Podcasts > Stuff You Should Know > Selects: Special Effects: A Short History

Selects: Special Effects: A Short History

By iHeartPodcasts

From early pioneers like Georges Méliès to modern marvels like "The Lord of the Rings" and "Gemini Man," this episode of Stuff You Should Know explores the evolution of special effects in filmmaking. It covers the fascinating history of practical, in-camera effects—from stop-motion to front projection—that laid the groundwork for today's cinematic wonders.

The summary delves into groundbreaking developments in CGI and motion capture technology that have allowed fantastical characters and scenes to come alive with unprecedented realism. Iconic techniques like matte painting and the Dykstra Flex system are highlighted alongside revolutionary advances like deep fake technology, painting a comprehensive picture of how special effects have pushed the boundaries of visual storytelling.

Listen to the original

Selects: Special Effects: A Short History

This is a preview of the Shortform summary of the Apr 20, 2024 episode of the Stuff You Should Know

Sign up for Shortform to access the whole episode summary along with additional materials like counterarguments and context.

Selects: Special Effects: A Short History

1-Page Summary

Practical Special Effects

Practical special effects have been essential in creating movie magic by turning imagination into visual reality. Legends like Dick Smith, Rick Baker, and Stan Winston have significantly influenced this art form. In-camera effects—which range from manipulating film speed to complex stop motion animation—allow filmmakers to craft compelling visuals directly within the camera. Rear and front projection can simulate dynamic environments, while physical simulations on set, paired with lighting effects, produce authentic-looking scenes.

Post-production effects also hold great importance, with techniques such as the Williams process enabling filmmakers to combine separate images during editing. Nowadays, digital enhancements and color grading in post-production have become as important as live-action filming. For instance, the yellow hue in "Oh Brother, Where Art Thou?" was achieved digitally, demonstrating post-production's vital role in the modern filmmaking process.

Early Special Effect Pioneers

Early special effects pioneers like Alfred Clark and Georges Méliès set the stage for future cinematic wonders. Clark executed one of the first special effects in "The Execution of Mary, Queen of Scots," ingeniously using the stop trick for a beheading scene. Méliès, considered the father of special effects, discovered the substitution splice by accident, later applying these techniques to create otherworldly narratives like "A Trip to the Moon." Their inventive contributions laid the bedrock for all special effects to follow.

Continuing Evolution in Special Effects

Following early pioneers, talents like Lon Chaney demonstrated innovative makeup skills during the silent film era, and Willis O'Brien popularized stop-motion photography with the iconic "King Kong." These artists contributed to the continuum of special effects that inspire and evolve with technology, ensuring that their creative legacy endures in contemporary cinema.

Evolution of Special Effects Techniques

Special effects have come a long way since the first films, with techniques like matte painting, motion control cameras, and the groundbreaking contributions of Industrial Light & Magic (ILM). Norman Don perfected the matte painting technique, and John Dykstra's creation of the Dykstra Flex system for "Star Wars" allowed for realistic portrayal of model ships in motion. ILM, founded by George Lucas, played a significant role in this evolution, using motion control cameras for special effects that have become industry standards.

Groundbreaking Special Effects

Significant breakthroughs in special effects have been achieved through CGI and motion capture technology, with movies like "The Abyss" earning the first Oscar for a CGI effect. Weta's advancement in motion capture technology allowed characters like Gollum in "The Lord of the Rings" to be realized with emotional depth and realism. The first full CGI character appeared in "Young Sherlock Holmes," and "Gemini Man" pushed the envelope further with a fully CGI younger version of Will Smith. Additionally, the development of deep fake technology, as seen in Bill Hader's video, illustrates the far-reaching impact and versatility of CGI-related techniques.

1-Page Summary

Additional Materials

Clarifications

  • Georges Méliès' discovery of the substitution splice was a groundbreaking special effects technique in early filmmaking. This method involved stopping the camera, changing the scene or actors, then restarting filming to create seamless transitions or magical transformations on screen. Méliès used this technique to achieve fantastical and surreal effects in his films, such as characters disappearing or objects magically changing. The substitution splice was a fundamental innovation that laid the foundation for modern visual storytelling and special effects in cinema.
  • Lon Chaney was a renowned actor in the silent film era known for his transformative makeup skills. He often created his own elaborate makeup designs to portray various characters, earning him the nickname "The Man of a Thousand Faces." Chaney's ability to physically transform himself through makeup was groundbreaking for the time and contributed significantly to the art of character portrayal in early cinema. His skill in using makeup to enhance his performances set a standard for future actors and makeup artists in the film industry.
  • The Dykstra Flex system, created by John Dykstra for "Star Wars," was a motion control camera system that allowed for precise and repeatable camera movements. It revolutionized the filming of visual effects sequences by enabling seamless integration of live-action footage with miniature models. This system played a crucial role in achieving the realistic portrayal of space battles and spacecraft movements in the original "Star Wars" film. John Dykstra's innovative technology set a new standard for special effects in the film industry and paved the way for future advancements in visual effects techniques.
  • CGI (Computer-Generated Imagery) involves creating visual effects using computer software to generate realistic images or animations. Motion capture technology captures the movements of actors or objects to create digital characters or enhance animations with lifelike movements. These technologies have revolutionized special effects in movies by allowing filmmakers to create fantastical creatures, environments, and characters with unprecedented realism and detail. CGI and motion capture technology have been instrumental in bringing to life iconic characters like Gollum in "The Lord of the Rings" and enabling filmmakers to push the boundaries of visual storytelling.
  • Weta's advancement in motion capture technology refers to the progress made by Weta Digital, a visual effects company based in New Zealand, in capturing and translating actors' movements into digital characters for films. This technology allows for more realistic and expressive digital characters by recording the actors' movements and facial expressions. Weta Digital's expertise in motion capture has been showcased in films like "The Lord of the Rings" trilogy, where characters like Gollum were brought to life through this technology. This advancement has revolutionized the way digital characters are created in modern filmmaking.
  • Deep fake technology involves using artificial intelligence to create highly realistic fake videos or images where a person appears to say or do things they never actually did. In the context of CGI-related techniques, deep fake technology can be used to manipulate and alter digital content, such as creating entirely computer-generated characters or enhancing existing footage with seamless visual effects. This technology has been increasingly utilized in the film industry for tasks like facial replacement, de-aging actors, or even resurrecting deceased actors for roles. Deep fake technology raises ethical concerns due to its potential misuse in spreading misinformation or creating convincing but fabricated content.

Counterarguments

  • While practical effects are celebrated for their ability to create visual reality, they can be limited by physical constraints and may not always achieve the desired level of detail or scale that digital effects can.
  • The influence of legends like Dick Smith, Rick Baker, and Stan Winston, while significant, should not overshadow the contributions of lesser-known artists and technicians who have also played crucial roles in the development of special effects.
  • In-camera effects, though impressive, can be more time-consuming and less flexible compared to digital post-production, where changes can be made more easily.
  • Rear and front projection techniques, while historically important, have largely been replaced by green screen and other digital compositing methods due to their limitations in realism and interactivity.
  • Physical simulations and lighting effects on set may not always be as safe or cost-effective as digital simulations, especially for large-scale disaster or action scenes.
  • The Williams process and other post-production techniques, while innovative, have been surpassed by digital compositing, which offers greater control and possibilities for filmmakers.
  • The importance of digital enhancements and color grading can sometimes lead to an over-reliance on post-production, potentially undermining the value of capturing authentic performances and settings during live-action filming.
  • The pioneering work of early special effects artists like Alfred Clark and Georges Méliès, while foundational, may not resonate with modern audiences accustomed to the more sophisticated effects of contemporary cinema.
  • The evolution of special effects with technology has sometimes led to an overemphasis on spectacle over storytelling, with some critics arguing that the reliance on effects can detract from character development and narrative coherence.
  • The advancements in CGI and motion capture technology, while groundbreaking, have also sparked debates about the loss of jobs for traditional artists and the ethical implications of recreating actors digitally, especially posthumously.
  • The use of deep fake technology, despite its versatility, raises concerns about its potential for misuse in creating misleading or harmful content, thus challenging the notion of its positive impact on the industry.

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
Selects: Special Effects: A Short History

Practical special effects

Practical special effects have long been a cornerstone of movie magic, bringing to life what only the imagination could see. Pioneers like Dick Smith and industry shapers Rick Baker and Stan Winston have left an indelible mark on the artistry of practical effects.

In-camera effects

Practical effects take various forms, including inventive in-camera effects that create illusions within the confines of the camera itself. These effects range from simple adjustments, manipulating the film's speed for slow or fast motion, to more complex techniques that involve stopping the film, changing something on the set, and then continuing to capture the action.

Innovations like stop motion animation, where objects are painstakingly moved and photographed frame by frame, allow for the creation of lifelike animation within a live-action context. Conversely, rear and front projection can simulate environments such as driving scenes by projecting a moving background behind live actors.

Physical simulations on set work in tandem with lighting effects to create hyper-realistic experiences. For instance, shaking a stationary vehicle and utilizing flashing lights can simulate driving at night, enhanced by artificially created rain. Such effects require a careful choreography of crew members to attain a seamless portrayal of the intended scene.

One historic example is the filming of "The Invisible Man," where Claude Rains wore a black bodysuit against a black backdrop, creating the illusion of invisibility on film thanks to carefully managed costuming and lighting.

Post-production effects

Though the wonders of in-camera trickery are myriad, post-production effects also play a pivotal role in movie production. They include techniques applied after the initial filming process, such as the groundbreaking Williams process. This method uses an optical printer to combine sep ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Practical special effects

Additional Materials

Clarifications

  • The Williams process, also known as the Williams double matting process, is a matte creation technique developed by American cinematographer Frank D. Williams in 1918. It allowed for integrating actors' movements with previously shot backgrounds, revolutionizing special effects in film production. This technique paved the way for more seamless visual effects by enabling the combination of separate images onto a single film strip. Williams' innovation marked a significant advancement in the history of special effects, influencing the development of the industry.
  • Computer-generated imagery (CGI) is the creation of visual content with the use of computer software. It is commonly used in movies to generate realistic scenes, creatures, or special effects that are difficult or impossible to achieve practically. CGI allows filmmakers to enhance visuals, create fantastical worlds, and bring to life elements that would be impractical or unsafe to film in reality. Post-production CGI involves adding or manipulating visual elements after filming to achieve the desired cinematic effects.
  • Color grading is the process of altering the appearance of an image through adjustments to attributes like contrast, color, saturation, and more. It is commonly used in filmmaking and video editing to achieve a desired visual style or tone. Color grading is now predominantly done digitally in controlled environments, allowing for precise manipulation of the image's color and overall look. This process is crucial for creating a cohesive ...

Counterarguments

  • While practical effects are celebrated for their tangible artistry, they can be more time-consuming and potentially more costly than digital effects due to the need for physical materials, specialized labor, and potential for reshoots if the effect doesn't work as planned.
  • The influence of pioneers like Dick Smith, Rick Baker, and Stan Winston, while monumental, should not overshadow the contributions of other special effects artists who have also shaped the industry.
  • In-camera effects, though innovative, can be limited by the physical constraints of the camera and the set, whereas digital effects offer a broader range of possibilities that can be achieved in post-production.
  • Rear and front projection have largely been supplanted by green screen and other digital compositing techniques, which can provide more convincing and flexible integration of actors into various environments.
  • Physical simulations, while effective for certain scenes, may not always achieve the desired level of realism or may be impractical for large-scale or dangerous scenarios, where digital effects can offer a safer and sometimes more convincing alternative.
  • The example of "The Invisible Man" is a testament to the ingenuity of practical effects, but modern audiences might find such techniques less convincing compared to contemporary digital invisibility effects.
  • The Williams process and other post-production techniques of the past are historically significant, but they have been largely replaced by digital composit ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
Selects: Special Effects: A Short History

Early Special Effect Pioneers

The art of special effects in cinema has been shaped by a number of innovative individuals whose creativity and ingenuity laid the groundwork for the stunning visual experiences we have today.

Alfred Clark - The Execution of Mary Queen of Scots

Alfred Clark made a significant contribution to the world of film by creating what is believed to be the first special effect. Around 1893 or 1895, in the film "The Execution of Mary, Queen of Scots," he employed a technique known as the stop trick. This groundbreaking effect was achieved by stopping the camera to replace Mary with a dummy just before the executioner's axe fell. When the film was played back, the switch was imperceptible to the audience, creating the illusion of a real beheading.

Georges Méliès - A Trip to the Moon

Georges Méliès, often referred to as the father of special effects, was an illusionist before turning his talents to the silver screen. He accidentally discovered the stop trick in 1896, when his camera jammed filmi ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Early Special Effect Pioneers

Additional Materials

Clarifications

  • The "stop trick" in special effects involves stopping the camera during filming to make a change in the scene, such as swapping an actor with a dummy. This technique allows for seamless transitions between different elements in a shot, creating illusions that appear continuous when played back. It was a pioneering method used by early filmmakers like Alfred Clark and Georges Méliès to achieve visual effects that were otherwise impossible at the time. The stop trick revolutionized the way filmmakers could manipulate reality on screen, laying the foundation for modern special effects in cinema.
  • A substitution splice is a special effect technique where one object is replaced with another during filming, creating a seamless transition between the two objects in the final footage. Georges Méliès used this technique in his films to achieve magical transformations and visual illusions, enhancing the storytelling with fantastical elements. This method allowed filmmakers to create scenes that defied reality and captivated audiences with its imaginative possibilities. The substitution splice was a pioneering technique in early cinema that laid the foundation for modern visual effects in movies.
  • Georges Méliès ...

Counterarguments

  • The claim that Alfred Clark created the first special effect in cinema might be contested by some historians who could argue that earlier examples of in-camera effects or stage tricks adapted for film existed.
  • The stop trick, while innovative, is just one of many techniques that were being explored at the time, and other filmmakers may have also contributed to the development of special effects in ways that are less documented or recognized.
  • The assertion that Georges Méliès accidentally discovered the stop trick could be nuanced by acknowledging that other filmmakers might have simultaneously or previously stumbled upon similar techniques, given the experimental nature of early cinema.
  • While Méliès was a pioneer, it's important to recognize that the development of special effects was a collaborative and evolution ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
Selects: Special Effects: A Short History

Continuing Evolution in Special Effects

Following in the footsteps of these early visionaries, artists such as Lon Chaney, known as "the Man of a Thousand Faces," displayed remarkable talent with makeup during the silent film era. He was revered for his ability to transform his appearance entirely for different roles.

The torch of innovation in special effects was carried on by Willis O'Brien, who brought stop-motion photography into the limelight with the iconic 1933 movie "King Kong." His groundbreaking work would pave the way for others, including Ray Harryhausen, who continued to push the boundaries of stop-motion in classic films like "Jas ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Continuing Evolution in Special Effects

Additional Materials

Clarifications

  • Lon Chaney, known as "the Man of a Thousand Faces," was a pioneering actor in the silent film era renowned for his transformative makeup skills. His ability to completely change his appearance for various roles set a high standard for special effects in early cinema. Chaney's innovative use of makeup techniques laid the groundwork for future advancements in the field of visual effects. His contributions to the art of on-screen transformation have had a lasting impact on the evolution of special effects in film.
  • Willis O'Brien played a crucial role in popularizing stop-motion photography through his work on the iconic 1933 film "King Kong." In the movie, O'Brien used stop-motion animation to bring the giant ape, King Kong, to life, creating groundbreaking visual effects for the time. This technique involved meticulously moving and capturing individual frames of the model to simulate motion in the final film. O'Brien's innovative use of stop-motion in "King Kong" set a new standard for special effects in cinema and influenced generations of filmmakers.
  • Ray Harryhausen was a renowned visual effects arti ...

Counterarguments

  • While Lon Chaney was indeed talented, it's important to recognize that makeup and character transformation in film have significantly evolved since the silent era, with new materials and technologies expanding what is possible beyond Chaney's techniques.
  • Willis O'Brien's work on "King Kong" was seminal, but stop-motion has been largely superseded by computer-generated imagery (CGI) in modern filmmaking, which some argue has led to a loss of the tactile charm found in stop-motion.
  • Ray Harryhausen's contributions to special effects are undeniable, but it could be argued that his style of stop-motion, while revolutionary for its time, may appear dated to contemporary audiences accustomed to the seamless visuals provided by CGI.
  • The assertion that foundational effects and techniques continue to inspire and evolve coul ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
Selects: Special Effects: A Short History

Evolution of special effects techniques

Special effects are an essential part of the movie-making process, evolving significantly from the invention of motion pictures up to the 1990s. The podcast hosts discuss how the foundation for special effects was established and persisted, with only refinements and improvements seen over time.

Matte painting

Norman Don - original negative matte painting

Matte painting is a technique used to create the illusion of an environment that isn't present on set. Painted scenes on a piece of glass are positioned to appear as part of the movie’s background. This craft became particularly notable with Norman Don, who is associated with original negative matte painting. Despite the denial of a patent, Don and his colleague were recognized for popularizing this technique. To ensure that cameras did not move during the shooting of matte paintings, which could ruin the illusion, cameras were sometimes buried a couple of feet into the ground to remain stable.

Motion control cameras

Motion control cameras brought a significant change in special effects techniques, offering precise and repeatable camera movements without manual operation. This technology enhanced the visual accuracy in films, particularly in close-up shots, such as those seen in food commercials. John Dykstra from Industrial Light & Magic pioneered the motion-controlled camera assembly known as Dykstra Flex for the first Star Wars movie, which is viewed as a groundbreaking contribution to the industry.

Industrial Light & ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Evolution of special effects techniques

Additional Materials

Clarifications

  • A negative matte painting is a technique where a painted scene on glass is used to create backgrounds that are not physically present during filming. This method allows filmmakers to incorporate detailed and expansive environments into their shots without the need for elaborate physical sets. Negative matte paintings were crucial in early special effects work, enabling filmmakers to achieve visual effects that were otherwise impractical or impossible to create.
  • An optical printer is a device used in filmmaking that combines and re-photographs strips of film to create various visual effects like fades, dissolves, and superimpositions. It allows filmmakers to manipulate and enhance footage by merging different elements into a single scene. Optical printers have been crucial in creating complex visual effects in movies by enabling the layering and blending of multiple images onto a single film frame. They have been instrumental in the history of special effects, allowing for the creation of intricate and seamless visual sequences.
  • Motion control cameras are a specialized technology used in filmmaking to precisely control and repeat camera movements without manual operation. These cameras revolutionized special effects by allowing for accurate and consistent shots, particularly in scenes requiring intricate movements or visual effects. They were instrumental in creating dynamic visuals in f ...

Counterarguments

  • While special effects have indeed evolved significantly, the text does not mention the explosion of digital effects post-1990s, which could be seen as an even more significant evolution than the period up to the 1990s.
  • The text implies that Norman Don's technique of matte painting was the primary or only method, but there were other techniques and artists contributing to the field of matte painting.
  • Burying cameras to prevent movement during matte painting shoots was one method used, but it was not the only method to ensure camera stability; other techniques such as locking the camera in place with heavy weights or using camera stands were also employed.
  • Motion control cameras were a significant advancement, but manual operation was still used for certain types of shots and effects, and the artistry of manual camera operation should not be understated.
  • John Dykstra was instrumental in the development of motion control technology, but it was a collaborative effort with contributions from other technicians and engineers.
  • ILM was a revolutionary force in special effects, but there were other companies and individuals outside of ILM who also made significant contributions to the industry.
  • The text credits ILM with the use of motion control cameras in "Star Wars: A New Hope," but it does not acknowledge the contributions of other films and ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free
Selects: Special Effects: A Short History

Groundbreaking special effects

The film industry has made significant leaps in creating visually stunning movies with the help of ingenious special effects, especially CGI and motion capture technology. These advancements have not only enriched the storytelling experience but have also been recognized with prestigious awards.

The Abyss - first CGI effect to win an Oscar

One of the landmark moments in special effects history is the creation of the first CGI character to win an Oscar. Although not directly related to motion capture, the film "The Abyss" featured groundbreaking CGI that nabbed the prestigious award. It set a precedent for the use of computer-generated imagery in films.

Motion capture technology

The evolution of special effects took a significant leap forward with the development of motion capture (MOCAP) technology. Weta, the company owned by filmmaker Peter Jackson, has been at the forefront of this innovation. Motion capture involves actors wearing suits adorned with markers at joints and crucial points on the body. The actors’ movements are then recorded and fed into a computer, which renders the movement into a fully CGI character.

One of the landmark achievements of MOCAP is brought to life through the character Gollum from "The Lord of the Rings" series. Gollum is recognized as one of the first fully CGI characters that delivered a convincing and emotionally rich performance, thanks to the technology.

Another significant piece of information in the timeline of CGI characters is the stained glass knight from "Young Sherlock Holmes," which is often cited as the first full CGI character ever to ...

Here’s what you’ll find in our full summary

Registered users get access to the Full Podcast Summary and Additional Materials. It’s easy and free!
Start your free trial today

Groundbreaking special effects

Additional Materials

Clarifications

  • CGI (Computer-Generated Imagery) is a technology that uses computer graphics to create or enhance images in various media forms like art, videos, and video games. It includes both 2D and 3D graphics to design characters, virtual worlds, scenes, and special effects in entertainment productions. CGI has been pivotal in revolutionizing visual effects in films, TV shows, and commercials, allowing for the creation of realistic and fantastical elements that enhance storytelling.
  • Motion capture technology (MOCAP) involves recording the movements of actors wearing suits with markers. These markers track the actors' motions, which are then translated into computer-generated imagery (CGI) characters. MOCAP allows for realistic and detailed animations by capturing the nuances of human movement. It has been instrumental in creating lifelike CGI characters in films and video games.
  • Weta is a visual effects company founded by filmmaker Peter Jackson, known for its pioneering work in motion capture technology. They have been instrumental in advancing CGI and special effects in the film industry, particularly through their work on movies like "The Lord of the Rings" series. Weta's contributions have significantly influenced the way CGI characters are created and integrated into films, setting new standards for visual storytelling.
  • "The Abyss" is a 1989 science fiction film directed by James Cameron. It follows a team working to recover a sunken submarine and encountering mysterious phenomena deep in the ocean. The film is notable for its groundbreaking CGI effects, which won an Academy Award.
  • Gollum is a CGI character in "The Lord of the Rings" series known for his complex and emotionally rich performance. Created using motion capture technology, Gollum's movements were performed by actor Andy Serkis wearing a motion capture suit with markers. The technology translated Serkis' movements into the CGI character, bringing Gollum to life on screen with remarkable realism and depth. Gollum's portrayal showcased the capabilities of motion capture in c ...

Counterarguments

  • While "The Abyss" featured groundbreaking CGI, it is important to note that the first CGI character to win an Oscar was not from "The Abyss" but rather the short film "Tin Toy" by Pixar in 1988. "The Abyss" did win an Oscar for visual effects, but not specifically for a CGI character.
  • The impact of CGI and motion capture on storytelling is a double-edged sword; some critics argue that over-reliance on these technologies can detract from the plot and character development, leading to visually impressive but emotionally shallow films.
  • The use of motion capture technology raises questions about the authenticity of performances and the role of actors. Some purists believe that it can undermine traditional acting techniques and the human element in performances.
  • The claim that Gollum is one of the first fully CGI characters to deliver a convincing performance might be contested by those who point to earlier examples of CGI characters that were also impactful, such as the T-Rex in "Jurassic Park" (1993).
  • The assertion that the stained glass knight from "Young Sherlock Holmes" is the first full CGI character in a movie could be challenged by mentioning earlier instances of CGI in film, such as the Genesis Effect sequence in "Star Trek II: The Wrath of Khan" (1982), although the knight is one of the earliest examples of a fu ...

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.
Get access for free

Create Summaries for anything on the web

Download the Shortform Chrome extension for your browser

Shortform Extension CTA