Baseball’s Plan To Save Itself From Boredom: An Update Podcast Summary with Michael Barbaro, Michael Schmidt, Announcer

Baseball’s Plan To Save Itself From Boredom: An Update

1-Page Summary

MLB's new pace-of-play rules to counter home runs' boring dominance

Major League Baseball (MLB) has introduced new rules to speed up the game, aiming to reduce the dominance of home runs and make the overall experience more dynamic.

Pitch clock and limits on pickoff attempts to speed up game

Commissioner Rob Manfred emphasizes the fans' desire for a faster game, leading to a new pitch clock rule. Pitchers now face a 15 or 20-second clock to deliver pitches, which has notably decreased game duration based on spring training evidence. The addition of restrictions on pickoff attempts further speeds up the action, minimizing unnecessary delays during the game.

Bigger bases to encourage more stolen bases

Bases have been increased in size with dual benefits in mind: enhancing player safety by reducing instances of collision and boosting the strategic value of stolen bases. The adjustment has already made a visibly positive impact on players' attempts and successes in stealing bases.

Restrictions on extreme defensive shifts

By limiting defensive shifts, MLB has created new offensive opportunities. Players can now take advantage of a more evenly distributed defense to create more action with ground balls and base hits.

Under these new regulations, fans are witnessing not only quicker games but also a greater frequency of stolen bases, the highest in over 30 years. These changes promise to bring more variety and excitement to the game, potentially rejuvenating fan interest and increasing game attendance. Commissioner Manfred's reforms seem to be hitting their stride, as both game pace and athletic diversity receive a boost.

1-Page Summary

Additional Materials

Clarifications

A pitch clock in baseball is a timer that limits the time a pitcher has to deliver a pitch. It aims to speed up the game by reducing delays between pitches. In MLB, pitchers now have either 15 or 20 seconds to throw the ball, helping to quicken the pace of play. The introduction of the pitch clock has been shown to decrease game duration and increase the overall speed of the game.
Pickoff attempts in baseball are when a pitcher tries to tag out a baserunner who is leading off the base too far. It is a defensive move to prevent the runner from stealing the next base. The pitcher throws the ball to a fielder positioned near the base the runner is leading off from, hoping to catch the runner off guard and get them out. These attempts are strategic plays that can help control the baserunners' movements and limit their ability to advance.
Defensive shifts in baseball involve positioning fielders in non-traditional locations based on statistical data to counter a batter's tendencies. Teams strategically move fielders to areas where the batter is most likely to hit the ball, aiming to increase the chances of making an out. This strategy has become more prevalent in recent years as teams use advanced analytics to optimize defensive alignments. By limiting extreme defensive shifts, MLB aims to create a more balanced playing field and increase offensive opportunities for hitters.

Counterarguments

The pitch clock may add pressure on pitchers, potentially affecting the quality of pitches and leading to more mistakes or injuries due to rushed preparations.
Restrictions on pickoff attempts could disproportionately benefit base runners, potentially upsetting the balance between offense and defense.
Larger bases might not significantly impact the game's pace or strategy as intended, and traditionalists may view this change as an unnecessary alteration of the game's fundamentals.
Limiting defensive shifts could be seen as a restriction on the strategic complexity of the game, potentially reducing the role of analytics and strategic planning in favor of a more standardized style of play.
While stolen bases have increased, it's unclear if this change will sustain fan interest in the long term or if the novelty will wear off.
The changes may not address other factors contributing to game length and pace, such as the number of commercial breaks or the time between innings.
Some fans may enjoy the strategic depth that home runs and defensive shifts bring to the game, and might not find the faster pace and increased stolen bases as engaging.
The impact of these rules on game attendance is uncertain and may be influenced by a variety of factors beyond pace of play, such as team performance, marketing efforts, and economic conditions.
The effectiveness of these rules in rejuvenating fan interest is yet to be fully assessed, as it may take several seasons to determine the long-term impact on the fanbase.

Learn more

New baseball rules for 2023 FAQ - MLB.com

The 2023 Major League Baseball season brings a wave of rules changes collectively aimed at improving the game’s pace of play and increasing action on the field. The arrival of the pitch timer, restrictions on defensive shifts and bigger bases makes for one of the more ambitious adaptations to the rule book in the modern era.

2023 MLB Rules Changes Effect on Stats and Pace of Play

This page attempts to show the statistical impact of MLB's rule changes for the 2023 season. If you have an idea, let us know. We also have all general stats computed on a per-game basis at the three links below. Year-by-year league-wide batting stats; Year-by-year league-wide pitching stats; Year-by-year league-wide fielding stats

Pitch perfect: MLB’s pace-of-play rules are showing that less is more

T he time – emphasis on time – has come to declare that Major League Baseball has nailed its effort to speed up games. MLB people always talked about wanting to finish games in less than three ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.

Get access for free

Baseball’s Plan To Save Itself From Boredom: An Update

MLB's new pace-of-play rules to counter home runs' boring dominance

Major League Baseball unveils significant rule changes aimed at speeding up the game and enhancing athleticism, while countering the dominance of home runs that some fans find monotonous.

Pitch clock and limits on pickoff attempts to speed up game

Commissioner Rob Manfred acknowledges that fans crave a brisker pace, and MLB’s response is a new pitch clock rule. The introduction of a 15 or 20-second clock means that pitchers are encouraged to deliver pitches more quickly, moving the game along faster, and thus shortening overall game times. Spring training games with the new rules were more than 20 minutes shorter compared to the previous year.

In addition to the pitch clock, there is a limitation on the number of pickoff attempts a pitcher can make, which also serves to avoid game delays.

Bigger bases to encourage more stolen bases

The implementation of larger bases is designed to both enhance player safety by reducing collision risk and to encourage more attempts at stolen bases. With bigger bases, players have also discovered that stolen bases are now more valuable within the game.

Restrictions on extreme defensive shifts

Defensive shifts have been restricted to prevent teams from stacking the defense on one side of the field. This opens up more of the field for hitting ground balls or base hits.

Positive impacts in faster, more exciting games

The new rules have successfully made games significantly shorter and more thrill ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!

Start your free trial today

MLB's new pace-of-play rules to counter home runs' boring dominance

Additional Materials

Clarifications

A pitch clock in baseball is a timer used to limit the time a pitcher has to deliver a pitch, aiming to speed up the game. It encourages quicker play by imposing a set time limit for pitchers to throw the ball, reducing delays and shortening game times. The introduction of a pitch clock in MLB has been part of efforts to enhance the pace of play and make games more engaging for fans. The pitch clock rule has been implemented in various baseball leagues globally, including MLB, to improve the flow of the game and increase its excitement.
Pickoff attempts in baseball are when a pitcher tries to tag out a baserunner who is leading off the base too far. It is a defensive move to prevent the runner from stealing a base. The pitcher throws the ball to a fielder positioned near the base the runner is leading off from. This action is aimed at catching the runner off guard and getting them out.
Defensive shifts in baseball involve positioning fielders in non-traditional locations based on data analysis of a batter's tendencies. Teams strategically move fielders to areas where the batter is statistically more likely to hit the ball, aiming to increase the chances of making an out. This strategy is used to counteract hitters who consistently hit the ball to specific parts of the field, disrupting their offensive effecti ...

Counterarguments

The pitch clock may add pressure on pitchers, potentially leading to more mistakes or injuries due to rushed preparations.
Limiting pickoff attempts could disadvantage pitchers by making it easier for base runners to steal bases.
Larger bases might not significantly reduce collision risk if players do not adjust their sliding techniques accordingly.
Restrictions on defensive shifts could be seen as a limitation on strategic aspects of the game, potentially reducing the importance of managerial decisions.
Shorter games might not necessarily equate to more excitement if the changes lead to a perceived dilution of the game's traditional strategies and complexities.
The increase in stolen bases might not appeal to all fans, especially those who enjoy the strategic duel between pitcher and hitter that home runs can represent.
The changes could disproportionately affect certain players, particularly those who have built careers around power hitting or specialized defensive positions.
While the rules aim to make the game ...