Podcasts > Sword and Scale > Episode 257

Episode 257

By Incongruity LLC

In this episode of Sword and Scale, the tragic case of Jessica Sacco and Matthew Puccio is explored. Jessica, struggling with bipolar disorder, stopped taking her medication after encouragement from Puccio. This caused her mental state to deteriorate, leading to the couple moving in with Puccio's friends into Jessica's cramped apartment.

As tensions mounted in the crowded living situation, jokes circulated about eliminating Jessica from the group. Ultimately, Puccio brutally murdered Jessica, with his friends assisting in the dismemberment and disposal of her remains. The episode details the harrowing events, the subsequent arrests, and the sentences received by those involved in this horrific crime.

Listen to the original

Episode 257

This is a preview of the Shortform summary of the Feb 5, 2024 episode of the Sword and Scale

Sign up for Shortform to access the whole episode summary along with additional materials like counterarguments and context.

Episode 257

1-Page Summary

Jessica's mental health and Puccio's influence

Jessica Sacco, struggling with bipolar disorder and low self-esteem, was convinced by boyfriend Matthew Puccio to stop taking her medication. This caused her mental state to decline, as evident from her concerning Facebook posts. Sue, Jessica's mother, feared this change in her daughter. When Puccio moved himself and two friends into Jessica's small apartment, her naïveté and poor judgement exacerbated the situation.

The group turning against Jessica

Initially, Jessica generously extended an invitation for Puccio's friends to stay. However, the cramped living situation led the group to find Jessica annoying, jokes about getting rid of her began circulating. Andrew Forney joked about Jessica's almond allergy, foreshadowing grave discussions about eliminating her from the group.

Matthew murdering Jessica

Puccio claimed self-defense, but Forney testified Puccio suffocated Jessica. Puccio confessed to stabbing Jessica to weaken her, putting bags over her head until she stopped moving. Wright heard muffled sounds and noticed Puccio had scratch marks, indicating Jessica fought back.

The group then assisted in dismembering and disposing of Jessica's body. With time constraints, they ceased dismemberment, bagging her remains to scatter across dumpsters. Instead, Linda Ginevsti's mother offered to dispose of the remains in Kentucky.

All involved being arrested and charged

Police swiftly arrested Puccio, Forney, Wright, Cook and others involved in the crime. Puccio faced charges like aggravated murder and tampering with evidence. The others were charged with crimes like abuse of a corpse and failure to report a crime.

Sentences received

Puccio received life with parole eligibility after 30 years, plus 12 extra years. Forney got 10 years, Candace Forney 6 years, Wright 4 years, and Cook 3 years, likely impacted by their plea deals and cooperation.

1-Page Summary

Additional Materials

Clarifications

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
Episode 257

Jessica's unstable mental health and relationship with Matthew Puccio

Jessica's life begins to unravel as she contends with her mental health and the influence of Matthew Puccio.

Jessica struggling with bipolar disorder and low self-esteem

Jessica Sacco was fighting her own battles with bipolar disorder and extremely low self-esteem, factors that affected her decision-making and relationships. Although she had recently moved into her own apartment in Urbana, Ohio, in an attempt to get back on her feet following a messy breakup, her history of struggling to make and maintain good relationships was a persistent issue. Jessica was medicated for bipolar disorder, and her mother, Sue, was well aware of the instability Jessica could face if she discontinued her medication.

However, Matthew Puccio, who also suffered from bipolar disorder, had successfully convinced Jessica to stop taking her medication. As a result, Jessica began referring to Matthew as her husband, and he, along with two friends, moved into her small apartment. During this time, Jessica's mental state appeared to decline, as indicated by the emotions of anger and self-pity that she expressed on Facebook, along with public expressions of wishing death upon someone with whom she was in conflict. In another Facebook status, Jessica spoke of feeling worthless and described a state of deep frustration and stress.

Matthew moving himself and two friends into Jessica's small apartment

Andrew Forney, one of the individuals residing in the apartment, recognized Jessica's extreme depression. He recalls an incident where Jessica ingested a large quantity of pills in a suicidal act. Forney intervened by calling Emergency Medical Services (EMS) and advocated for Jessica to remain in medical care longer as he believed she needed more extensive help, noting that suicide was ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Jessica's unstable mental health and relationship with Matthew Puccio

Additional Materials

Clarifications

  • Jessica and Matthew Puccio had a complex relationship marked by shared struggles with bipolar disorder. Matthew convinced Jessica to stop taking her medication, leading to a decline in her mental state. He moved into Jessica's apartment with two friends, further complicating their dynamic and creating a crowded living situation. Jessica's vulnerability and lack of judgment in relationships made her susceptible to Matthew's influence, exacerbating her existing mental health challenges.
  • Jessica Sacco was dealing with bipolar disorder, a mental health condition characterized by extreme mood swings. She was prescribed medication to help manage her symptoms and stabilize her moods. However, her decision to stop taking her medication, influenced by Matthew Puccio, had a significant impact on her mental state and well-being.
  • Matthew Puccio, who also had bipolar disorder, convinced Jessica to stop taking her medication. This decision was detrimental to Jessica's mental health, as medication is often crucial in managing bipolar disorder symptoms. By influencing Jessica to discontinue her medication, Matthew played a significant role in exacerbating Jessica's mental health struggles.
  • Jessica's social media posts reflected her inner turmoil and emotional distress, with expressions of anger, self-pity, and feelings of worthlessness. These posts indicated a decline in her mental state and hinted at the influence of Matthew Puccio and her struggles with bipolar disorder. Jessica's online behavior, such as expressing wishes of harm towards others and describing deep frustration, highlighted the challenges she was facing in her personal life. Her mother noticed these concerning posts and suspected that Jessica might have stopped taking her bipolar medication, adding to the complexity of the situation.
  • Jessica's mother, Sue, was concerned about her daughter's mental health and stability. She was aware of Jessica's struggles with bipolar disorder and the importance of her medication in managing it. Sue observed changes in Jessica's behavior and online presence that indicated potential issues arising from Jessica's decision to stop taking her medication. These observations led Sue to fear for Jessica's well-being and recognize the need for interve ...

Counterarguments

...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
Episode 257

The group turning against Jessica

Jessica's seemingly generous decision to offer her home to others turned sour as the group she welcomed began to find her presence undesirable and discussed wanting her gone.

Jessica allowing the group to move into her apartment

Jessica had a roommate, Matthew Puccio, whom she referred to as her husband. Matt invited his friends Andrew Forney and Forney's wife, who were relying on social assistance, to stay at Jessica's one-bedroom apartment after a Thanksgiving visit. Although it seemed like it was Matt who offered the space, using their Juggalo community ties to his advantage, Jessica was the one who initially extended the invitation. It's implied that she may not have been fully aware of the permanency of this arrangement. Eventually, Andrew and Candace Forney moved in with Jessica and Matt, and her relationship with Matt was already showing problems.

The group finding Jessica annoying

Soon after the group moved into Jessica's place, they began to find her annoying. The Forneys, along with two others they met, Chris Wright and Sharon Cook, would hang out at Jessica's house and the library. Andrew Forney recognized it was Jessica's place and that they had to abide by her rules, but the sentiment among the group soon soured towards her. Sharon Cook, in particular, expressed her disdain for Jessica's behavior, indicating that at least some members were irritated with her.

Discussing wanting Jessica gone

The small apartment strained under the pressure of four unemployed adults, with arguments erupting frequent ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

The group turning against Jessica

Additional Materials

Clarifications

  • An almond extract allergy is a severe adverse reaction to almond extract, a concentrated flavoring made from almonds. Symptoms can range from mild to life-threatening, including hives, swelling, difficulty breathing, and anaphylaxis. Individuals with this allergy must avoid almond extract in all forms to prevent serious health complications. In the context provided, the mention of almond extract allergy highlights a potential danger if someone were to use it to harm the individual with the allergy.
  • Andrew Forney was a friend of Jessica's roommate, Matthew Puccio. Forney and his wife were invited to stay at Jessica's apartment by Matthew. Andrew was part of the group that moved in with Jessica and Matthew, leading to tensions and conflicts within the living situation. As the group dynamics shifted, Andrew was involved in discussions and jokes about wanting Jessica gone, which escalated to disturbing levels.
  • The group's comfort with discussing Jessica's murder suggests a disturbing lev ...

Counterarguments

  • Jessica's decision to offer her home may have been made with the best intentions, and the group's negative reaction could be more reflective of their own issues than Jessica's behavior.
  • It's possible that Matt had more influence over the decision to invite the group to stay than is apparent, and Jessica's consent might have been assumed rather than explicitly given.
  • The group's finding Jessica annoying could be subjective and based on personal differences rather than Jessica's actions being objectively irritating.
  • Sharon Cook's disdain for Jessica could be a personal conflict that does not reflect the feelings of the entire group.
  • Discussions about wanting Jessica gone could have been hyperbolic expressions of frustration rather than serious considerations.
  • The frequent arguments in the apartment could be a result of the stress of the living situation and not solely due to Jessica's behavior.
  • The ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
Episode 257

Matthew murdering Jessica

A grim narrative unfolds as details surrounding the demise of Jessica Rae Sacco come to light. Jessica's ex-boyfriend, Matthew Puccio, is said to have killed her under the guise of self-defense.

Matthew stabbing and suffocating Jessica

Matthew Puccio's claim that Jessica had planned to kill him and that he acted in self-defense was cast into doubt by the testimony of Andrew Forney. Forney indicated that Puccio suffocated Jessica, a fact corroborated by the coroner's ruling that she died of suffocation.

Puccio confessed in detail how the incident transpired. He admitted to stabbing Jessica, not out of mercy, but to weaken her. The resultant stab wound did not immediately prove fatal. Jessica's struggle for life was evident when she ripped the first bag Puccio put over her head to suffocate her. It took a second bag for her to eventually stop moving. Christopher Wright recalls hearing muffled sounds that he thought might be Jessica being suffocated and noted that Puccio had scratch marks on his arm, indicating Jessica fought back. The group later saw her body with a bag tightly around her head.

The group helping dismember and dispose of Jessica's body

The murder was implied to require assistance from others, suggesting that a group was involved in managing the aftermath. Christopher Wright testified that he, along with others, took part in dismembering Jessica's body. They lifted her into a bathtub, each person holding a limb. The group, equipped w ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Matthew murdering Jessica

Additional Materials

Clarifications

...

Counterarguments

...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
Episode 257

All involved being arrested and charged

Police acted swiftly following the discovery of Jessica's body, collecting evidence that led to the rapid arrest of five people. Matthew Puccio, along with his two friends and fellow 'Juggalos' members, were apprehended in Hamilton. Interviews were conducted post-plea, and participants were made aware that their plea deals would be invalidated should they fail to tell the truth. Christopher Wright and his girlfriend Sharon Cook, who had only recently met the rest of the group, were arrested for their involvement in the attempted cover-up of the murder.

Matthew Puccio and the four others, including Andrew Forney, Candace Forney, Christopher Wright, and Sharon Cook, were taken into custody in connection with the crime. Puccio faced a series of charges: aggravated murder, felonious assault, felony and misdemeanor abuse of a corpse, possession of criminal tools, and tampering with evid ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

All involved being arrested and charged

Additional Materials

Clarifications

  • Juggalos are dedicated fans of the hip hop group Insane Clown Posse or other artists on Psychopathic Records. Some individuals who identify as Juggalos have been involved in criminal activities, leading to the classification of certain groups as criminal gangs by law enforcement agencies. These criminal Juggalo gangs engage in various illegal behaviors, including extortion, murder, drug trafficking, and ...

Counterarguments

...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
Episode 257

Sentences received for their roles in Jessica's murder

An overview of the sentencing for the individuals involved in Jessica’s murder reveals a range of jail terms correlating with their involvement and plea deals made with investigators.

Matthew Puccio, the main defendant, changed his plea from not guilty by reason of insanity to guilty. He did not take a plea deal like the others, and he even mentioned at one point that he planned to plead guilty, believing he deserved the death penalty. Ultimately, Puccio did not receive the death penalty but was sentenced to life in prison with the possibility of parole after 30 years for the aggravated murder charge. Additionally, he received 12 extra years for other charges.

Andrew Forney faced a 10-year prison sentence, while Candace Forney, who had to forfeit her va ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Sentences received for their roles in Jessica's murder

Additional Materials

Clarifications

  • The term "aggravated murder" typically denotes a more severe form of homicide, often involving specific circumstances that make the crime especially heinous or malicious. In legal terms, it carries harsher penalties compared to regular murder charges. Plea deals are agreements between the prosecution and the defendant where the defendant agrees to plead guilty in exchange for certain concessions, such as a reduced sentence or dropping some charges. The possibility of parole after a specified period means that the individual may be eligible for release from prison under certain conditions before serving the full sentence.
  • Plea deals can impact sentencing outcomes by offering defendants a reduced sentence i ...

Counterarguments

...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free

Create Summaries for anything on the web

Download the Shortform Chrome extension for your browser

Shortform Extension CTA