Podcasts > The Daily > The Deserter: Parts 4 and 5

The Deserter: Parts 4 and 5

By The New York Times

In this multi-part episode about a Russian soldier's desertion from the war in Ukraine, intimate details are revealed about the harrowing process of evading deployment. The podcast explores Ivan's elaborate ruse to fake an injury and forge documents to escape Russia safely. It then highlights the dangers he faced crossing borders and the persistent fear of Russian authorities even after reaching asylum.

The episode also provides insight into the broader challenges facing deserters — severe punishments, lack of passports, violence and deportation risks, separation from families — and the reluctance of many countries to accept them amid vetting concerns. The plight of Russian deserters illustrates the human toll and constant vulnerability faced by those fleeing military service in the Ukraine conflict.

Listen to the original

The Deserter: Parts 4 and 5

This is a preview of the Shortform summary of the Sep 29, 2024 episode of the The Daily

Sign up for Shortform to access the whole episode summary along with additional materials like counterarguments and context.

The Deserter: Parts 4 and 5

1-Page Summary

Ivan's Desertion Tactics

To avoid being redeployed, Ivan feigned a herniated disc injury. As Margo Sanger-Katz explains, Ivan meticulously rehearsed limping and grimacing, using props to appear severely disabled and convince doctors that surgery was essential to avoid the front lines.

Ivan also devised an intricate scheme to forge his passport. Michael Barbaro notes that Ivan altered his appearance in Photoshop and paid for a high-quality counterfeit document. Ivan then craftily swapped the real and fake passports when an inexperienced officer borrowed his for his wife's job application.

Ivan's Dangerous Escape

Ivan cautiously navigated through Belarus to reach Turkey, heeding warnings about using only his domestic passport. At checkpoints, Sanger-Katz says Ivan took steps like picking quick-moving lines to avoid scrutiny over his military service.

Even after reaching Turkey, the risks continued, with Ivan narrowly avoiding a swindle involving fake travel documents. Meanwhile, Barbaro recounts that Anna faced intimidation from an unknown man threatening Ivan.

Life in Asylum

Though they reached safety, Sanger-Katz explains their fear never subsided, constantly paranoid about Russian authorities. Rebuilding lives as refugees brought bureaucratic hurdles like finding housing. The segment emphasizes their struggle to normalize their new reality while shadows of the past lingered.

Rising Russian Military Desertions

Desertion has spiked during the Ukraine invasion, but as Sanger-Katz highlights, those caught face severe punishments like long prison terms. Even if they flee, deserters face major obstacles securing asylum, with many countries reluctant to accept them over fears of infiltrators.

The segment details the arduous journey deserters face - lacking passports, risking violence or detention, and struggling with deportation after reaching perceived safe havens. Barbaro underscores the human toll, with deserters separated from families amid constant fear of recapture.

1-Page Summary

Additional Materials

Counterarguments

  • Ivan's feigning of an injury could be seen as an unethical way to avoid military service, which others fulfill dutifully.
  • The act of forging documents, such as a passport, is illegal and undermines the integrity of legal and immigration systems.
  • Ivan's tactics to avoid detection, while clever, could be interpreted as deceptive and potentially harmful to others who may be unjustly suspected or scrutinized in his stead.
  • The fear Ivan and Anna experience could be considered a consequence of the choices Ivan made to desert and deceive authorities.
  • While desertion rates have spiked, it's important to consider the broader context of why individuals like Ivan are choosing to desert, which may include moral objections or fear for personal safety.
  • The severe punishments for deserters could be argued as a necessary deterrent to maintain military discipline and effectiveness.
  • The difficulties faced by deserters in securing asylum could be seen as part of the necessary vetting process to protect national security.
  • The separation of families and the constant fear of recapture could be viewed as regrettable but part of the accountability for deserting military service.
  • The human toll on deserters, while sympathetic, does not address the potential impact of their desertion on their comrades and the operational capacity of their units.

Actionables

  • You can develop empathy for refugees by volunteering at local support organizations, where you can assist with language translation, job search, and cultural orientation for those who've fled conflict zones.
    • By engaging directly with individuals who have experienced similar challenges as Ivan and Anna, you gain a deeper understanding of the emotional and practical difficulties faced by refugees. For example, helping someone draft a resume or navigate public transportation in a new country can provide insight into the bureaucratic hurdles mentioned.
  • Enhance your awareness of legal and human rights by attending webinars or community college classes on international law and refugee rights.
    • This knowledge can empower you to advocate for fair treatment and support of deserters seeking asylum. For instance, understanding the legal distinction between a refugee and an asylum seeker can help you provide accurate information to those in need or correct misconceptions in your community.
  • Create a personal safety net by learning basic survival skills, such as first aid, emergency preparedness, and self-defense, through local workshops or online courses.
    • These skills can prepare you for unexpected situations, similar to how Ivan navigated challenges during his journey. For example, knowing how to treat minor injuries or being aware of your surroundings can be invaluable in emergencies or when traveling in unfamiliar environments.

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
The Deserter: Parts 4 and 5

Ivan's attempts to avoid deployment and desert the military

Ivan tried various tactics to avoid being sent back to the front line after surviving the initial invasion

Ivan shrewdly decides to feign a herniated disc that he had suffered from years earlier. He methodically exaggerates his pain during a medical examination, yelping prematurely to suggest the severity of his discomfort. He strategically claims that wearing his body armor worsens his pain and insists on surgery as the only solution, hoping it will grant him a reprieve from redeployment. With consistent practice, he refines his exaggerated limping, utilizing props like a solid black cane with a retractable spike to heighten the authenticity of his ruse. Ivan is set on appearing disabled enough to convince the military doctors. He even goes as far as to recall the gait of a colleague named Roman to make his act more convincing, ensuring his limp and grimaces signal a dire need for surgery.

Ivan communicates his back pain concern to the base's personnel, presenting his situation as needing urgent surgical attention and claiming an injection can temporarily alleviate his pain. He privately maintains his charade, moving without assistance while safely inside his apartment. At the field hospital, he leverages the term "hernia," which persuades the medic to place him on a list promising further medical evaluation.

Realizing the importance of a compelling story, Ivan tells others that he had been advised to have surgery even before the war, aiming to solidify his account. He consistently rehearses his behavior to better sell the severity of his condition. With the medical evidence suggesting surgery and his six-month reliance on a cane, Ivan convinces a doctor to recommend the operation. In an effort to bolster his case, he contacts his mother's acquaintance, a military neurosurgeon, seeking assistance in solidifying his ploy to avoid the horrors of redeployment.

Ivan carefully planned and executed a complex scheme to swap his real passport with a forged one to facilitate his escape

In a strategic twist, Ivan crafts a meticulous plan to forge his passport, using Photoshop to alter his appearance and paying for a high-quality counterfeit document. With his understanding of the HR office's procedures, Ivan conceives a daring in-person pas ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Ivan's attempts to avoid deployment and desert the military

Additional Materials

Clarifications

  • Ivan's use of a solid black cane with a retractable spike is a strategic choice to enhance the authenticity of his act of feigning a herniated disc. The retractable spike could symbolize a hidden weapon or a tool for added dramatic effect in his performance. This prop helps Ivan appear more convincing in his portrayal of someone in need of urgent medical attention, adding a layer of detail to his deception. The cane with a retractable spike serves as a visual aid to support his narrative of severe pain and disability.
  • Ivan sought assistance from a military neurosurgeon to add credibility to his feigned medical condition. By involving a professional in the military medical field, Ivan aimed to strengthen his deception and increase the likelihood of being exempted from redeployment. This collaboration was a strategic move to enhance the authenticity of his need for surgery and support his efforts to avoid returning to the front line.
  • Ivan's use of a coded phone call to Anna involves using predetermined signals or phrases to convey specific messages without revealing sensitive information to anyone ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
The Deserter: Parts 4 and 5

Ivan's dangerous journey to escape Russia and reach safety

The article details how Ivan and his family braved considerable risks to flee Russia for a safer country where they could seek asylum, following Ivan's direct involvement in conflict.

Ivan navigated numerous challenges and checkpoints to cross the Belarus border and reach Turkey

Ivan managed to carefully navigate his way through Belarus with tactical planning. He was warned to use only his domestic passport to avoid additional checks, especially at the Minsk airport, where security systems were closely synchronized with Russia's. Ivan also made diligent moves to cover his tracks, such as purchasing his train ticket with cash to avoid a digital trace and portraying himself as a web designer on vacation rather than revealing his military involvement.

At the Minsk airport, Ivan took strategic steps to ensure a smooth passage. He picked the passport control line with a lady who seemed soft-hearted and had a quick-moving line. Even when the officer's computer froze, which he feared was a check against a database for service members not allowed to leave, Ivan remained composed and eventually was let through due to a wider computer system issue.

Ivan faced the risk of being swindled or robbed as he arranged onward travel from Turkey to his final destination

Ivan's journey continued to be riddled with risk, as he narrowly avoided a swindle involving a fake plane ticket and subsequent flight reservations that weren't properly booked. He painstakingly managed to confront the swindler and secured a genuine ticket to Turkey, but his onward travel remained uncertain.

Anna, Ivan's wife, also faced dangers and difficulties in preparing for their escape and relocation

Concurrently, Anna was preparing for their escape and eventual relocation. She pursued cosmetology, knowing that they had to relocate to a non-extradition country. Anna's resolve was tested when an unknown man approached her, insinuated threats towards Ivan, and suggested violent consequences. Despite the intimidation, she remained determined, and soon they were both on their way to escape the imminent threat.

Ivan and his family ultimately reached a safe country where they could seek asylum, despite the ever-present threat of being tracked down by Russian authorities

They lived in constant fear and paranoia, even after successfully fleeing ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Ivan's dangerous journey to escape Russia and reach safety

Additional Materials

Actionables

  • You can develop adaptability by practicing scenario planning, where you imagine various challenging situations and outline potential solutions. For example, consider what steps you would take if you suddenly had to move to a new city, including how you would find housing, a job, and integrate into the community.
  • Enhance your problem-solving skills by engaging in role-playing games that simulate escape or survival scenarios. This can help you think critically and make quick decisions, much like creating a strategy to cross borders under pressure.
  • Bui ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
The Deserter: Parts 4 and 5

The broader context and challenges faced by Russian deserters

The war in Ukraine has led to an uptick in desertions from the Russian military, but deserters face severe consequences and significant challenges in finding refuge and legal status abroad.

Desertion from the Russian military has become increasingly common during the invasion of Ukraine, but the consequences can be severe

Men forced to fight in the initial invasion or who tried unsuccessfully to break their contracts and fled are at risk of severe consequences if caught by the Russian authorities. Punishments for desertion can include long prison sentences. There are constant rumors about another round of mobilization and fears of a barring order preventing men from leaving Russia. Examples include Mikhail Zhilin, a Federal Guard Service Officer who was arrested and deported back to Russia from Kazakhstan after requesting asylum and was sentenced to six and a half years in prison for desertion and illegal border crossing.

Under Russian law, deserters can only be punished if there's an intent to desert permanently. Soldiers can be away from base for a long period before being charged with being AWOL, carrying a shorter sentence than desertion. Commanding officers may avoid officially declaring a subordinate as AWOL, which sometimes allows deserters to continue receiving their full salary for months without being formally charged.

The conversation also touches on strategies used to flush deserters from their homes, like cutting electricity, and forceful methods used to apprehend deserters and bring them to the military service location (SVO). The man who approached Anna suggested that deserters take drastic actions to escape, further implying the grave risk of long prison terms for deserters.

Examples are provided of deserters who faced extreme challenges escaping Russia due to lack of documentation and threats of retaliation. Deserters have attempted measures as desperate as mutilation to avoid service. Defection is portrayed as very dangerous, especially for former regime members, with stories of people being kidnapped or detained even after reaching assumed safety.

Compounding these difficulties is the reluctance of European countries to offer asylum due to fears of spies or infiltrators. Deserters have faced difficulties in boarding planes and securing visas, even ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

The broader context and challenges faced by Russian deserters

Additional Materials

Actionables

  • You can raise awareness by creating a digital storytelling platform where individuals can anonymously share their experiences related to military desertion. This platform could be a website or a social media page where stories are shared through articles, videos, or audio recordings, providing a safe space for deserters to express their struggles without revealing their identity. This initiative would help humanize the issue and potentially garner support for those affected.
  • Consider starting a peer-to-peer support network for individuals facing similar challenges as the deserters. This network could operate online, connecting people through forums or chat groups, allowing them to exchange practical advice on navigating legal hurdles, finding safe passage, and coping with the emotional toll of their situation. By facilitating these connections, you provide a community for mutual support and resource sharing.
  • Engage in advocacy by contact ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free

Create Summaries for anything on the web

Download the Shortform Chrome extension for your browser

Shortform Extension CTA