Podcasts > Stuff You Should Know > The Power of the Wind

The Power of the Wind

By iHeartPodcasts

This episode of Stuff You Should Know explores the history and current landscape of wind power. The hosts provide an overview of early wind turbine innovations in the 19th century and trace the eventual decline of wind power as coal-fired electric grids expanded.

They examine the modern horizontal axis wind turbine design, detailing the components that enable efficient conversion of wind to electricity. The episode also covers the recent growth of wind power capacity in the U.S. and globally, highlighting ambitious renewable energy targets and investment from governments. Additionally, it looks at the environmental impacts of wind farms, including potential harm to wildlife and disruption to habitats, as well as debates surrounding these issues.

Listen to the original

The Power of the Wind

This is a preview of the Shortform summary of the Apr 23, 2024 episode of the Stuff You Should Know

Sign up for Shortform to access the whole episode summary along with additional materials like counterarguments and context.

The Power of the Wind

1-Page Summary

History of wind power and wind turbines

Early wind power innovators in the 19th century

Scottish engineer James Blythe designed the first wind turbine for generating electricity in 1887. Danish meteorologist Poul La Cour made advancements, with Denmark having 72 wind-electric systems by 1908, according to Sanger-Katz.

Wind power declined as coal-fired grids expanded

Initially competitive, especially in rural areas without grids, wind power declined with the expansion of coal-fired electric grids, claims Sanger-Katz.

Modern horizontal axis wind turbines

Wind turbine components

Horizontal axis wind turbines (HAWTs) are preferred for large-scale wind power. Josh Clark notes they have rotors up to 800 feet wide, generators, and controllers to adjust blade angles for efficiency.

Improving turbine design

Larger turbines are more efficient at converting wind to electricity (35-45%). Reducing noise and enabling future recycling are priorities, according to Clark and Bryant.

Wind power capacity and growth

U.S. and global expansion since the 1990s

The U.S. now has about 70,000 turbines with 146 gigawatts capacity, supplying 10% of electricity. Texas leads production. Growth is expected with billions invested, says Clark and Bryant.

Increasing wind power targets and investments

The Biden administration aims for 30,000 megawatt-hours offshore by 2030. Legislation like the Inflation Reduction Act spurs renewable investment. Internationally, China and California set ambitious wind targets.

Environmental impacts

Harm to wildlife

Turbines can kill birds/bats and disrupt marine life migration. Mitigation through planning is possible, according to Clark and Bryant.

Debates over habitat disruption

Opponents cite impacts on property values, views, and community disruption. Poorer areas may get more wind farms. Some oppose wind farms' industrialization of nature. European studies show impacts on animals like deer and reindeer, leading to wind farm closures in Norway to protect indigenous Sami reindeer herding practices.

1-Page Summary

Additional Materials

Clarifications

  • Poul La Cour, a Danish meteorologist, made significant advancements in wind-electric systems in Denmark by 1908. His work contributed to the establishment of 72 wind-electric systems in the country by that time, showcasing early progress in harnessing wind power for electricity generation. La Cour's innovations helped pave the way for the development and adoption of wind turbines as a renewable energy source.
  • Horizontal axis wind turbines (HAWTs) are a common type of wind turbine design where the main rotor shaft and electrical generator are at the top of a tower. The rotor blades of HAWTs rotate around a horizontal axis, facing into the wind to capture its energy efficiently. Components of HAWTs include rotor blades, a hub to connect the blades, a nacelle housing the gearbox and generator, and a tower to support the turbine at an elevated height. These turbines are known for their scalability and are often used in large-scale wind power projects due to their high efficiency in converting wind energy into electricity.
  • Larger wind turbines are more efficient at converting wind to electricity due to their increased rotor size, which allows them to capture more wind energy. This efficiency improvement is also attributed to advancements in turbine design and technology, such as better aerodynamics and more sophisticated control systems. The larger size enables these turbines to generate more electricity per unit of wind compared to smaller turbines. This increased efficiency contributes to the overall effectiveness and competitiveness of wind power as a renewable energy source.
  • The Biden administration aims to achieve a target of generating 30,000 megawatts of electricity from offshore wind power by the year 2030. This goal is part of the administration's broader strategy to increase renewable energy production and reduce reliance on fossil fuels. Offshore wind power has the potential to significantly contribute to the U.S. energy mix and help combat climate change. The target signifies a commitment to scaling up offshore wind projects to meet clean energy goals and drive economic growth in the renewable energy sector.
  • Wind turbines can have negative impacts on wildlife, such as birds and bats, as they can collide with the rotating blades. Additionally, marine life can be affected by the underwater noise generated by offshore wind turbines. Habitat disruption can occur due to the installation of wind farms, which can lead to changes in local ecosystems and potential displacement of certain species. Efforts are made to mitigate these impacts through careful planning and monitoring to minimize harm to wildlife and habitats.
  • European studies have shown that wind farms can impact animals like deer and reindeer. These impacts include changes in behavior, habitat displacement, and potential disruptions to migration patterns. In some cases, these effects have led to the closure of wind farms in certain areas to protect the local wildlife populations. Mitigation measures are being explored to address these concerns and minimize the impact on wildlife.

Counterarguments

  • While James Blythe designed an early wind turbine, it's important to recognize that the concept of using wind for power dates back centuries, with windmills used for grinding grain and pumping water.
  • Poul La Cour's advancements were significant, but other innovators in different countries also contributed to the development of wind power technology.
  • The decline of wind power in favor of coal might have been influenced by economic and policy decisions that favored fossil fuels, rather than a straightforward technological superiority of coal.
  • HAWTs are commonly used, but vertical axis wind turbines (VAWTs) also exist and can be more suitable in environments where wind direction varies greatly.
  • The efficiency of larger turbines is notable, but it's also important to consider the diminishing returns in terms of material use, transportation, and construction challenges as turbines get larger.
  • The U.S. wind power capacity is growing, but it's still a small fraction compared to other energy sources, and the intermittency of wind power presents challenges for grid integration.
  • The Biden administration's offshore wind power targets are ambitious, but achieving them will require overcoming significant logistical, regulatory, and environmental hurdles.
  • While the Inflation Reduction Act and similar legislation encourage renewable investment, the effectiveness of these policies in accelerating the transition to renewables can be debated.
  • The setting of ambitious wind power targets by regions like China and California is a positive step, but meeting these targets will require addressing technological, economic, and social challenges.
  • Mitigation strategies can reduce the harm to wildlife from wind turbines, but they may not eliminate it entirely, and the effectiveness of these strategies can vary.
  • The impact of wind farms on property values and community disruption is complex and can depend on various factors, including the design and location of the wind farm.
  • The placement of wind farms in poorer areas raises environmental justice concerns, and the benefits and burdens of renewable energy infrastructure need to be distributed more equitably.
  • The closure of wind farms in Norway to protect indigenous practices highlights the need for careful consideration of local and indigenous rights and traditions when planning renewable energy projects.

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
The Power of the Wind

History of wind power and wind turbines

The journey of wind power from its origins in the 19th century to its clash with coal power in the 20th century reflects a history of innovation, adaptation, and competition.

Early innovators in the 1800s generate wind power on a small scale

In 1887, Scottish engineer James Blythe took a historic step in renewable energy by designing the first wind turbine specifically intended for generating electricity. Blythe's turbine was a pioneering departure from previous wind-based structures like Dutch windmills. His invention led to a surplus of power in his second home in the town of Merrickirk, Scotland, leading him to generously offer the excess electricity to the town. He even implemented a storage solution, utilizing twelve batteries to store the electricity produced by his wind turbine.

Similarly, Danish meteorologist Poul La Cour made significant strides in wind-generated power in the 1890s. La Cour's efforts provided enough power for the village of Askov, and he went on to establish the Society of Wind Electricians. By 1908, Denmark boasted 72 wind-electric systems, with capacities ranging from 5 to 25 kilowatts, reflecting La Cour's impactful advancements in harnessing wind for electricity.

Wind is competitive in rural areas but gets supplanted by coal plants and grids in the 1900s

I ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

History of wind power and wind turbines

Additional Materials

Clarifications

  • Wind power and coal power have historically clashed in the energy sector due to competition for dominance in electricity generation. While wind power offers renewable and environmentally friendly energy, coal power has been a traditional and dominant source of electricity, leading to a clash between the two in terms of market share and policy support. This clash has been influenced by factors such as technological advancements, government regulations, and economic considerations, shaping the energy landscape over time. The transition towards cleaner energy sources like wind power has often been challenged by the established infrastructure and economic interests associated with coal power.
  • Dutch windmills were traditional wind-powered structures used for various purposes like grinding grain, sawing wood, and pumping water. They featured large, wooden structures with sails that captured wind energy to perform mechanical tasks. These windmills were prevalent in the Netherlands and other parts of Europe for centuries before the development of modern wind turbines for el ...

Counterarguments

  • While James Blythe designed an early wind turbine, it's important to note that wind power had been used for centuries in different forms, such as for mechanical power in windmills.
  • Blythe's offer of excess electricity to Merrickirk may not have been as straightforward as altruism; there could have been technical or regulatory challenges in distributing this power.
  • The storage solution using twelve batteries was innovative, but it's worth considering the efficiency and capacity of such early storage technology compared to modern standards.
  • Poul La Cour's contributions were significant, but the text does not mention other innovators who may have also contributed to the development of wind power technology during the same period.
  • The statement that Denmark had 72 wind-electric systems by 1908 could be misleading without context regarding the overall energy production and how it compared to other energy sources at the time.
  • The competitiveness of wind power in rural areas is highlighted, but the text does not address the potential limitations or inefficiencies of early wind power systems compared to modern ones.
  • The reliance on wind systems in rural areas might have been due to a lack of alternatives rather than the superiority of wind power.
  • The decline in wind turbine use wit ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
The Power of the Wind

Modern horizontal axis wind turbines

Horizontal axis wind turbines, known as HAWTs, are the dominant technology in the field of wind power generation, vastly preferred over less efficient vertical axis wind turbines (VAWTs) for large-scale use.

Components like rotors, generators, controllers

HAWT systems consist of significant components such as rotors, generators, and controllers. Rotors come in various sizes, from a mere eight feet in diameter for small wind turbines to the colossal 800-foot rotors used in offshore turbines. Onshore farms typically feature turbines with a diameter in the 400 to 450-foot range, situated about 30 to 35 feet off the ground. They generally possess three blades designed to balance electricity generation efficiency while minimizing drag.

The turbines are equipped with yaw systems that allow them to swivel and face the wind directly, and pitch systems to adjust the blades' angle to the wind. This is crucial for optimizing performance in varying wind conditions. Josh Clark points out that the turbine connects to a rotor and a generator, which may utilize a gearbox when the rotor can't spin fast enough to generate electricity efficiently using traditional electromagnetics.

Windmill rotors can spin at varying speeds, sometimes slower than the 1,800 rotations per minute required for traditional generators, necessitating the use of gearboxes to increase rotation speed. However, Chuck Bryant notes that gearboxes, while useful, come with their own set of problems, such as noise and mechanical breakdowns. An alternative to gearboxes is the direct-drive system, which eliminates many of these issues but requires larger components.

Improving efficiency, capacity, height, noise

Modern horizontal axis wind turbines are consciously designed to be more efficient and quieter as they become larger. Larger turbines can generate more electricity, thus requiring fewer turbines per site. The pitch sy ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Modern horizontal axis wind turbines

Additional Materials

Clarifications

  • Yaw systems in wind turbines allow the turbine to turn and face the wind directly, optimizing energy capture. Pitch systems adjust the angle of the turbine blades to control the rotor speed and maximize efficiency in varying wind conditions. These systems are crucial for ensuring the wind turbine operates efficiently and generates electricity effectively.
  • Gearboxes in wind turbines are used to increase the rotation speed of the rotor to efficiently generate electricity. They help match the varying speeds of the rotor with the constant speed needed by traditional generators. However, gearboxes can introduce noise and maintenance issues. Direct-drive systems, on the other hand, eliminate the need for gearboxes by directly connecting the rotor to the generator, resulting in quieter operation but requiring larger components.
  • The efficiency of wind turbines in converting wind to electricity typically ranges from about 35 to 45 percent. This efficiency represents the portion of wind energy that is successfully transformed into electrical power. Efforts are ongoing to enhance this conversion rate through technological advancements and design improvements. Despite these efforts, there is a theoretical maximum efficiency limit determined by the laws of physics.
  • Disposing of large turbine blades poses challenges due to their size, composition, and the limited recycling options available. These blades are typically made of composite materials like fiberglass and carbon fiber, which are difficult to recycle. As wind turbines age and are decommissioned, finding sustainable disposal methods for these blades becomes a significant environmental concern. ...

Counterarguments

  • While HAWTs are indeed the dominant technology, VAWTs offer advantages in certain contexts, such as lower wind speed areas, urban environments, or where noise and bird strikes are significant concerns.
  • The efficiency of HAWTs is mentioned, but it's important to note that efficiency can vary significantly depending on the design, location, and wind conditions.
  • The statement that larger turbines are more efficient and quieter could be misleading; larger turbines can face logistical challenges, increased visual impact, and may not always be quieter due to the larger surface area of the blades.
  • The conversion rate of 35 to 45 percent of wind to electricity is an average; some turbines may perform below or above this range.
  • The pitch system's ability to control rotor speed for efficiency and protection in high winds is a simplification; other factors such as turbine design, material strength, and control systems also play critical roles in performance and safety.
  • The claim that direct-drive systems require larger components is generally true, but ongoing research and development may lead to more compact and efficient direct-drive generators.
  • The focus on recyclable turbine materials is commendable, but the current state of recycling for turbine blades is still in its infancy, and significant challenges remain in recycling composite materials. ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
The Power of the Wind

Wind power capacity and growth

Wind power is experiencing significant growth in the United States and across the globe, transforming how electricity is generated and consumed.

Significant expansion since 1990s in the US and globally

Since the 1980s, the United States has seen tremendous growth in wind power capacity. From virtually zero wind power, it now boasts approximately 70,000 wind turbines with a combined potential capacity of about 146 gigawatts, supplying 10% of the country's electric capacity. Texas leads the production, generating about a quarter of the U.S. total. The turbines themselves have grown in size and capacity over time, underscoring the expanding technology and infrastructure.

Investments to further increase capacity

Investment in wind energy is increasing, with multinational corporations funneling tens and hundreds of billions of dollars into the sector, and starting to reap the benefits, suggesting ongoing and future capacity growth. Both Chuck and Josh highlight the lucrative financial aspects, indicating that significant funds will continue to be channeled into wind power.

Further illustrating the trend, the Biden administration has an ambitious target of 30,000 megawatt-hours from offshore wind by 2030, while California aims for 25,000 megawatts by 2045, planning to use floating turbines because of the Pacific's depth. Nationally, offshore wind has the potential to supply between 10 and 25% of all U.S. energy by 2050, according to a study from Cal Berkeley.

Legislation plays a critical role in fostering this expansion. The Inflation Reduction Act, focusing on U.S. infrastructure and renewable energy, has already led to a 300 ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Wind power capacity and growth

Additional Materials

Clarifications

  • The Inflation Reduction Act of 2022 is a significant U.S. federal law aimed at addressing inflation by impacting various sectors like the federal budget deficit, prescription drug prices, and clean energy investments. It was passed as a budget reconciliation bill and includes provisions for tax reform, prescription drug reform, and substantial spending on energy and climate change initiatives. The law represents a substantial investment in combating climate change and includes measures to modernize the Internal Revenue Service. It is a key legislative effort to address economic and environmental challenges in the United States.
  • Offshore wind energy involves generating electricity from wind turbines located in bodies of water, typically oceans. The U.S. aims to have offshore wind power contribute between 10% and 25% of the country's total energy needs by 2050. This goal is part of broader efforts to increase renewable energy sources and reduce reliance on fossil fuels for electricity generation. Offshore wind farms can harness stronger and more consistent winds compared to onshore locations, making them a promising source of clean energy for the future.
  • Legislative proposals hindering wind power investment could include regulations that impose restrictions or additional costs on wind energy projects, making them less financially viable. These proposals might involve changes to tax incentives, permitting processes, or land use regulations that create barriers to the development of wind farms. Such hindrances can slow down the growth of wind po ...

Counterarguments

  • While wind power capacity has grown, it still faces intermittency issues, as wind is not a constant and predictable energy source.
  • The growth in wind power capacity in the U.S. may not be sustainable without continued government subsidies and incentives.
  • Texas, while leading in wind power production, also faces challenges such as grid integration and managing supply with demand.
  • The increase in size and capacity of wind turbines can lead to higher costs and more complex maintenance and logistical challenges.
  • The financial benefits highlighted by Chuck and Josh may not be universally experienced, as market conditions and policy changes can affect profitability.
  • The Biden administration's offshore wind targets are ambitious and may face technical, environmental, and regulatory hurdles that could impede progress.
  • California's aim for wind power capacity using floating turbines is innovative but unproven at scale, and may encounter technological and cost barriers.
  • The potential for offshore wind to supply a significant portion of U.S. energy is contingent on overcoming environmental concerns and stakeholder opposition.
  • The Inflation Reduction Act's impact on investment in renewable storage capacity may not be as significant in the long term if technology costs do not decrease or if market dynamics change.
  • China's goal for carbon neutrality by 2060 is ambitious, and the role of wind power in achi ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
The Power of the Wind

Environmental impacts

While wind energy is often championed as a sustainable and clean power source, there are growing concerns over its direct impact on wildlife and the ensuing debates regarding the disruption of habitats by wind farms.

Direct harm to animals that fly near or live around turbines

Wind turbines, particularly the spinning blades, have been found to kill birds and bats that collide with them. Ocean-based wind turbines also carry risks for marine life; the sound they generate can rupture whales' eardrums and disturb their breeding grounds. However, measures to mitigate these impacts are available. Strategic planning can help avoid whale migration paths and breeding grounds during construction.

Supporters and opponents debate habitat disruption from wind farms

Josh and Chuck outline the debates surrounding habitat disruption caused by wind farms. They acknowledge legitimate opposition to local wind projects, citing impacts on real estate values, viewshed, and community life. Also mentioned is the phenomenon of NIMBYism, where residents support wind energy theoretically but oppose local projects due to potential disruptions. There is often a socioeconomic disparity in the placement of these projects; poorer communities may have wind projects imposed on them due to less political influence while wealthier areas may successfully resist similar developments.

Offshore wind projects attract resistance as well, particularly from wealthy beachfront property owners who value their views. The Vineyard Wind project, for instance, came into conflict with local fishermen, whose fishing grounds were affected, leading to the need for alternative fishing locations or compensation.

The "viewshed" issue is also a hot topic, with some stakeholders not wanting the presence of wind turbines, no matter how s ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Environmental impacts

Additional Materials

Clarifications

  • NIMBYism, short for "Not In My Backyard," describes the opposition by local residents to proposed developments in their area, often due to concerns about how the projects may impact their immediate surroundings. This term is commonly used to highlight the resistance to infrastructure projects like wind farms, housing developments, or waste facilities when they are planned close to where people live. NIMBYism reflects a complex interplay of local interests, environmental concerns, and community dynamics in decision-making processes regarding development projects. The term underscores the tension between the need for progress and the desire to preserve the status quo in local communities.
  • A viewshed is the visible area from a specific location, encompassing all points that can be seen from that vantage point. It is commonly used in various fields like urban planning, archaeology, and military science to analyze visibility and plan accordingly. In urban planning, viewsheds are crucial for preserving scenic or historic areas from development. Viewsheds can be represented using raster data to show visibility from a viewpoint.
  • Degrowth is a movement critical of the emphasis on economic growth, advocating for a shift towards sustainable well-being over continuous GDP expansion. It argues for reevaluating societal priorities beyond material wealth and consumption, focusing on ecological preservation and human welfare. Degrowth challenges the notion that perpetual economic growth is compatible with finite global resources, proposing alternative indicators for progress and advocating for social and economic transformations. The movement emphasizes the need for systemic changes, including reduced consumption, community cooperation, and a reevaluation of the current economic paradigm.
  • The Sami people are an Indigenous group primarily inhabiting parts of Norway, Sweden, Finland, and Russia. They have a distinct culture, language, and traditional lifestyle closely connected to reindeer herding. The Sami have faced challenges to their traditional way of life due to factors like industrial development and environmental changes. The ...

Counterarguments

  • Wind turbines' impact on birds and bats is context-dependent, and many studies suggest that with proper siting and technology, the impact can be significantly reduced compared to other human-related causes of bird and bat mortality.
  • The noise from ocean-based wind turbines may affect marine life, but the extent of this impact is often less than that from other marine activities such as shipping, naval exercises, and seismic surveys for oil and gas.
  • While habitat disruption is a concern, wind farms can coexist with local wildlife through careful planning and management, and the overall habitat loss is typically less than that from other forms of energy production.
  • The effect of wind farms on real estate values is mixed, with some studies finding no significant impact or even positive effects due to the perception of a green community.
  • NIMBYism, while a real phenomenon, does not necessarily reflect a majority view, and public opinion can shift positively when community engagement and benefits are effectively communicated.
  • The claim that poorer communities are disproportionately affected by wind farm placement may not account for instances where these communities actively seek out wind projects for the economic benefits they bring.
  • Opposition from wealthy beachfront property owners may not take into account the long-term environmental and economic benefits of offshore wind projects, including job creation and clean energy generation.
  • Conflicts with fishermen, such as in the case of the Vineyard Wind project, can often be resolved through stakeholder engagement, compensation, and the creation of artificial reefs that enhance fish populations.
  • The visual impact of wind turbines is subjective, and some people appreciate the aesthetic of wind turbines as modern structures symbolizing progre ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free

Create Summaries for anything on the web

Download the Shortform Chrome extension for your browser

Shortform Extension CTA