Podcasts > Stuff You Should Know > Faking Your Own Death: We All Do It, But Why?

Faking Your Own Death: We All Do It, But Why?

By iHeartPodcasts

In this episode of Stuff You Should Know, the hosts explore the phenomenon of pseudocide—faking one's own death. While movies often depict people faking their deaths to abandon their families, real-life cases frequently stem from financial pressures, attempts to escape criminal prosecution, or efforts to leave abusive relationships. The hosts examine how people attempt pseudocide and the extensive planning required to establish a new identity.

Through various real-world examples, the episode delves into both successful and failed pseudocide attempts, from elaborate schemes involving staged plane crashes to cases where individuals were caught after contacting family members. The hosts also discuss a related phenomenon: faked online deaths, where people fabricate their demise on social media platforms for attention or to escape personal commitments, highlighting how the digital age has created new variations of this age-old practice.

Listen to the original

Faking Your Own Death: We All Do It, But Why?

This is a preview of the Shortform summary of the May 20, 2025 episode of the Stuff You Should Know

Sign up for Shortform to access the whole episode summary along with additional materials like counterarguments and context.

Faking Your Own Death: We All Do It, But Why?

1-Page Summary

Reasons and Motivations For Attempting Pseudocide

People attempt pseudocide (faking their own death) for various reasons. Chuck notes that while movie plots often feature individuals seeking to abandon their families for a fresh start, real-life cases frequently involve financial pressures. Clark observes an increase in pseudocide attempts following the 2008 financial crisis, particularly among those seeking to escape debt or commit insurance fraud. Bryant points out that wealthy individuals sometimes attempt pseudocide to avoid criminal prosecution, while others might use it to escape abusive relationships.

Challenges and Risks In Executing a Successful Pseudocide

Modern pseudocide requires extensive planning and careful execution. A successful attempt typically involves establishing a false identity in advance, sometimes using services that provide "pseudocide kits" including new passports and birth certificates. Curtis Wallen's case demonstrates the importance of building legitimacy for a new identity well in advance, including securing proper documentation and accumulating substantial cash reserves. The challenges of modern surveillance are significant, requiring individuals to evade facial recognition, cell phone tracking, and digital footprints while completely severing ties with their previous life.

Real-Life Examples and Cases of Pseudocide Attempts

Josh introduces several notable cases, including Petra Pazika, a German student who successfully lived under a new identity for 25 years before being discovered following a burglary. Sam Israel III, a hedge fund manager who embezzled $300 million, attempted pseudocide but was caught after contacting his mother. Marcus Shrinker's elaborate 2009 scheme involved staging a plane crash and parachuting to safety, demonstrating the complex planning often involved in pseudocide attempts.

The phenomenon of faked online deaths differs from traditional pseudocide, often motivated by a desire for attention and sympathy. A notable example is the "Casey Nicole" case, where Debbie Swenson created a fictional teenager with leukemia, maintaining the deception for two years. Similarly, author Susan Meachin faked her suicide, allegedly due to online bullying, but was exposed through her distinctive writing style. Some cases involve individuals attempting to escape personal commitments, such as writers on forums who fake their deaths to avoid acknowledging failed promises.

1-Page Summary

Additional Materials

Clarifications

  • Pseudocide is the act of faking one's own death. This can involve creating a new identity to escape various situations like financial troubles, criminal prosecution, or abusive relationships. Successful pseudocide requires careful planning to establish a false identity, evade surveillance, and sever ties with one's previous life. Real-life cases of pseudocide have varied motivations and complexities, often involving elaborate schemes to maintain the deception.
  • Financial pressures leading to pseudocide attempts often stem from situations like overwhelming debt or the desire to commit insurance fraud. Individuals facing financial difficulties may see faking their own death as a way to escape these challenges. The 2008 financial crisis, for example, led to an increase in pseudocide attempts as people sought drastic solutions to their financial woes. Wealthy individuals might also consider pseudocide to avoid legal consequences related to financial crimes or to escape abusive relationships.
  • In executing a successful pseudocide, individuals face challenges from modern surveillance technologies like facial recognition, cell phone tracking, and digital footprints. Evading these surveillance methods is crucial for those attempting to disappear, as any trace of their previous identity could lead to exposure. Successfully severing ties with their past life requires meticulous planning to avoid leaving any digital or physical breadcrumbs that could reveal their true whereabouts. This necessitates a deep understanding of how surveillance tools work and the ability to navigate them effectively to maintain anonymity.
  • Faked online deaths involve pretending to die on the internet for attention or sympathy, often without the intention of disappearing in real life. Traditional pseudocide, on the other hand, involves individuals faking their own deaths in the physical world to escape various situations like debt, criminal prosecution, or abusive relationships. The motivations and methods differ significantly between these two phenomena, with faked online deaths typically being more about emotional manipulation or seeking validation in a virtual space.

Counterarguments

  • While financial pressures are a common reason for pseudocide, it's important to consider that not all financial crises lead to such drastic measures, and many individuals find legal and ethical ways to manage debt and financial failure.
  • The text implies that pseudocide kits and false identities can be easily obtained, but in reality, the use of such kits is illegal in many jurisdictions, and obtaining them can be much more difficult and risky than suggested.
  • The cases mentioned may not represent the full spectrum of pseudocide attempts, as they focus on more sensational and elaborate schemes, potentially overlooking simpler or less dramatic cases that may be more common.
  • The effectiveness of modern surveillance in preventing pseudocide might be overstated, as there are documented cases where individuals have successfully evaded detection for extended periods.
  • The motivations for faked online deaths are varied, and while attention-seeking is one aspect, it may not be fair to generalize this as the primary motivation without considering the complex psychological factors that can contribute to such behavior.
  • The text does not address the ethical implications and the harm caused to family members, friends, and society by pseudocide and faked online deaths, which could be considered a significant oversight in discussing the phenomenon.
  • The text may inadvertently glamorize pseudocide by focusing on successful cases, without adequately addressing the more common outcomes of legal repercussions, failure to maintain the deception, and the personal toll of living a lie.
  • The mention of individuals faking their deaths to avoid acknowledging failed promises may oversimplify the reasons behind such actions and does not consider the potential for underlying mental health issues or other serious personal crises.

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
Faking Your Own Death: We All Do It, But Why?

Reasons and Motivations For Attempting Pseudocide

Pseudocide, the act of faking one's own death, has varied motives ranging from the desire for a fresh start to escaping abuse.

Escaping Personal Relationships or Obligations

Desire to Abandon Family For a Fresh Start

Chuck notes that a person may attempt pseudocide due to a desire to abandon their family to start anew, a trope more commonly found in movies than in reality.

Resolving Financial Troubles

Individuals might be driven to pseudocide to alleviate financial pressures.

Attempting to Commit Insurance Fraud or Escape Debt

Financial incentives, such as escaping significant debt or engineering insurance fraud for a payout, can motivate pseudocide. Clark has observed an uptick in such cases, particularly after the 2008 financial crisis. For example, Elizabeth Greenwood pondered pseudocide as a means of escaping her student loans.

Seeking to Avoid Incarceration for Criminal Activities

Bryant points out that individuals, especially those with greater means, may try pseudocide as a way to avoid legal consequences for crimes like embezzlement. Clark mentions that it's not uncommon for those facing imminent incarceration to consider this drastic option.

Life insurance companies are vigilant ag ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Reasons and Motivations For Attempting Pseudocide

Additional Materials

Counterarguments

  • While the text suggests that pseudocide is a method to abandon family for a fresh start, it's important to consider that such actions can cause significant emotional trauma to the family members left behind, who may believe their loved one is truly deceased.
  • The text implies that financial pressures can lead to pseudocide, but it's worth noting that there are legal and ethical alternatives to managing debt and financial crises that do not involve deception.
  • Regarding the avoidance of incarceration, it's critical to acknowledge that while some may consider pseudocide, the majority of individuals facing legal consequences do not resort to such extreme measures and instead navigate the legal system.
  • The vigilance of life insurance companies against death fraud is mentioned, but it could be argued that despite their efforts, some cases of pseudo ...

Actionables

  • You can create a support network for individuals seeking to leave abusive situations by establishing a confidential helpline that connects them with legal, financial, and psychological resources. This helpline would operate with discretion to ensure the safety of those in danger, providing a step-by-step guide to legally and safely restart their lives without resorting to extreme measures like pseudocide.
  • Develop a financial literacy program that teaches people how to manage debt and financial crises without resorting to fraudulent activities. This program could include workshops on budgeting, debt management, and understanding insurance policies, helping individuals to see viable alternatives to faking their own death when facing financial hardships.
  • Volunteer with ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
Faking Your Own Death: We All Do It, But Why?

Challenges and Risks In Executing a Successful Pseudocide

Pseudocide, or faking one’s death, requires intricate planning and evasion techniques due to modern technological advancements. The hosts examine the hurdles and potential risks involved in executing a convincing and successful pseudocide.

Extensive Planning and Preparation Required

Establishing a Developed False Identity In Advance

To execute pseudocide, one needs a meticulously crafted false identity. Obtaining actual dead bodies from black market morgues, especially in countries like the Philippines, can lend credibility to the deception. People might purchase unidentified or unclaimed bodies to stage a pseudocide. An official death certificate may be procured for a few hundred dollars in such countries. Pseudocide "kits" that include a new passport and a birth certificate may be part of the service.

If someone contemplated pseudocide a decade ago, they might have already been building legitimacy for their new identity by securing credit cards and establishing a credit history. Performance artist Curtis Wallen created an alter ego with a driver’s license and other forms of identification, demonstrating an advance setup of an alternate identity.

Accumulating Cash and Avoiding Suspicious Financial Activity

Curtis Wallen's case suggests that substantial funds are essential, sometimes requiring tens of thousands of dollars for more elaborate schemes. As transactions leave a financial trail, having considerable cash on hand is crucial. To avoid detection, one should make purchases in cash and consider converting assets to Bitcoin. It’s important to plan ahead and save discretely—perhaps burying money in mason jars—while maintaining regular bank activities. Accumulating cash without raising suspicion is vital, exemplified by scenarios such as picking up a year's supply of medication and visiting long-lost relatives to feign planning for the future.

Overcoming Modern Surveillance and Identification Technologies

Evading Facial Recognition, Cell Phone Tracking, Digital Footprints

Evading facial recognition and cell phone tracking requires altering one’s appearance significantly. An artist, Curtis Wallen, manipulated his driver's license photo to include features from others, creating an image that could bypass facial recognition yet appear normal in person. However, every technology from emails to phone calls ca ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Challenges and Risks In Executing a Successful Pseudocide

Additional Materials

Counterarguments

  • The notion of obtaining actual dead bodies from black market morgues raises serious ethical and legal concerns, and suggesting it as a strategy for pseudocide is highly problematic.
  • The text seems to normalize the idea of pseudocide without addressing the potential harm to family and friends who believe their loved one has died.
  • The discussion of pseudocide "kits" and false identities may inadvertently provide a guide for illegal activities, which is irresponsible.
  • The emphasis on cash and Bitcoin to avoid detection does not acknowledge the increasing capabilities of law enforcement to trace financial transactions, even with cryptocurrencies.
  • The idea of evading modern surveillance technologies underestimates the sophistication of these systems and the resources available to law enforcement agencies.
  • The text does not address the psychological impact on the individual attempting pseudocide, including the stress of maintaining a false identity and the isolation from cutting off all previous ties.
  • The text does not consider the legal repercussions and potential criminal charges that could result from faking one's death and the associated fraudulent activities.
  • The text fails to mention the pos ...

Actionables

  • You can explore the world of alternate reality games (ARGs) to understand the complexities of identity and evasion in a controlled environment. ARGs often involve creating a character or narrative that can include elements similar to pseudocide, such as crafting a backstory and evading detection within the game's framework. This can give you a taste of the intricacies involved in such a process without any real-world consequences.
  • Start a creative writing project focused on a character who must disappear and assume a new identity, using your imagination to navigate the challenges they might face. This exercise can help you understand the depth of planning required for pseudocide by considering all aspects of the character's old and new life, from financial to social ties. It's a way to engage with the concept creatively while enhancing your storytelling skills.
  • ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
Faking Your Own Death: We All Do It, But Why?

Real-Life Examples and Cases of Pseudocide Attempts

Pseudocide, the act of faking one's own death, is a phenomenon that both fascinates and puzzles the public. In our investigation of this curious subject, we explore various real-life attempts, both failed and purportedly successful, and the complications that arise not just legally, but also ethically.

Unsuccessful Attempts Quickly Uncovered by Authorities

Josh introduces the topic of pseudocide by stating that we only hear about unsuccessful attempts that have been quickly uncovered by authorities, suggesting that there may be more undetected cases. They highlight the case of Petra Pazika, a German student who in 1984 disappeared at the age of 24. She managed to remain hidden for 25 years, living under a new identity, using cash, and avoiding credit transactions. Her ruse came to an end following a burglary when she was compelled to contact police, who then requested identification that exposed her true identity. Pazika did not face charges since she had not engaged in fraud or obtained false documents; she chose to step away from her previous life, and the reasons for her disappearance are still a mystery to her family.

Sam Israel III, a hedge fund manager who embezzled $300 million, also attempted pseudocide. Facing prison and considerable debt, in June 2008, he staged a suicide. Security footage later showed him escaping with an accomplice. Israel was caught after contacting his mother, who convinced him to surrender to the authorities.

Rare Cases of Long-Term Successful Pseudocide

Marcus Shrinker's case is mentioned in reference to the challenge of maintaining a fabricated identity over time. In 2009, Shrinker, a money manager from Indianapolis, staged a plane crash in hopes of evading lawsuits and divorce proceedings. He had planned thoroughly, securing a large sum of cash which he stowed in a storage facility. Shrinker then parachuted from his plane after signaling distress and left the unmanned aircraft to crash in Florida. He was later discovered after emailing a friend about his escapade.

This reference to Shrinker reveals how complex and calculated pseudocide can be, illustrating that it often involves much mo ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Real-Life Examples and Cases of Pseudocide Attempts

Additional Materials

Actionables

  • You can explore the psychology behind extreme behaviors by starting a journal to reflect on what drives people to drastic actions like pseudocide. Write down your thoughts on what pressures or situations might lead someone to consider such a measure, and how ethical considerations play a role in these decisions. This can increase your empathy and understanding of human behavior under stress.
  • Develop a creative writing hobby where you craft fictional stories based on the concept of starting over or reinventing oneself without resorting to pseudocide. Use characters to explore the complexities and consequences of such decisions, which can enhance your problem-solving and critical thinking skills.
  • Engage in role-playing ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
Faking Your Own Death: We All Do It, But Why?

Faked Online Death As a Related Phenomenon

The hosts explore the concept of faked online deaths, discussing instances and motivations behind this behavior which often relates to psychological issues rather than criminal intent.

Manipulative Motive to Gain Sympathy and Attention

Case of the "Casey Nicole" Online Death Hoax

People fake their own deaths online primarily to gain attention and sympathy, drawing parallels to factitious disorder. An infamous case is that of "Casey Nicole," a supposed teenager with leukemia, who captivated chat forum users beginning in 1999. In May 2001, a post appeared claiming Casey had died. Followers later spotted inconsistencies in her medical details and out-of-place song lyrics. Eventually, a 40-year-old woman, Debbie Swenson, admitted to fabricating "Casey Nicole" using a local girl basketball star’s photo. This hoax lasted two years before she exposed herself. Upon her return, Swenson posted, "Let the fun begin," anticipating a welcoming response; instead, she was met with anger for manipulating people and exploiting online sympathy for her own ego.

Exploitation of Online Anonymity and Lack of Verification

Author Susan Meachin Faked Suicide For two Years

Susan Meachin, a self-published romance author, supposedly died by suicide after being bullied online, as announced by a "daughter." The writing community was outraged at the bullying. Nevertheless, it was later uncovered that Meachin was alive and that her death was a hoax. The key was a specific grammatical quirk in Meachin's writing style that appeared in the posts supposedly made b ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Faked Online Death As a Related Phenomenon

Additional Materials

Counterarguments

  • While the text suggests that faking one's death online is primarily for attention and sympathy, it could also be argued that some individuals may do it as a form of social experiment or artistic expression, challenging the notion that it's always linked to psychological issues or a desire for attention.
  • The case of "Casey Nicole" highlights the manipulative aspect of faking an online death, but it could also be discussed that the perpetrator might have been dealing with complex personal issues, suggesting that not all such hoaxes are done with purely selfish intentions.
  • In the case of Susan Meachin, the criticism of her actions does not consider the possibility that she might have been experiencing severe distress due to the bullying, which could have influenced her decision to fake her death, indicating a need for a more nuanced understanding of her motives.
  • The text implies that faking death to avoid commitments is less manipulative than other moti ...

Actionables

  • You can enhance your digital literacy by learning to spot inconsistencies in online narratives, which could indicate a hoax. Start by reading various online stories and posts critically, looking for patterns or signs that suggest a story might not be genuine, such as sudden changes in writing style or unverifiable dramatic events. This skill can help you avoid being misled by false stories and can be useful in identifying when someone might be seeking attention through deceit.
  • Develop a personal code of ethics for your online interactions to ensure you handle online pressures responsibly. Write down a set of principles that guide your behavior on social media and forums, such as being honest about your achievements and struggles, and committing to taking breaks rather than resorting to extreme measures like faking your own departure from a community. This can help you navigate online commitments and pressures in a healthy way.
  • Create a support network fo ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free

Create Summaries for anything on the web

Download the Shortform Chrome extension for your browser

Shortform Extension CTA