Podcasts > The Daily > How Air-Conditioning Conquered America

How Air-Conditioning Conquered America

By The New York Times

In this episode of The Daily, Emily Badger explores the rise of air conditioning in America and its far-reaching impacts. Once an industrial technology, air conditioning transformed architectural design, urban planning, energy consumption, and societal norms. Badger examines how our reliance on climate-controlled spaces enabled population growth in hot regions but introduced environmental challenges.

She further delves into how air conditioning reshaped cultural expectations, fostering an indoor lifestyle disconnected from local climates. Badger's insights shed light on the intricate ways this ubiquitous modern convenience has shaped our built environment and perspectives on comfort, prompting a critical evaluation of its sustainability.

Listen to the original

How Air-Conditioning Conquered America

This is a preview of the Shortform summary of the Aug 16, 2024 episode of the The Daily

Sign up for Shortform to access the whole episode summary along with additional materials like counterarguments and context.

How Air-Conditioning Conquered America

1-Page Summary

Personal and historical experiences with air conditioning

Emily Badger recounts her childhood in Chicago without air conditioning, contrasting it with moving to Orlando and being constantly in climate-controlled spaces. She explains how Willis Carrier's air conditioning technology progressed from industrial uses to residential adoption. By the 1970s, air conditioning enabled population growth in hot states, with two-thirds of modern American homes now having central air.

Architectural and urban development impacts of air conditioning

Prior to air conditioning, buildings were designed to interact with local climates using features like thick walls and porches. Emily Badger notes how architectural styles diversified regionally based on climate. Modern buildings are now engineered as sealed environments dependent on air conditioning, allowing energy-intensive designs like glass towers. However, some aim to reduce air conditioning reliance through sustainable practices.

Emily Badger highlights buildings account for around 30% of U.S. greenhouse gas emissions, much from cooling systems. Modern air conditioning-optimized design is unsustainable and energy-intensive. Over-reliance creates vulnerability during power outages, especially in populated regions enabled by air conditioning. Settlements have expanded into inhospitable climates that require significant energy for climate control.

Cultural and societal changes driven by air conditioning

Air conditioning has created an expectation of constant controlled temperatures between 68-72°F. Emily Badger notes adjusting comfort norms for sustainability is difficult given the ingrained sense of entitlement. Increased indoor living has reduced community interaction, while demographic shifts redistributed populations toward hot regions enabled by air conditioning.

1-Page Summary

Additional Materials

Counterarguments

  • While air conditioning has facilitated population growth in hot states, it's also worth noting that other factors like economic opportunities and lower cost of living have also played significant roles in demographic shifts.
  • The assertion that two-thirds of modern American homes have central air might not account for the diversity in housing types and the presence of alternative cooling methods like window units or passive cooling in some regions.
  • The idea that buildings pre-air conditioning were universally designed to suit local climates may overlook examples where design was influenced more by aesthetic or cultural factors than by climate.
  • Modern buildings, while often reliant on air conditioning, are not universally energy-intensive; there are many examples of energy-efficient buildings that also rely on air conditioning.
  • Some argue that the increase in greenhouse gas emissions from buildings is not solely due to air conditioning but also to other factors like heating and electrical appliances.
  • The vulnerability created by over-reliance on air conditioning during power outages can be mitigated through improved infrastructure, emergency planning, and the use of renewable energy sources.
  • The expansion of settlements into inhospitable climates is not solely due to air conditioning; advancements in water supply, transportation, and communication have also made these areas more livable.
  • The expectation of constant temperatures might be seen not just as an entitlement but as a health and productivity necessity for certain populations and in specific contexts.
  • While increased indoor living has been associated with reduced community interaction, other factors like technology and changing social norms also play significant roles.
  • The redistribution of populations towards hot regions is not solely a result of air conditioning but also of broader socio-economic trends and personal preferences.

Actionables

  • You can embrace passive cooling by opening windows during cooler hours and using fans to circulate air, reducing the need for constant air conditioning.
  • By creating airflow and allowing your home to cool naturally when outdoor temperatures drop, you can save energy and acclimate to a wider range of indoor temperatures. For example, use window fans in the evening to draw in cool air and close curtains during the day to keep out the sun.
  • Experiment with adjusting your thermostat by one degree each week to become more comfortable with a wider range of temperatures.
  • Gradually increasing the thermostat setting in summer or decreasing it in winter can help your body adapt to different temperatures, potentially leading to energy savings and a reduced carbon footprint. Keep track of how you feel and any changes in your energy bill to see the impact over time.
  • Incorporate plants and greenery into your living space to improve air quality and provide natural cooling.
  • Houseplants can absorb toxins and release moisture into the air, which can help cool your home. Consider plants like snake plants or spider plants that are easy to care for and effective at improving indoor air quality. Additionally, planting shade trees outside can shield your home from direct sunlight, naturally lowering indoor temperatures.

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
How Air-Conditioning Conquered America

Personal and historical experiences with air conditioning

Emily Badger recounts her personal experiences with air conditioning, reflecting changing attitudes and the technology's spread in American life over the past century.

Emily Badger's personal experience with air conditioning growing up in Chicago

Emily Badger grew up in an old brick three-flat apartment building in Chicago without air conditioning, which was typical at the time. She and her family used passive cooling techniques, such as cross breezes from opened windows and Lake Michigan's breeze. Emily recalls employing strategies like taking cold showers or eating ice cream to cope with the heat. She can't even remember if her schools had air conditioning, indicating it was not a significant part of her childhood or a comfort she often considered.

Emily's shift to an air-conditioned environment when moving to Florida after college

After college, Emily moved to Orlando for her first job and encountered a lifestyle completely reliant on air conditioning. In stark contrast to her upbringing in Chicago, she found herself constantly moving from one air-conditioned space to another—apartment, car, office, and bars were all climate-controlled.

The gradual spread of air conditioning into American homes and culture over the 20th century

Emily explains how air conditioning, invented at the beginning of the 20th century by Willis Carrier, initially focused on controlling temperature, humidity, and air purity for industrial purposes, like in a printing plant where humidity interfered with the printing process. Over time, this technology moved from industrial settings to places like theaters, where it was used as a marketing tool to draw people in.

As the technology advanced and became more affordable, it made its way into American homes through w ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Personal and historical experiences with air conditioning

Additional Materials

Counterarguments

  • While air conditioning has become a standard feature in many homes, there is a growing concern about its environmental impact, including high energy consumption and the release of hydrofluorocarbons (HFCs) which are potent greenhouse gases.
  • The reliance on air conditioning could be seen as a lack of adaptation to local climates, with some arguing for the design of buildings that naturally stay cooler without the need for artificial cooling.
  • The widespread use of air conditioning has been linked to increased energy demands, which can strain power grids and lead to outages during heatwaves when the demand is highest.
  • There is a socioeconomic aspect to consider, as not everyone can afford the luxury of air conditioning, which can exacerbate issues of inequality during extreme heat events.
  • Some health experts argue that over-reliance on air conditioning may lead to a decrease in people's tolerance to natural temperatures, potentially affecting their health and well-being.
  • The narrative that ...

Actionables

  • You can experiment with passive cooling in your own home by strategically opening windows on opposite sides to create a cross breeze on cooler days instead of immediately turning on the air conditioning.
    • This not only helps you become more energy-efficient but also allows you to understand how air flows through your living space. For example, you might open a window on a shaded side of your house and another directly across to encourage a natural flow of air, cooling your space without using electricity.
  • Try taking a 'thermal audit' of your home to identify areas where you can improve insulation or seal leaks, reducing the need for constant air conditioning.
    • Use a simple infrared thermometer to detect hot spots around windows, doors, and walls. Once you've identified these areas, you can apply weather stripping or insulation to keep cool air in and hot air out, potentially lowering your reliance on air conditioning and saving ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
How Air-Conditioning Conquered America

Architectural and urban development impacts of air conditioning

Air conditioning has fundamentally altered the course of architectural and urban development. The way buildings interact with the outdoor environment has shifted from natural cooling strategies to a dependence on technology to manage interior climates.

How buildings were designed to interact with the outdoor climate before air conditioning

Prior to the widespread adoption of air conditioning, architectural design was informed by local climates and the need to manage indoor temperatures through design features that worked with the environment.

Homes and buildings were thoughtfully designed with features like thick walls, raised foundations, and porches to passively cool and ventilate spaces

In areas like the southwest U.S., homes adapted to the heat with features such as thick adobe walls that acted as natural insulators. Southeastern homes were constructed with raised foundations to avoid heat absorbed from the ground and equipped with large windows to facilitate cross-ventilation. Widespread strategies also included high ceilings to keep living spaces cool by allowing hot air to rise above.

The architectural styles and layouts of buildings varied based on the local climate, creating regional diversity

Emily Badger explains that these climate-adaptive features led to a diversity of architectural styles across regions. Buildings in Georgia were markedly different from those in Arizona or Chicago because each was designed to meet the specific climatic challenges of its location.

How air conditioning has fundamentally changed building design

With the advent of air conditioning, the necessity to marry building design with the natural elements for cooling has diminished, leading to changes in the way buildings are constructed and experienced.

Modern buildings are engineered to be hermetically sealed from the outdoor environment, with features like non-opening windows, that make them dependent on air conditioning

Modern buildings, including the iconic tall glass office towers that are recognizable around the world, operate as greenhouses and would be unbearable without air conditioning. These structures are designed to be airtight, often with non-opening windows, separating the internal climate completely from the outdoors.

Emily Badger highlights that t ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Architectural and urban development impacts of air conditioning

Additional Materials

Clarifications

  • Hermetically sealed buildings are structures designed to be completely airtight, preventing air exchange with the outside environment. This tight seal is achieved through features like non-opening windows and sealed doors. Such buildings rely heavily on artificial climate control systems like air conditioning to regulate temperature and air quality. The design of hermetically sealed buildings prioritizes maintaining a controlled interior environment separate from external weather conditions.
  • Energy-intensive building designs typically refer to structures that consume significant amounts of energy for their operation, particularly for heating, cooling, and lighting. These buildings often feature characteristics like extensive use of glass, large floor areas, and complex HVAC systems that contribute to high energy consumption. The reliance on air conditioning in such designs can lead to increased energy costs and environmental impacts due to the continuous need for climate control. Efforts to reduce energy intensity in buildings involve implementing strategies to improve energy efficiency, utilize renewable energy sources, and enhance overall sustainability.
  • Tall glass office towers are modern skyscrapers characterized by their extensive use of glass in their facades. These buildings are designed to be visually striking and often house offices and commercial spaces. The glass exteriors allow natural light to penetrate deep into the building, creating bright and open interior spaces. Tall glass office towers are a common sight in many urban landscapes and are often associated with contemporary architecture.
  • "Climatically managing spaces" involves controlling the indoor environment of a building to ensure comfort and functionality. This includes regulating factors like temperature, humidity, and air quality to create a suitable indoor climate. Techniques such as heating, ventilation, and air conditioning (HVAC) systems are commonly used to achieve this control. The goal is to optimize the indoor conditions for occupants' well-being and productivity.
  • Architectural evolution and energy-consuming designs in the context of air conditioning refer to ...

Counterarguments

  • While air conditioning has influenced architectural design, it is not the sole factor; economic, cultural, and technological changes also play significant roles.
  • Some traditional buildings were still uncomfortable in extreme climates despite natural cooling strategies, and air conditioning has improved livability and productivity.
  • The assertion that all modern buildings are hermetically sealed and dependent on air conditioning overlooks the trend in sustainable design that incorporates both natural and mechanical ventilation systems.
  • The diversity in architectural styles was not solely due to climate but also influenced by available materials, cultural preferences, and historical styles.
  • The development of energy-intensive buildings is also a result of other factors like urban density, land values, and the desire for panoramic views, not just the availability of air conditioning.
  • There is a growing movement ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
How Air-Conditioning Conquered America

Environmental and energy-related implications of air conditioning

Air conditioning has become an essential part of modern life, particularly in hotter climates. Despite the comfort it provides, this technology has significant environmental and energy-related implications that are increasingly concerning.

The huge energy demands of air conditioning and its contribution to greenhouse gas emissions

Buildings account for around 30% of U.S. greenhouse gas emissions, much of which is due to the energy required to power air conditioning systems

In the United States, buildings contribute to approximately 30% of greenhouse gas emissions. A substantial portion of this is attributable to the energy needed for heating and cooling, especially from systems like air conditioning that require significant electricity, often produced from the burning of fossil fuels.

The design of many modern buildings, optimized for air conditioning, has led to high energy consumption that is unsustainable

Modern buildings are often designed with air conditioning in mind, resulting in structures that are sealed from the outdoor environment, maximizing the efficiency of climate control systems. However, this detachment from the natural environment leads to a cycle of high energy consumption that is not sustainable in the long run, both from an environmental and an energetic perspective.

The vulnerability created by over-reliance on air conditioning

When air conditioning fails, often during extreme heat events, it can put millions of people at risk, especially in regions that have become heavily populated due to the presence of air conditioning

The heavy reliance on air conditioning creates a vulnerability during extreme weather events. When these systems fail, particularly during periods of intense heat, millions are put at risk. This risk is exacerbated in densely populated regions, where the availability of air conditioning has been a significant factor in their development and continued ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Environmental and energy-related implications of air conditioning

Additional Materials

Clarifications

  • The buildings in the United States contribute to approximately 30% of greenhouse gas emissions, with a significant portion stemming from the energy required for heating and cooling systems like air conditioning.
  • Buildings optimized for air conditioning are designed with features like sealed windows and insulation to maximize the efficiency of cooling systems. This design approach aims to create a controlled indoor environment that minimizes heat exchange with the outdoors. By reducing heat gain and loss, these buildings require less energy to maintain comfortable temperatures, but this design can lead to high energy consumption in the long term.
  • During extreme heat events, the failure of air conditioning systems can pose serious risks to human health and safety, especially in densely populated areas where reliance on cooling is high. The inability to maintain comfortable indoor temperatures can lead to heat-related illnesses and even fatalities, highlighting the critical role of air conditioning in protecting individuals from extreme heat. The reliance on air conditioning in such regions has shaped urban development patterns, making populations more vulnerable when these systems malfunction. This vulnerability underscores the importance of resilient infrastructure and emergency preparedness to mitigate the impacts of air conditioning failures during heatwaves.
  • Air conditioning allows people to live comfortably in regions with extreme climates that w ...

Counterarguments

  • Buildings' contribution to greenhouse gas emissions is a complex issue, and while air conditioning is a factor, other elements such as heating, lighting, and electronic equipment also play significant roles.
  • Modern building designs may incorporate energy-efficient technologies and materials that reduce overall energy consumption, including that of air conditioning systems.
  • The vulnerability during extreme heat events is not solely due to over-reliance on air conditioning but also due to other factors such as power grid reliability, building insulation quality, and emergency preparedness.
  • Human settlement in harsh climates has been facilitated by various technologies and innovations, not just air conditioning, and these regions can be sustainable wi ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
How Air-Conditioning Conquered America

Cultural and societal changes driven by air conditioning

Air conditioning has significantly shaped our societal expectations regarding comfort while also influencing social behavior and demographics.

How air conditioning has shaped our expectations and relationship to comfort

The presence of air conditioning has established a cultural norm of expecting a constant and perfectly controlled indoor temperature. This has led people to be less tolerant of natural temperature variations, creating a sense of entitlement to comfort. The ingrained need for a comfort level set between 68-72 degrees Fahrenheit, as Emily Badger notes, is a social construct developed over decades by the air conditioning industry, architects, builders, and culture at large.

Discussing air conditioning within the context of climate change highlights the need to adjust our relationship with indoor comfort. Behaviors such as delaying the use of air conditioning, turning it off at night, or being comfortable with warmer temperatures while sleeping are suggested changes. Nonetheless, these changes challenge deeply established norms, as the conversation acknowledges the difficulty of asking people to endure discomfort even for sustainability's benefits.

The prevalence of air conditioning and difficulties in sustainability

Air conditioning's pervasive reach across the country has framed modern life around the convenience it offers, bringing about the expectation and perceived entitlement to comfort. This expectation is now deeply rooted in culture and not confined to specific regions, presenting a broad challenge in encouraging sustainable habits regarding air conditioning use.

The social and behavioral changes brought about by air conditioning

Air cond ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Cultural and societal changes driven by air conditioning

Additional Materials

Clarifications

  • The comfort level set between 68-72 degrees Fahrenheit is a social construct influenced by the air conditioning industry, architects, builders, and cultural norms. It represents the ideal temperature range for indoor spaces that has been widely promoted and accepted over decades. This range is considered the standard for comfort in many modern buildings and homes, reflecting a societal expectation for a controlled and consistent indoor environment. The prevalence of this specific temperature range showcases how air conditioning has shaped our perception of comfort and influenced our daily lives.
  • Encouraging sustainable habits regarding air conditioning use involves promoting behaviors like adjusting temperature settings, using energy-efficient systems, and reducing overall reliance on air conditioning to lessen environmental impact and energy consumption. This can be challenging due to deeply ingrained cultural norms around indoor comfort, the convenience air conditioning provides, and the resistance to enduring discomfort even for sustainability's sake. Balancing comfort expectations with environmental concerns requires a shift in mindset and behavior towards more conscious and responsible cooling practices.
  • The American Sun Belt is a region in the southern United States k ...

Counterarguments

  • While air conditioning has set a norm for controlled indoor temperatures, it can also be argued that this expectation is a natural evolution of technological advancement and human progress, similar to expectations for clean water or electricity.
  • Some individuals and cultures may still have a high tolerance for natural temperature variations, especially in regions where air conditioning is not as prevalent or culturally significant.
  • The sense of entitlement to comfort could be seen as a desire for improved quality of life, which is a legitimate aspiration for many people.
  • The standard comfort level of 68-72 degrees Fahrenheit, while influenced by social constructs, may also be based on research suggesting these temperatures can improve productivity and health.
  • The relationship with indoor comfort and climate change is complex, and some argue that modern air conditioning is becoming more energy-efficient, reducing its environmental impact.
  • Suggested changes to air conditioning habits may not be practical or healthy for all individuals, such as those with certain medical conditions that require consistent temperature control.
  • The cultural shift towards convenience is not solely due to air conditioning but is part of a broader trend towards technology making life easier in many respects.
  • Air conditioning may have changed social ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free

Create Summaries for anything on the web

Download the Shortform Chrome extension for your browser

Shortform Extension CTA