Podcasts > The Daily > Biden Supports Israel. Does the Rest of America?

Biden Supports Israel. Does the Rest of America?

By The New York Times

Dive into "The Daily" with Michael Barbaro and his guest Jonathan Weisman for an insightful exploration of the changing American sentiment towards Israel and Palestine in their recent episode. Weisman sheds light on the pronounced shift among younger generations in the United States, who are increasingly empathetic towards Palestinians, upending long-standing perspectives. With the conservative policies of Benjamin Netanyahu's government influencing their view of Israel as an unyielding power rather than a nation seeking peace, young Americans are questioning their government's support, foreshadowing a significant realignment in US foreign policy.

This nuanced discussion captures the complexity of generational divides and how historical events have left an indelible mark on the political consciousness of Millennials and Gen Z. Barbaro and Weisman delve into the implications of these evolving views on the future of US-Israel relations, particularly the potential reevaluation of military and economic aid. As the voices of youth signal a fresh critique of international alliances, Israel faces the challenge of gaining favor with a generation poised to reshape global policies, marking a critical juncture in diplomatic ties.

Listen to the original

Biden Supports Israel. Does the Rest of America?

This is a preview of the Shortform summary of the Dec 22, 2023 episode of the The Daily

Sign up for Shortform to access the whole episode summary along with additional materials like counterarguments and context.

Biden Supports Israel. Does the Rest of America?

1-Page Summary

Younger Americans increasingly sympathize with Palestinians over Israel

Jonathan Weisman reports on a noticeable shift in the attitudes of younger Americans toward the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, with an increasing number of them sympathizing with Palestinians more than Israel. This shift appears to stem from their exposure to a version of Israel shaped largely by the conservative policies of Benjamin Netanyahu's government. The younger demographic, especially those aged 18 to 29, have not experienced the peace processes earlier generations witnessed and have thus only known a powerful Israel resistant to peace. Reflective of this perspective is their approval rating for Biden's handling of the conflict, with only 20% in support, and a clear decrease in sympathy compared to older generations. A significant 46% of 18 to 29-year-olds express sympathy for Palestinians over 27% for Israelis.

Weisman notes that among younger Americans, particularly Generation Z, Israel is increasingly seen as the aggressor rather than the victim—a view largely different from that held by older generations. Historical events like the war in Gaza have been pivotal in shaping these perceptions, leading to a decline in American support among this group.

Israel faces questions about future US support as views shift among younger Americans

Michael Barbaro and Jonathan Weisman discuss how evolving attitudes among young Americans could impact US-Israel relations in the future. They highlight a growing disillusionment with Israel within these younger demographics. Many oppose continued economic and military aid, preferring to see US involvement in the region recalibrated.

Barbaro and Weisman reveal that, due to Millennials' critical view of Netanyahu's stance on the two-state solution and the enduring conflicts, as they come into power, there may be substantial reconsideration and potential reduction of the aid given to Israel.

To maintain the level of US support, Israel might have to engage more actively with these younger generations. The discussions suggest that the rise of Palestinian sympathy could lead to these young adults scrutinizing and potentially cutting military aid to Israel as they assume influential roles.

Israel may witness internal political shifts that could potentially alter young Americans' views of the country. As Israel confronts its existential challenges, there is recognition that it needs to possibly recalibrate its approach to garner support from the younger American population whose disillusionment could have serious implications for future US-Israel relations.

1-Page Summary

Additional Materials

Clarifications

  • Benjamin Netanyahu, a prominent Israeli politician, served as the Prime Minister of Israel for several terms. During his tenure, Netanyahu's government pursued conservative policies that included a strong stance on security and defense, prioritizing Israeli interests in negotiations with Palestinians, and promoting settlement expansion in the West Bank, which drew international criticism. Netanyahu's leadership style and policies often shaped the perception of Israel on the global stage, influencing how different demographics, including younger Americans, viewed the Israeli-Palestinian conflict.
  • US-Israel relations have historically been strong, with the US providing significant economic and military aid to Israel. This aid is seen as crucial for Israel's security and defense. However, shifts in public opinion, especially among younger Americans, could lead to potential changes in the level of aid and support provided to Israel in the future. Israel may need to adapt its approach to engage with younger generations to maintain US support.
  • A shift in younger Americans' attitudes towards Israel, with increasing sympathy for Palestinians, could lead to potential reductions in economic and military aid from the US. This shift may impact future US-Israel relations, as younger generations express disillusionment with Israel's policies and actions. Israel may need to engage more actively with these demographics to maintain support and prevent significant changes in aid levels. The rise of Palestinian sympathy among young Americans could result in them scrutinizing and potentially cutting military aid to Israel as they assume influential roles.
  • The internal political shifts in Israel could influence young Americans' views by potentially altering Israel's policies and approach towards the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. These shifts may impact how Israel is perceived by the younger generation in the U.S., especially if there are changes in leadership or significant policy adjustments. As Israel adapts to address its challenges, such changes could shape the narrative and attitudes of young Americans towards the country.

Counterarguments

  • Sympathy for Palestinians may not solely be due to exposure to conservative Israeli policies but also to increased awareness and sensitivity to human rights issues globally.
  • Some younger Americans may still support Israel based on democratic values, shared interests, and historical alliances.
  • The low approval rating for Biden's handling of the conflict could be influenced by a variety of factors, not just the younger generation's views on Israel.
  • The perception of Israel as an aggressor may not take into account the complex security challenges and existential threats it faces.
  • The historical events shaping perceptions, such as the war in Gaza, are multifaceted, and some may argue that Israel's actions are often defensive.
  • The impact of young Americans' attitudes on future US-Israel relations may be overstated, considering the strong institutional and strategic ties between the two nations.
  • Opposition to economic and military aid to Israel may not reflect a nuanced understanding of the geopolitical importance of the aid for regional stability.
  • Criticism of Netanyahu's stance on the two-state solution may not account for the political and security realities that make the peace process challenging.
  • The potential reduction of aid to Israel by Millennials could undermine the United States' ability to influence the region towards peace.
  • Israel's engagement with younger generations may already be underway through various educational and cultural exchange programs.
  • The rise of Palestinian sympathy does not necessarily translate into a comprehensive understanding of the conflict or its possible resolutions.
  • Internal political shifts in Israel could lead to policies that align more closely with the values of younger Americans, thus changing their perceptions.
  • The need for Israel to recalibrate its approach to garner support may also require a reciprocal understanding and engagement from younger Americans.
  • The implications for future US-Israel relations may evolve as younger Americans gain a deeper understanding of the complexities of international diplomacy and security.

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
Biden Supports Israel. Does the Rest of America?

Younger Americans increasingly sympathize with Palestinians over Israel

Jonathan Weisman explores the changing attitudes of younger Americans toward the conflict between Israel and Palestinians, highlighting a shift in sympathies away from Israel and towards Palestinians.

There is a decline in American support for Israel from older to younger generations

Weisman brings attention to the generational shift in American sentiment toward Israel.

Younger generations mainly know Israel under right-wing Netanyahu government which is not pursuing peace

According to Weisman, Millennials' views on Israel have been significantly coloured by the actions and policies of Benjamin Netanyahu's government. The 18 to 29-year-old demographic in particular has been exposed to an Israel led by a conservative figure who has openly rejected a two-state solution and expressed opposition to peace with Palestinians, resulting in these younger generations never experiencing peace processes and only knowing an Israel that is powerful and not seeking peace. This generational perspective shift becomes apparent when considering the approval ratings for Biden's handling of the conflict, showing only 20% of 18 to 29 year olds in support. Additionally, polling reflects a linear progression of decreasing sympathy from older generations who lived through the Holocaust and Israel's early wars to younger ones who have witnessed an era defined by right-wing politics in Israel, with only 27% of 18 to 29 year olds expressing sympathy for Is ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Younger Americans increasingly sympathize with Palestinians over Israel

Additional Materials

Clarifications

  • Benjamin Netanyahu's government, known for its right-wing stance, has been criticized for its settlement expansion in the West Bank, which is seen as a barrier to peace negotiations. Netanyahu has been vocal in his opposition to a two-state solution, a key element in resolving the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. His government's military actions in Gaza, including airstrikes and blockades, have drawn international scrutiny and condemnation. Netanyahu's policies have been perceived by critics as prioritizing Israeli security over pursuing peace with the Palestinians.
  • The war in Gaza referenced as the seminal event for Generation Z is likely alluding to the conflict between Israel and Hamas in Gaza, which has been ongoing for years. This specific conflict, marked by intense violence and casualties, may have had a significant impact on shaping the perceptions and attitudes of Generation Z individuals towards Israel and the Palestinia ...

Counterarguments

  • The perception of Israel as not pursuing peace could be challenged by pointing out efforts and offers made by Israel for peace negotiations that were not accepted by Palestinian leadership.
  • The view of Israel as a bully overlooks the complex security challenges it faces, including terrorism and rocket attacks from groups like Hamas, which necessitate strong military responses.
  • The generational shift in sentiment might not fully account for the diversity of opinions among younger Americans, some of whom may support Israel due to shared democratic values or concerns about anti-Semitism.
  • The focus on Netanyahu's government may ignore the broader historical context of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, including periods when Israel was led by more centrist or left-wing governments that actively sought peace.
  • The decline in support for Israel among younger Americans could be a reflection of broader trends in political ideology, such as a rise in progressive values that emphasize human rights and social justice, rather than a specific indictment of Israeli policies.
  • The war in Gaza is often presented without the context of the provocations that led to it, such as the kidnapping and murder of I ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
Biden Supports Israel. Does the Rest of America?

Israel faces questions about future US support as views shift among younger Americans

Michael Barbaro and Jonathan Weisman examine the changing attitudes among younger Americans toward Israel and how this shift could impact the future of US-Israel relations.

Young Americans are skeptical of Israel and may reduce aid when in power

Barbaro and Weisman explore the generational gap within the Democratic Party and note that younger demographics are becoming increasingly disillusioned with the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. This disillusionment among younger voters is substantial; many oppose further economic and military aid to Israel.

They discuss the growing skepticism towards Israel among these younger Americans, which goes beyond mere skepticism due to the disapproval of Israel's actions. Millennials, in particular, are more aware of Prime Minister Netanyahu's opposition to a two-state solution and view the Middle East as a region full of division and conflict. This perspective may cause them to reconsider the current level of support and aid provided to Israel as they rise to positions of influence and power.

Israel may need to appeal to young Americans to maintain US support

The discussions by Barbaro and Weisman suggest that as these younger Americans mature and influence policy, the US's dynamic with Israel could become increasingly strained. Given the rapid growth of sympathy for Palestinians among this demographic, the likelihood that they might scrutinize and potentially cut military aid to Israel appears to be growing.

The potential deepening disillusionment of young Americans cou ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Israel faces questions about future US support as views shift among younger Americans

Additional Materials

Clarifications

  • Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu of Israel has been known for his strong stance on security and defense issues, often advocating for a tough approach towards threats faced by Israel. He has been a vocal critic of the Iran nuclear deal and has emphasized the importance of Israel's security above all else. Netanyahu's policies have sometimes been controversial, especially regarding settlements in the West Bank, which have drawn criticism from the international community. Additionally, Netanyahu's opposition to a two-state solution for the Israeli-Palestinian conflict has been a significant point of contention, as it contrasts with the views of many other world leaders and organizations advocating for a two-state resolution.
  • A significant shift in Israeli politics could involve changes in leadership, policies, and priorities within the Israeli government. This shift may impact how Israel approaches key issues like the Israeli-Palestinian conflict and its relationship with the United States. It could lead to internal debates and reforms that shape Israel's stance on critical matters, potentially influencing how the country is perceived internationally. Such a shift could have ripple effects on various aspects of Israeli society and its interactions with other nations.
  • The United States provides significant military and economic aid to Israel, which has been a cornerstone of the U.S.-Israel relationship for decades. This aid is primarily aimed at bolstering Israel's security and defense capabilities in a volatile region. The support includes military assistance, such as funding for defense systems and equipment, as well as economic aid to help with various development projects and initiatives in I ...

Counterarguments

  • Younger Americans' disillusionment with the Israeli-Palestinian conflict may not fully account for the complexity of the situation or the historical context that has shaped current policies.
  • Opposition to further economic and military aid to Israel among younger Americans might overlook the strategic importance of Israel as a US ally in the Middle East.
  • Awareness of Prime Minister Netanyahu's stance on a two-state solution may not consider the diversity of opinions within Israel or the political constraints he faces.
  • Viewing the Middle East solely as a region of division and conflict could ignore the efforts towards peace and cooperation that have occurred.
  • The assumption that younger Americans will reconsider support and aid to Israel as they gain power may not take into account the potential for their views to evolve with age and experience.
  • The idea that Israel must appeal to young Americans to maintain US support could underestimate the influence of other demographic groups and the bipartisan nature of support for Israel.
  • The potential strain in the US-Israel dynamic as younger Americans mature and influence policy may not manifest if geopolitical realities necessitate continued strong relations.
  • Growing sympathy towards Palestinians among younger Americans might not translate into policy changes due to the complex nature of international diplomacy and national security considerations.
  • The possibility of younger Americans scrutinizing and potentially cutting military aid to Israel does not consider the legisl ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free

Create Summaries for anything on the web

Download the Shortform Chrome extension for your browser

Shortform Extension CTA