Podcasts > Stuff You Should Know > How Automats Worked

How Automats Worked

By iHeartPodcasts

Stuff You Should Know explores the intriguing history of the automat, an iconic coin-operated restaurant concept that originated in Germany and thrived in the U.S. during the early 20th century.

The episode delves into the rise of the Horn & Hardart automat chain, which became America's largest restaurant franchise during the Great Depression by offering affordable, high-quality comfort food in an elegant, futuristic setting. It also examines the automat's unique features, amenities, and cultural legacy, including its influence on films and literature, despite its eventual decline due to changing economic and social factors.

Listen to the original

How Automats Worked

This is a preview of the Shortform summary of the Jan 23, 2025 episode of the Stuff You Should Know

Sign up for Shortform to access the whole episode summary along with additional materials like counterarguments and context.

How Automats Worked

1-Page Summary

Origins and Spread of the Automat Concept

The automat concept originated in Berlin in 1895 as a vending machine-like restaurant celebrated at the Brussels World Fair. It was first introduced to the U.S. by Joseph Horn and Frank Hardart, who opened their first automat in Philadelphia in 1902.

Despite initial setbacks, Horn and Hardart's automat concept thrived and expanded across the Northeast, becoming the largest U.S. restaurant chain at that time.

Horn & Hardart Automat Chain's Rise and Success

The elegant Art Deco automats served quality pre-made dishes via an iconic coin-operated system allowing customers to retrieve items like oyster stew from behind glass compartments. The automats afforded affordable dining and were an inclusive space welcoming all backgrounds.

During the Great Depression, the automats flourished by offering inexpensive comfort food. By 1932, with locations across NYC and Philadelphia, Horn & Hardart became the nation's largest restaurant chain.

Unique Features and Amenities

The transparent, coin-operated model gave diners autonomy to inspect and select their meals. Automat decor was ornate and futuristic, drawing customers with large windows, marble, and Italian-dolphin inspired coffee dispensers serving quality brews.

Employee perks like company picnics and family holiday events boosted morale and community.

Decline and Cultural Legacy

Suburbanization, economic shifts, and clientele changes led to Horn & Hardart's decline. They eventually replaced automats with Burger King franchises.

Despite fading away, automats made a lasting cultural impact, becoming iconic NYC symbols celebrated in films, TV shows, and literature. Revivals have emerged but failed to match Horn & Hardart's success.

1-Page Summary

Additional Materials

Clarifications

  • The automat concept originated in Berlin in 1895 as a type of restaurant where food was served through vending machine-like systems. Customers could select and retrieve pre-made dishes from compartments by inserting coins, offering a unique dining experience. This concept was later introduced to the U.S. by Joseph Horn and Frank Hardart in 1902, marking the beginning of its popularity in America.
  • The Art Deco automats were characterized by elegant and futuristic design elements, featuring ornate decor with large windows, marble finishes, and Italian-dolphin inspired coffee dispensers. These automats provided a unique dining experience with quality pre-made dishes displayed behind glass compartments, accessible through a coin-operated system. The design aimed to attract customers with a blend of sophistication and convenience, offering a visually appealing setting for patrons to enjoy affordable meals. Employee benefits such as company picnics and family holiday events contributed to a positive work environment and community spirit within the automats.
  • The coin-operated system in automats allowed customers to purchase food by inserting coins into slots, which then unlocked compartments containing pre-made dishes. Customers could see the food through glass windows before making a selection, providing transparency and convenience in the dining experience. This innovative system gave diners control over their meal choices and enabled quick service without the need for traditional waitstaff interaction. The coin-operated feature was a key element of the automat concept, contributing to its efficiency and unique appeal in the early 20th century dining scene.
  • Horn & Hardart's rise in the restaurant industry was propelled by their innovative automat concept, offering affordable and quality pre-made dishes through a coin-operated system. Their expansion across the Northeast and focus on inclusivity contributed to their success, making them the largest U.S. restaurant chain at the time. Despite economic challenges during the Great Depression, the automats thrived by providing inexpensive comfort food and maintaining a strong presence in major cities like New York City and Philadelphia.
  • Employee perks and community events at Horn & Hardart automats were additional benefits provided to the staff beyond their regular work duties. These perks could include activities like company picnics and holiday events for employees and their families. Such initiatives aimed to boost morale, foster a sense of community among the staff, and create a positive work environment within the company. These efforts were part of Horn & Hardart's approach to employee relations and were designed to enhance employee satisfaction and loyalty.
  • The decline of Horn & Hardart's automats was primarily due to factors like suburbanization, economic changes, and shifts in customer preferences. These factors led to a decrease in the popularity and profitability of the automat concept, eventually resulting in the replacement of automats with Burger King franchises. Despite their decline, automats left a lasting cultural impact and are still remembered as iconic symbols in various forms of media.
  • Automats left a lasting cultural impact in NYC, becoming iconic symbols in popular culture such as films, TV shows, and literature. They were celebrated for their unique dining experience and historical significance in the city's culinary landscape. Despite their decline, automats remain a nostalgic and cherished memory for many New Yorkers, symbolizing a bygone era of affordable and convenient dining. Revivals of automats have been attempted but have not achieved the same level of success and cultural significance as the original Horn & Hardart establishments.

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
How Automats Worked

Origins and Spread of the Automat Concept

The automat concept has a rich history that dates back to the late 19th century in Berlin and eventually became an American sensation through the efforts of entrepreneurs Joseph Horn and Frank Hardart.

Automat Concept Began In Late 19th Century Berlin As Vending Machine-Like Restaurant

The automat originated in Berlin in 1895, where it was celebrated with a gold medal at the Brussels World Fair. The term "automat" was then commonly used in Germany to refer to what is essentially a vending machine. This concept of selling food through automated systems quickly caught on and spread across Europe within the next five years.

Automat Concept Introduced To U.S. by Joseph Horn and Frank Hardart, First Opening in Philadelphia, 1902

In the United States, the automat concept was introduced by Joseph Horn and Frank Hardart, who already owned a chain of cafeterias in Philadelphia. They made the decision to bring this innovative self-service restaurant model to the U.S. Their first Automat opened its doors in Philadelphia in 1902.

After Initial Failures, Horn and Hardart's Automats Thrived, Expand ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Origins and Spread of the Automat Concept

Additional Materials

Actionables

  • Explore the history of innovation in your city by visiting local museums or historical landmarks to see how past inventions have shaped the present. This can give you a sense of how ideas like the automat have evolved and influenced modern society, encouraging you to think about how current innovations might shape the future.
  • Start a themed dinner club with friends where each meal is inspired by historical food concepts, like the automat. This not only makes for a unique social gathering but also allows you to creatively explore the evolution of food service and presentation, perhaps leading to your own innovative ideas for food distribution.
  • Create a personal challenge to automate a small aspect of your daily r ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
How Automats Worked

Horn & Hardart Automat Chain's Rise and Success

The Horn & Hardart Automat chain was a fixture in American dining, combining quality food with a unique dining experience that resonated with people from all walks of life, thriving even during times of economic hardship.

Horn & Hardart Automats Offered Quality Food In an Elegant Art Deco Setting

The Automats were not only known for their rigorous cleanliness and the freshness of their food, as unsold food was never used the following day, but also for their elegant Art Deco settings. These dining establishments featured large windows, marble, stained glass, bronze details, and even mezzanines for upstairs dining—a trend reflective of the times.

Coin-Operated System For Retrieving Pre-made Dishes Behind Glass Compartments

Horn & Hardart's coin-operated system was iconic, allowing customers to retrieve pre-made dishes from behind glass compartments. This system was so effective that the price of coffee remained fixed at a nickel for 38 years, despite the coin-operated mechanism's limitations, which only accepted nickels. Clark clarifies that while the automat gave an illusion of robotic service, behind the scenes was a busy staff who stocked the compartments with food from the central commissaries. Customers would use a coin to access selections like a bubbling oyster stew.

Automats Thrived In Depression With Affordable Meals

During the Great Depression, the automats flourished by serving affordable comfort food. By 1932, they expanded to become the largest restaurant chain in the U.S., with 42 automats in New York City and another 20 in Philadelphia. The automats were prized for their nickel cups of good coffee and the ability for patrons to sit undisturbed for extended periods due to the absence of traditional front-house sta ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Horn & Hardart Automat Chain's Rise and Success

Additional Materials

Clarifications

  • Art Deco settings in the context of the Horn & Hardart Automats referred to the design style characterized by bold geometric forms, bright colors, and luxurious materials popular in the 1920s and 1930s. These settings featured elements like large windows, marble, stained glass, bronze details, and mezzanines, reflecting the elegance and modernity of the Art Deco movement. The Art Deco design of the Automats aimed to create a visually striking and sophisticated dining environment for patrons, enhancing their overall dining experience. The incorporation of Art Deco elements contributed to the unique and upscale ambiance of the Horn & Hardart Automats, setting them apart from traditional dining establishments of the time.
  • A central commissary in the context of Horn & Hardart Automats was a central kitchen facility where food was prepared and distributed to the various Automat locations. This central kitchen ensured consistency in food quality and allowed for efficient restocking of the glass compartments in the Automats. Staff at the central commissaries prepared and supplied the pre-made dishes that customers could access using the coin-operated system in the Automats. The central commissaries played a crucial role in the operation of the Automat chain, supporting the unique dining experience offered to customers.
  • Front-house staff typically includes servers, hosts, and managers who interact directly with customers in a restaurant setting. They are responsible for taking orders, serving food and drinks, and ensuring a positive dining experience for patrons. In the context of the Automats, the absence of traditional front-house staff meant that customers retrieved their food directly from the coin-operated compartments without the need for servers or managers. This unique setup ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
How Automats Worked

Unique Features and Amenities of the Automat Restaurants

Automat restaurants revolutionized dining with their coin-operated, self-service model and their ornate, futuristic decor. They also provided a welcoming environment for both customers and employees.

Automat's Coin-Operated, Self-Service Model Gave Diners Control

The self-service, coin-operated model of automat restaurants gave diners the independence to inspect and select their meals. Customers could easily see and choose their preferred dishes through glass display cases. Change employees, specifically women referred to as "nickel throwers," provided patrons with the necessary coins to operate the vending machines where food items like oyster stew were displayed behind glass compartments accessible by inserting a coin and pulling a lever. Although the automation of food dispensing was perceived as high-tech, staff worked behind the scenes to continually refill the compartments ensuring a steady supply of fresh food.

Glass Display Cases Let Customers Inspect and Select Dishes

The hosts discuss the transparent nature of Automat's food service that allowed customers control over their dining experience. Bryant and Clark touch on how the glass display cases and coin-operated system let patrons choose exactly what they wanted, bringing a sense of autonomy and immediate satisfaction to the experience.

Automat restaurants weren't just about food; they provided a distinctive atmosphere that felt both elegant and forward-looking. They featured a two-story facade, abundant light from large windows, and were often decorated with fine details like marble and stained glass. These aesthetic choices, combined with the Jetson-like futuristic elements as described by Josh Clark and Chuck Bryant, drew people in and made the dining experience uniquely appealing, especially to children.

Employee Perks: Coffee and Family Holiday Events Boosted Automat's Appeal

Automats were known for their coffee, which was maint ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Unique Features and Amenities of the Automat Restaurants

Additional Materials

Counterarguments

  • The coin-operated, self-service model may have limited the menu variety and freshness of food compared to traditional restaurants.
  • While the glass display cases provided transparency, they might have also led to increased food waste if items were not chosen by customers.
  • The novelty of the coin-operated system could wear off, potentially making the experience less appealing over time.
  • The reliance on "nickel throwers" could be seen as an unnecessary intermediary in the dining process.
  • The ornate, futuristic decor might have resulted in higher costs for the establishment, which could have been passed on to customers in the price of the food.
  • The frequent brewing of coffee every 20 minutes, while ensuring freshness, could also be seen as potentially wasteful if demand did n ...

Actionables

- You can create a themed dinner experience at home by setting up a self-service buffet with clear labeling and a unique decor inspired by a past era or a futuristic theme. For example, use glass containers to display food and decorate your dining area with elements reminiscent of the Automat's art deco style to give your family or guests a sense of autonomy and a unique dining experience.

  • Organize a community event where local residents can exchange homemade dishes using a token system, similar to the Automat's coin-operated model. Set up booths with clear displays of food, and provide tokens that people can use to 'purchase' different dishes, encouraging a sense of community and sharing among neighbors.
  • Implement a tradition of hosting small, themed gatherings with friends or f ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
How Automats Worked

The Decline and Cultural Legacy of the Automat

The automat, once an iconic part of urban life, particularly in New York City, has descended into obscurity, yet it has left an indelible mark on American culture.

Suburbanization and Economic Shifts Ended Horn & Hardart

Horn & Hardart, facing the decline of their automats, saw their valuable real estate as a silver lining. They decided to replace the automats with Burger King franchises, effectively ending the era of their iconic self-service eateries.

Horn & Hardart's Automat Adaptation Failed

As Horn & Hardart's business waned, a shift in clientele took place. The spaces that were once family-friendly became havens for the homeless and transient, deterring the traditional middle-class customers. Despite their ethos of serving everyone equally, the change in patronage contributed to a vicious cycle of decline.

The rise of suburbanization pulled people away from city centers, and neighborhood disruption due to the construction of U.S. interstates dealt another blow to the automat concept. With reduced patronage, the economics of scale that once made their huge central commissary kitchens viable ceased to be efficient.

Cultural Impact of Automats: Iconic NYC Symbols Inspiring Books, Films, TV

Even though the automats faded, their cultural impact endured. Celebrities such as Audrey Hepburn were fans, and automats became ingrained as a symbol of New York, comparable to the Empire State Building or Broadway plays.

Attempts to Revive Automats Fall Short of Horn & Hardart's Success

Automats entered the realms of film and television as a trope to evoke the ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

The Decline and Cultural Legacy of the Automat

Additional Materials

Clarifications

  • Automats were self-service restaurants where customers could obtain food and drinks from vending machines or behind glass doors by inserting coins. They were popular in urban areas like New York City, offering convenience and quick service. Automats became cultural icons, symbolizing modernity and urban life, inspiring various forms of art and entertainment. Despite their decline in popularity due to economic shifts and changing consumer preferences, automats remain a significant part of American culinary history.
  • Horn & Hardart was a prominent company known for popularizing and operating automats, self-service restaurants where customers could purchase food from vending machines. They played a significant role in shaping American dining culture, particularly in urban areas like New York City. Horn & Hardart faced challenges as economic shifts and changing demographics led to the decline of the automat concept, ultimately impacting their business success. Despite their historical significance, attempts to revive the automat concept have struggled to replicate the iconic status and widespread popularity of Horn & Hardart's original automats.
  • Suburbanization drew people away from city centers, reducing patronage at urban establishments like automats. The construction of U.S. interstates disrupted neighborhoods and further impacted the viability of automats by altering urban landscapes. These shifts in population and infrastructure contributed to the decline of automats as they struggled to maintain their customer base and economic sustainability.
  • Automats have been featured in various forms of media like books, films, and TV shows as a symbol of New York City. They are often used to evoke a sense of nostalgia or urban life in the past. These cultural representations showcase the unique self-service dining experience and the social dynamics of automats. Characters interacting in automats in these works often reflect a specific time period or social atmosphere.
  • The decline of automats was primarily due to suburbanization drawing people away from city centers, economic shifts leading to changes in patronage, and neighborhood disruptions caused by the construction of U.S. interstates. Additionally, the rise of fast-food chains like Burger King replac ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free

Create Summaries for anything on the web

Download the Shortform Chrome extension for your browser

Shortform Extension CTA