Podcasts > The Ben Shapiro Show > Pro-Hamas Protesters Want To Intimidate You

Pro-Hamas Protesters Want To Intimidate You

By Ben Shapiro

Delve into the latest episode of "The Ben Shapiro Show" where host Ben Shapiro, joined by guest Senator Joe Manchin, offers up his assertive political commentary on the complexities of pro-Hamas protests and the ramifications of anti-Semitic violence on Western society. Shapiro argues that these protests are less about supporting Palestinian rights and more about inciting intimidation, as he dissects the concerning global trend of increased aggression toward Jewish communities.

As Shapiro breaks down the sociopolitical climate, he critiques the lukewarm societal responses to extremist demonstrations and lambasts the Biden administration for its perceived failures in upholding a consistent stance on Israel. He further explores the possibility of a political shift in the American electoral landscape and the impact of economic and immigration policies, while promoting a dialogue on national security and acknowledging Veterans Day with a tribute to a veteran-owned business. Overall, Shapiro stirs the pot of political discourse, challenging listeners to consider the deeper implications of current events while offering exclusive content to his dedicated members.

Listen to the original

Pro-Hamas Protesters Want To Intimidate You

This is a preview of the Shortform summary of the Nov 10, 2023 episode of the The Ben Shapiro Show

Sign up for Shortform to access the whole episode summary along with additional materials like counterarguments and context.

Pro-Hamas Protesters Want To Intimidate You

1-Page Summary

Political Analysis and Critique

The Intimidation Tactics of Pro-Hamas Protests

Ben Shapiro expresses a strong conviction that the pro-Hamas protests occurring in various locations are motivated by a desire to intimidate rather than to genuinely advocate for Palestinian rights. He contends that if protestors truly cared for Palestinians, their demonstrations would target Hamas's violent and corrupt history, not support it.

Rising Anti-Semitic Violence Linked to Rallies

Expanding on the nature of these protests, Shapiro underscores the aggression and riotous behaviors they often entail, citing violence against Jews, as exemplified by an attack on a Jewish person in New York City. These incidents fall within a broader surge in anti-Semitic hate crimes, with Jewish monuments, such as the Museum of Tolerance in Los Angeles, vandalized during the protests.

Western Response to Aggressive Pro-Hamas Movements

Shapiro criticizes society's tepid reaction to these actions and mocks the occupation of the New York Times office by protestors. He suggests that the goal of these protests is to pressure institutions into compliance by leveraging perceived legitimate grievances.

Shifting Geopolitical Dynamics and Radicalism in Europe

Shapiro comments on the demonstrations across Europe, especially in London, that seem to voice support for Hamas. He connects these events to wider concerns about their radical implications, alluding to the UK Home Secretary's criticism of police handling of these protests and resulting strains with the Prime Minister.

Public Demonstrations and the Support of Extremism

Shapiro addresses the growing support for Marine Le Pen in France and her efforts to distance herself from anti-Semitism. He controversially touches upon 'no-go zones' in Paris, immigration in Europe, and its consequential cultural segregation.

Radicalization and Its Effects on the Political Sphere

The right-wing's response to perceived Islamic radicalism is noted, as Shapiro predicts firmer Western strategies against radical Islamic factions. He also critiques President Joe Biden's handling of multiple issues, including immigration policy.

Electoral Strategies and Political Futures

The American Electoral Landscape

The political landscape is dissect by Shapiro, focusing on Senator Joe Manchin's decision not to seek re-election and the prospect of Republicans gaining an edge in an evenly split Senate. Shapiro also evaluates the potential for right-wing victories in battleground states and assesses the electoral strategies of both major American parties.

Prospects for a Moderate 'No Labels' Political Movement

Shapiro ponders the role that a bipartisan, moderate movement could play in future elections, speculating about a potential Manchin-Romney ticket and its appeal to moderate voters dissatisfied with the current political offerings.

U.S. Domestic and Foreign Policy Commentary

Allegations of Media Bias and Administrative Shortcomings

The contradiction in the U.S. Administration's external support for Israel while internally faulting it for human rights abuses is highlighted by Shapiro. He finds the protestors' accusations against the New York Times ironic, considering its critical stance on Israel.

Challenges Facing U.S. Economic and Immigration Policies

Federal Reserve Tactics Against Inflation

Shapiro touches briefly on economic challenges, noting Federal Reserve Chairman Jerome Powell's approach to combating inflation and the expectation of interest rate hikes.

The Impact of Illegal Immigration

A separate focus is placed on national security and immigration, as Shapiro recounts Texas' efforts to reclaim parts of the Rio Grande to prevent illegal crossings. He details the challenges law enforcement faces at the border with a special mention of Lieutenant Chris Oliveras's experiences.

Advertising and Corporate Partnerships

Supporting Veterans and Promotions

Shapiro uses the platform to promote services and products such as PolicyGenius, Renewal by Anderson, and Blinds.com. He also acknowledges Veterans Day, spotlighting Black Rifle Coffee Company, a veteran-owned business supporting veteran causes, and advocating for its support.

Content and Audience Engagement

Discussions with Senator Joe Manchin

The conversation with Joe Manchin covers a range of themes, though Manchin's comments on the podcast remain minimal and are mostly acknowledgments without substantial commentary.

Exclusive Content and Membership Incentives

Shapiro concludes by directing listeners towards a member-specific segment of his show where he plans to discuss the portrayal of OnlyFans by The Washington Post as empowering for women. He urges listeners to sign up for a membership, offering a special code for an annual subscription deal.

1-Page Summary

Additional Materials

Clarifications

  • The connection between pro-Hamas protests and intimidation tactics lies in the belief that these protests aim to instill fear and coerce compliance rather than genuinely advocate for Palestinian rights. Critics argue that the demonstrations often involve aggressive and riotous behaviors, contributing to a broader surge in anti-Semitic hate crimes. The protests are seen as a means to pressure institutions and individuals into aligning with their cause by leveraging perceived grievances and resorting to intimidation tactics. This perspective suggests that the demonstrations prioritize promoting Hamas's agenda through fear and coercion rather than constructive advocacy for Palestinian rights.
  • Marine Le Pen is a prominent French politician known for her far-right views, particularly on immigration and national identity. She leads the National Rally party and has been vocal about her concerns regarding immigration policies in France. 'No-go zones' in Paris are areas where some believe law enforcement and government authority are limited, often associated with high crime rates and social unrest. These zones have been a topic of debate, with some arguing they are exaggerated or mischaracterized.
  • Predictions of firmer Western strategies against radical Islamic factions suggest anticipated stronger actions by Western governments to combat extremist groups and ideologies. This could involve increased security measures, intelligence operations, and diplomatic efforts to counter the influence and activities of radical Islamic organizations. The aim is to address the perceived threat posed by these factions to national security and stability, both domestically and internationally. Such strategies may encompass a range of approaches, including military interventions, counterterrorism initiatives, and partnerships with other nations to tackle radicalization and extremism.
  • The contradiction in the U.S. Administration's stance on Israel and human rights abuses stems from the dual approach of supporting Israel externally while criticizing it internally for alleged human rights violations. This duality creates a perception of inconsistency in the U.S.'s position on Israel's actions and treatment of Palestinians. The criticism from protestors and commentators like Shapiro highlights the complexities and challenges in maintaining a balanced foreign policy stance on Israel and addressing human rights concerns simultaneously.
  • The Federal Reserve's tactics against inflation typically involve adjusting interest rates to influence borrowing and spending in the economy. By raising interest rates, the Fed aims to reduce consumer spending and investment, which can help cool down inflationary pressures. Conversely, lowering interest rates can stimulate economic activity during periods of low inflation or economic downturns. The Federal Reserve closely monitors various economic indicators to determine the appropriate timing and magnitude of these interest rate adjustments.
  • Challenges related to national security, illegal immigration, and border control involve issues such as securing the country's borders to prevent unauthorized crossings, addressing the influx of individuals entering the country without proper documentation, and managing the impact of illegal immigration on various aspects of society, including law enforcement and resources. These challenges often require a comprehensive approach that balances security concerns with humanitarian considerations and international obligations. Efforts to enhance border control may involve strategies like increasing surveillance, deploying additional personnel, implementing technology solutions, and collaborating with other agencies or countries to address the complexities of illegal immigration and national security threats. The management of these challenges can be politically contentious and require ongoing policy discussions and adjustments to effectively address the multifaceted issues at hand.
  • Ben Shapiro promoted services and products like PolicyGenius, Renewal by Anderson, and Blinds.com. He also highlighted the Black Rifle Coffee Company, a veteran-owned business supporting veteran causes.
  • Ben Shapiro offers exclusive content and membership incentives to his audience, encouraging them to sign up for a membership to access additional segments of his show. This exclusive content may include discussions on specific topics or interviews with notable figures. By providing this extra content, Shapiro aims to engage his audience further and offer them a more in-depth experience beyond his regular public broadcasts. To access this exclusive content, listeners are typically required to pay for a membership, which may come with special deals or benefits.

Counterarguments

  • Pro-Hamas protests may include individuals genuinely concerned about Palestinian rights and not support Hamas's actions.
  • Some participants in demonstrations may be peacefully exercising their right to free speech without engaging in violence.
  • Society's response to pro-Hamas movements could be seen as measured and respectful of the right to protest.
  • Protests in Europe could reflect a complex set of issues beyond support for Hamas, including opposition to Israeli policies or solidarity with Palestinians.
  • Support for Marine Le Pen could be driven by a variety of domestic factors unrelated to cultural segregation or anti-Semitism.
  • Strategies against radical Islamic factions might need to balance security concerns with respect for civil liberties and human rights.
  • President Joe Biden's handling of various issues may have supporters who believe in the effectiveness of his policies.
  • The potential for Republican gains in the Senate could be overstated, and electoral outcomes are often unpredictable.
  • A bipartisan, moderate political movement might face challenges in gaining traction in a polarized political environment.
  • The U.S. Administration's stance on Israel could reflect a nuanced approach to foreign policy and human rights.
  • The Federal Reserve's approach to combating inflation might be supported by some economists as necessary to maintain economic stability.
  • Efforts to control illegal immigration and secure borders could be seen as necessary for national security, while also respecting human rights and due process.
  • Promotions of services and products, including those supporting veterans, could be viewed as beneficial for the community and economy.
  • The conversation with Senator Joe Manchin might provide valuable insights into his perspectives, even if his comments were minimal.
  • Exclusive content and membership incentives could be a legitimate way to engage an audience and sustain a media platform.

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
Pro-Hamas Protesters Want To Intimidate You

Political Analysis and Critique

The Intimidation Tactics of Pro-Hamas Protests

Ben Shapiro expresses a strong conviction that the pro-Hamas protests occurring in various locations are aimed more at intimidation than genuine advocacy for Palestinian rights.

He links this behavior directly to the rise in violent acts against Jews, including the attempted assault on a Jewish institution in Montreal.

Shapiro contends that if protesters truly cared for Palestinians, their demonstrations would target Hamas's violent and corrupt history, not support it.

Rising Anti-Semitic Violence Linked to Rallies

Shapiro underscores the aggression and riotous behaviors of the pro-Hamas protests, emphasizing their anti-Semitic undertones.

He insists on the necessity of a resolute stance including stern confrontation and legal action against such aggression, advocating for the expulsion of non-citizen supporters of Hamas as a potential measure.

Western Response to Aggressive Pro-Hamas Movements

Shapiro is critical of what he sees as the Western media's failure to stand up to intimidatory tactics by pro-Hamas demonstrators, and challenges the calls for humanitarian breaks by Israel in its conflict with Hamas.

He emphasizes that Israel is conducting an extremely precise military campaign and argues civilian casualties are a direct consequence of Hamas using people as a defensive cover.

Shifting Geopolitical Dynamics and Radicalism in Europe

Shapiro comments on the demonstrations across Europe, especially in London, that seem to voice support for Hamas. He explicitly points out the recent instances of violence and disorder in the city, suggesting that such events are indicative of the intimidating nature of the protests.

Shapiro warns of potential conflicts that could arise from these protests on Armistice Day, underscoring the gravity of the situation.

He also exposes the internal political strain within the UK government, highlighting the public dissent against UK Home Secretary Suleilah Braverman and the scrutiny she faces from the Prime Minister. This internal conflict reflects the broader challenge of dealing with protests that ostensibly support Palestine but which Shapiro argues, in reality, function as endorsements for the militancy of Hamas.

Public Demonstrations and the Support of Extremism

Shapiro addresses the growing support for Marine Le Pen in France and her efforts to distance herself from anti-Semitism.

He controversially touches upon 'no-go zones' in Paris, immigration in Europe, and its consequential cultural segregation.

Radicalization and Its Effects on the Political Sphere

The right-wing's response to perceived Islamic radicalism is highlighted, with Shapiro observing a significant increase in the momentum of far-right political factions as a reaction. These groups are gaining traction due to cultural tensions and demographic changes, signaling a potential shift in Western European political dynamics.

Electoral Strategies and Political Futures

The American Electoral Landscape

The political landscape is dissect by Shapiro, focusing on Senator Joe Manchin's decision not to seek re-election and the prospect of Republicans gaining an edge in an evenly split Senate. He delves into the likelihood of Manchin's se ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Political Analysis and Critique

Additional Materials

Clarifications

  • The connection between pro-Hamas protests and the rise in violent acts against Jews stems from the perception that these protests, by supporting Hamas, a group known for its hostility towards Israel, can fuel anti-Semitic sentiments and actions among certain individuals or groups. This association is often made due to the complex and longstanding Israeli-Palestinian conflict, where support for Hamas can be seen as endorsing violence against Israel, which can, in turn, lead to a rise in anti-Semitic incidents targeting Jewish communities.
  • Marine Le Pen, a prominent figure in French politics, has made efforts to distance herself and the National Rally party from anti-Semitism. This move is part of a broader strategy to appeal to a wider electorate and shed the party's historical associations with extremist views. Le Pen has sought to present a more moderate and inclusive image to attract support beyond the party's traditional base. These efforts are aimed at reshaping the party's image and increasing its acceptability in mainstream politics.
  • The rise of far-right political factions in response to perceived Islamic radicalism in Western Europe reflects a trend where some right-wing groups gain support due to concerns about Islamic extremism. This phenomenon is often fueled by cultural tensions, demographic changes, and security fears within European societies. The far-right's increased momentum is a response to events like terrorist attacks and issues related to immigration and integration. This dynamic has implications for the political landscape and can lead to shifts in power and policies within Western European countries.
  • The potential Manchin-Romney ticket alludes to a hypothetical scenario where Senator Joe Manchin, a Democrat known for his moderate stance, and Senator Mitt Romney, a Republican also recognized for his centrist positions, could run together as a bipartisan team in an election. This pairing aims to appeal to moderate voters who ...

Counterarguments

  • Pro-Hamas protests could be seen as a form of legitimate political expression by those who believe that Hamas represents a resistance movement against what they view as Israeli occupation.
  • The rise in violent acts against Jews may not be directly linked to pro-Hamas protests but could be part of a broader increase in anti-Semitic incidents globally, with multiple contributing factors.
  • Critics might argue that focusing on Hamas's violent history without acknowledging the context of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict oversimplifies the issue and ignores legitimate grievances of Palestinians.
  • Some may contend that labeling pro-Hamas protests as inherently anti-Semitic could be an attempt to delegitimize criticism of Israeli policies.
  • Expelling non-citizen supporters of Hamas could be seen as a violation of free speech and due process rights, and may not be a proportionate or effective response to the issue at hand.
  • There could be a perspective that the Western media has a responsibility to report on the complexity of the issue, including the reasons behind pro-Hamas demonstrations, rather than simply taking a stand against them.
  • The argument that civilian casualties are solely the result of Hamas using people as human shields may be challenged by those who believe that the responsibility for avoiding civilian casualties lies with the attacking force, in this case, Israel.
  • The potential conflicts arising from pro-Hamas protests in Europe could be interpreted as a sign of a healthy democracy where diverse opinions are allowed and public dissent is possible.
  • The internal political strain within the UK government could be viewed as a natural outcome of a vibrant democratic process where different viewpoints are represented and debated.
  • Marine Le Pen's growing support in France could be attributed to a variety of factors, including economic concerns and a desire for change, rather than solely her stance on anti-Semitism ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
Pro-Hamas Protesters Want To Intimidate You

U.S. Domestic and Foreign Policy Commentary

Allegations of Media Bias and Administrative Shortcomings

Shapiro discusses a Harvard-Capps-Harris poll that reveals American support for Israel against Hamas, which he uses to counter the argument that President Joe Biden's popularity might suffer due to his pro-Israel stance.

In his conclusion, Shapiro counters the notion that reducing civilian casualties will prevent the future rise of Hamas militants and proposes that the genuine catalyst for terrorism is the belief that the West can be defeated. He commends Israel for its humanitarian efforts, including establishing field hospitals in Gaza to treat those affected by the conflict.

Challenges Facing U.S. Economic and Immigration Policies

Federal Reserve Tactics Against Inflation

Shapiro touches briefly on economic challenges, noting Federal Reserve Chairman Jerome Powell's ongoing struggle with mounting inflation and highlighting the strong possibility of further interest rate hikes to tackle the continuous inflationary pressures, as hinted by Powell in The Wall Street Journal.

This inflation is significantly affecting people's purchasing power due to consistent wage-price increases.

The Impact of Illegal Immigration

Shapiro critiques President Joe Biden's handling of immigration policy, drawing attention to ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

U.S. Domestic and Foreign Policy Commentary

Additional Materials

Clarifications

  • The argument that reducing civilian casualties won't prevent the rise of Hamas militants suggests that the root cause of Hamas' actions is not solely based on civilian casualties but on broader ideological beliefs and motivations. Hamas' militant activities are often driven by a complex mix of political, social, and religious factors beyond just the immediate impact of civilian casualties. Addressing the underlying grievances and motivations that fuel Hamas' actions is crucial in preventing their resurgence, rather than solely focusing on minimizing civilian casualties in conflicts.
  • Jerome Powell, as the Federal Reserve Chairman, faces challenges with inflation. Inflation is the general increase in prices of goods and services in an economy over a period of time. Powell's struggle involves managing inflation to ensure it remains stable and does not erode the purchasing power of consumers. This can involve implementing policies like adjusting interest rates to control inflationary pressures.
  • Interest rate hikes are a tool used by central banks like the Federal Reserve to combat inflation. When inflation rises too quickly, central banks may increase interest rates to make borrowing more expensive, which can help slow down spending and reduce price increases in the economy. Higher interest rates can also encourage saving over spending, which can further ...

Counterarguments

  • American support for Israel against Hamas, as indicated by the Harvard-Capps-Harris poll, may not fully represent the diversity of opinions within the United States, and other polls might show different levels of support or concern regarding the implications of a pro-Israel stance.
  • The argument that reducing civilian casualties won't prevent the rise of Hamas militants could be countered by suggesting that addressing the humanitarian and political needs of the Palestinian people might reduce the appeal of militant groups.
  • While Israel's establishment of field hospitals in Gaza is commendable, critics might argue that addressing the root causes of the conflict and lifting restrictions that affect the quality of life in Gaza are also necessary for a long-term solution.
  • The Federal Reserve's approach to tackling inflation through interest rate hikes could be criticized for potentially slowing down economic growth and negatively impacting employment.
  • The impact of inflation on purchasing power is a complex issue, and some might argue that focusing on improving the minimum wage and social safety nets could help mitigate these effects.
  • Criticism of President Biden's immigration policy might be met with arguments that emphasize the need for comprehensive immigration reform that balances border security with humane treatment ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
Pro-Hamas Protesters Want To Intimidate You

Advertising and Corporate Partnerships

Supporting Veterans and Promotions

In recognition of Veterans Day, Shapiro commends Black Rifle Coffee Company, a veteran-owned business, for its active support in veteran-related initiatives. This includes the Boot Campaign, the Medal of Honor Museum, and support for veterans' mental health.

Additionally, he shares an inspiring anecdote, inviting listeners ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Advertising and Corporate Partnerships

Additional Materials

Clarifications

  • The Boot Campaign is a charitable organization that raises awareness and funds to support military veterans. It is known for its signature combat boots that symbolize the sacrifices made by service members. The campaign focuses on providing assistance to veterans in various aspects of their lives, including health and wellness programs. Through various initiatives and partnerships, the Boot Campaign aims to make a positive impact on the lives of veterans and their families.
  • The Medal of Honor Museum is an institution dedicated to preserving and honoring the recipients of the United States' highest military decoration for valor in combat. It showcases the stories of Medal of Honor recipients, highlighting their extraordinary acts of bravery and sacrifice. The museum serves as a tribute to these individuals and aims to educate the public about their contributions to the nation's history and values. It plays a crucial role in recognizing and commemorating the heroism displayed by service members in defense of their country.
  • Clint Trial is a former Marine Recon, which stands for Marine R ...

Counterarguments

  • While Shapiro commends Black Rifle Coffee Company for its support of veteran-related initiatives, it could be argued that corporate support should not be the primary means of addressing veterans' needs, and that more systemic solutions provided by government and public institutions are necessary.
  • The focus on a single company's efforts, such as Black Rifle Coffee Company, might overshadow the need for a broader, more inclusive approach to veteran support that involves multiple stakeholders and a variety of support mechanisms.
  • Highlighting personal stories, like that of Clint Trial, is powerful, but it is important to ensure that such narratives do not inadvertently create a single story or stereotype about veterans or their experiences.
  • The promotion of veteran-related initiatives by a company can sometimes be perceived as self-servin ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
Pro-Hamas Protesters Want To Intimidate You

Content and Audience Engagement

Discussions with Senator Joe Manchin

The conversation with Joe Manchin involves his significant political decision not to seek re-election for the Senate, presenting an advantage for Republicans in West Virginia, traditionally a conservative state. Shapiro discusses Manchin's critical role as a conservative Democratic vote in the Senate, with his exit anticipated to create notable political ripples. He speculates on Manchin's future with ties to the emerging 'No Labels' bipartisan group.

In his retirement announcement, Manchin expressed a profound desire to unify Americans, setting the stage for his future political endeavors. Additionally, Shapiro delves into Senator Joe Manchin's connection with No Labels, a group intent on providing voters an alternative to both President Biden and former President Trump, demonstrating a moderate stance. No Labels has been making strides, having acquired the ability to appear on ballots in a dozen states.

However, there is an inclination within No Labels toward selecting a Republican to spearhead its efforts, which might sideline Manchin if this preference persists.

Exclusive Content and Membership Incentives

Shapiro concludes by directing listeners towards a member-specific segment ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Content and Audience Engagement

Additional Materials

Clarifications

  • Joe Manchin's role as a conservative Democratic vote in the Senate is significant because he often takes more moderate or conservative positions compared to other Democrats, influencing the balance of power in the Senate. This makes him a key figure for bipartisan negotiations and a potential swing vote on crucial issues. Manchin's stance can impact the passage or rejection of legislation, especially in a closely divided Senate. His decisions can shape the direction of policies and the success of certain agendas.
  • The 'No Labels' bipartisan group aims to bridge the gap between Democrats and Republicans by promoting cooperation and problem-solving across party lines. They advocate for pragmatic, centrist polic ...

Counterarguments

  • Joe Manchin's decision not to seek re-election could open opportunities for Democrats to present a fresh face and potentially re-energize their base in West Virginia.
  • Manchin's exit from the Senate might not have as significant political consequences as speculated if his successor maintains a similar voting pattern or if the balance of power in the Senate remains unaffected.
  • The association with 'No Labels' could be seen as a strategic move for Manchin to remain influential in politics, rather than a genuine effort to unify Americans.
  • The aim to unify Americans is a common political rhetoric that may not necessarily translate into effective action or policy change.
  • No Labels' offer of an alternative to Biden and Trump might not resonate with voters who are looking for more progressive or more conservative options than what a moderate stance provides.
  • Gaining the ability to appear on ballots does not guarantee electoral success for No Labels, as voter support is ultimately what determines political viability.
  • The preference within No Labels for a Republican leader could be a strategic decision to attract conservative voters who are disillusioned with the current Republican options, rather than a marginalization of Manchin.
  • Shapiro' ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free

Create Summaries for anything on the web

Download the Shortform Chrome extension for your browser

Shortform Extension CTA