Podcasts > The Daily > The American Journalist on Trial in Russia

The American Journalist on Trial in Russia

By The New York Times

In an episode exploring the arrest and detention of Wall Street Journal journalist Evan Gershkovich in Russia, The Daily delves into the increasingly hostile climate for foreign journalists in Moscow. Correspondent Anton Troianovski sheds light on Gershkovich's background and the Kremlin's calculated move to accuse him of espionage, likely aiming to strengthen Russia's stance and facilitate a prisoner swap with the U.S.

The episode offers insights into Gershkovich's harsh confinement conditions and the expected trajectory of his trial, which will likely lead to a conviction despite a lack of evidence. While a guilty verdict is anticipated due to Russia's skewed judicial system, Gershkovich's best hope may lie in becoming a bargaining chip for a prisoner exchange.

Listen to the original

The American Journalist on Trial in Russia

This is a preview of the Shortform summary of the Jul 3, 2024 episode of the The Daily

Sign up for Shortform to access the whole episode summary along with additional materials like counterarguments and context.

The American Journalist on Trial in Russia

1-Page Summary

Evan Gershkovich's background

Evan Gershkovich's Russian roots, stemming from his Soviet Jewish immigrant parents, cultivated his proficiency in Russian and interest in the country. His journalism career advanced from the Moscow Times to respected foreign correspondent for the Wall Street Journal.

Hostile climate for journalists in Russia

Anton Troianovski notes the increasingly hostile environment for foreign journalists in Moscow prior to and after the 2022 Ukraine invasion. The "fake news" law imposed severe penalties for misspeaking about the war, prompting Gershkovich and others to temporarily leave Russia.

Gershkovich's arrest approved by the Kremlin

The FSB's March 2023 announcement of Gershkovich's detention on espionage charges suggests Kremlin approval, signaling Putin's calculated move to escalate tensions with the West. Troianovski reveals Putin likely aims to strengthen Russia's stance, create challenges for Western powers, and potentially facilitate a prisoner swap with the U.S.

Gershkovich's harsh confinement conditions

Gershkovich is held in the notoriously isolating Lefortovo prison, spending 23 hours per day confined to a small cell under constant lighting. His only link to the outside is censored correspondence, yet he maintains humor and resilience.

Trial expected to lead to conviction and prisoner swap

With a 99% conviction rate in Russian courts, Gershkovich's closed-door trial is widely expected to convict him. However, his best hope lies in negotiations for a prisoner swap between the U.S. and Russia, with Putin potentially using Gershkovich as leverage to secure the release of Russians imprisoned abroad.

1-Page Summary

Additional Materials

Counterarguments

  • The assertion that the Kremlin approved Gershkovich's arrest on espionage charges could be challenged by suggesting that the FSB operates with a degree of autonomy and that not all actions necessarily reflect direct orders from the Kremlin.
  • While the text suggests that Putin's involvement is to escalate tensions with the West, an alternative view could be that the arrest was a matter of national security from the Russian perspective, independent of broader geopolitical strategies.
  • The idea that Gershkovich's harsh confinement conditions are notorious could be countered by pointing out that such conditions are not unique to Russia and can be found in high-security prisons around the world, including in the United States.
  • The expectation of a conviction in Gershkovich's trial could be seen as presumptive, as every trial should be viewed as subject to the presentation of evidence and the rule of law, despite statistical trends.
  • The notion of a prisoner swap being Gershkovich's best hope might be challenged by the possibility of diplomatic efforts or legal appeals within the Russian system that could lead to a different outcome.
  • The suggestion that Putin is using Gershkovich as leverage could be countered by arguing that such a strategy, if true, might not be solely for the purpose of exchanging prisoners but could also be aimed at internal politics or reinforcing certain laws and policies domestically.

Actionables

  • You can enhance your understanding of international journalism by learning basic Russian phrases and familiarizing yourself with Russian news outlets. This will give you a better grasp of the challenges faced by journalists like Evan Gershkovich and the nuances of reporting from countries with different press freedoms. Start with free online resources or apps dedicated to language learning and seek out English translations of Russian journalism to compare perspectives.
  • Develop a habit of writing to elected representatives to express concerns about press freedom and specific cases like Evan Gershkovich's. This action can contribute to political pressure for change. Research the correct contact information for your representatives, draft a concise letter outlining your concerns, and encourage friends and family to do the same to amplify the impact.
  • Engage in digital security practices to protect your online communications, inspired by the restricted communication faced by Gershkovich. Use encrypted messaging apps and email services for sensitive conversations, and educate yourself on digital privacy rights and tools. This not only secures your own information but also raises awareness about the importance of communication security in restrictive environments.

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
The American Journalist on Trial in Russia

Evan Gershkovich's background and the changing landscape for foreign journalists in Russia

Exploring Evan Gershkovich’s roots and the shifting conditions for foreign journalists in Russia reveals a complex interplay between personal heritage and professional challenges in a rapidly changing press landscape.

Gershkovich's Russian roots and journey into journalism

Evan Gershkovich grew up in a household steeped in the Russian language and culture after his Soviet Jewish parents emigrated to the U.S. in 1979. This environment fostered both his personal and professional interest in Russia, shaping his path as a journalist.

From the Moscow Times to the Wall Street Journal

Gershkovich's proficiency in Russian and his deep-rooted interest in the country’s affairs propelled him from an entry-level role at the Moscow Times to becoming an experienced and respected foreign correspondent for the Wall Street Journal. His work reflected a nuanced understanding of the Russian socio-political landscape.

Hostile climate pre- and post-invasion of Ukraine

Foreign correspondents once navigated a thriving journalism scene in Moscow, but the ambience has grown hostile over time, especially with the events leading up to and following the 2022 invasion of Ukraine.

Tightened restrictions and risks for journalists

Prior to the invasion, Anton Troianovski noted the increasingly hostile environment in Russia toward journalists. Despite such conditions, foreign correspondents like Gershkovich manag ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Evan Gershkovich's background and the changing landscape for foreign journalists in Russia

Additional Materials

Counterarguments

...

Actionables

  • Explore your family's heritage to deepen your understanding of global issues by researching the history and current events of your ancestors' country of origin, which can provide personal insights into international affairs.
  • Develop language skills relevant to your heritage or interests through online courses or language exchange meetups, as this can open up opportunities in international careers or understanding foreign media.
  • Stay info ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
The American Journalist on Trial in Russia

The circumstances and political motivations behind Gershkovich's arrest and detention

The arrest of American journalist Evan Gershkovich in March 2023 has drawn considerable attention due to the circumstances of his detention and the political motivations likely driving it.

Kremlin Approval and Direct Involvement

On March 29, 2023, Evan Gershkovich went missing while reporting in Yekaterinburg. Shortly after preliminary reports of his disappearance, the FSB announced his detention on suspicions of espionage, alleging that he had been gathering information for the United States regarding Russia's military-industrial complex. The Kremlin's spokesman, Dmitry Peskov, stated that Gershkovich was caught "red-handed," signaling the Kremlin's direct approval and possible order for the arrest. Anton Troianovski observes that this stance from the Kremlin indicates a calculated move to escalate tensions with the West, especially as President Vladimir Putin uses the incident to strengthen Russia's stance and create challenges for Western powers.

Escalating Tensions and Cracking Down on Journalism

Troianovski reveals that Evan Gershkovich’s parents had previously fled the Soviet Union to escape repression, yet now their son faces repression under a very similar regime. The decision to detain Gershkovich is seen as Putin's strategic move to intensify the conflict with the West. Furthermore, Putin is explicitly using Gershkovich's arrest to suggest readiness to push boundaries with the West and as a bargaining chip to possibly exchange prisoners with the United States.

Broader Political Conflict and Suppressi ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

The circumstances and political motivations behind Gershkovich's arrest and detention

Additional Materials

Counterarguments

...

Actionables

  • You can enhance your media literacy by researching the signs of state-influenced media to discern bias and propaganda in news reports. Start by looking at various international news sources and compare their coverage of major events, noting the differences in tone, focus, and the presence of certain narratives. This will help you understand how different governments might influence media to serve their own agendas.
  • Develop a habit of supporting independent journalism by subscribing to or donating to organizations that are known for their investigative reporting and independence. By financially contributing to these outlets, you're helping to ensure that there's a counterbalance to state-controlled media, which can be crucial in situations where journalists face risks for their reporting.
  • Engage in conversations with peers about the importance of press freedom, using current even ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
The American Journalist on Trial in Russia

The treatment and conditions of Gershkovich's imprisonment

The conditions of Gershkovich's confinement in the notorious Lefortovo prison in Moscow paint a picture of severe isolation and restriction, though he maintains a lifeline to the outside world through censored correspondence.

Gershkovich has been held in the notoriously isolating Lefortovo prison in Moscow, with extremely limited contact with the outside world.

Gershkovich's confinement at Lefortovo prison is characterized by harsh conditions with a strong emphasis on isolation. This detention center is infamous for its intensely solitary environment where inmates, including Gershkovich, spend 23 hours a day in small cells under constant artificial lighting, contributing to the mental stress and disorientation of prisoners.

Inmates in Lefortovo are kept in small cells for 23 hours a day with the lights constantly on, and even movements through the prison corridors are highly restricted.

The solitude extends to all aspects of life in Lefortovo, where it is clear to the prisoners that they are cut off from each other. This is reinforced by the prison's policy of severely limiting inmate movements through the corridors during any required transfers, ensuring that any sense of connection to the world or fellow inmates remains minimal at best.

The only connection Gershkovich has maintained is the ability to exchange letters with the outside world, which are censored by the prison system.

Despite the severe conditions of his detention, Gershkovich has been permitted a thread of communication with the outside through letters. While this correspondence o ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

The treatment and conditions of Gershkovich's imprisonment

Additional Materials

Counterarguments

...

Actionables

  • You can foster empathy and awareness by writing letters to people in isolated conditions, such as prisoners or the elderly in care homes. By doing this, you not only provide companionship and a link to the outside world for someone who may be experiencing isolation, but you also develop a deeper understanding of the psychological impacts of solitude. For example, you could reach out to organizations that facilitate letter exchanges and commit to writing monthly letters, sharing positive news, and offering moral support.
  • Engage in a personal experiment where you spend a set amount of time in solitude to better understand the effects of isolation. Start with a manageable time frame, like one hour of solitude without any distractions or interactions. Use this time to reflect on your thoughts and feelings, perhaps keeping a journal to document the experience. This can increase your self-awareness and give you a small-scale insight into the challenges faced by those in extreme isolation.
  • Create a humor and resilience journal where you document daily instanc ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
The American Journalist on Trial in Russia

The sham nature of Gershkovich's trial and the prospects for his release through a prisoner swap

As Gershkovich's trial begins in Russia, the outlook within the Russian judicial system appears grim, but opportunities for his release may lie in the political sphere with a possible prisoner swap.

Gershkovich's trial, which has just begun, is widely expected to be a foregone a conclusion, as over 99% of Russian criminal cases result in conviction.

Anton Troianovski points out that with the commencement of Gershkovich's trial, his conviction seems almost certain, noting that more than 99% of Russian criminal cases end in a conviction. The process is shrouded in secrecy, as the trial will be conducted behind closed doors with no public access, under the guise of protecting state secrets. This secrecy comes despite the absence of any credible evidence being presented against Gershkovich.

Gershkovich's best hope for release lies not in the Russian judicial system, but in negotiations for a prisoner swap between the U.S. and Russia.

Troianovski argues that Gershkovich's most realistic chance for freedom is not through the legal process but rather through diplomatic channels—in particular, a prisoner exchange between Vladimir Putin and the United States. The Russians have stated they would only consider an exchange if Gershkovich is convicted.

Evan Gershkovich has, in essence, become a chess piece in the larger geopolitical standoff, with Putin using such arrests to exert pressure and seek out tactical advantages in his ongoing confrontation with the United States. Such tactics are seemingly becoming a pattern, as evidenced by the recent arrests of other foreigners in Russia.

Putin has expressed interest in using Gershkovich as a bargaining chip. One potential exchange highlighted by Troianovski could involve Vadim Krasikov, a Russian imprisoned in Germany for a political assassination. Releasing Krasikov would unde ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

The sham nature of Gershkovich's trial and the prospects for his release through a prisoner swap

Additional Materials

Counterarguments

  • The high conviction rate in Russian criminal cases does not necessarily indicate that every trial is unfair or predetermined; each case may have its own merits and complexities.
  • Secrecy in trials involving state secrets is not unique to Russia and can be a standard practice in many countries to protect national security.
  • Diplomatic negotiations for prisoner swaps are complex and may involve considerations beyond the immediate individuals concerned, including broader geopolitical implications and legal principles.
  • The characterization of Gershkovich as a "bargaining chip" may oversimplify the situation and ignore the legal processes and considerations at play in his case.
  • The suggestion that Putin has little to lose in the situation assumes a specific outcome and does not consider the potential diplomatic costs or internal political consequences of such prisoner swaps.
  • The idea that Western European nations are simply influenced by the U.S. may not fully acknowledge the autonomy and comple ...

Actionables

  • You can enhance your critical thinking by analyzing the dynamics of the Gershkovich case to understand geopolitical strategies. Start by reading about historical prisoner swaps and their outcomes. Compare these with the current situation to identify patterns and tactics used by governments. This will help you develop a keener sense for political maneuvers in international relations.
  • Develop negotiation skills by role-playing scenarios based on the Gershkovich case. Gather a group of friends and assign roles such as the negotiators from the U.S., Russia, and a neutral party. Use the information about the case to simulate a negotiation process for a prisoner swap. This exercise can improve your ability to communicate and negotiate in high-stake situations.
  • You can practice ethical decision-making by creating a personal case st ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free

Create Summaries for anything on the web

Download the Shortform Chrome extension for your browser

Shortform Extension CTA