Short Stuff: Hot Cold Plunge | STUFF YOU SHOULD KNOW Podcast Summary with Theme Song, Josh Clark, Chuck Bryant

Short Stuff: Hot Cold Plunge | STUFF YOU SHOULD KNOW

1-Page Summary

Physiological responses to extreme temperature changes

Exposure to extreme temperatures elicits significant physiological responses, placing stress on the body's systems. When the body suddenly encounters cold temperatures, there is an immediate response characterized by an increase in breathing, heart rate, and blood pressure, as cautioned by the National Center for Cold Weather Safety. This reaction can be perilous for those with cardiovascular issues, potentially leading to cardiac arrest or hypothermia.

Lack of large-scale studies on health benefits and risks

Despite the popularity of heat and cold therapies, Bryant and Clark highlight the need for more extensive research. Anecdotal evidence suggests benefits such as elevated mood and reduced inflammation, but there is no solid proof combining heat and cold therapies yields additional advantages. Critics like Bryant call for large-scale, diverse participant studies to quantify health benefits and risks, emphasizing the importance of robust scientific evidence before making medical recommendations.

Origins and cultural role of saunas

Saunas, deeply rooted in Finnish culture, are recognized for their cleansing benefits, dating back to a time when hot running water was unavailable in Finland. The Finnish tradition includes not only using the sauna for heat bathing but also plunging into cold lakes or rolling in snow afterwards, a practice highlighting the affinity between Finns and their environment, which is thought to enhance health.

Safe ways to try heat-cold therapy

For those interested in experiencing heat-cold therapy, safety is paramount, especially for individuals with heart conditions. Josh Clark advises against cold plunging for those with cardiac conditions without prior consultation with a doctor. Total submersion in very cold water is not recommended due to risks of cold water shock and drowning. Clark suggests that even a 10-degree difference in water temperature, such as using 70 degrees Fahrenheit water, can offer therapeutic benefits without the extreme risks posed by colder temperatures.

1-Page Summary

Additional Materials

Clarifications

The National Center for Cold Weather Safety is an organization that provides guidance and resources related to staying safe in cold weather conditions. They offer information on how to prevent cold-related health issues and promote awareness about the risks associated with exposure to extreme cold temperatures. The center's recommendations often focus on protecting vulnerable populations, such as individuals with cardiovascular conditions, from the dangers of cold weather. Their advice includes strategies to mitigate the physiological responses that occur when the body is exposed to cold environments.
Heat and cold therapies involve using temperature variations to promote health benefits. Heat therapy, like using hot water or heating pads, can help with pain relief and muscle relaxation. Cold therapy, such as cold plunges or ice packs, can reduce inflammation and promote recovery. These therapies have been used for various conditions but require caution, especially for individuals with certain health issues.
Cold water shock is a physiological response that can occur when the body is suddenly immersed in cold water, leading to an involuntary gasp reflex and potential drowning due to the body's reaction to the sudden temperature change. This reaction can be dangerous, especially for individuals with underlying health conditions, as it can cause a rapid increase in heart rate and blood pressure, potentially resulting in cardiac issues. It is important to be cautious when exposing oneself to cold water to avoid the risks associated with cold water shock.

Counterarguments

While extreme temperatures can stress the body's systems, some research suggests that controlled exposure to these temperatures can lead to adaptations that improve the body's ability to handle stress.
The immediate physiological response to cold temperatures is part of the body's natural defense mechanism, and with proper acclimatization, these responses can be mitigated.
While individuals with cardiovascular issues should be cautious, not all individuals with heart conditions will necessarily experience negative outcomes from exposure to cold, and some may benefit from carefully monitored exposure.
The lack of large-scale studies does not invalidate the potential benefits of heat and cold therapies; it simply indicates that more research is needed to understand these effects fully.
Anecdotal evidence, while not as reliable as scientific studies, can still provide valuable insights and lead to hypotheses that can be tested in future research.
Critics may call for large-scale studies, but smaller, well-designed studies can also contribute valuable information and help build a foundation for larger research projects.
Saunas and cold plunges may have cultural significance, but their health benefits could be universal and not limited to Finnish traditions.
While safety is important, the advice against total submersion in very cold water may be overly cautious for some individuals, particularly those who are experienced with cold exposure and understand their own limits.
The recommendation of a 10-degree difference in water temperature as a safer alternative may not apply to or be necessary for everyone, as individual tolerance to temperature changes can vary widely.

Learn more

Effects of environmental temperature on physiological responses during ...

It is concluded that physiological responses and endurance exercise capacity are impaired under cool or hot conditions compared with moderate conditions, suggesting that environmental temperature conditions play an important role for exercise performance.

Using heat and cold for pain | Mayo Clinic Connect

Heat helps reduce pain by relaxing and loosening tense muscles, and it promotes blood and nutrients to speed healing. Use a heating pad or a moist towel warmed in the microwave and apply it to the painful area. Or you can take a warm bath or shower. Apply heat for up to 20 minutes three times a day. If you use a heating pad, never sleep with it.

Mechanisms and efficacy of heat and cold therapies for ... - PubMed

Pain Management / methods* Nonpharmacological treatment strategies for acute musculoskeletal injury revolve around pain reduction and promotion of healing in order to facilitate a return to normal function and activity. Heat and cold therapy modalities are often used to facilitate this outcome despite prevalent confusion abou …

Get access to the context and additional materials

So you can understand the full picture and form your own opinion.

Get access for free

Short Stuff: Hot Cold Plunge | STUFF YOU SHOULD KNOW

Physiological responses to extreme temperature changes

Facing extreme temperatures can provoke intense physiological responses, potentially putting a strain on the body's systems.

Shocking the body with extreme heat and cold stresses the body's systems

Rapid shifts from normal to extreme temperatures, especially cold, can have immediate and severe impacts on bodily functions.

Rapid changes in breathing, heart rate, and blood pressure

The National Center for Cold Weather Safety warns that a sudden exposure to cold can cause a cold shock response. This includes a rapid increase in breathing, heart rate, and blood pressure. Such changes can be particularly dangerous for individuals with compromised cardiac health.