increasing it as your financial situation improves, focusing on the growth over decades rather than short-term fluctuations.
  • Engage in a monthly "Financial Endurance Review ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
Moment 208: The Dumbest Financial Advice Everyone Weirdly Follows That’s Keeping Them Poor!

Limits of Foresight and Dangers of Overconfidence In Forecasting

Bartlett and Housel discuss the seductive allure of forecasting in various aspects of life, from investing to personal circumstances, and the need for humility and prudence in the face of uncertainty.

Faith in Forecasts Stems From Desire For Certainty

People yearn for forecasts as a way to bring a sense of control and predictability to the inherently uncertain future.

Investment Forecasts and Predictions, Like Horoscopes, Offer a False Sense of Control and Certainty, Despite Being Meaningless

Bartlett observes a friend who regularly posts optimistic forecast graphs for stocks or cryptocurrencies, mirroring a widespread behavior where people cling to predictions. Housel draws a comparison between these investment forecasts and horoscopes, pointing out that although they provide comfort, they lack any real predictive power.

Investors Prefer Forecasts Confirming Biases Over Objective Accuracy

Investors tend to gravitate towards forecasts that confirm their biases as opposed to those grounded in objective accuracy. This preference illuminates the human desire for reassurance rather than factual foresight.

True Humility Recognizes Future Unpredictability and Knowledge Limits

Acknowledging the fundamental unpredictability of the future is a form of wisdom essential for realistic and flexible planning.

Narrator Admits Inability to Foresee Future or Predict Major Risks

Housel candidly admits his own inability to predict the future, whether it's the timing of the next recession, career trajectories over decades, the duration of personal relationships, or longevity. Furthermore, by reflecting on unforeseen major risks like 9/11 or the COVID-19 pandemic, Housel implicitly accepts the limitations in forecasting significant events.

Humility Leads To Prudent, Resilient Investing Over Overconfident Market Timing

Bartlett stresses the importance of humility ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Limits of Foresight and Dangers of Overconfidence In Forecasting

Additional Materials

Counterarguments

  • While forecasts may often fail, they can be based on rigorous models and historical data, which can provide some probabilistic guidance rather than being entirely meaningless.
  • Some investment forecasts are made by experts with deep understanding of market dynamics and should not be dismissed as equivalent to horoscopes.
  • It is possible for investors to use forecasts as one of many tools in decision-making without being overconfident or biased, especially when they critically evaluate the source and methodology of the forecast.
  • While the future is inherently unpredictable, scenario planning and risk management strategies can help individuals and organizations prepare for a range of possible futures, rather than just one predicted outcome.
  • Admitting the inability to foresee the future does not necessarily preclude the value of preparing for likely risks based on trends and availa ...

Actionables

  • You can create a 'future-proof' financial diary to embrace uncertainty and improve decision-making. Start by jotting down your investment decisions, the reasons behind them, and your emotional state at the time. Review this diary periodically to identify patterns in your thinking and to remind yourself of the unpredictability of markets. This practice encourages humility and helps you avoid making the same mistakes due to overconfidence or bias confirmation.
  • Develop a 'bias-buster' investment club with friends or family members with diverse viewpoints. Meet monthly to discuss different investment strategies, ensuring that each person presents an argument that challenges the group's prevailing biases. This can help you recognize and counteract your own biases, fostering a more objective and resilient approach to investing.
  • Engage in a 'scenario sandbox' ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free

Create Summaries for anything on the web

Download the Shortform Chrome extension for your browser

Shortform Extension CTA