DEI Could Get You Killed In The Operating Room Podcast Summary with Ben Shapiro, Vignesh Raman, Madeline Torres, Ariel Nehemiah, Paris Butler, Letitia Bradford, Tammy Duckworth, Donald Trump, Nikki Haley, Chaya Raichik, Taylor Lorenz

DEI Could Get You Killed In The Operating Room

1-Page Summary

Critical Race Theory / Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion (DEI) in medicine and surgery

Shapiro critically examines the introduction of DEI initiatives within the medical and surgical fields. He argues that these policies may diminish reliance on merit-based competence. Case studies provided include Kaishel Del Rosario, who allegedly caused harm to a patient and spoke about it online, yet faced minimal repercussions from Wake Forest University. Furthermore, Ewan Lou, whose association with Del Rosario did not prevent his hiring at U Penn Health, calls into question the standards used to advance medical professionals.

The selection of surgical residents now emphasizes personal backgrounds over conventional success metrics, as evidenced by Duke University's change after George Floyd's death. This shift towards a holistic review process is seen as possibly prioritizing DEI over qualifications, which may neglect critical medical contributions based on race-related criteria. Shapiro expresses concern that this trend could lead to unqualified surgeons and increasing medical errors, given that medical errors are a leading cause of death, and DEI-based promotions could aggravate the issue.

Illegal immigration and open border policies leading to increased crime

Shapiro and others ignite debate on illegal immigration's impact, asserting a link between open borders and rising crime rates. Shapiro recounts a situation where an illegal immigrant is charged with the murder of a University of Georgia student. He notes the suspect's prior arrest record and his brother's criminal activity as evidence of flaws in U.S. immigration policies, insinuating that these lapses lead to increased violent crime.

Former President Donald Trump establishes a concept of "migrant crime" at CPAC, implying that delinquents are entering the U.S., potentially increasing the risk of violence. Shapiro shows frustration with the legal system that allows known illegal immigrant criminals to remain in the U.S. The collective analysis suggests that current immigration policies directly contribute to growing criminal activity.

Candidate strategies to appeal to high vs. low propensity voters in the 2024 election

Casting an eye towards the 2024 election, Shapiro reports on how Trump and Biden intend to woo voters. Trump's record of engaging low propensity voters, particularly less-educated white males, could compel him to target the center and independent voters as well. Meanwhile, Biden's campaign works to entice minority and young voters, groups traditionally less active in elections.

Strategies discussed include Trump banking on Biden's inability to inspire low propensity voters and Biden's political maneuvers aimed at rallying these same demographics.

Trump's proposed policies in a second term and media attempting to scare voters

Shapiro dissects the media portrayal, specifically Politico's, of Trump's proposed policies for a second term as 'extreme.' Trump's agenda seeks to undo Biden's policies, appoint loyalists over traditionalists to senior positions, and imposes more conservative views in federal courts.

The policies in question involve a 16-week abortion ban, actions against federal climate science directives, tariffs on Chinese goods, and a gradual tapering of essential imports from China. Trump's immigration policies, his National Guard comment, and his stance on NATO contributions and cryptocurrency regulations are also scrutinized by the media, which Shapiro contends, presents these policies as radical rather than objectively assessing their merits and drawbacks.

1-Page Summary

Additional Materials

Clarifications

DEI initiatives in medicine and surgery aim to promote diversity, equity, and inclusion in these fields. Critics argue that these initiatives may shift focus away from merit-based competence, potentially impacting traditional standards for evaluating medical professionals. This shift raises concerns about the potential for unqualified individuals to advance based on factors other than merit, which could have implications for patient care and safety. The debate centers on finding a balance between promoting diversity and maintaining high standards of competence in medical and surgical practices.
In the context of DEI initiatives in medicine and surgery, concerns about unqualified surgeons and increased medical errors arise from the fear that prioritizing diversity and inclusion over traditional qualifications may lead to individuals being promoted based on factors other than merit or competency. This shift in focus towards personal backgrounds and diversity criteria during the selection process could potentially overlook critical skills and experience necessary for medical professionals, ultimately impacting patient care and safety. The worry is that emphasizing DEI in promotions without a strong emphasis on qualifications could result in the placement of individuals who may not possess the necessary skills or expertise, leading to a higher risk of medical errors and compromised patient outcomes.
The link between open borders and rising crime rates is a contentious issue often debated in the context of immigration policies. Critics argue that lax border controls can allow individuals with criminal backgrounds to enter a country illegally, potentially leading to an increase in criminal activities. Specific cases, such as an illegal immigrant being charged with a serious crime like murder, are sometimes highlighted to support the argument that open borders can contribute to rising crime rates. However, it's essential to note that the relationship between immigration policies, border security, and crime rates is complex and multifaceted, with various factors influencing the overall impact on public safety.
The argument presented suggests that flaws in U.S. immigration policies are underscored by instances where illegal immigrants or their relatives engage in criminal activities. This highlights concerns about how individuals with criminal backgrounds or associations are able to enter or remain in the country despite prior offenses. The implication is that these cases point to gaps or inadequacies in the immigration system's ability to prevent individuals with problematic histories from entering or staying in the United States.
Trump's strategy to engage low propensity voters involves targeting individuals who are less inclined to vote, such as less-educated white males, to increase his support base. Biden's focus on minority and young voters aims to mobilize groups that historically have lower voter turnout, potentially boosting his electoral prospects. These strategies reflect the candidates' efforts to appeal to specific demographics that could sway the outcome of the election. By tailoring their approaches to these voter groups, Trump and Biden seek to secure crucial support for their campaigns.
Trump's proposed policies for a second term were labeled 'extreme' by the media due to plans such as a 16-week abortion ban, actions against federal climate science directives, tariffs on Chinese goods, and changes in immigration policies. Additionally, Trump's agenda included appointing loyalists over traditionalists to senior positions, imposing more conservative views in federal courts, and making statements on NATO contributions and cryptocurrency regulations.

Counterarguments

DEI initiatives in medicine and surgery aim to address systemic biases and ensure a diverse workforce, which can improve patient outcomes by providing care that is more culturally competent and inclusive.
Personal backgrounds and experiences can be an important aspect of a medical professional's qualifications, as they can contribute to a more empathetic understanding of patients from diverse backgrounds.
Holistic review processes in resident selection can enhance the quality of care by considering a wider range of factors that contribute to a physician's ability to serve their community effectively.
There is no direct evidence that DEI initiatives lead to unqualified surgeons or increased medical errors; in fact, diversity in healthcare teams can lead to more innovative problem-solving and better patient care.
Studies have shown that immigrants are less likely to commit crimes than native-born citizens, and there is no conclusive evidence that illegal immigration is correlated with higher crime rates.
Immigration policies are complex, and crime rates are influenced by a multitude of factors; focusing solely on immigration status can overlook the broader social and economic issues that contribute to criminal behavior.
Engaging low propensity voters is a legitimate strategy for any political campaign, and both Trump and Biden's efforts to reach out to different demographics reflect the diverse political landscape of the United States.
Political strategies to appeal to various voter groups are common practice in elections and reflect the candidates' attempts to build a broad coalition of support.
Media scrutiny of proposed policies is a normal part of the democratic process, and labeling policies as 'extreme' can be subjective; different media outlets may have varying interpretations based on their editorial stance.
Policy proposals, such as those related to abortion, climate science, tariffs, and immigration, are subject to public debate, and it is the role of the media to present different perspectives to inform the electorate.

Learn more

Critical race theory in medicine - PMC - National Center for ...

Critical race theory is organized around 4 main ideas, referred to by the terms “race consciousness,” “contemporary orientation,” “centring the margins” and “praxis.” 2. Race consciousness refers to an understanding of racialization, or the creation of “race” as a social process that assigns meaning and value to physical and ...

Prioritizing DEI in health care | Deloitte Insights

Health system and plan executives agree that health equity is important, and many of them have made it a strategic priority for 2021. Half of the health care CEOs we surveyed said health equity was among their top three organizational priorities for 2021 (figure 1). Six respondents said that DEI of the workforce—which we define as one of the ...

Diversity and Inclusion: A Review of Effective Initiatives in Surgery

Studies describing interventions for promoting UIM and female matriculation in surgery by type. Six overarching types of intervention were identified in the literature, and one study described using two types, clerkship and holistic review, in its intervention. Studies described interventions targeting women (5/16, 31%), UIM (4/16, 25%), or ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.

Get access for free

DEI Could Get You Killed In The Operating Room

Critical Race Theory / Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion (DEI) in medicine and surgery

Shapiro offers a critical perspective on the impact of Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion (DEI) initiatives in the fields of medicine and surgery, suggesting that they may undermine traditional merit-based measures of competence.

Examples of incompetent/ideologically-driven surgeons being advanced due to DEI mindset

Concerns have been raised about DEI initiatives leading to less competent individuals being advanced within medical fields. Shapiro discusses the case of Kaishel Del Rosario, a medical student from Wake Forest who allegedly injured a conservative patient and bragged about this on Twitter. Remarkably, Wake Forest did not expel or suspend Del Rosario but instead allowed her a voluntary leave of absence without issuing an apology.

Furthermore, U Penn Health hired Ewan Lou, a colleague of Rosario’s who seemed to condone her actions on Twitter. Despite this, Lou was awarded for excellence in patient care by Wake Forest, which raises questions about the criteria being used to advance medical professionals.

Surgeons/professors advocating for DEI and ignoring traditional merit-based metrics

The shift in focus from traditional metrics of success to a candidate's background story during surgical residencies selection processes is criticized. Shapiro flags this as a potential issue, alluding to the risk of advancing less qualified surgeons due to a DEI mindset.

Vignesh Raman discussed Duke’s efforts to diversify their department after the George Floyd incident by focusing less on traditional hiring metrics. Duke moved to a holistic review process, abandoning certain metrics and screens, and choosing instead to learn about an applicant’s life story and their journey into surgery, replacing quantitative evaluations of competence.

Moreover, Shapiro refers to individuals who, influenced by DEI ideologies, express reluctance to recognize the work of white men who only collaborate with other white men. He suggests ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!

Start your free trial today

Critical Race Theory / Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion (DEI) in medicine and surgery