The Stuff You Should Know hosts explore the puzzling phenomenon of "pruney" fingers after extended water exposure. They delve into the humble origins of the topic and trace how early theories gave way to our current understanding of the vasoconstriction process behind skin pruning.
The episode examines the evolutionary debate surrounding pruning. While some scientists propose that pruning evolved to enhance grip in wet conditions, skeptics argue it may simply be a byproduct of conserving body heat and blood flow. By presenting perspectives from various experts, the hosts offer listeners an insightful overview of this peculiar biological response and the scientific discussions around its purpose.
Sign up for Shortform to access the whole episode summary along with additional materials like counterarguments and context.
Chuck shares how his daughter's 7-hour bath sparked his curiosity about skin pruning - the extreme wrinkling of her fingertips prompted him to research whether it was harmful.
The modern interpretation, per Chuck Bryant, is that skin pruning results from vasoconstriction - the shrinking of blood vessels under the skin triggered by the autonomic nervous system in response to prolonged water exposure.
However, the evolutionary advantage is still debated. Skeptics suggest pruning may simply be a byproduct of the body conserving heat and blood flow in water (Chuck Bryant).
1-Page Summary
Chuck shares a personal story about his daughter's long bath time, which sparked his curiosity about skin pruning.
One day, Chuck's daughter decided to partake in an extended bath session that lasted over seven hours. During this marathon soak, she was happily engaged, playing with her bath toys and listening to her favorite podcasts. When she finally emerged from the bathtub, Chuck was struck by the extreme degree of pruning on her hands, a seemingly exaggerated version of what most people experience after a short soak.
Faced with his daughter's wrinkled fingertips, Chuck was prompted to delve into whether this unusually long bath and the resulta ...
The origin story of the topic and personal anecdote
The science behind pruney skin has evolved over time, changing the way we understand this common experience.
Early scientists theorized that skin pruneyness was due to osmosis affecting the skin's outer layers, causing them to expand. However, as Josh Clark points out, this theory was disproven in the 1930s when it was observed that nerve damage could prevent pruney fingers even after soaking in water for an extended period.
This discovery led researchers to question their previous osmosis theory, as it became clear that skin pruning did not occur in all circumstances. Skin with nerve damage did not exhibit the wrinkling response, contradicting the idea that osmotic expansion of the skin's outer layer was the sole reason behind the phenomenon.
As Chuck Bryant explains, the modern interpretation is that the wrinkling of skin, or vasoconstriction, is a response triggered by the autonomic nervous system due to prolonged exposure to water.
Historical theories about why skin prunes
Scientists have been studying the phenomenon of skin pruning and propose that it might be an evolutionary advantage, evolving as an adaptation to improve grip and traction in wet conditions. However, the specific benefits associated with pruning are still subject to debate.
Marc Cangisi and his colleagues are among those who consider skin pruning as a potential evolutionary adaptation that could provide practical benefits when handling objects in wet environments.
The UK group from Newcastle University conducted studies to test this hypothesis. In one of their experiments, they found that people with pruned fingers could pick up wet marbles roughly 12% faster than people with un-pruned fingers.
The biologists from Newcastle University described that the wrinkled skin on pruned fingers acts much like the treads on tires. These treads create channels allowing for water to be evacuated, which doesn't necessarily increase contact with the road but gives better traction. This analogy is used to explain how wrinkled skin pruned by water exposure helps to channel water away, thus enhancing grip in wet conditions.
Chuck Bryant also comments on the benefits of pruning, using the metaphorical "Tuk Tuk in the rain" situation. He suggests that evolutionary advantages might include not just the ability to grasp wet objects more effectively but also maintaining better traction to prevent slips and falls, potentially when gathering wet berries or navigating slippery surfaces.
The proposed evolutionary advantages of pruning
Download the Shortform Chrome extension for your browser