Podcasts > Stuff You Should Know > SYSK's 12 Days of Christmas… Toys: How the Nintendo Entertainment System Changed Gaming Forever

SYSK's 12 Days of Christmas… Toys: How the Nintendo Entertainment System Changed Gaming Forever

By iHeartPodcasts

In this episode of Stuff You Should Know, Josh Clark and Chuck Bryant examine Nintendo's role in reviving the video game industry after its dramatic crash in the early 1980s. They detail how Nintendo entered a market that retailers had abandoned, implementing strict quality control measures and introducing innovative hardware designs that would influence gaming for decades to come.

The hosts explore the technical and cultural impact of the Nintendo Entertainment System (NES), from its revolutionary controller design to groundbreaking games like Super Mario Bros. and The Legend of Zelda. The discussion covers Nintendo's experimental accessories, including successes like the NES Zapper and failures like R.O.B., while explaining how the company's business practices helped transform gaming from a niche hobby into mainstream entertainment.

Listen to the original

SYSK's 12 Days of Christmas… Toys: How the Nintendo Entertainment System Changed Gaming Forever

This is a preview of the Shortform summary of the Dec 12, 2025 episode of the Stuff You Should Know

Sign up for Shortform to access the whole episode summary along with additional materials like counterarguments and context.

SYSK's 12 Days of Christmas… Toys: How the Nintendo Entertainment System Changed Gaming Forever

1-Page Summary

Video Game Market Crash and Nintendo's Revival

In their podcast episode, Josh Clark and Chuck Bryant explore the dramatic story of the video game industry's collapse and resurrection. They explain how the industry experienced a devastating crash in the early 1980s, exemplified by Atari's dramatic fall from $2 billion in earnings to a $536 million loss between 1982 and 1983.

Nintendo's Revolutionary Approach

Nintendo entered the market when video games were considered "dead" and retailers were still bitter from the crash. According to Clark and Bryant, Nintendo's success stemmed from learning from Atari's mistakes. They implemented strict quality control measures, including a lock chip system that only accepted officially licensed games and limiting third-party developers to two games annually.

The NES's Innovative Design

The hosts discuss how the Nintendo Entertainment System (NES) revolutionized gaming through its controller design, introducing the now-iconic D-pad and A/B button layout. This design, first tested on Nintendo's Game & Watch handhelds, became the standard for how games would be controlled for decades to come. The console's advanced architecture also enabled superior graphics and gameplay compared to previous systems.

Impact of Iconic NES Games

Clark highlights how games like "Super Mario Bros." transformed gaming by introducing unprecedented depth and hidden content. Meanwhile, Bryant notes that "The Legend of Zelda" and "Metroid" pioneered open-world exploration and non-linear progression, expanding what was possible in video games.

Nintendo's Experimental Peripherals

While discussing Nintendo's accessories, the hosts explain that many experimental peripherals like R.O.B. (Robotic Operating Buddy) and the Power Glove failed to gain traction. However, the NES Zapper, bundled with games like Duck Hunt, became a beloved part of the ecosystem, using innovative light detection technology for an immersive shooting experience.

Industry-Wide Influence

According to GamePro writer Tae K. Kim, the NES controller became the "language of console gaming." Nintendo's strict quality control and licensing practices set industry standards for platform management, though their dominant market position eventually drew FTC scrutiny. These practices, combined with their innovative games, helped transform gaming from a niche hobby into mainstream entertainment.

1-Page Summary

Additional Materials

Counterarguments

  • While Nintendo's quality control measures were beneficial, they could also be seen as restrictive and monopolistic, stifling creativity and competition by limiting third-party developers.
  • The claim that the NES's architecture was superior to all previous systems could be contested, as it was more about the right balance of technology and cost rather than outright technical superiority.
  • The assertion that games like "Super Mario Bros." introduced unprecedented depth might overlook earlier games on other platforms that also offered depth and complexity.
  • The idea that "The Legend of Zelda" and "Metroid" pioneered open-world exploration could be challenged by noting earlier examples of non-linear gameplay in video games.
  • The success of the NES Zapper and other peripherals might be attributed not just to their innovative technology but also to effective marketing and the novelty factor.
  • The NES controller's influence, while significant, was not the only "language of console gaming," as other controllers and systems also contributed to the evolution of game control.
  • The view that Nintendo's practices set industry standards could be seen as an oversimplification, as other companies and market forces also played significant roles in shaping the industry.
  • The impact of FTC scrutiny on Nintendo could be discussed more deeply, considering the balance between market dominance and fair competition.
  • The transformation of gaming into mainstream entertainment was a multifaceted process, with other companies, technological advancements, and cultural shifts also playing crucial roles.

Actionables

  • You can explore the evolution of gaming by creating a timeline that charts the major milestones in video game history, including the crash, Nintendo's rise, and the introduction of iconic games and technology. Start by researching key events and their impact on the industry, then use a free online tool or app to visualize this timeline. Share your findings with friends or on social media to spark discussions about how these events shaped modern gaming.
  • Develop a critical eye for quality in media by setting up a "quality control" book club or discussion group that focuses on analyzing the storytelling and production values of various forms of entertainment. Choose a mix of critically acclaimed works and lesser-known pieces, discuss what makes them successful or not, and apply these insights to understand the importance of quality control in creative industries.
  • Enhance your understanding of design by customizing a controller for a gaming console or computer that reflects the ergonomic and aesthetic principles of the NES controller. Use online resources to learn about controller design, then either modify an existing controller with a DIY kit or design a skin or overlay that pays homage to the NES's influence. This hands-on project will give you a deeper appreciation for the innovation and lasting impact of the NES controller design.

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
SYSK's 12 Days of Christmas… Toys: How the Nintendo Entertainment System Changed Gaming Forever

Video Game Market Crash and Nintendo's Revival

Josh Clark and Chuck Bryant delve into the rise, fall, and resurgence of the video game industry, with the North American video game market crash of the early 1980s followed by Nintendo's innovative approach to console gaming.

Early 1980s North American Video Game Industry Crash

Video Game Industry Boomed In Late 1970s, but Poor-Quality Games Caused Backlash Against Consoles

Clark and Bryant discuss how the video game industry, exemplified by Atari, experienced a boom in the late 1970s. However, poor-quality games like E.T. led to declining interest and factored into the video game market crash. Clark mentions that the video game crash of the early 1980s was highlighted by Atari's nosedive from earning $2 billion in 1982 to a loss of $536 million in 1983, with this dramatic shift suggesting that a saturated market and subpar products caused a backlash against consoles.

Disillusionment in Video Game Market as a Fading Fad

The hosts reminisce about Atari's simplistic but enjoyable game designs. However, they also note that as personal computers rose in popularity, the video game industry sank to such depths that video games were seen as a fading fad, much like disco. An article from the time declared video games as "dead, dead, dead," with PCs seen as the multifunctional technology of the future. With retailers having been burned by the crash, video game consoles were regarded with a "never again" mentality.

Nintendo Revived Industry With Innovative Console

Nintendo Avoided Atari's Mistakes With Nes Design After Market Crash

Nintendo entered the market during a period when the industry was at rock bottom and perceived as unlikely to rebound. Despite the challenges, including skepticism from retailers who were still managing unsold Atari consoles, Nintendo targeted North America. After their Famicom found success in Japan, Nintendo made its first foray into the North American market with the AVS but faced stiff resistance.

They mitigated the risk for a test market in New York City by offering free shipments and accepting returns of unsold units, provi ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Video Game Market Crash and Nintendo's Revival

Additional Materials

Counterarguments

  • The attribution of the video game crash solely to poor-quality games like E.T. may oversimplify the issue, as there were multiple factors, including market saturation and the rise of home computers, which also played significant roles.
  • While Atari's financial decline is notable, it's important to consider that other companies were also affected by the crash, and the industry's issues were not solely due to Atari's business practices.
  • The comparison of video games to a fading fad like disco might not fully acknowledge the cultural and technological differences between the two phenomena.
  • The "never again" mentality among retailers may not have been as widespread or as long-lasting as suggested, given the industry's ability to recover and grow in subsequent years.
  • Nintendo's strategy in New York City was indeed innovative, but it could be argued that other factors, such as the quality of the games themselves, played a more significant role in the NES's success.
  • The strict quality control and licensing by Nintendo, while successful, could be criticized for being too restrictive and potentially stifling creativity and innovation among third-party developers.
  • The limitation of two games per year for third-party developers might have inadvertently favored ...

Actionables

  • You can learn from past industry mistakes by researching the history of a product before purchasing it. By understanding the rise and fall of products like video game consoles, you can make more informed decisions about what to invest in. For example, before buying the latest tech gadget, look into its company's track record, market trends, and consumer reviews to gauge its potential longevity and value.
  • Mitigate personal investment risks by adopting a test-and-learn approach similar to Nintendo's New York City strategy. When trying out a new hobby or investing in a new market, start small and scale up only after seeing some success. For instance, if you're considering investing in cryptocurrency, begin with a small amount you're comfortable potentially losing, and only increase your investment after you've learned more and seen positive results.
  • Embrace ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
SYSK's 12 Days of Christmas… Toys: How the Nintendo Entertainment System Changed Gaming Forever

Design and Features of the Nintendo Entertainment System

The Nintendo Entertainment System (NES) is known for its significant contributions to console gaming, from its controller design to its advanced gaming capabilities.

Nes's Controller Design Set Console Gaming Standard

The NES's controller design has become iconic in the video game industry, setting the standard for console gaming controls.

Nes Controller Introduced Iconic D-Pad and a/B Layout For Decades

While Nintendo's initial offering, the AVS, featured a joystick, it was the NES's controller that introduced the iconic D-pad and A/B button layout. The red and white box of the Famicom, the Japanese version of the NES, featured a top-loading design and two wired controllers. These controllers showcased an important feature: a directional pad (D-pad) on the left with four arrows and separate A and B buttons on the right.

The D-pad itself was first seen on the Game & Watch handheld games before making its way to the NES controller. This feature was particularly beneficial in games like "Donkey Kong," which required precise directional controls. The functionality of the A/B button layout has also been emphasized, showcasing its influence on game control.

This Design Revolutionized how Players Controlled Games

The Famicom's controller design was a game changer, likened to inventing the airplane and getting it right on the inaugural flight. It essentially set the standard for how games were to be controlled in the future. Chuck Bryant suggested that the introduction of the D-pad was a natural evolution in gaming, similar to the replacement of older joysticks with modern mini joysticks, signifying a revolutionary shift in controller design from the NES era and onwards.

Nes Enabled Visually Impressive, Advanced Gaming

The console's technological advancements allowed for a significant leap in gaming experiences compared to previous systems like the Atari 2600.

Console's Architecture and Lock-Out Chip Enabled Nintendo to Control Game Quality

The NES's internal architecture played a crucial role in maintaining game quality. The system featured a lock and key chip mechanism, which Ninte ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Design and Features of the Nintendo Entertainment System

Additional Materials

Counterarguments

  • While the NES controller design was influential, it wasn't the first to use a directional pad; handheld electronic games and some home computer systems had used similar concepts before.
  • The A/B button layout, while iconic, was not the only effective design at the time, as other consoles like the Sega Master System also had their own successful controller layouts.
  • The top-loading design of the Famicom was not unique to Nintendo; other consoles before and after also used top-loading mechanisms.
  • The D-pad, while innovative, may not have been as universally praised upon release as it is in retrospect, with some players preferring the joystick or other input methods.
  • The lock-out chip, while intended to maintain game quality, also stifled third-party development and could be seen as a monopolistic practice by Nintendo.
  • The NES's superiority over the Atari 2600 in graphics and gameplay is subjective and could be debated by fans of the Atari's simpler, more arcade-like games.
  • The legal de ...

Actionables

  • Explore the evolution of game controllers by comparing your current console's controller with images of the NES controller online to appreciate the design legacy. By doing this, you'll gain a better understanding of how the ergonomic and functional aspects of modern controllers have been shaped by the NES's innovations.
  • Create a simple game using free game development software like Scratch to experiment with control schemes, using the D-pad and A/B button layout as inspiration. This hands-on activity will give you a feel for how game design is directly influenced by controller configuration, and you might even come up with a unique control scheme of your own.
  • Educate yourself on consum ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
SYSK's 12 Days of Christmas… Toys: How the Nintendo Entertainment System Changed Gaming Forever

Impact and Legacy of Iconic NES Games Like Super Mario Bros

The NES games, especially "Super Mario Bros.," "Zelda," and "Metroid," have left an indelible mark on the world of gaming through their innovative design and engaging player experiences.

Super Mario Bros. NES Release Raised Game Design and Replayability Bar

With the release of Super Mario Bros. alongside the NES Control Deck, game design and player engagement took a monumental leap forward.

Super Mario Bros.: Unprecedented Depth, Exploration, and Hidden Content

Super Mario Bros. presented advanced gameplay and visuals that had a profound impact on children and the gaming industry as a whole. The game introduced players to extensive exploration through its hidden worlds and Easter eggs, offering a new way of gaming that captivated players. This allowed them to continuously discover new areas, like secret levels and hidden bricks, which engaged them for extended periods. The depth of gameplay and ability for long sessions of play without losing interest was a stark contrast to previous gaming experiences, such as those found on the Atari.

Iconic Characters, Memorable Levels, and Addictive Gameplay Created a Phenomenon

With its iconic characters and memorable levels, Super Mario Bros. provided an addictive gameplay that created a gaming phenomenon. Players were drawn to explore every aspect of the Mushroom Kingdom, making the game a pioneer in terms of replayability and attention to detail.

Landmark NES Titles Like Zelda and Metroid Pushed Game Design and Player Experience Boundaries

Following the success of Super Mario Bros., other NES titles like "Zelda" and "Metroid" continued to push the limits of game design and player experience.

Games Pioneered Open-World and Non-linear Progression, Expanding Medium Possibilities

Josh Clark mentions "Metroid" as a groundbreak ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Impact and Legacy of Iconic NES Games Like Super Mario Bros

Additional Materials

Counterarguments

  • While NES games like "Super Mario Bros.," "Zelda," and "Metroid" were innovative, they were not the only games to influence the industry; other platforms and titles also played significant roles in advancing game design.
  • The advancements in game design and player engagement attributed to Super Mario Bros. were part of a broader trend in the industry, with many developers contributing to these improvements.
  • The claim that Super Mario Bros. offered a stark contrast to earlier gaming experiences might overlook the complexity and depth of some Atari games and other contemporaneous titles that also offered rich gameplay experiences.
  • The idea that "The Legend of Zelda" was one of the first successful open-world games could be contested by pointing out earlier examples of open-world design in gaming history.
  • The influence of NES games on subsequent game design and developers, while significant, is just one part of a larger tapestry of influences that includes many other games and technological advancements.
  • The assertion that NES titles like "Zelda" and "Metroid" pushed boundaries may not fully acknowledge the contributions of other contempor ...

Actionables

  • Explore the roots of modern gaming by playing NES classics to understand their design principles and influence. By experiencing games like "Super Mario Bros.," "Zelda," and "Metroid" firsthand, you'll gain a deeper appreciation for the evolution of game mechanics and storytelling. For example, notice how the hidden worlds in "Super Mario Bros." encourage exploration, or how "Metroid" allows for non-linear progression, and compare these elements to modern titles you enjoy.
  • Create a simple game level using free online tools to experiment with design concepts introduced by NES games. Tools like Super Mario Maker or similar level-design platforms enable you to craft levels that incorporate hidden areas, Easter eggs, and open-world elements, giving you a practical understanding of the game design process and the challenges involved in creating engaging player experiences.
  • Start a casual gaming journal to track your e ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
SYSK's 12 Days of Christmas… Toys: How the Nintendo Entertainment System Changed Gaming Forever

Nintendo's Accessories and Peripherals for the Nes

Nintendo sought to capture a wider audience with a variety of innovative, if sometimes unsuccessful, peripherals for the NES.

Nintendo Marketed the Nes With Peripherals to Broaden Appeal

With the goal of appealing to a broad user base, Nintendo bundled the AVS with multiple peripherals, such as a joystick, a musical keyboard, and a ray gun zapper. This strategy was designed to offer diverse functionalities that varied beyond traditional gaming.

R.O.B.: Unsuccessful Attempt to Market Nes as Interactive Toy

The introduction of R.O.B. (Robotic Operating Buddy) was a marketing ploy by Nintendo aimed at positioning the NES as more of a toy to appeal to parents, and not just a conventional gaming console. At the CES, the robot garnered considerable attention as part of the NES system. R.O.B. was designed to interact with the game Gyromite through slow movement with spindle tops, contributing to the initial success of the NES in test markets as purchasers cited R.O.B. as a selling point. However, with limited game support and slow performance, R.O.B. was eventually phased out during the NES's national rollout.

Innovative but Flawed Nes Accessories: Power Pad and Power Glove

Similar innovative strategies saw the introduction of accessories such as the Power Pad and Power Glove. The Power Pad, originally Bandai's Fun and Fitness Pad, was rebranded by Nintendo for the NES, targeting track and field games and foreshadowing modern arcade dance games. Nevertheless, its in-home reception was tepid, as kids often preferred less active engagements indoors. The Power Glove, synonymous with coolness and often recognized from the game Punch-Out, had very few games to support its advanced capabilities. Ultimately, both the Power Pad and Power Glove, much like R.O.B., were seen as before their time and did not achieve lasting success.

Many of Nintendo's Peripheral Experiments Failed, but the Nes Zapper Became a Beloved Part of the Ecosystem

Zapper's Light Detection Offered an Immersive Experience

Although many peripherals failed to make a lasting impact, the Zapper gun was integral to the NES from the beginning. Its light detection feature of the Zapper g ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Nintendo's Accessories and Peripherals for the Nes

Additional Materials

Clarifications

  • The Nintendo Entertainment System (NES) is a home video game console released in the 1980s that revived the video game industry after a market crash. It introduced iconic games and characters, setting standards for game design and quality. The NES popularized cartridge-based games and helped establish Nintendo as a leading company in gaming. Its success laid the foundation for modern console gaming.
  • R.O.B. used optical sensors to detect flashing lights on the TV screen during the game Gyromite. It responded by physically picking up and placing spinning tops (spindles) on the game’s controller buttons. These actions controlled the in-game character by pressing buttons indirectly. This mechanical interaction allowed R.O.B. to "play" the game alongside the player.
  • The Power Pad is a floor mat controller with pressure-sensitive pads that detect players' steps and movements. It was originally created by Bandai as the Fun and Fitness Pad for exercise and interactive games. Nintendo licensed and rebranded it for the NES to encourage physical activity through gameplay. This concept was an early precursor to modern motion-based gaming peripherals.
  • The Power Glove was an early motion-controlled controller that allowed players to move their hand to control games. It used sensors to detect hand position and finger movements, aiming to provide a more immersive experience. Its futuristic design and appearance in popular media, like the movie "The Wizard," made it seem very "cool" at the time. However, its technology was limited and often inaccurate, which hindered gameplay.
  • The NES Zapper detects light by sensing changes in brightness on the TV screen when the trigger is pulled. When fired, the game briefly turns the screen black and then flashes white squares where targets are located. The photodiode in the Zapper detects the white light from these squares to determine if the aim is on target. This method relies on the timing of the screen's light changes to register hits accurately.
  • The NES Zapper is a light gun accessory designed specifically for shooting games. Duck Hunt is the most famous game that uses the Zapper, where players shoot ducks on the screen. The Zapper detects light from the TV to determine if the player hits the target. This combination made Duck Hunt a popular and memorable game for the NES.
  • DuckTales is mentioned to highlight the variety of popular games that contributed to the NES's cultural impact. Although it did not use the Zapper peripheral, it was a well-known title that enriched t ...

Counterarguments

  • The assertion that R.O.B. was phased out due to limited game support and slow performance could be countered by noting that it served its primary purpose as a Trojan horse to get the NES into homes during a time when video games were viewed skeptically by many parents.
  • The idea that the Power Pad and Power Glove were ahead of their time might be challenged by arguing that they were not just premature but also fundamentally flawed in design or execution, which contributed to their lack of success.
  • The claim that the Power Pad's tepid reception was due to kids preferring less active indoor activities could be countered by suggesting that the technology might not have been engaging or responsive enough to sustain interest.
  • The success of the NES Zapper could be critiqued by noting that its technology was limited to a very specific type of game interaction, which may have hindered broader application or long-term relevance in the face of advancing technology.
  • The cultural significance of the NES and its peripherals might be downplayed by arguing that while they were ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
SYSK's 12 Days of Christmas… Toys: How the Nintendo Entertainment System Changed Gaming Forever

Nes Influence on Game Design and Industry

The NES (Nintendo Entertainment System) holds a prominent place in gaming history, largely credited with shaping the fundamentals of game design and influencing the video game industry standards.

Nes Set Game Design Conventions As Industry Standards

Nes Controller Influenced Future Console Controller Designs

The NES controller, revolutionary for its time, marked a significant departure from prior controllers like the Atari joystick. Designed to cater to children and allow them to control gameplay primarily with their thumbs, the NES controller laid the groundwork for most subsequent console controllers. Tae K. Kim, a writer at GamePro, called the NES controller the "language of console gaming," highlighting how it became a template for the industry.

Nes's Focus on Quality Control and Licensing Set a Precedent For Platform Ecosystem Management

Nintendo's approach to quality control and licensing was decidedly rigorous. They demanded detailed explanations of a game's gameplay, characters, and design, often requiring changes to meet their standards. With a dominant market position, Nintendo's strict quality control protocols became so pronounced that they attracted scrutiny from the FTC. These assertive practices set a vital precedent for future platform ecosystem management.

Impact of Nes Titles: Success of Super Mario Bros. and Zelda on Industry

While ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Nes Influence on Game Design and Industry

Additional Materials

Counterarguments

  • While the NES controller was influential, it's important to recognize that it was part of an evolutionary process in controller design, and subsequent consoles introduced their own innovations that were not directly derived from the NES.
  • The quality control and licensing practices of Nintendo, although setting a precedent, were also criticized for being overly restrictive and creating a barrier to entry for smaller developers, which could be seen as stifling creativity and competition.
  • The success of NES titles like Super Mario Bros. and Zelda was significant, but it's also important to acknowledge the contributions of other platforms and games that were influential in expanding the video game industry.
  • The NES's role in transforming video gaming into a dominant force in global entertainment is clear, but it was not the sole factor; the rise of personal computers and other gaming platforms also played a crucial role in this transformation.
  • The idea that the NES set high expectations for quality and sophistication in game design could be seen as overlooking the contributions of earlier platforms and games that also set high standards and introduced ...

Actionables

  • You can explore the evolution of game design by playing a variety of video games from different eras, starting with NES titles. By experiencing the gameplay and mechanics firsthand, you'll gain an appreciation for how the NES set standards in the industry. For example, play an NES game like "Super Mario Bros." and then a modern game to notice the differences and similarities in design and control schemes.
  • Create a simple game concept that adheres to the principles of early NES games, focusing on straightforward controls and immersive gameplay. You don't need to build the game; just sketch out the idea on paper, considering how to make it engaging within the constraints of simpler technology. This exercise will help you understand the design challenges and innovations of the NES era.
  • Reflect on the importance of quality control by evaluating the products you use ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free

Create Summaries for anything on the web

Download the Shortform Chrome extension for your browser

Shortform Extension CTA