Podcasts > Stuff You Should Know > True Mysteries of the Internet

True Mysteries of the Internet

By iHeartPodcasts

The "Stuff You Should Know" podcast plunges into the depths of the internet's most intriguing mysteries, from the Cicada 3301 puzzle series that challenged codebreakers worldwide to the decades-long hunt for the anonymous artist behind the enigmatic synthpop song recorded off German radio in the 1980s.

The podcast also delves into the captivating tale of John Titor, the alleged time traveler who shared vivid details of a post-apocalyptic 2036 America. These unsolved mysteries, propelled by the internet, have sparked intense speculation, investigative efforts, and philosophical musings about privacy, time travel, and the motives behind their creators.

Listen to the original

True Mysteries of the Internet

This is a preview of the Shortform summary of the Aug 20, 2024 episode of the Stuff You Should Know

Sign up for Shortform to access the whole episode summary along with additional materials like counterarguments and context.

True Mysteries of the Internet

1-Page Summary

The Cicada 3301 Puzzle Series

The Cicada 3301 puzzle series, starting in January 2012, presented an enigmatic set of cryptic online puzzles that captured internet users' attention.

Encoded Puzzles Spurring a Virtual Scavenger Hunt

The challenges, posted anonymously on 4chan and Twitter, required skills like steganography, cryptography, and code-breaking to decode hidden messages and clues. Participants had to navigate multi-layered puzzles featuring encoded images and messages, at times using tools from Welsh legends to Mayan numerals.

Real-World Locations and an Abrupt Ending

Decoded clues led solvers on an international journey, ultimately directing them to physical locations with QR codes. However, before all could finish, the creators took down the final website due to disappointment over some solvers' collaboration.

Theorizing the Creators' Motives

While a government recruitment effort has been suggested, commentators like Marcus Wanner propose the creators were likely a hacker collective interested in internet privacy and freedom, seeking talented codebreakers. An ex-member's leak hints at transformational goals aligning with hacker ideologies.

The Most Mysterious Song on the Internet

Despite extensive sleuthing, the origins of "the most mysterious song on the internet" remain unknown, puzzling music enthusiasts for decades.

An Unidentified 1980s Song Recorded Off Radio

In the 1980s, a German man named Darius recorded a distinctive synthpop/post-punk song off NDR Eintz radio. Analysis places the song's broadcast around 1983-1984, yet it does not appear on archived station playlists.

Extensive Search Efforts

Efforts to identify the song have included spectrographic analysis, scrutinizing old radio playlists, and crowdsourcing online. Theories propose it could be from an obscure Eastern Bloc musician, while the artist may be aware yet elusive.

The Story of John Titor, The Supposed Time Traveler

The tale of John Titor, who claimed to travel from 2036, spinning a vivid future narrative, has become one of the internet's greatest mysteries.

Claims of a Post-Apocalyptic Future America

According to Titor, America in 2036 had been ravaged by civil war and WWIII, with a collapsed economy yet stronger communities. His scientific explanations of time travel using actual physics terms lent some credence.

Efforts to Verify Titor's Identity

Investigations have traced online breadcrumbs to Florida's Haber brothers and their company, as well as lawyer Kay Titor. However, key identity details behind the persona remain uncertain, shrouded in further mysteries like Joseph Matheny's alleged role.

Resonance through Philosophical Musings

Titor's story resonates due to his philosophical reflections contrasting the 2000s with his described 2036, as well as the creativity behind the unsolved mystery surrounding his true identity and motives.

1-Page Summary

Additional Materials

Counterarguments

  • The creators of Cicada 3301 may not have been disappointed with collaboration but rather expected it, as collaboration is often necessary in solving complex problems.
  • It's possible that the Cicada 3301 creators were not a hacker collective but rather an individual or a group from a different background with different motives.
  • The "most mysterious song on the internet" might not be from an obscure Eastern Bloc musician but could be a one-time project or a song by a Western band that didn't gain popularity.
  • There may be more practical explanations for the song's anonymity, such as lost records or a small production run, rather than the artist being deliberately elusive.
  • John Titor's claims could be entirely fictional, created as a form of entertainment or social experiment, rather than a genuine account of time travel.
  • The connections to the Haber brothers and Kay Titor might be coincidental or part of an elaborate hoax, rather than evidence of their involvement in the John Titor story.
  • Titor's use of actual physics terms could be seen as a way to add plausibility to a fictional story, rather than lending credence to his claims.
  • The resonance of Titor's story might be less about philosophical musings and more about the human fascination with time travel and dystopian futures.

Actionables

  • You can enhance your problem-solving skills by creating a puzzle hunt for friends using basic ciphers and hidden messages in images. Start by learning simple encryption methods online, then hide clues in pictures you send to your friends, leading them to a small prize or gathering spot in your town.
  • Develop your historical analysis abilities by researching a lesser-known event or figure from your local area's past. Visit your local library or historical society, gather information, and try to piece together a story or timeline that's not widely known, which can give you a sense of being a detective in your own community.
  • You can explore philosophical ideas by writing a short story set in a future based on current societal trends. Think about how today's world might evolve, and create characters that embody different philosophies or reactions to that future, helping you reflect on your own thoughts about the direction society is heading.

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
True Mysteries of the Internet

The Cicada 3301 puzzle series

The Cicada 3301 puzzle series is an enigmatic phenomenon that captured the attention of cryptographers and conspiracy theorists alike when it appeared anonymously online.

A series of cryptic online puzzles that captured the attention of internet users

A cryptic message that appeared on the 4chan media platform challenged potential solvers with a cryptic image and a promise of a hidden message inside—an incentive that quickly caught the eye of internet users worldwide.

The puzzles were posted anonymously on 4chan and Twitter starting in January 2012, challenging participants to solve encoded messages and find clues

The Cicada 3301 puzzles, a set of three puzzles beginning on January 4th, 2012, were originally posted on platforms like 4chan and later on Twitter. Solvers had to dive into various encoded and hidden messages, which often featured an image of a cicada.

Solvers had to use skills like steganography, cryptography, and code-breaking to progress through the multi-layered puzzles

Participants had to employ a wide range of skills to navigate through the complex web of puzzles Cicada 3301 presented. Josh Clark mentions that steganography, cryptography, and code-breaking were all essential components of the mystery, with steganography, in particular, being the method used within many of the challenges. Tools on the internet facilitated the decoding of these steganographic messages. For instance, a 15-year-old known as Tech discovered a message through Notepad that indicated a Caesar cipher, which led to a website. Steganography and other sophisticated methods were repeatedly employed, utilizing everything from Welsh Arthurian legends to Mayan numerals that had to be decoded.

Puzzles led participants on a scavenger hunt in the real world

The complexity of these puzzles transcended the virtual realm and led participants on an international journey.

Clues eventually directed solvers to physical locations around the world, where they had to find flyers with QR codes

Decoded clues led to a website with a countdown clock, after which GPS coordinates provided centred on several real-world locations. Solvers were directed to these coordinates, spanning the globe from America to Spain, where they found flyers with QR codes on telephone poles.

The final puzzle website was taken down before some participants could reach the end

However, not everyone made it to the final leg of the series; Joel Erikson, a solver who closely followed the clues, found that the final website was taken down due to the creators' disappointment in the collaborative efforts of some participants.

The identity and purpose of the Cicada 3301 creators remains a mystery

Despite the intense scr ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

The Cicada 3301 puzzle series

Additional Materials

Actionables

  • You can sharpen your problem-solving skills by creating a puzzle night with friends where each person brings a unique, encrypted message to solve. This encourages you to practice cryptography in a fun, social setting and can be as simple as using a Caesar cipher or creating a basic substitution code.
  • Enhance your awareness of digital privacy by setting up a personal challenge to learn about and implement one new internet privacy tool each month, such as a VPN, encrypted messaging app, or privacy-focused browser. This helps you understand the importance of internet privacy and take proactive steps to protect your own information.
  • Explore your local area with a self-organi ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
True Mysteries of the Internet

The "most mysterious song on the internet"

"The most mysterious song on the internet," an enigma that has puzzled online communities and music aficionados for years, remains an unsolved riddle. Its origins and creator stay elusive despite extensive detective work by enthusiasts and experts alike.

An unknown 1980s synthpop/post-punk song recorded off the radio by a German man named Darius

In the early 1980s, a German man named Darius S recorded the song off the radio along with 25 other tracks on a mixtape. With a distinctive rigid beat, dry vocals, and a pronounced guitar riff, the song was the only one Darius could not identify, marking it with a question mark on the tracklisting. His mixtape, known as cassette four, featured known bands such as XTC and The Cure, suggesting a possible timeframe of 1983-1984 for the mysterious track, based on the tape deck model and the era of the included songs.

Decades-long efforts to identify the song and its creators have been unsuccessful

Efforts to uncover the song's origins have been meticulous and constant. Spectrogram analysis has verified the song was recorded from Germany's NDR Eintz radio station. Enthusiasts have scrutinized playlists from various radio shows, including those of Paul Baskerville, who hosted a radio show in 1984, yet no matches have been found. The song does not appear on any archived playlist, despite the confirmation that it was played on that station.

Darius's sister, Lydia H, propelled the search onto the internet in 2007, and the song has been posted on multiple websites to crowdsource its identification. Yet, attempts to decipher the presumably English lyrics, spoken by a seemingly non-American, have only led to speculative titles such as "Like the Wind", "Blind the Wind," "Locked Away," "Check it in, check it out," "Take it in, take it out," and "Disco Woman."

The mys ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

The "most mysterious song on the internet"

Additional Materials

Counterarguments

  • The assumption that the song was recorded from Germany's NDR Eintz radio station based solely on spectrogram analysis might be questioned, as this does not conclusively prove the song's broader origins or its artist.
  • The idea that the song's artist might be aware of its recent attention but chooses to remain anonymous is purely speculative and assumes the artist's knowledge and intent without any direct evidence.
  • The theory that the song may have been created by an obscure East German or Eastern Bloc musician is one of many possibilities and may overshadow other plausible explanations about the song's origins.
  • The focus on the song's mystery might inadvertently romanticize the lack of information, potentially detracting from a more critical analysis of why certain music becomes lost or forgotten.
  • The narrative that the song is a cultural phenomenon may be influenced by th ...

Actionables

- You can explore the power of crowd-sourcing by starting a social media group dedicated to uncovering lost media from personal collections, encouraging members to share and investigate unlabelled or mysterious recordings they possess.

  • By creating a platform for collective investigation, you tap into the collective memory and resources of a community. For example, members can upload images of unmarked cassettes or vinyl records, share audio clips of unknown songs, and collaborate to trace their origins using various online databases and forums.
  • You can develop your analytical listening skills by creating a playlist of obscure music and practicing identifying unique elements in each track, such as the beat, vocal style, or instrumental riffs.
  • This exercise will enhance your ability to discern distinct musical features, which can be useful in various contexts, from enjoying music more deeply to contributing to discussions about unidentified songs. For instance, you might note down the tempo, key, and any unusual instruments you hear in a song, then compare your observations with others to see if there are common patterns or identifiers that emerge.
  • You can contribute to the preservation of music history by digitizing any old mixtapes or recording ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
True Mysteries of the Internet

The story of "John Titor", the supposed time traveler

The enigmatic tale of John Titor, who claimed to be a time traveler from the year 2036, has become one of the top three great mysteries of the internet. His story captivates many, as it involves elements like fax machines and radio, predating the mainstream internet.

John Titor was an anonymous internet poster who claimed to be a time traveler from the year 2036

Titor described a future America that had been torn apart by a civil war followed by World War III, leading to a collapsed economy. He provided detailed technical information on time travel that seemed plausible to some and made predictions about societal changes that resonated with philosophical undertones.

Titor described a future America torn apart by civil war and World War III, with a collapsed economy

John Titor claimed to be from an America in 2036 that was affected by a civil war which led into World War III. He stated that he was on an official mission to retrieve an IBM 5100 computer from 1975, which had a special feature that was able to emulate other computer programs—a fact that was not widely publicized by IBM but was later confirmed to be true. Titor described his time as one where despite what might be considered "hard living" by contemporary standards, there was a strong sense of community and family values. He claimed that the U.S. was divided into five zones and that time travel had been developed in 2034.

He provided detailed technical information about time travel that seemed plausible to some

Titor shared intricate details about his time machine, including its use of cesium clocks and twin micro-singularities. He mentioned his vehicle, a 1966 Corvette, which was outfitted with a "stationary mass temporal displacement unit powered by two top spin dual positive singularities producing a standard offset Tipler sinusoid." The scientific terms he used, such as "Tipler sinusoids," are rooted in actual physics, adding a layer of authenticity to his claims. Titor also referenced the "many worlds" theory, suggesting that every possible outcome occurs in a different universe, which covers any potential discrepancies in his story due to timeline alterations.

Titor's identity and the veracity of his claims have been extensively investigated

The search for validation and the identity behind John Titor has led many to become obsessive, with some stating that getting involved in the mystery could lead a person to "go crazy."

Efforts to trace Titor's online posts and identity have pointed to a group of brothers in Florida

Several individuals have attempted to solve the mystery of John Titor’s identity, with some tracking computer location metadata to a specific area in Florida. Investigations led to a company registration that included the word “Titor” and pointed to connections with the Haber brothers, Larry or John, who are believed to have some connection to the story.

However, key details about the individuals involved remain uncertain or disputed

Despite these leads, key details about the true identity of John Titor remain uncertain. The Haber brothers are known to run the John Titor Foundation, but the existe ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

The story of "John Titor", the supposed time traveler

Additional Materials

Counterarguments

  • The claims of John Titor have never been substantiated and lack empirical evidence, which is a fundamental requirement for scientific acceptance.
  • The detailed technical information about time travel provided by Titor aligns with known pseudoscience and speculative physics, rather than established scientific principles.
  • The story's consistency with known facts about the IBM 5100 could be attributed to retroactive continuity or prior knowledge rather than actual time travel.
  • Efforts to trace Titor's identity may be inconclusive and could point to an elaborate hoax rather than a genuine mystery.
  • The philosophical musings att ...

Actionables

  • Explore the plausibility of science fiction concepts by reading up on basic physics and time travel theories to better understand the line between science and fiction. This can help you critically evaluate claims like those made by John Titor and differentiate between what's currently scientifically accepted and what remains speculative. Start with free online resources or library books that explain the fundamentals of physics in layman's terms.
  • Reflect on your own views of society by journaling your thoughts after consuming speculative narratives. Write down how you feel about the current state of society and where you see it heading, much like Titor's philosophical musings. This personal reflection can offer insights into your own beliefs and how they align or contrast with speculative scenarios.
  • Engage in online detective work by learning basic in ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free

Create Summaries for anything on the web

Download the Shortform Chrome extension for your browser

Shortform Extension CTA