Podcasts > Stuff You Should Know > The Silurian Hypothesis

The Silurian Hypothesis

By iHeartPodcasts

In this Stuff You Should Know episode, the hosts explore the Silurian Hypothesis, a thought experiment examining how evidence of ancient civilizations could potentially be detected on Earth. They delve into the immense challenges posed by erosive forces that erase physical traces over millennia, from ruins to fossils, as well as the scarcity of fossilization.

The episode touches on potential "techno-fossils" like plastic that might persist as markers of human activity. It also discusses geological and geochemical signals that could hint at the existence of past industrial societies, such as atmospheric carbon buildup and temperature changes preserved in the geological record. While acknowledging the uncertainties involved, the conversation provokes thought about what clues, if any, might remain of civilizations that preceded modern humans.

Listen to the original

The Silurian Hypothesis

This is a preview of the Shortform summary of the May 16, 2024 episode of the Stuff You Should Know

Sign up for Shortform to access the whole episode summary along with additional materials like counterarguments and context.

The Silurian Hypothesis

1-Page Summary

The Silurian Hypothesis and its origins

The Silurian Hypothesis, proposed by astrophysicist Adam Frank and NASA scientist Gavin Schmidt, is a thought experiment examining the possibility of detecting remnants of ancient civilizations on Earth. It originated from a discussion about finding evidence of such civilizations beyond Earth, with Schmidt suggesting applying the same approach to our own planet.

The hypothesis explores how we could detect signs of advanced societies that preceded us. However, the hosts note the unfortunate naming decision - a reference to a fictional race in Doctor Who - undermines the seriousness of the academic exercise.

Potential evidence for ancient civilizations

Discovering evidence of ancient civilizations poses immense challenges due to Earth's erosive processes concealing potential clues over millennia.

Physical ruins and artifacts

Physical evidence like cities and structures would likely disappear due to erosion and corrosion. Ruins underwater or buried might survive, though only 2.7-2.8% of Earth is currently urbanized.

Fossils

Fossilization is extremely rare, with only 0.1% of all species fossilized. Despite this scarcity, fossils like Australopithecus anamensis offer a window into our distant past.

"Techno-fossils"

Our modern era may leave "techno-fossils" like plastics and bricks. Josh Clark speculates these artificial materials could mark human activity for future civilizations.

Geochemical and geological markers

Human activities leave distinct markers in the geological record. The podcast discusses how past events like the Paleocene-Eocene Thermal Maximum (PETM) - characterized by massive carbon dioxide release and global temperature rise - could indicate impacts from ancient industrial civilizations.

The rapid pace of modern climate change, causing extinctions and atmospheric carbon buildup, may also create a pronounced signal in future geological records, as suggested by Clark and Bryant.

They also acknowledge the potential for nuclear war to leave a significant geological marker, and the billion-year gap in Earth's geological record that complicates interpretation of such signals.

1-Page Summary

Additional Materials

Clarifications

  • The Silurian Hypothesis is a thought experiment exploring the potential detection of ancient civilizations on Earth before humanity, considering geological evidence and indirect markers like climate changes or nuclear waste. Astrophysicists Adam Frank and Gavin Schmidt proposed this concept in 2018, suggesting that while direct evidence like technological artifacts is unlikely to survive, indirect clues in Earth's geological record or even on celestial bodies like the Moon and Mars could hint at pre-human civilizations. The hypothesis draws its name from a fictional species in Doctor Who, known for establishing an advanced civilization before humans, and has sparked discussions about the detectability of ancient civilizations through scientific methods.
  • The Paleocene-Eocene Thermal Maximum (PETM) was a short period around 55.8 million years ago marked by a significant global temperature increase of 5-8°C. It was characterized by a massive release of carbon into the atmosphere and oceans, leading to major changes in Earth's carbon cycle. The event is associated with distinct geological and biological changes, including mass extinctions and the sudden appearance of new species like modern mammal orders. The PETM is a crucial event in Earth's history for understanding past climate changes and their impacts on the planet's ecosystems.

Counterarguments

  • The Silurian Hypothesis, while a thought-provoking idea, is highly speculative and lacks direct evidence to support the existence of pre-human advanced civilizations on Earth.
  • The reference to Doctor Who in the naming of the Silurian Hypothesis could be seen as a playful nod to popular culture rather than a serious undermining of the hypothesis's academic value.
  • The rarity of fossilization and the small percentage of Earth's urbanization might not necessarily preclude the discovery of ancient civilizations; there could be undiscovered methods or technologies that could aid in such discoveries.
  • The concept of "techno-fossils" assumes that future civilizations would interpret these materials as we do, which may not be the case given different cultural and scientific contexts.
  • While human activities are leaving distinct markers in the geological record, it is uncertain how recognizable these markers will be after millions of years and what conclusions future scientists might draw from them.
  • The interpretation of past events like the PETM as indicators of ancient industrial civilizations is highly conjectural and not widely supported in the scientific community.
  • The idea that modern climate change will create a pronounced signal in future geological records assumes that future scientists will have similar scientific methods and understandings to interpret these signals correctly.
  • The potential for nuclear war to leave a significant geological marker is based on the assumption that such an event would occur and that its geological impact would be distinguishable from natural events.
  • The billion-year gap in Earth's geological record is indeed a challenge, but it may not be insurmountable with advances in technology and scientific understanding.

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
The Silurian Hypothesis

The Silurian Hypothesis and its origins

The Silurian Hypothesis, proposed as a serious academic thought experiment, examines the possibility of detecting remnants of ancient civilizations on Earth.

The Silurian Hypothesis was proposed by astrophysicist Adam Frank and NASA scientist Gavin Schmidt as a thought experiment to explore the possibility of detecting evidence of ancient civilizations on Earth.

Astrophysicist Adam Frank and NASA scientist Gavin Schmidt proposed what they called the Silurian Hypothesis as a way to think about how one might detect evidence of long-gone civilizations on Earth. The idea originated from a discussion about finding evidence of such civilizations beyond Earth. Josh Clark points out that Frank and Schmidt were the first to seriously consider the notion that Earth could have hosted previous intelligent civilizations and suggests that the hypothesis helps guide us in understanding what signals our current civilization might leave behind.

The hypothesis was named after the fictional Silurian race from the Doctor Who universe, which the podcast hosts found to be an unfortunate naming decision that undermines the seriousness of the academic exercise.

While discussing the hypothesis, the podcast host Josh Clark notes that he would rename the Silurian Hypothesis if he could, indicating his belief that the current name was a poor choice. The name, derived from a race of lizard people in the "Doctor Who" series, who supposedly lived around 300 million years ago during the Carboniferous period, not the actual Silurian geological period, seems to be at odds with the serious nature of the scientific inquiry proposed by Frank and Schmidt. The hosts feel that the reference to the fictional Doctor Who race lends an ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

The Silurian Hypothesis and its origins

Additional Materials

Clarifications

  • The Silurian Hypothesis is a serious academic thought experiment that explores the potential for detecting traces of ancient civilizations on Earth. It was proposed by astrophysicist Adam Frank and NASA scientist Gavin Schmidt to consider how evidence of past intelligent societies could be identified. This hypothesis offers a unique perspective by applying methods used in the search for extraterrestrial civilizations to investigate the possibility of ancient advanced societies on our own planet. The aim is to understand what indicators such civilizations might have left behind and how we could recognize these remnants.
  • Detecting remnants of ancient civilizations on Earth involves searching for physical or cultural traces left behind by past human societies. This can include archaeological artifacts, structures, writings, or other evidence that provides insights into the lives and activities of ancient peoples. Scientists and researchers use various methods such as excavation, analysis of artifacts, and studying historical records to piece together the history of these civilizations. The study of ancient civilizations helps us understand human development, societal structures, technological advancements, and cultural practices from different time periods.
  • The Silurians are a fictional race in the British TV series "Doctor Who," depicted as an ancient reptilian humanoid species that lived on Earth millions of years ago. They are known for their advanced technology and complex society, often portrayed as having a complex relationship with humans. The Silurians are a recurring element in "Doctor Who," representing a unique take on the idea of ancient civilizations on Earth. The name "Silurian" in the context of the Silurian Hypothesis is a reference to this fictional race, chosen by the creators of the hypothesis for its connection to ancient civilizations and advanced beings.
  • The Silurian Hypothesis, named after a fictional race from "Doctor Who," is criticized for its choice of name as it may detract from the seriousness of the scientific inquiry. The reference to a fictional lizard race living millions of years ago in a TV show contrasts with the scholarly nature of the hypothesis proposed by Adam Frank and Gavin Schmidt. This naming discrepancy could lead some to perceive the hypothesis as less rigorous or credible due to its association with a fictional narrative. The concern is that the whimsical connotation of the name might undermine the gravity of the academic exercise, p ...

Counterarguments

  • The Silurian Hypothesis, while a thought-provoking exercise, may be criticized for lacking empirical evidence to support the existence of such ancient civilizations on Earth.
  • Some may argue that the geological and fossil records on Earth are well-studied, and there is no substantial evidence to suggest that an intelligent civilization existed before humans.
  • The hypothesis could be seen as diverting attention from the search for extraterrestrial intelligence (SETI) to a speculative idea that may not yield fruitful results.
  • The name "Silurian Hypothesis" could be defended as a creative way to engage the public's interest in science, even if it draws from popular culture.
  • Critics might suggest that the hypothesis does not sufficiently account for the destructive forces of geological processes, which would likely erase most traces of such an ancient civilization.
  • There could be an argument that ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
The Silurian Hypothesis

Potential evidence for ancient civilizations

Discovering evidence of ancient civilizations poses significant challenges due to Earth’s dynamic processes eroding and concealing potential clues over millennia.

Physical ruins and artifacts

Physical evidence of ancient civilizations left on Earth's surface, like cities and structures, would likely disappear over time due to processes like erosion and corrosion. Ruins along water bodies, such as the under-sea-level New Orleans, might be covered by sediment, potentially preserving a city in some form. Yet, most of Earth hasn't been urbanized, as liberal estimates suggest only about 2.7-2.8% urbanization, indicating ancient civilizations might not have occupied a large percentage of the Earth.

The Earth's surface has been recycled countless times, with its oldest stretch being less than 2 million years old. Over time, processes like the movement of earthworms through the soil can erode evidence, causing potential indications of ancient civilizations to return to square one. Subterranean infrastructure, like networks of pipes, would also eventually succumb to erosion due to earth movements and geological processes.

Fossils

Fossilization is a rare occurrence, with estimates that only 0.1% of all species that have existed have been fossilized. This rarity, coupled with the difficulty of discovery, makes finding biological evidence of an ancient intelligent species an immense challenge. Despite the infrequency of fossilization, fossils such as Australopithecus anamensis, dating around four and a half million years ago, have been discovered.

Fossils offer a window to our distant past, but their scarcity showcases the challenges in retrieving such data. For instance, despite approximately 2.5 billion individual T-Rexes existing during their 2.5 million year reign, only about 50 fossilized skeletons have been found.

"Techno-fossils"

Our modern era may leave behind "techno-fossils," such as smartphones and plastic grocery bags. However, items significantly more likel ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Potential evidence for ancient civilizations

Additional Materials

Clarifications

  • Urbanization estimates typically indicate the percentage of a country's population living in urban areas. Liberal estimates of Earth's urbanization suggest that around 2.7-2.8% of the Earth's surface is urbanized, meaning developed or built-up areas like cities and towns. This statistic helps understand the extent to which human settlements have impacted the Earth's landmass. Urbanization rates can vary widely between countries and regions, influencing factors like infrastructure development, resource consumption, and environmental impact.
  • Earthworms, through their burrowing activities, can disturb and mix up soil layers where artifacts or structures from ancient civilizations might be buried. This movement can bring buried items closer to the surface, where they are more vulnerable to erosion and other natural processes that could eventually destroy them. Over time, the continuous activity of earthworms can contribute to the degradation and loss of archaeological evidence that may have been preserved underground.
  • Networks of pipes succumbing to erosion can be understood as underground systems of pipes, like those used for water or sewage, deteriorating over time due to natural processes. Factors such as shifting soil, geological movements, and chemical reactions can contribute to the degradation of these pipes. This erosion can lead to the breakdown and eventual collapse of the pipe networks, impacting their functionality and potentially causing issues like leaks or blockages.
  • Australopithecus anamensis is an ancient hominin species that lived around 4.2 to 3.8 million years ago in East Africa. It is considered one of the earliest known Australopithecus species and is significant in the study of human evolution. Fossil evidence suggests that A. anamensis coexisted with another hominin species, Australopithecus afarensis, and may have played a role in the evolutionary lineage leading to modern humans. The discovery of numerous fossil specimens in Kenya and Ethiopia has provided valuable insights into the characteristics and behaviors of this early human ancestor.
  • Fossilization is rare because the conditions required for an organism to become a fossil are specific and uncommon. Factors like rapid burial, lack of oxygen, and the presence of minerals are necessary for the preservation process to occur. The vast majority of organisms decay or are consumed by scavengers before fossilization can take place. This rarity explains why only a small fraction of all species that have ever existed are found as fossils.
  • T-Rex fossilization statistics: Despite an estimated 2.5 billion individual T-Rexes existing during their reign, only about 50 fossilized skeletons have been found, highlighting the rarity of T-Rex fossils in the fossil record. This scarcity is due to various factors like the conditions required for fossilization and the likelihood of fossil preservation over millions of years ...

Counterarguments

  • While physical evidence of ancient civilizations may erode over time, some materials like stone can survive for millions of years under the right conditions, suggesting that not all evidence would disappear.
  • The idea that most of Earth hasn't been urbanized doesn't necessarily mean ancient civilizations didn't occupy a large percentage of the Earth, as they may have had different settlement patterns or used land differently than modern urbanization.
  • Subterranean structures, depending on depth and construction materials, could potentially survive longer than suggested, as some ancient underground sites have been found well-preserved.
  • The rarity of fossilization is true, but it's also possible that we have not yet found the right conditions or locations where more fossils of ancient intelligent species could be preserved.
  • Techno-fossils like plastics may not be as clear-cut indicators of human activity as suggested, considering that natural processes could potentially break them down more effectively than currently understood.
  • The assumption that future civilizations will interpret plastics and other materials as clear indicatio ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
The Silurian Hypothesis

Geochemical and geological markers

The podcast features discussions on how human activities leave distinct markers in the geological record, pointing to the possibility that past events, such as the Paleocene-Eocene Thermal Maximum, could indicate the impact of an ancient industrial civilization.

Sudden, unexplained spikes or anomalies in the geological record

Events like the Paleocene-Eocene Thermal Maximum

The podcast delves into the Paleocene-Eocene Thermal Maximum (PETM), which took place about 56 million years ago, marking a massive increase in global temperatures. Sea surface temperatures in the Arctic during the PETM were comparable to those of the Gulf of Mexico today. This event, characterized by a large release of carbon dioxide into the atmosphere, led to sea-level rise, mass extinctions, and substantial climatic alterations. The PETM lasted around 100,000 years and was not unique; similar events occurred throughout the Cretaceous, Jurassic, and Paleozoic eras, as well as more in the last six million years. These repeated incidents, sharing similar characteristics, may indicate substantial impacts from potential ancient civilizations.

The signals left by modern human-caused climate change

The present-day impacts of human activities, such as climate change, may be similarly detectable in the future geological record. Clark and Bryant discuss how the sedimentary record of the future may indicate traces of this era through unusual spikes, such as elevated levels of nitrogen and polymers from plastics. Radioactivity, especially from nuclear tests, could also be a marker, with elements like plutonium-244 and iodine-129 potentially leaving signals in the geological record for millions of years. The discussion also contemplates whether direct traces—like fossils or elements—or the impressions an ancient civilization left on Earth are better indicators of its existence.

The rapid pace of modern climate change ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Geochemical and geological markers

Additional Materials

Clarifications

  • The Paleocene-Eocene Thermal Maximum (PETM) was a brief period around 55.8 million years ago marked by a significant global temperature rise of 5-8°C. It was characterized by a massive release of carbon into the atmosphere and oceans, leading to major environmental changes. The event is associated with a notable negative shift in carbon isotope records globally, indicating a substantial disruption in the Earth's carbon cycle. Fossil records from this time show significant turnovers in various organisms, both in marine and terrestrial environments.
  • The comparison made in the text between the sea surface temperatures in the Arctic during the Paleocene-Eocene Thermal Maximum (PETM) and those of the Gulf of Mexico today highlights the extreme warmth experienced during the PETM. This comparison emphasizes the significant global temperature increase that occurred during the PETM event, providing a relatable reference point for readers to understand the magnitude of the temperature change. The mention of the Gulf of Mexico's current temperatures serves as a familiar benchmark for contemporary readers to grasp the exceptional warmth that characterized the Arctic region during the PETM. This comparison underscores the dramatic nature of the climate conditions during the PETM, showcasing the profound impact of the event on Earth's climate.
  • Plutonium-244 and iodine-129 are radioactive isotopes produced by nuclear reactions. These isotopes have long half-lives, making them potential markers of human nuclear activities in the geological record. Their presence in certain geological layers could indicate past nuclear events, such as nuclear tests or accidents.
  • Direct traces left by an ancient civilization on Earth could include physical artifacts like tools, structures, or remains. Impressions could be more subtle, such as changes in the environment like deforestation patterns, altered landscapes, or chemical signatures left behind by industrial activities. These markers could provide evidence of past civilizations and their impact on the planet, helping researchers understand ancie ...

Counterarguments

  • The idea that past events like the PETM could indicate the impact of an ancient industrial civilization is speculative and not widely supported by the scientific community. The majority consensus is that the PETM was a result of natural processes.
  • While the PETM and similar events are characterized by significant climatic and biotic changes, attributing them to ancient civilizations lacks concrete evidence and is more a thought experiment than a hypothesis grounded in current scientific understanding.
  • The assertion that modern human-caused climate change could leave detectable signals in the future geological record is likely, but the exact nature and detectability of these signals are uncertain due to the complex processes that affect the preservation of geological markers.
  • The suggestion that elements like plutonium-244 and iodine-129 could leave signals in the geological record for millions of years is theoretically sound, but the actual longevity of such signals can be influenced by geological processes that may disperse or alter these markers.
  • The idea that the rapid pace of modern climate change could create a distinct signal in the geological record is plausible, but it is also possible that future geological processes could obscure these signals, making them less distinct than anticipated.
  • The notion that the sustainability of human ways of living might leave just a blip in the geological record is a subjective interpretation. The long-term geological impact of human civilization could be more significant than a "blip, ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free

Create Summaries for anything on the web

Download the Shortform Chrome extension for your browser

Shortform Extension CTA