Podcasts > The Ben Shapiro Show > The Clock Chimes Doom For TikTok

The Clock Chimes Doom For TikTok

By Ben Shapiro

In the latest episode of The Ben Shapiro Show, Ben Shapiro, alongside a diverse panel including Senator Ted Cruz, Senator Rand Paul, Representatives Eric Swalwell and Matt Gaetz, experts like Rebecca Zimmerman, officials such as Karine Jean-Pierre and Janet Yellen, and political figures Jill Biden and Kristi Noem, delve into the pressing issue of TikTok's future in the United States. The conversation weaves through the intricacies of the "Protecting Americans from Foreign Adversary Controlled Applications Act," exploring its implications on civil liberties and the growing bipartisan concern regarding the app's influence on American culture, as well as national security worries stemming from its Chinese ownership.

Furthermore, the discussion shifts to the evolving political landscape as Shapiro unpacks the decline in President Biden's approval ratings among black and Hispanic voters. Through data analysis and reference to polls, the episode sheds light on the Democratic party's waning grip on historically reliable voter blocks, as well as the implications of the President's policy directions. The episode also scrutinizes the Democrats' heavy bet on abortion policy as the midterms loom near, casting a critical gaze on the efficacy of roping in celebrities to sway voter sentiments. With perspectives from a spectrum of lawmakers and commentators, the podcast examines these pivotal strategies and their potential consequences on upcoming elections.

Listen to the original

The Clock Chimes Doom For TikTok

This is a preview of the Shortform summary of the Mar 14, 2024 episode of the The Ben Shapiro Show

Sign up for Shortform to access the whole episode summary along with additional materials like counterarguments and context.

The Clock Chimes Doom For TikTok

1-Page Summary

Divestment of Chinese ownership of TikTok

The United States House of Representatives has passed a significant bill to coerce ByteDance, the Chinese parent company of TikTok, to relinquish its ownership due to worries over national security. Legislators are concerned about the potential influence of apps like TikTok on American politics and culture. In addressing the legal repercussions, Shapiro brings up the overwhelming Congressional vote for the ban, highlighting the civil liberties objections tied to the First Amendment and property rights issues related to the Fifth Amendment mentioned by Senator Rand Paul. The primary piece of legislation, known as the "Protecting Americans from Foreign Adversary Controlled Applications Act," spearheaded by Representatives Gallagher and Krishnamoorthi, seeks to remove App Store availability and U.S. web hosting for ByteDance applications. Despite Donald Trump's inconsistent views on the issue, likely influenced by a major Republican donor involved in TikTok, Biden has signaled willingness to sign the bill into law. The legislation has considerable bipartisan backing, despite concerns regarding the sufficiency of debate and transparency of national security issues.

Biden's decline in the polls among black and Hispanic voters

Recent trends indicate a shrinking Democratic hold on key voter blocks, with President Biden experiencing a particular decline among black and Hispanic voters. Data reveals the lowest Democratic margins with these groups in over sixty years, signaling a worrying trend for Biden and his party. The noticeable shift of Latino voters toward Republican affiliation over the past two decades has become more apparent. Shapiro cites a New York Times-Siena College poll showing a significant drop in non-white American support for Biden, potentially caused by the President's further lean into left-wing policies that may not align well with the moderate and conservative social views of black and Hispanic voters respectively.

Democrats betting on abortion policy in the midterms

As midterms approach, the Democratic Party is focusing intensely on abortion, centering their campaign around the Roe vs. Wade decision. They are leveraging public figures like First Lady Jill Biden and celebrities such as Christina Aguilera and Olivia Rodrigo to deliver their abortion rights message conspicuously. While Rodrigo takes a direct approach by handing out Plan B pills at concerts, the enlistment of such high-profile individuals as part of the political strategy is nonetheless met with skepticism by analysts like Shapiro. He suggests that celebrity endorsement may not effectively resonate with swing voters, referencing historical examples where such tactics have been less influential in shaping voter behavior.

1-Page Summary

Additional Materials

Clarifications

  • President Biden's decline in support among black and Hispanic voters can be attributed to his administration's perceived shift towards left-wing policies that may not align with the moderate and conservative social views held by these voter groups. This shift has led to a noticeable decrease in non-white American support for Biden, as highlighted in recent polls. The trend is particularly significant among Latino voters, who have shown a growing inclination towards Republican affiliation over the past two decades. This decline in support underscores the challenge faced by the Democratic Party in maintaining its traditional voter base while navigating evolving political landscapes.
  • The shift of Latino voters toward Republican affiliation over the past two decades can be attributed to various factors such as religious beliefs, conservative social values, and economic interests. Republicans have made efforts to engage with Latino communities, addressing issues like entrepreneurship, family values, and anti-socialism, resonating with some Latino voters. This shift is not uniform across all Latino subgroups, with differences in voting patterns based on factors like age, region, and country of origin. The Republican Party's outreach strategies and messaging have played a role in attracting Latino voters who may feel disillusioned with the Democratic Party.
  • The Democratic Party is using public figures and celebrities like Jill Biden, Christina Aguilera, and Olivia Rodrigo to promote their stance on abortion rights. They are employing these high-profile individuals to bring attention to the importance of protecting abortion rights, especially in the context of the Roe vs. Wade decision. This strategy aims to engage and mobilize supporters by using well-known personalities to advocate for the party's position on this contentious issue. However, there is skepticism about whether celebrity endorsements will effectively sway swing voters or impact voter behavior significantly.
  • The effectiveness of celebrity endorsements in influencing swing voters is a topic that involves the use of well-known figures to support political candidates or causes. While celebrities can attract attention and generate buzz, their impact on swing voters, who are less ideologically committed and more open to changing their vote, is debated. Some argue that celebrity endorsements may not sway swing voters significantly due to these voters' tendency to weigh a variety of factors beyond celebrity support when making their decisions.

Counterarguments

  • The bill to force ByteDance to divest ownership of TikTok may be criticized for potentially setting a precedent for government overreach into private business, especially if the national security concerns are not transparently substantiated.
  • Some may argue that the influence of apps like TikTok on American politics and culture is overstated and that users are capable of discerning content without government intervention.
  • Concerning civil liberties, there could be an argument that the First Amendment rights of users could be infringed upon if access to platforms like TikTok is restricted.
  • The bipartisan support for the legislation might not fully reflect public opinion, and some may argue that more debate and transparency are needed before such significant decisions are made.
  • The decline in support among black and Hispanic voters for Biden could be interpreted in various ways, with some arguing that it may not necessarily be due to a shift in political alignment but rather a response to specific policies or a broader political climate.
  • The focus on abortion policy by the Democratic Party could be criticized for potentially alienating voters who are concerned with a wider range of issues, such as the economy or healthcare.
  • The use of celebrities in political campaigns could be defended as a legitimate strategy to reach younger demographics and engage them in political discourse.
  • Some may argue that the effectiveness of celebrity endorsements should not be dismissed outright, as they can raise awareness and potentially influence public opinion, especially among fans and followers.

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
The Clock Chimes Doom For TikTok

Divestment of Chinese ownership of TikTok

The House of Representatives has passed a bill aiming to force the divestment of TikTok’s Chinese ownership due to national security concerns, as legislators seek to address the influence of applications like TikTok on American politics and culture.

Details of bipartisan legislation to force ByteDance to divest

Shapiro examines the legal implications of the legislative attempts to force TikTok’s divestment. Congress has voted with an overwhelming majority (352 to 65) to ban TikTok’s owner, ByteDance, from having ownership in the United States. Shapiro discusses the significant First Amendment concerns raised by civil liberties organizations, which argue that content on TikTok is protected free speech. Additionally, Fifth Amendment concerns are raised by Senator Rand Paul, who points out property rights issues for American investors in TikTok and the need to ensure their investment is not unjustly stripped without due process.

The bipartisan legislation, the "Protecting Americans from Foreign Adversary Controlled Applications Act," proposed and pushed by Representatives Mike Gallagher and Raja Krishnamoorthi, aims to prevent App Store availability or web hosting services in the U.S. for ByteDance-controlled applications such as TikTok. This bill addresses concerns that TikTok could be used by the Chinese government to undermine American social unity by promoting politically polarizing content.

Trump flip-flopping on the issue due to Republican donor pressure

Despite this legislative momentum, Donald Trump has shown inconsistent positions on TikTok's presence in the U.S. Though initially in favor of a ban, speculation arises that Republican billionaire and TikTok investor Jeff Yass has swayed Trump's stance through threatened withdrawal of financial suppor ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Divestment of Chinese ownership of TikTok

Additional Materials

Clarifications

  • The national security concerns related to TikTok stem from fears that the Chinese government could potentially access user data and use the platform to influence American politics and culture. Lawmakers worry that TikTok, owned by ByteDance, could be exploited to spread politically divisive content and compromise U.S. social unity. This has led to bipartisan efforts to address these concerns through legislation aimed at restricting Chinese ownership of TikTok in the United States.
  • The First Amendment concerns regarding TikTok content revolve around the argument that the content on TikTok is considered protected free speech. Civil liberties organizations raise these concerns to highlight the potential infringement on users' rights to express themselves on the platform. The debate questions whether restricting TikTok's ownership due to national security reasons could conflict with the constitutional right to free speech. This issue underscores the complex balance between national security interests and individual freedoms in the digital age.
  • The Fifth Amendment concerns related to property rights for American investors in TikTok stem from worries that their investments could be taken away without proper legal procedures or compensation, potentially violating their constitutional rights to due process and protection of property. This issue highlights the legal complexities surrounding the divestment of Chinese ownership of TikTok and the need to balance national security interests with safeguarding the rights of American stakeholders.
  • Jeff Yass is a Republican billionaire and investor in TikTok. He reportedly influenced Trump's stance on TikTok through the threat of withdrawing financial support to Republican politicians. Yass's actions were seen as a way to protect his investments in TikTok amidst the legislative push for divestment.
  • Divesting TikTok's Chinese ownership involves forcing ByteDance, the Chinese company that owns TikTok, to sell its ownership stake in the app due to national security concerns. This process aims to address worries about the influence of Chinese-owned apps like TikTok on American politics and cult ...

Counterarguments

  • The bill may be seen as an overreach of government power into the private sector and international business.
  • The First Amendment concerns suggest that the government's actions could set a precedent for infringing on free speech in digital spaces.
  • The Fifth Amendment concerns highlight the potential for government action to disrupt the legitimate financial interests of American investors without due process.
  • The effectiveness of the legislation in protecting national security may be questioned, as users could potentially find alternative ways to access TikTok or similar apps.
  • The bill could be criticized for potentially harming U.S.-China relations and impacting other areas of trade and cooperation.
  • There may be concerns about the impact on the millions of Americans who use TikTok for entertainment, creative expression, and business.
  • The approach to national security may be seen as reactive rather than proactive, with a focus on individual companies rather than a comprehensive digital policy.
  • The influence of political donors like Jeff Yass could raise broader concerns about the integrity of the political process and the influence of money in politics.
  • The urgency with which the bill is being pushed may not allow for sufficient public debate an ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
The Clock Chimes Doom For TikTok

Biden's decline in the polls among black and Hispanic voters

Recent data reveals a weakening grip of the Democratic Party on its traditional voter bases, with President Biden and congressional Democrats facing new vulnerabilities.

New data showing erosion of traditional Democratic advantages

According to new findings, Democratic advantages with black, Latino, and Asian American voters have dwindled to the lowest margins in over six decades. These changes signify a potential risk for the Democratic leadership, particularly for President Biden. While Latino voters have historically skewed Democratic, there’s been a notable gradual pivot towards Republican affiliation over the last twenty years.

Biden doubling down on left-wing positions further alienating these voters

Shapiro reflects on a New York Times-Siena College poll indicating President Biden's support among non-white Americans has fallen to a 56-44 lead—a stark contrast to the almost 50-point advantage he enjoyed in the 2020 Presidential Election. Commentator ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Biden's decline in the polls among black and Hispanic voters

Additional Materials

Clarifications

  • In the 2020 Presidential Election, Joe Biden, a Democrat, ran against the incumbent President Donald Trump, a Republican. Biden won the election and became the 46th President of the United States. The election saw high voter turnout and was held amidst the backdrop of the COVID-19 pandemic, with a significant portion of votes cast through mail-in ballots. Biden's victory was attributed to strong support from key demographics, including black and Latino voters.
  • Hispanic voters in the United States often prioritize issues related to immigration due to personal or family backgrounds. Many Hispanic voters support policies that prioritize border security and legal immigration processes. This stanc ...

Counterarguments

  • The decline in support among black and Hispanic voters could be due to a variety of factors, not solely President Biden's policy positions. Economic conditions, local issues, or the effectiveness of Republican outreach could also play significant roles.
  • The erosion of traditional Democratic advantages might not be as severe as suggested, considering the complexity of voter behavior and the influence of specific candidates and campaigns that can sway voter preferences in any given election cycle.
  • The shift towards Republican affiliation among Latino voters might be overstated or more nuanced, with many still supporting Democratic candidates and policies, especially on issues like healthcare and workers' rights.
  • The characterization of Biden's policies as "left-wing" could be a matter of perspective, and some voters might see them as centrist or even not progressive enough, depending on their own political views.
  • The 56-44 lead among non-white Americans could still be considered a strong advantage for Democrats, and it's not uncommon for presidential approval ratings to fluctuate during a term.
  • The decline in support from the 2020 Presidential Election could be partly attributed to the unique circumstances of that election, including the response to the Trump administration and the impact ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
The Clock Chimes Doom For TikTok

Democrats betting on abortion policy in the midterms

In the lead-up to the midterm elections, Democrats are doubling down on the abortion issue, a move that some analysts view with skepticism regarding its impact on swing voters.

Jill Biden and celebrities pushing abortion message

Political commentator Shapiro remarks on the strategy adopted by the Democrats who are elevating Roe vs. Wade to a central issue in their campaign. He underscores that this focus comes even though only a small fraction of Americans are in support of abortion up to birth—a position he associates with President Joe Biden.

Additionally, prominent figures such as First Lady Jill Biden and pop star Christina Aguilera are using their platforms to speak out on the matter of Roe vs. Wade and abortion rights. Shapiro highlights this enlistment of celebrities as a tool in political messaging, noting their team-up in the lecture circuit on this contentious topic.

Another significant entry into the political arena is singer Olivia Rodrigo, who is actively engaging her audience on this issue by distributing Plan B pills at her concerts from the Missouri Abo ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Democrats betting on abortion policy in the midterms

Additional Materials

Clarifications

  • The abortion issue being focused on by Democrats revolves around the landmark Supreme Court case Roe v. Wade, which established a woman's legal right to abortion in the United States. Democrats are emphasizing the importance of protecting this right amid concerns about potential challenges to abortion access. This focus on Roe v. Wade is part of a broader effort to defend reproductive rights and access to abortion services. Prominent figures, including celebrities like Jill Biden and Olivia Rodrigo, are using their platforms to advocate for maintaining these rights.
  • The involvement of celebrities like Jill Biden, Christina Aguilera, and Olivia Rodrigo in advocating for abortion rights is a strategic move by Democrats to leverage their influence and reach a wider audience on the issue of Roe vs. Wade. Celebrities often use their platforms to raise awareness about social and political issues, aiming to spark conversations and mobilize support for causes they believe in. By aligning with well-known figures, political campaigns can attract attention and engage with demographics that might not typically be reached through traditional political channels. This tactic can help amplify the message and potentially sway public opinion on contentious topics like abortion rights.
  • Pol ...

Counterarguments

  • The focus on abortion rights by Democrats may resonate with a broader base than suggested, as reproductive rights are a significant concern for many voters, not just a small fraction.
  • Elevating Roe vs. Wade as a central issue could mobilize voters who are concerned about women's rights and healthcare access, which could be a strategic move rather than a narrow focus.
  • The association of President Joe Biden with the position of supporting abortion up to birth may not accurately reflect the nuances of his stance or the Democratic platform on abortion, which typically includes a range of positions and circumstances.
  • Utilizing the platforms of public figures like Jill Biden and Christina Aguilera could effectively raise awareness and foster dialogue on important issues like abortion rights.
  • Celebrities have influence and reach that can be beneficial in raising awareness and potentially affecting public opinion on social and political issues.
  • Olivia Rodrigo's distribution of Plan B pills could be seen as a form of activism and support for reproductive rights, which may resonate with her audience and align with their values.
  • The skepticism about the effectiveness of celebrity endorsements in p ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free

Create Summaries for anything on the web

Download the Shortform Chrome extension for your browser

Shortform Extension CTA