Podcasts > Stuff You Should Know > Short Stuff: The wAve

Short Stuff: The wAve

By iHeartPodcasts

In this episode of the Stuff You Should Know podcast, the hosts explore the origins of the wave—a phenomenon at large sporting events that has sparked debate over its validity and impact.

While two individuals claim independent credit for inventing the wave in the early 1980s, the discussion examines the details that set their versions apart. The wave's global rise to popularity is traced, from its debut at the 1986 World Cup to its unique variations adopted by various teams and stadiums.

Additionally, the episode dives into the scientific analysis conducted by Hungarian physicists, uncovering insights into the physical and social dynamics behind the wave's propagation. Finally, the hosts weigh the arguments from critics who view the wave as a distraction and supporters who celebrate it as an exciting tradition, leaving the audience to judge this longstanding debate.

Listen to the original

Short Stuff: The wAve

This is a preview of the Shortform summary of the Nov 13, 2024 episode of the Stuff You Should Know

Sign up for Shortform to access the whole episode summary along with additional materials like counterarguments and context.

Short Stuff: The wAve

1-Page Summary

The Disputed Origins of the Wave

According to the podcast, two individuals independently claim to have invented the wave at sporting events in the early 1980s:

George Henderson, a San Jose State cheerleader known as "Crazy George," asserts he developed the wave concept and executed an early "proto-wave" version at an Oakland A's game in 1981.

Rob Weller, the "yell king" at the University of Washington, conceptualized an "expandable cheer" in 1981. After a suggestion from the band director Bill Bissell to reverse the direction, it became a continuous, oval motion - the wave as we know it today.

Bill Bissell strongly contests Henderson's claim, arguing Henderson's version didn't truly form the oval shape required for a legitimate wave in a baseball stadium.

The Wave Goes Global

Though originating in the U.S., the wave quickly gained international popularity after being featured at the 1986 World Cup in Mexico, earning the name "Mexican wave" worldwide.

Teams and stadiums in the U.S. developed unique variations like the "silent wave" at Michigan Stadium and incorporating the jingling of car keys to add an auditory element.

Scientific Analysis of the Wave

In 2002, Hungarian physicists used computer models to study the wave, uncovering:

  • As few as 20-30 people can successfully start a wave traveling clockwise at ~20 seats per second
  • An individual's "readiness" to join based on neighbors' behavior influences participation
  • Insights into the physical and social dynamics driving wave propagation

Debate over Wave's Impact on Sporting Events

Critics argue the wave distracts from crucial gameplay moments when fan focus is needed, potentially impacting results. A "stopthewave.net" campaign emerged against the practice.

Supporters like inventor Rob Weller view the wave as an exciting, joy-bringing tradition enhancing the overall atmosphere. Despite some opposition, Weller acknowledged people "still like it" and reluctantly accepted its continued existence.

1-Page Summary

Additional Materials

Counterarguments

  • George Henderson's claim to have developed the wave could be challenged by the lack of documented evidence or eyewitness accounts corroborating his version of events.
  • Rob Weller's claim might be contested by those who argue that the wave could have emerged organically from crowd behavior without a single inventor.
  • Bill Bissell's insistence on the oval shape might be seen as too strict a criterion, as the wave's essence is in its continuity and crowd participation, not necessarily its shape.
  • The term "Mexican wave" might be considered a misnomer by those who argue that the wave's origins are in the United States, and the World Cup simply popularized it internationally.
  • The unique variations of the wave, such as the "silent wave" or the jingling of car keys, might be criticized for not adding significant value to the tradition and potentially causing distractions themselves.
  • The findings of the Hungarian physicists could be challenged on the basis that computer models may not fully capture the spontaneity and human elements of crowd behavior.
  • The argument that the wave distracts from gameplay could be countered by pointing out that many aspects of fan participation, such as cheering or booing, could also be seen as distractions but are generally accepted parts of the sporting event experience.
  • The view of the wave as a tradition that enhances the atmosphere could be opposed by those who feel it has become an overused and clichéd part of sporting events, losing its original charm and excitement.

Actionables

  • You can explore the social dynamics of group activities by initiating a new wave variation at a local sports event. Start by gathering a small group of friends and propose a unique motion, like a "high-five wave" where each person high-fives their neighbor to pass the wave along. This can be a fun experiment to see how quickly a new idea can catch on and spread through a crowd.
  • Enhance your understanding of crowd psychology by observing reactions to the wave at different types of events. Attend various sporting events or concerts and take note of when the wave starts, how people react to it, and whether it seems to affect the atmosphere of the event. This can give you insights into how collective behaviors form and evolve in different settings.
  • Use the concept of the wave to create a team-building exercise in a non-sporting context. For example, during a company meeting or workshop, introduce a "wave of ideas" where each participant contributes a thought or suggestion in quick succession, creating a visual and participatory representation of brainstorming. This can help encourage participation and make the process of sharing ideas more dynamic and engaging.

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
Short Stuff: The wAve

The competing claims of the wave's invention

An intriguing controversy exists over the true originator of the wave, with two individuals, George Henderson and Rob Weller, independently claiming to have invented it, each presenting a distinct narrative of its invention.

Two individuals, George Henderson and Rob Weller, independently claim to have invented the wave in the early 1980s, with their versions debuting within two weeks of each other.

George Henderson, a San Jose State cheerleader, claims he developed the wave concept in the late 1970s and first executed it at an Oakland A's game in 1981, though his version was more of a "proto-wave" than a fluid, continuous motion.

George Henderson, known as "Crazy George," was a San Jose State cheerleader who asserts that the wave was an idea he'd worked on for years. It finally came to fruition at an Oakland A's game on October 15, 1981. Although this initial version, captured on camera, involved one section following another rather than a seamless motion, Henderson insists that it was the early inception of the wave.

Rob Weller, known as the "yell king" at the University of Washington, had a similar concept he called the "expandable cheer" in 1981, but it was a section-by-section motion until a band director suggested reversing the direction to create a true wave.

Rob Weller's journey with the wave began at the University of Washington, where, as a cheerleader and the "yell king," he spearheaded an "expandable cheer." Initially, this cheer progressed section by section in an upward motion. It wasn't until Bill Bissell, the band director, proposed inverting the direction—sending the motion outward rath ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

The competing claims of the wave's invention

Additional Materials

Counterarguments

  • The claim that George Henderson executed the first wave at an Oakland A's game in 1981 might be contested by pointing out that without widespread documentation or third-party verification, it's difficult to establish the authenticity of his account.
  • Rob Weller's "expandable cheer" might not be considered a true invention of the wave if it required the suggestion from Bill Bissell to reverse the direction to create the continuous motion we associate with the wave today.
  • Bill Bissell's argument that Henderson's wave did not form a true oval shape and therefore should not be considered the legitimate form of the wave could be seen as overly rigid, as the essence of the wav ...

Actionables

  • You can explore the nature of collaboration by teaming up with a friend to create a small project, like a themed dinner party, and see how your combined ideas evolve.
  • By working together, you'll experience firsthand how ideas can merge and change with input from others, much like the wave concept developed through collaboration. For example, you might start with an Italian dinner theme, and your friend could suggest a twist by turning it into a costume party, showing how ideas expand and take on new forms.
  • You can practice critical observation by attending a local sports event and analyzing the crowd's behavior.
  • Pay attention to how people react collectively to different stimuli, such as music or exciting moments in the game. This will give you insight into group dynamics and how certain actions, like the wave, can be initiated and spread through a crowd. Take notes on what triggers the most synchronized responses and reflect on the factors that contribute to successful collective actions.
  • You can engage in a playful debate w ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
Short Stuff: The wAve

The international spread and renaming of the wave

The phenomenon known as the wave has transcended its American origins, becoming an international spectacle particularly associated with soccer matches around the globe.

While the wave originated in the United States, it quickly spread to Mexico, where it was hosted during the 1986 World Cup and became known internationally as the "Mexican wave."

After beginning in the United States, the wave found its way to Mexico and subsequently captured the hearts of global audiences during the 1986 World Cup. There, it was embraced and celebrated for its captivating, fluid motion and became a regular feature at soccer/football matches. Owing to its breakout at this international event, it earned the name "Mexican wave" and is still called this outside the United States.

Some stadiums and teams in the US developed their own unique variations of the wave

While the core phenomenon of the wave remained co ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

The international spread and renaming of the wave

Additional Materials

Counterarguments

  • The claim that the wave is universally beloved might be overstated, as there are individuals and groups who find it distracting or uninteresting.
  • The term "Mexican wave" might be seen as a misnomer since the wave did not originate in Mexico, which could lead to misunderstandings about its origins.
  • The assertion that the wave is a staple at all sporting events could be challenged, as its popularity and occurrence can vary greatly depending on the sport, the country, and the specific culture of the fans.
  • The idea that the wave has become an international spectacle might be contested by pointing out that ...

Actionables

  • You can create a personalized wave routine to share with friends at local events, incorporating elements that represent your group's interests or in-jokes. For example, if you and your friends are into sci-fi, you could all wear glow-in-the-dark bracelets and raise them during the wave, creating a 'galactic wave' effect at night-time events.
  • Start a social media challenge where you encourage people from different parts of the world to post their unique take on the wave. This could involve using local cultural symbols, traditional clothing, or even local music to add a distinct flair to the wave, fostering a sense of global community and creativity.
  • Organize a small-scale wave at family gath ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
Short Stuff: The wAve

The scientific analysis and understanding of the wave

Physicists from the Hungarian Academy of Sciences delved into the science behind the wave phenomenon at sporting events through computer models, revealing not only the minimum requirement for its initiation but also its predictable directions and the underlying social behavior.

In 2002, physicists from the Hungarian Academy of Sciences conducted computer models and studies on the wave at sporting events, identifying key parameters that influence its propagation.

Based on the findings reported in the esteemed journal Nature, the researchers identified three key parameters that determine the wave's success: the distance between spectators, the number of neighbors a spectator could see, and an individual's readiness to stand up if others nearby are already standing. These parameters helped to provide a deeper understanding of the mechanics of wave creation and momentum.

The studies found that as few as 20-30 people are needed to start a successful wave, which almost invariably travels in a clockwise direction at a speed of about 20 seats per second.

The studies intriguingly revealed that it only takes about 20-30 people to initiate a successful wave. This small group, through their actions, is able to catalyze a larger crowd into participating in the wave that then travels almost invariably in a clockwise direction at a consistently measured pace of approximately 20 seats per second.

The studies also examined the "readiness" or probability of individuals to stand up and participate, based on the actions of those around them, highlighting the social dynamics involved in the wave's spread.

By examining factors like the readiness of an individual to join in the wave based on the behavior of their i ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

The scientific analysis and understanding of the wave

Additional Materials

Clarifications

  • The minimum requirement for initiating the wave phenomenon at sporting events is as few as 20-30 people standing up in unison. This small group's coordinated action can catalyze a larger crowd to participate in the wave. The wave typically starts in a section of the audience and spreads in a clockwise direction at a speed of about 20 seats per second. The readiness of individuals to stand up and join in, influenced by the behavior of those around them, plays a crucial role in the wave's initiation and propagation.
  • The specific parameters identified by the researchers that determine the success of the wave are: the distance between spectators, the number of neighbors a spectator could see, and an individual's readiness to stand up if others nearby are already standing. These factors play a crucial role in understanding how the wave initiates and spreads among a crowd at sporting events.
  • The speed at which the wave travels is approximately 20 seats per second in a clockwise direction. This means that the wave moves around the stadium at a consistent pace, with each "seat" of spectators participating in the wave moving forward at this speed. The speed of the wave is influenced by the initial group of 20-30 people who start it, setting the pace for others to follow suit. The wave's speed is a result of the coordinated standing and sitting movements of spectators as it progresses through the crowd.
  • The wave phenomenon at sporting events showcases how individual actions, like standing up, can inf ...

Counterarguments

  • The study's findings may not be universally applicable to all sporting events or cultural contexts, as crowd behaviors can vary significantly across different regions and sports.
  • The model's parameters, while insightful, may oversimplify the complexity of human social behavior and the spontaneity of crowd actions.
  • The research assumes a level of homogeneity in crowd behavior that may not account for the diversity of individual motivations and actions within a large group.
  • The study's focus on the mechanics of the wave might overlook other relevant factors that contribute to the phenomenon, such as the influence of alcohol, team performance, or the overall mood in the stadium.
  • The conclusion that the wave travels almost invariably in a clockwise direction might be an oversimplification, as there could be instances where the wave travels counter-clockwise or changes direction based on specific crowd interactions or stadium designs.
  • The research might benefit from cross-disciplinary perspectives, incorporating insights from sociology or psychology to deepen the understanding of the social dynamics involved.
  • The number of people required to initiate a wave (20-30) could be contingent on various factors not fully explored in the study, such ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
Short Stuff: The wAve

The debate around the merits and downsides of the wave at sporting events

The wave, a common sight at sporting events, prompts a heated debate about whether it enhances the overall experience or interrupts the focus on the game.

The Argument Against the Wave

Some fans and commentators believe that the wave can distract from crucial moments of live gameplay. They argue that executing the wave at a critical time not only detrails the attention but could be detrimental to the outcome of the game for the home team, as intense moments require full audience concentration.

A website by the name of "stopthewave.net" was launched to advocate against this practice, emphasizing the downsides of participating in the wave. It evolved into a Facebook group and Tumblr, reflecting an ongoing campaign against the practice. In 2022, the Texas Rangers took humor in the debate, cautioning fans on the scoreboard that taking part in the wave could lead to pulled muscles and jokingly warned that children found doing the wave might be sold to the circus.

Debating the Wave’s Merits

On the flip side, individuals like Josh Clark argue that the wave is an integral and exciting part of sporting events, contributing energy and joy to the stadium atmosphere. These sentiments suggest that there is a faction of fans and sp ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

The debate around the merits and downsides of the wave at sporting events

Additional Materials

Counterarguments

  • The wave may not actually distract players as they are trained to focus and often tune out crowd noise and activities.
  • The timing of the wave is usually managed by fans, who often choose less critical moments to participate, minimizing potential negative impact on the game.
  • The wave can be seen as a form of collective expression and unity among fans, which could be argued to enhance the community aspect of sporting events.
  • The warnings about pulled muscles and selling children to the circus by the Texas Rangers are clearly in jest and not serious criticisms of the wave.
  • The wave's contribution to energy and joy in the stadium could be subjective, as not all attendees may feel this way; some might find it a disruption to their enjoyment of the game.
  • While the wave is a cherished tradition for some, others may not share this sentiment and could prefer other forms of fan engagem ...

Actionables

  • You can create a personal code of conduct for attending live sports events to ensure you're contributing positively to the game atmosphere. Decide in advance at which moments you'll join in activities like the wave and when you'll stay focused on the game. For example, you might choose to participate in the wave during halftime or breaks but remain attentive during crucial plays.
  • Develop a simple stretching routine to do before participating in stadium waves to prevent muscle strains. This could include shoulder rolls, arm stretches, and gentle torso twists. Share these stretches with friends or fellow fans around you to promote a safer way to enjoy the tradition.
  • ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free

Create Summaries for anything on the web

Download the Shortform Chrome extension for your browser

Shortform Extension CTA