Podcasts > The Daily > Introducing ‘The Wirecutter Show’

Introducing ‘The Wirecutter Show’

By The New York Times

In this episode of The Daily, learn about the rigorous and completely independent product testing methodology employed by the trusted review site Wirecutter. Their dedicated team of journalists put products through extensive real-world testing—from hiking thousands of miles in boots to conducting controlled burns—to offer unbiased recommendations to consumers.

Drawing from Wirecutter's laundry expertise, the episode also provides insights on the unique capabilities of different detergent types and stain removal strategies. You'll discover tips for selecting the right products and techniques to effectively tackle every laundry challenge, from delicate garments to deep-set stains, while exploring eco-friendly practices to reduce your environmental impact.

Listen to the original

Introducing ‘The Wirecutter Show’

This is a preview of the Shortform summary of the Aug 25, 2024 episode of the The Daily

Sign up for Shortform to access the whole episode summary along with additional materials like counterarguments and context.

Introducing ‘The Wirecutter Show’

1-Page Summary

Wirecutter's Rigorous and Independent Product Testing

Wirecutter is renowned for its extensive and unbiased product evaluations conducted by a team of dedicated journalists. Their methodical approach involves analyzing items through in-depth and hands-on testing, such as hiking thousands of miles in hiking boots and burning fire safes in a controlled environment.

Wirecutter operates independently, rejecting complimentary products and company influences. Their recommendations stem solely from genuine belief in a product's merit, ensuring trustworthy advice for consumers.

Detergent Properties and Stain Removal

Wirecutter laundry expert Andrea Barnes highlights the different strengths of liquid and powder detergents. Liquids like Tide Free & Gentle effectively remove body oils, while powders with oxygen bleach, like Tide Ultra Oxy, excel at dirt and set-in stains.

Pre-treating and Water Temperature

Barnes emphasizes pre-treating stains before washing as crucial. Cold water prevents blood stain setting, warm water lifts oils, and hot sanitizes fabrics. For stubborn stains, Barnes recommends Amadex stain remover.

Delicates and Vintage Garments

For delicate items like cashmere, Barnes suggests hand-washing with Soak, a no-rinse detergent that evaporates without residue. Restoration's pure oxygen bleach stands out for safely restoring heavily soiled vintage pieces.

Eco-Friendly Laundry Practices

Wirecutter experts highlight simple ways to reduce environmental impact when doing laundry:

  • Washing in cold water dramatically cuts energy usage for water heating.
  • Using minimal amounts of concentrated detergent prevents chemical residue buildup.

1-Page Summary

Additional Materials

Counterarguments

  • While Wirecutter claims to reject complimentary products and company influences, it's important to consider that no evaluation process is entirely free from bias, as personal preferences or industry standards can subtly influence outcomes.
  • The effectiveness of liquid versus powder detergents can vary depending on the specific formulation and the type of washing machine used, so the superiority of one over the other is not absolute.
  • Pre-treating stains is generally advised, but some fabrics or finishes might be damaged by pre-treatment products, suggesting that a one-size-fits-all approach to stain removal is not always ideal.
  • The recommendation for water temperature in washing is sound, but it may not apply to all types of stains or fabrics; some delicate materials might be damaged by warm or hot water.
  • Amadex stain remover may be effective, but there could be other stain removers that work equally well or better, depending on the type of stain and fabric.
  • Hand-washing with no-rinse detergents like Soak is recommended for delicates, but some garments may require specific care instructions that differ from this general advice.
  • The endorsement of Restoration's pure oxygen bleach for vintage garments doesn't account for the possibility that some vintage fabrics might be too delicate for any bleach, even those labeled as safe for such items.
  • The environmental recommendations assume that all users have access to and can afford concentrated detergents and have the capability to adjust water temperature, which might not be the case for all consumers.
  • Reducing energy usage by washing in cold water is a good practice, but it may not be effective for sanitizing or thoroughly cleaning certain types of laundry, such as cloth diapers or medical uniforms.

Actionables

  • Create a personalized laundry guide by experimenting with different water temperatures and detergents on a variety of stains and fabrics. Keep a notebook in your laundry area to record the outcomes, such as which combination of detergent and water temperature worked best for specific stains or fabric types. This will help you develop a tailored approach to laundry that maximizes effectiveness while minimizing damage to your clothes.
  • Designate a "stain treatment station" in your home with all the necessary tools for pre-treating stains, including a soft brush, white cloths, and a mix of DIY stain removers made from household items like baking soda, vinegar, and lemon juice. This encourages immediate action on stains and provides an alternative to commercial stain removers, potentially discovering new, effective combinations through trial and error.
  • Start a "laundry savings challenge" where you track the reduction in your utility bill by exclusively washing in cold water for a month. Use a measuring cup to ensure you're using the correct amount of detergent for each load. Document the savings and the state of your laundry to evaluate the impact of these changes on both your finances and your clothes' cleanliness.

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
Introducing ‘The Wirecutter Show’

Wirecutter's product testing and review process

Wirecutter is a product recommendation service recognized for conducting rigorous and independent testing to ascertain the best products for consumers.

Wirecutter's team of dedicated journalists uses extensive testing to provide objective and thorough recommendations. Their commitment to unbiased reviews is apparent in their refusal to allow company influences or freebies to skew their judgement.

Methodical and In-Depth Evaluations

The Wirecutter team of roughly 140 journalists carries out methodical and in-depth evaluations across various products. For instance, their dedication to accuracy is evident in the way they analyzed 55 pairs of hiking boots, a process that involved hiking 1,400 miles over a span of seven years.

Their scrupulous assessment extends to other product categories, as well. To verify the efficacy of fire safes, Wirecutter constructed an entire room just to burn it down with the safes inside, testing their resilience in extreme conditions. Andrea Barnes, who is Wirecutter's authority on big home appliances, has conducted hands-on tests with different washers and dryers and detergent types. Their office itself is a testament to their meticulous process, bustling with activity around stained clothing and a plethora of detergents for testing.

Independent and Consumer-focused Recommendations

The integrity of Wirecutter's recommendations is paramount. The organization operates independently ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Wirecutter's product testing and review process

Additional Materials

Clarifications

  • Wirecutter's commitment to independence means they do not let companies influence their reviews or judgments. They do not accept free products or any form of payment that could bias their recommendations. This ensures their reviews are unbiased and based solely on the merits of the products tested. By maintaining this strict policy, Wirecutter aims to provide trustworthy advice to consumers.
  • The Wirecutter team rigorously tested 55 pairs of hiking boots by collectively hiking a total of 1,400 miles over seven years. This extensive process allowed them to evaluate the durability, comfort, and performance of each pair in real-world conditions. By wearing and testing the boots over such a long period and distance, they could provide thorough and reliable recommendations based on their hands-on experience. This methodical approach ensured that their reviews were comprehensive and based on practical, long-term usage rather than just initial impressions.
  • Testing fire safes by burning them in a room is a method used to evaluate the safes' ability to withstand high temperatures and protect their contents during a fire. By subjecting the safes to controlled fire conditions, researchers can observe how well they maintain their structural integrity and insulation properties. This rigorous testing process helps determine the safes' effectiveness in real-world fire scenarios, providing valuable insights for consumers looking to protect important documents and valuables.
  • Andrea Barnes, Wirecutter's expert on big home appliances, conducts hands-on tests with washers, dryers, and detergent types to provide thorough and reliable recommendations to consumers. This involves physically testing the performance and features of various models to assess their effectiveness in real-world scenarios. By evaluating these products firsthand, Andrea can offer practical insights and advice ba ...

Counterarguments

  • While Wirecutter's testing process is rigorous, it may not always capture the full range of consumer experiences due to the inherent limitations of testing environments versus real-world use.
  • Objectivity in product recommendations can be difficult to achieve completely, as personal biases of journalists, even if subtle, can influence outcomes.
  • Refusing company influences or freebies is commendable, but it does not guarantee that other factors, such as affiliate marketing relationships, don't influence product recommendations.
  • Methodical and in-depth evaluations are resource-intensive and may not be sustainable for all types of products, potentially leading to gaps in Wirecutter's coverage.
  • The example of analyzing 55 pairs of hiking boots over seven years is impressive, but it may not reflect the frequency of updates needed to keep recommendations current with market changes.
  • Constructing a room to test fire safes shows dedication but may not replicate all the variables present in real house fires.
  • Hands-on tests of washers, dryers, and detergents are valuable, but long-term durability and customer service experiences are also critical factors that might not be fully captured.
  • Operating ind ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
Introducing ‘The Wirecutter Show’

Laundry Detergent and Stain Removal Techniques

The podcast episode delves into the intricacies of laundry care, exploring products and techniques, with staff writer and laundry expert Andrea Barnes sharing insights from testing and research.

Liquid and Powder Detergents Have Different Properties

The episode discusses the differing capabilities of liquid and powder detergents, with liquid detergent generally recommended for its effectiveness in removing body oils from clothing. Liquid detergent’s surfactants have a similarity to oils, enabling them to better absorb oil stains. Wirecutter suggests Tide Free & Gentle liquid detergent for most laundry due to its stain removal efficacy and hypoallergenic properties.

On the other hand, for individuals who frequently encounter dirt or mud stains, powder detergent may be a better solution. Powder formulations often include oxygen bleach, boosting their stain-removing prowess, particularly for set-in stains. Oxygen bleach, unlike chlorine, is safe for colored fabrics, albeit testing on a small area is advised. Wirecutter recommends Tide Ultra Oxy for dirt-heavy clothing.

Pre-treating Stains Before Washing

Pre-treating stains by applying a stain remover or laundry detergent directly onto the affected area before washing is emphasized as a significant step in improving stain removal. For nearly all stains, a standard laundry detergent should suffice for pre-treatment, but for more stubborn stains like makeup and permanent ink, Amadex, an all-purpose stain remover, is recommended. Andrea Barnes notes that pre-treating oil stains with warm water and liquid laundry detergent can be particularly effective, even on stains that have survived previous wash cycles.

The type of water temperature is imparted as an essential factor: cold water is crucial for blood stains to prevent setting, and warm water is ideal for lifting oil stains. F ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Laundry Detergent and Stain Removal Techniques

Additional Materials

Counterarguments

  • While liquid detergents may be effective for oil stains, they can sometimes be less economical due to the tendency for overuse, and their plastic packaging may be less environmentally friendly compared to powder detergents.
  • Powder detergents may not dissolve as well in cold water, which can leave residue on clothing, and they might not be as effective in high-efficiency washing machines that use less water.
  • Pre-treating stains is an extra step that requires additional time and resources, and it may not always be necessary for all types of stains or with high-performance detergents.
  • Amadex and other specialized stain removers may not be readily available or cost-effective for all consumers, and some may prefer natural or homemade alternatives.
  • The recommendation for warm water for oil stains does not consider the energy consumption and potential environmental impact of using warm or hot water compared to cold water.
  • Hot water can set certain types of stains or damage some fabrics, so its use for sanitizing should be balanced with the potential for harm to certain garments.
  • No-rinse detergents like Soak may not be as effective for heavily soiled garments or for consumers who prefer the ...

Actionables

  • Create a stain removal guide for your laundry area by categorizing fabrics and stains, then listing the appropriate detergent type and water temperature for each. For example, next to "body oils," note "liquid detergent and warm water," and under "blood stains," write "cold water." This visual reminder will help you quickly apply the correct treatment when doing laundry.
  • Experiment with a DIY pre-treatment solution for various stains using household items not mentioned in the podcast, like baking soda for grease or white vinegar for deodorant marks. Apply these to a small, inconspicuous area of the fabric first to ensure they don't cause damage, then observe the results and adjust your method accordingly.
  • Organize a "laundry swap" wi ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
Introducing ‘The Wirecutter Show’

Sustainable and eco-friendly laundry practices

Caira Blackwell and Christine Cyr Clisset discuss simple changes that can be made during laundry routines to reduce environmental impact.

Washing in cold water, using less detergent, and air-drying clothes are simple ways to reduce the environmental impact of doing laundry.

The energy required to heat water accounts for a significant portion of a washing machine's energy use, so cold water washes are more efficient.

Blackwell highlights washing in cold water as a key takeaway for being more eco-friendly during laundry. Clisset agrees, noting that the energy required to heat water in washing machines is the biggest environmental impact of doing laundry, and advocating cold water washes as a way to address this. While not directly mentioning the energy needed to heat water, the conversation suggests that cold washes are more efficient, indirectly addressing the benefit of cold water for certain stains.

Andrea Barnes adds that washing in cold water is better in terms of energy efficiency, because a significant portion of a washing machine’s energy use goes to heating water. Barnes suggests using cold water for most stains, including urine, as it is generally pretty sterile, and only recommends hot water for sanitizing purposes. This reinforces the notion that cooler temperatures are typically sufficient for cleaning, aligning with the practice of reducing energy use by washing in cold water.

While there was no specific mention in the conv ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Sustainable and eco-friendly laundry practices

Additional Materials

Counterarguments

  • Cold water may not be as effective for all types of stains or for sanitizing clothes, which could lead to hygiene issues or the need for re-washing, potentially offsetting the energy savings.
  • Some detergents are designed to work optimally at specific temperatures, and using less than recommended might result in poorly cleaned clothes, requiring additional wash cycles.
  • Air-drying clothes can be impractical in humid or polluted environments, or for those living in small spaces without outdoor access, potentially leading to dampness and mold issues.
  • Energy-efficient washing machines and water heaters can mitigate the environmental impact of warm water washes, making them more comparable to cold water washes in terms of energy use.
  • The production and disposal of highly concentrated detergents may have environmental impacts that offset the benefits of using less product per wash.
  • Some stains or laundry needs may require more detergent than the minimal recommended amount fo ...

Actionables

  • You can create a visual guide for your laundry area that outlines the types of stains and the recommended water temperature for each. This can be a simple chart that you hang near your washing machine, ensuring you remember to use cold water for most stains and reserve hot water for sanitizing when necessary.
  • Start a "detergent diary" to track the amount of detergent you use per load and the cleanliness of your clothes post-wash. By noting the outcomes, you can fine-tune the amount of detergent to find the minimal effective quantity, reducing residue and chemical waste without compromising on cleanliness.
  • Invest in a high-quality laundry ball or a similar reusa ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free

Create Summaries for anything on the web

Download the Shortform Chrome extension for your browser

Shortform Extension CTA